Reviews of Bonfyre American Grille (Restaurant)

2601 W Beltline Hwy, Madison, WI 53713

Average Rating:

DESCRIPTION

Here you will see the feddbacks of real people like you who know the products of Bonfyre American Grille (Restaurant) in the area close to the state of Wisconsin.

At the present the business gets a score of 4.3 out of 5 and this score is based on 900 reviews.

You must have seen that the average of ratings is really good, and it is founded on a high number of reviews, so we can think that the evaluation is very accurate. If there are many people who bothered to give their score when they are pleased with the business, it works.

As you know, we do not usually bother to put reviews when they are good and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Restaurant corresponds to the category of American restaurant.

Where is Bonfyre American Grille?

REVIEWS OF Bonfyre American Grille IN Wisconsin

Adam Newman

Consistency is king when I dine out. And I know that Bonfyre delivers every time. I am a big fan of the curry, Korean and chicken dishes . . . All of them. The staff is mindful of your time and the table conversation. Perfect place for a business lunch.

Nathan Johnson

A high end place to grab bite to eat for lunch or dinner, located just off the beltline. A wide selection of dishes to choose from. Bonfyre offers salads, sandwiches, stakes, and bowls. There are vegetarian options along with gluten free as well. The veggie black bean burger is good. For a side the roasted red potatoes I would recommend. Nice open bar to sit at while you wait for your table. Good beer and cocktail selection. Service is very good, friendly, and attentive. Extra parking in the ramp is available in the back if you can't find a spot out front. It can get a bit loud when it is busy so it can be hard to hold a conversation. The cheesecake mousse dessert is amazing. Try it you won't be disappointed.

James Silberschlag

Today was served buffet style only, no menu items. Everything was fresh and sufficiently full. Most items I tried we're tasty. Attentive waitstaff. Overall very good.

Paul Erixson

Awesome food and atmosphere

Shanna Gordon

Food is great quality, ambiance is great, not too fancy not too casual.

Todd Bussan

Really liked the atmosphere and food was tasty. Portion size could have been better but was ok

Adam Newman

Consistency is king when I dine out. And I know that Bonfyre delivers every time. I am a big fan of the curry, Korean and chicken dishes . . . All of them. The staff is mindful of your time and the table conversation. Perfect place for a business lunch.

Nealie Quinn

Great food and nice staff for a 4.3 star ratting. First time being there.

Sue Powers

The cheese curds are fantastic. I know every restaurant in Wisconsin probably claims that and I have little experience judging but these are very good. So is the butternut squash soup. I would come back in a heartbeat.

Megan Garry

Always friendly, attentive servers. The food is great, and so are the happy hour deals from 3-7 M-F!

Brea Kleine

Great chicken, always friendly staff, easy to reserve a table online.

Omar A. Adorno

excellent service, food and atmosphere (for a special dinner)

Jeff Statz

Besides the occasional seating mistake by a host, this is my favorite go-to spot for business lunches. They need more booths, but it's right off the Beltline, so it's a handy location. After a dozen+ visits the food has always been top notch and made exactly to order.

Genesis Noftle

Love this place. Their chocolate martini is to die for. Food is also amazeballs.

Skip Hake

Wait staff is wonderful... Food is phenomenal... Atmosphere is just as great... 4 thumbs up... I will be returning soon... Amos is a wonderful Waiter

Dean Halverson

Outstanding Poke!

Drew L

Our first visit, and it was for Fathers Day. From the Service, decor, the entrees, and dessert. It was amazing. The best-grilled shrimp I think I've ever had.

Seth Nicholson

Great food & great service.

Corrine O'Day McAuliffe

Quality food, but expensive. Good portion sizes.

Diane Meyer VanNote

Met friends there for lunch. Once we found it; it's tucked in the bottom floor of a larger building. It was a tasty treat! My husband and I had the grilled shrimp. Our friends the pot roast and salmon. All wonderful. We all would go there again!

Maggie Ley

Had lobster ravioli that tasted as if it were from a can. Made me ill.

