Reviews of Comstock Tire & Auto (Tires)

Nick Swedlund

I made an appointment and they got me in and out quickly after repairing two flats. 10/10 will return again.

William Miller

Always fast, nice and affordable for all tire needs.

Aimee Arts

Awesome! The guys are super nice and truly care about you and your vehicle.

Andy Tan

Had a flat, they were super flexible with letting me drop off at any time, even after hours. When I called in the morning they gave me a number of different options (different tires and new vs used) and once decided they were finished within the hour and I had my car by the time I needed to get to work. That's great customer service.

Holly Cegielski

One of the workers here forgot to reconnect a hose, so it was leaking exhaust on the inside of the car! We couldn't even breathe when we drove the car around afterwards. They wanted to charge us for a diagnostic test even though it was obviously their fault. We got it fixed with another company who agreed it was Comstock's fault. I asked for a refund and they absolutely refused to acknowledge their mistake, let alone apologize or try to make up for it. Awful customer service. Will not be returning.

Jung-Hun Seo

These guys are really professional!! They're timely, precise, and skillful!! Also, the service fee is cheaper than other mechanical shop!!!

TJ Voelske

Overpriced, dishonest and won't own up to their mistakes. Took my car to another shop and they found that the technician at Comstock forgot to reconnect a hose, so it was leaking exhaust into the cabin of the car. I asked Comstock for a refund and didn't get it.

William Young

Several in my family have been going to Comstock for a variety of repairs over the last 3 years. No surprises. Always solid work, fair price, fast turn around.

Donna Wasley

These guys are organized. Waiting area is clean, organized with pop machine and coffee. Very polite and friendly and get the job done in record time. They even checked my tires for me to make sure the air pressure was good after I asked if perhaps one of the tires was a low on air. A great place to go for oil changes, tires, etc. We got 2 coupons each for $3.00 a piece on line and used them on oil changes for both our vechicles.

Kay Wade

I drove here from Seattle, Wa and within my first week here, my rear tire literally popped when it got wedged in one of the holes with broken concrete and steel wedged inside while I was exiting one of the highways. I asked my new neighbors for a place I could go to replace my tire that wouldn't take advantage of me. And most of them suggested Comstock without a second thought. So I looked up Comstock's number, called them, and made an appointment for Monday morning at 7 a.m. Then I got up super early Monday morning to drive there so I wouldn't have to pay for a tow truck or interrupt work commuter traffic as I slowly crept along the side of the road. And I was very happy to see their doors open and ready for business when I pulled into their parking lot at 7 a.m. Then I was even happier about how pleasant the front desk gentleman was, especially on a Monday morning, smiling. End result: Within 30 minutes my tire was replaced with a bran new one for only $60! And Patrick, the front desk gentleman, was even nice about my dog (suggested where we could go when I said I'd like to take her for a walk while waiting for the tire replacement). So If you need any kind of tire service and prefer giving your money to nice people (instead of grumpy ones, smiling) who get the job done quickly and for a reasonable price, I suggest you give these folks a try. And feel free to tell Patrick that Mini Pearl (my nosey little mini poodle who also enjoyed visiting there, smiling) said Hi! Still smiling, K.

Brittany Wenger

Look elsewhere.. issues with the work I had done, will not be returning.

Donna Clausen

Great experience. They were able to get me in same day to take a look at my tire and do an oil change. I thought I might have to replace my tire but they took a look at it and determined it was safe and I could continue driving on it. I truly appreciated their honesty and the fact they didn't try to sell me services I did not need. The woman who worked in the waiting room was very kind and welcoming while I waited, something I normally don't experience in an auto shop waiting room. I also appreciated the WiFi that allowed me to work during my appointment. I'm new to Madison and it's always hard to find a trustworthy mechanic/auto shop in a new city. It's something I personally dread. But I really lucked out with Comstock and I will definitely be back for future services.

Ed Hillman

Jon Leatherberry very helpful should get a raise.

Liam Scott

Fast, friendly, no bs

Theresa Haywood

I brought my tires from Firestone most of my auto repair is done with Firestone and I can't believe this place charged me $3 to put air in my tire

Sarah Naomi

5 stars for customer service. Extremely helpful, honest, and quick. Had a flat and they were able to squeeze me in that same afternoon. Great price.

Sue Miller

I've purchased tires from Comstock twice and get regular maintenance there. They do good work for a fair price and take care of their customers. They've even accommodated a few last minute requests and they do everything with courtesy and professionalism. #customerforlife

Zeke Jewel

Found a nail on my way to work. They were able to replace with a used tire and re-balance in under 40 minutes so I wasn't too late.

Cat Like Meow

My tire was bald and also just not holding air anymore and when I noticed I had been riding around almost completely flat, I called to make an appointment. Got me in for the very first appointment the next day and had my tire done in about a half-hour. Staff was also friendly, and tire prices are definitely reasonable! I still need three new tires before winter comes so I know where I'll be going for those!

Mike Nagy

Have been going since a friend referred me. I mainly get oil changes which are a fair price and the service is wonderful. They are always upfront and I can trust that they will do the work correct the first time.

John Wolfe

Good service and prices. In and out within a half hour.

Spanish kiss893

First time customer very satified. I called first to get an oil changed. I was greeted as soon as I walked in. The wait was not too long.

