Reviews of Allegheny Cellars (Winery)

Chris Yost

The 2 girls working here only know how to pour samples and ring sales. They seem to have zero knowledge of wine. When asked about where a certain wine rated on the sugar code and what scale they used, one of the girls gave a very smartass answer of, "Well, I've worked here 8 years and never had anyone ask me that. The winemaker knows all that." There will be no repeat business from me. I can only assume that all of the high reviews came from either family or the incredibly easily pleased."

scott messenger

Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon with my wife. We sampled several wines based on the suggestion of the lady working the counter. Each wine tasted delicious. With a rather large selection of wines we were pleasantly surprised at the assortment of 187 mL bottles. These bottles were available individually or as a build your own four pack. At a winery where they pour 15+ varietals and blends having the option to purchase a small sampler pack is ideal. The 4 star rating is the result of their labeling. Each bottle has a cute name that corresponds to the local attractions. However the label doesn't tell you the varietal or blend. There was a printed wine list that we only discovered after we had walked the store once trying to decide what to sample.

Dave Johnson

We were introduced to the Allegheny Wine cellers this spring at the Luthersburg Wine on the hill event. They were our favorite vendor there. Not a bad bottle in the lot. We left with at least 6 bottles from their winery.

Lisa Gottschalk

I love Allegheny Cellars... along with the owners ... Allen and Tina! Great wine and a great place in Sheffield Pa on route 6. I go there once a year! Was happy to see Tina... missed Allen this year! Always next year to see Allen! Thank you guys, for the best wine ever! Number 1!!

Tracey Morrison

I really like their variety of sweet wines! Wonderful hospitality every time I stop in.

Britt Fox

I stopped here on my way to the Kinzua skywalk bridge 09/13/2014. I like trying out new wineries. It has a gift shop, which was very nice, some of their wines were really sweet; which I love. Wine tasting was available, but I knew what I came for. They are know around the Allegheny region for their Big Foot Shadows. If you like sweet wines, then you would love Big Foot Shadows and like this place. The prices were reasonable and the staff was very knowledgably and helpful with other selections my group made that day. They do have shipping available and I took advantage of their gift wrapping on two of the bottles I purchased. The staff went above and beyond to accommodate us; I would definitely recommend this place to anyone. They got a quality product and an amazing staff.

Cecelia Peterson

I visit every time I come to the area.

GrayhatJen

I know absolutely nothing about wine but the staff here was not only knowledgeable but also patient with my many questions. Award winning wines, rustic elegance and a positively outstanding staff.

Shannon Homick

My husband & i took a road trip to go to this winery. Excellent wine & service

Julie Dyer

We are from Indiana - and wanted to stop on our way home from Massachusetts. We called twice to see if they were open (which was recommended) no answer and not a call back. VERY disappointed... I have enjoyed their wine in the past and would have bought TWO cases. Guess business is not needed. Oh well plenty of other winereries.

Jerry Cataldo

I absolutely love the folks there. They are always enjoyable to talk to and love the varieties of wine. Tina spoils my kids every time I go there (not with wine...) LOL! I can't wait for them to come to my neck of the woods at the Pennsylvania Farm Show.

Jim Montgomery

Staff was rude at the Franklin wine walk. I was going around to all the wineries with my friends and tasting together. But at Allegheny I was past by twice as the lady poured for my friends. I asked if I could taste too, she replied in an annoyed manner "I don't know what you want".

Larry Horning

Excellent wine variety