Joel Kinzalow

Great seafood and quick service

Rusty O'Neill

Great food

Kirsten Bushek

My husband and I have driven past this place 1000x on the beltline. We finally resolved to try it on our one year anniversary. We called ahead and made reservations at 5:30pm for a 6:45 meal, and were seated directly when we arrived. We were greeted promptly by out server, Kayla who was friendly, warm and knowledgeable. I had the pleasure of ordering a glass of riesling, which was perfectly chilled. We ordered cheese curds and calamari for appetizers, which were outstanding. Our dinners came in a timely manner. I have to say, people online comment on the herb roasted chicken and say it's amazing - they are absolutely right! Out of all the food we ate, the chicken really stood out. I couldn't give five stars only because I the side dishes couldn't hold up to the star of the plate - that amazing chicken. I would recommend going in to try their chicken, and I can say I will be back to see how their Friday and Saturday morning brunch fare. It's worth your time - just be prepared from your pocket book as it is a bit more costly compared to others.

Julie Lockwood

Absolutely amazing experience. Food was delicious, drinks were sublime, and the wait staff were wonderful. I can't recommend this place enough!

rycerz

Food was great.

Christine Berndt Althaus

Fantastic meal of filet mignon with red wine butter. Outstanding!

Kari Drexler

Best food .great service

Jeff Redington

Great food and service.

Adultery77

Food is great, but it's a bit on the pricey side. I've also been here for a company party... The Bloody Mary is tasty and Morty makes a mean pot roast.

Allison Champion

Food and atmosphere were both fabulous. Cheese curds were exceptional!

Andrea Mogensen

Excellent food and service.

Erin Cornwell

The Seafood Cobb Salad is fantastic! Great atmosphere & great service!

Melodie Betts

Seriously, I gave them a chance to respond twice, and they don't care. I was there on a Saturday with two others who were looking forward to the truffle fries (they no longer have)...ok, so we ordered. I had the crab cake Benedict, and what a disappointment. Advertising lump crab and all you receive on a small stale cousaunt and two think sliced silver dollar sized crab cakes. The brunch potatoes were frozen hashbrowns that the cheese sauce had broken and they gave me the burnt corner of the pan which was not edible. My friends food wasn't much better, they ate 1/2 their sandwich and all their Frites. The buger that she asked to be cooked well was SO well, it broke off in crumbs and was super tough. My other friend had the steak sandwich and it was cubes of meat and of really poor quality. She couldn't eat a cubes of meat in the sandwich...who could? We had just gotten done taking a class and we're very hungry and it was about 1:15...not busy at all.

Sand Fred

Patio service was great on a summer night. Whisky flights and tuna poke were a great combination. Colorful, unique flavor combinations. I look forward to returning!

Andrew French

Really great menu, had the veggie burger, and a cheese plate appetizer... Yummy!

Stephanie Blankenheim

Great lunch with chicken and pasta followed by caramel chocolate mousse dessert. Great service too! Had a steak there too awhile back... everything was delicious.

Scott Van Derven

Atmosphere was upscale but we only went for drinks. The kitchen was busy and the chef's line is visible to the diners. They were busy and the seafood was obviously the star of the show. Intrigued to go back the next time we're in Madison to sample the fare.

Scott Van Derven

Atmosphere was upscale but we only went for drinks. The kitchen was busy and the chef's line is visible to the diners. They were busy and the seafood was obviously the star of the show. Intrigued to go back the next time we're in Madison to sample the fare.

Eric Updike

We have had our company holiday party at Bonfyre for the past 3 years. It has always been amazing! This year we booked the Beacon Lounge at Bonfyre. What an amazing facility and even better staff! We will definitely be back again next year. Thanks for all that you do!

Greyfaction Inc

Excellent food on the pricey end though a+ service

Ryan Clare

Great venue, good food. Is it worth the price? Certainly if you're on the company dime.

Bradley Ganske

Great food along with great atmosphere!

Mandy Bell

Great service

Robin Lickel

Alicia great server. Delicious food and yummy desserts.

Gregory Miller

Our only real disappointment was the noise level due to the bar crowd. While I understand that it was a Friday at 6pm, it would have been nice if our reservations had been considered for a quieter table, rather than right next to the bar. Our server, Elicia, took very good care of us and the food was nicely presented and very good. We enjoyed the walleye, pot roast, mixed grill, fillet, and steak sandwich.

Mark Korres

Bartenders where attentive and very nice. Thanks Julia. The serving staff was busy yet very attentive. Thanks Chase. The food was very good, and the prices were reasonable. I'll go back.

Keith Hopson

Quite possibly the best steak I have ever eaten. Ate there twice in one week while on a work related trip. So fantastic. The staff was great and the food was amazing!