Elissa Sprecher

I have an older car, and with that I have needed some repairs. The owner and employees at Comstock are always fair, knowledgeable and compassionate (shout out to Pat the mechanic!). They provide great service and can always fit me into their schedule. Thanks Comstock!

Sherry Zeier

Great tires

Austin D

I came in with a leaking tire caused by a screw. The tire was not repairable due to the screw being too close to the sidewall. However, they sold me a tire at a great price so I could get back on the road. They were extremely quick, friendly, and very fairly priced. Would definitely recommend.

Tyler Leahy

Called at 7. Got my car in 5 minutes later. Got a tire in 15. So fast and friendly!

Max Rusek

Excellent service - and quick!

Abram Haesemeyer

Guys told me exactly what needed to be done and made every thing perfect. I love Comstock tires!! Thanks to your crew I can drive my family safely every day!

Michael O'Brien

Always quick, friendly, and fairly priced.

Jessica Morrow

Excellent service!

Redwolf Scott

Very professional very knowledgeable and excellent staff. A plus service

Blazin' Professional Auto Detailing & Refurbishing

professional and fair prices

Joseph Ross

Fair prices, timely service and very friendly people. Been here several times and never felt pressured. Good place.

Adam Milkowski

Great service and awesome prices

Ricky Erdman

Great experience quick professional and reasonably priced

Mary Hetrick

These guys are the best in town. Flexible, efficient, and most importantly - kind. Comstock acts like a small town business in a big city, where they treat customers well and provide services at an incredibly fair price.

David Snook

Always helpful. Competitive prices and neighborhood service.

ana maria Viada

(Translated by Google) Only passing (Original) Solo de paso

Dmitry RA

Unfriendly, snobby, refused to provide the service without giving a reason. Illegally accessed and re-parked my open car without my permission when I came for service at the appointed time, but then refused to service when I pointed out it's illegal to drive one's car without consent from the owner. The pretext they claim in response below is a completely false statement. I should have called the authorities on them.

Alyssa Leatherberry

Excellent staff & service!! They know how to get the job done! Love the dog they sometime have in, Buddy!

Jeremy Ryan

Originally went to Comstock for their pricing. Needed 4 new tires for some 22s on my Chrysler 300 and the lowest I was quoted outside of them was $1300. They found me a set brand new for about $900. They were able to have them two days later which was a major plus. Staff was caring and helpful, facility is older but clean. The original appointment went well and was pretty quick given as I had 3 bottles of Slime in one tire. When I left I had noticed one of the TPMS sensors went out and my tire was still leaking. Called them the next morning and they got me in the same day. Said the TPMS sensor went out which can happen. Also said there was some debris in the rim causing the leaking. They really excelled however when they decided to replace the faulty TPMS sensor and clean out the debris free of charge. A++++ will be going there in the future and would enthusiastically recommend!

Tim Sweeney

We have been getting our fleet tires taken care of at Comstock for 30 years. Always great service. Thanks Tim

Liz Budd

Am a first time customer who intends to be a life-long customer. Wonderful experience. 4 new tires plus other work done. Personable, skilled, affordable, and quick. These guys make you feel like an individual, not a number. Definitely worth checking out.

Cassandra C

Tried to leave a message over the weekend, no answering machine. Went and got a new tire on Monday. Really great deal on the tire and i was able to get my oil changed. The woman at the front counter was very friendly. However, they just threw my tire into my trunk all willy nilly, didnt put it back in the proper place and they broke the special necklace i had on my mirror.

Charles Gervasi

My brakes started dragging severely when I was nearby. I was a little cautious about going in b/c I thought this was a somewhat rough neighborhood. The people in this shop, though, are very friendly and professional. My problem was minor, so they fixed it FOR FREE. It will likely happen again if I don't replace some part. They wrote down the name of the part and gave me the number for their mechanic who could replace the part when I'm ready. My car was fixed FOR FREE. Amazing.

Niklas Gahm

Service was good, fast, and cheap.

Jon Mortrud

I have a fleet of 10 trucks and cars and been purchasing from Comstock for over 30 years; service and support are great. Comstock pricing is inexpensive considering all the 'salesmanship' (a kinder word than others) they don't put you through. I rate them by how they deal with a crises, they always pull you though no matter the situation.

Jeff Killian

Had to get a new tire as my old one popped. They were extremely helpful, and honest. Instead of trying to get me to buy 4 new tires, they let me know mine were low, but that I could survive another couple months on mine. On top of this, they lowered the price for the tire I bought because it was a slightly busier morning (I only waited 5 or 10 minutes extra). I'm going back later this week for a full checkup. Would definitely recommend.

Ryan Keuler

Holmes tire wanted 240 dollars to dismount 3 tires and mount and balance 4 wheels due to me wanting to use aftermarket rims on my audi. Brought it to these guys and they took care of the situation perfectly. They knew the brand and fitment of the wheels and knew they would fit because they are professionals and don't slap a 60 dollar "test fitment" fee like Holmes. And they only charged 68 bucks. Highly recommend to anyone who is a car guy and wants to be treated right.

Casey Kavanaugh

Great Company! Good Service at a decent price.

Yukon Cornelious

Brought in a snowblower tire. Took care of me on the spot. Nice. Good shop to check out.

Donald Rosby

Great prompt friendly service!

Patrick Lueck

Friendly, honest service. Competitive prices. Will come back!

Jan Lindeman

Great service and prices

John Spencer

Great service mechanic was very knowledgeable and pointed out another problem