Bruce Blix

Fantastic place, fantastic service, fantastic food. The service at the bar is always superb (shout out to Rachel and Julia) and the ambience is excellent. Try the zucchini fries. 12/26/2018 - Once again the food was excellent and the service impeccable. Try Mort's Pot Roast for a down home comfort food experience.

Kevin Gardner

Service was great, very pricey.

Joshua Schultz

Food is a few bucks more than at other restaurants, but they have a very nice dining area and service was decent. All our food was hot and tasted good.

Shawn Bettinger

Great atmosphere, great food!

Ruth Larson

I was limited in what I could have because I could only have soft foods. I had the risotto and squash soup. Both were delicious. The prices were high so I would not go frequently.

Josh Reiner

I had the crispy fish tacos. They were delicious. The service was incredible. My waitress let me take my time and enjoy my time with my sister. I would recommend this place to anyone.

Jeff Cherwinka

Best ribs in Madison

mandy

The bartender was very nice and the drink menu was a refreshing change from the usual. If you’re looking for more “classic” drinks or to try something I would recommend going here.

Dan Frahm

Excellent food and ambience.

Shannon Arndt

Every time I have been here the food is always delicious and service is good.

Kim Slava

Very nice, great service, classy place, no surprises....

Spencer Francis

Steak prices too high, but other entries were reasonable . Everything ale carte. All our dishes very good, but we avoided the expensive ones.

Phil Zenebisis

Looking forward to the next time I am in town and have the opportunity to visit again. Shrimp are oversized and delicious and steak was cooked to perfection.

Alvin Jonathan

My experience here is really bad. I ordered bone-in ribeye and asked for medium. The waiter just gave me the steak without asking me how it was. The steak was cooked almost well-done and I had to ask other waiter to call my waiter. My waiter finally took out my steak. A few minutes later, the waiter brought a new steak for me and it was blue! (Not even rare). She took out again my steak, brought a new one a few minutes later, and the steak was cooked rare. I was so disappointed that the restaurant couldn't even cook medium for 3 times. This is not good at all! The only good thing from this restaurant is the food presentation

Barbara Gulten

Rather an accessible location off the beltline, with convenient parking, this is a reliable happy hour spot. During summer they also setup outdoor seating. Service is friendly, professional, prompt and attentive; makes a difference folks! Has a cozy atmosphere and a huge bar area with plenty of seating, as well as high tops and other tables. Wide selection on their drink menu for both beers and wine. Food is ok, good enough to accompany drinks but not for fine dining. Check it out, enjoy!

brandon sanchez

Food was good. Service was good

korteks visceralzen

Great place

Michael Holz

great atmosphere, great food. good location.

Sarah Crandall

Food is quite good, service is excellent

Kristy Ellen

Butternut squash soup was excellent!

Emily Sobiek

Excellent flat bread and service!

Kraamer Rickard

Bonfyre has a great environment with great food following suit. The drinks are always good, the portions are large, and the food is cooked perfectly. I always enjoy stopping in here with a group of friends, or dinner with family before a show.

Pamela Powell

Went to this restaurant on New Years Eve. It was my first time visiting this place. We had reservations. Once we were seated we were greeted by our server. She told us the special and asked us what we wanted to drink. I was planning on ordering a bottle of wine and had some questions. I understand that she may of had to go ask the bartender for the answer. She just seemed very overwhelmed. Now on a night like New Years Eve a restaurant should have all their best servers on or at least make sure the staff is prepared. As far as the food....It was delicious. All four of us had different entrees. Scallops, prime rib, new york strip, and jambalaya. Could of asked for anything to be different. I will definitely want to eat there again!!

Kevin Utz

Good food, good drinks, good atmosphere. Nice spot for conversational dinners.

Brittany Hillman

Great experience, great bartender/waitress at the bar. Wish I remembered her name! Cant complain. Great place.

rutta ouk

Food and service is always fantastic been here many times and it’s always been great!!!

Lisa Klahn

The service and food were outstanding

Amie Brown

Food was amazing! Cooked perfectly, presented beautifully. Staff is great! Can't wait to go back! It was a memorable anniversary dinner.

Mostapha bin Ali

Great Service....Absolutely Fantastic⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Danny Brauns

I have eaten at nearly every higher scale restaurant in the Madison area and Bonfyre is my go to.

Linda Sanders

Food is always very good. Pretty standard menu with lots of choices. Service is excellent. The restaurant is not too noisy which is a positive I'm my book.

Tom Burns

Always love stopping in here when i am in town. Great food and great service. Cheese curds are amazing!!!

Chuck C

Very good food. Very good atmosphere. Attentive staff. A little pricey. Perfect for a special night out.

Emilio Dlism

Great service and atmosphere. Had a late lunch and everything on the menu sounded amazing. Ordered the Bahn Mi pork sandwich with roasted red potatoes and left very full and satisfied! My boyfriend got the Chicago beef sandwich with shoestring potatoes and a garden salad. I sampled his salad and it was really good. I wish I lived in this area so I could sample everything on the menu!

ROBERT BARNES

Two large pieces of Walleye served, fishy and lots of fine bones. The green beans were 85% raw, with little flavor. Disappointing. The service was good; only a few other customers on a Friday night. Others in our party ordered meat; they made no comments, positive or negative. Although, nor did I.

Moriah S

Friday evening my guy and I enjoyed a wonderful meal at the Bonfyre American Grille. The atmosphere was warm and slightly rustic with romantic balance. The service was surprisingly fast for a sit down restaurant and the food was delicious! Our server, Bridget was very friendly, and knowledgeable when asked for suggestions. We both highly recommend Bonfyre American Grille. Thank you all for a wonderful experience

Barbara Novick

WOW!!! Probably my favorite place to eat on a city FULL of great places to eat. Great atmosphere. Wonderful menu.

Carl segias

This place deserves 5 stars! outstanding service and food definitely leaving you fulled and satisfied! Highly recommend.

Tracy L.

We are always pleased with the food and service. Next time I.ll submitt some photos with another review. If it's Badger or Packer Game Days the bar area can be a bit loud. Do if that's not your thing request a table away from that area.

Eric Lundell

Excellent food, reasonable prices. Really great atmosphere, too.

Samantha Belanger

I love going here for happy hour but they removed my favorite entree, the Lobster Ravioli. I’ve asked about it multiple times and have been assured it would come back but it’s been well over a year and I still haven’t seen the dish come back on the menu. So sad because I would go there so much more if they still had this dish.

Amy Klarkowski

The food is always good.

Maryellen Jenson

Enjoy coming after work for a glass I'd wine, great eats and my girlfriends. Big fav.

Nicole Sharon

Love the oysters (especially the grilled ones) and the happy hour is great.

Emilio Dlism

Great service and atmosphere. Had a late lunch and everything on the menu sounded amazing. Ordered the Bahn Mi pork sandwich with roasted red potatoes and left very full and satisfied! My boyfriend got the Chicago beef sandwich with shoestring potatoes and a garden salad. I sampled his salad and it was really good. I wish I lived in this area so I could sample everything on the menu!

Wesley Mills

Our experience was amazing. The food was beyond amazing and our server Dawn gave exceptional service. She knew what to do and what to suggest. It was my first experience there and I will be back for sure when I'm am in town.

Kellie Jo Roesslein

I love this place. The atmosphere, the smell, the staff. Every experience has been fantastic.

Edward Elskamp

Always a great place for lunch or dinner!

Troy Schmitz

Pot roast and wood fired rotisserie chicken dishes was awesome. Mashed potatoes were great also. Only reason for 4 stars was the vegetables, green beans had no flavor and undercooked. Asparagus and carrots cooked but no flavor at all.

Drew Halverson

The crab cake benedict was really, really good. Service was excellent. The coffee was not amazing but overall brunch here was a fantastic experience.

ROBERT BARNES

Two large pieces of Walleye served, fishy and lots of fine bones. The green beans were 85% raw, with little flavor. Disappointing. The service was good; only a few other customers on a Friday night. Others in our party ordered meat; they made no comments, positive or negative. Although, nor did I.

Silas Rogers

The manager Katie is terrible, doesn’t care about customers and treats her wait staff like trash. Food is good, it’s the management that sucks.

Pamela Woodruff

Varied menu, but not overly large like so many restaurants. Service was prompt and unobtrusive. Staff handled a large table (18 people) next to us quietly and efficiently.

rick knutson

Lobster ravioli was great! Immediate seating with great service. Not the cheapest place but there quality makes up for it. Try their grilled Romaine salad...it's incredible!

Joni Dalhoff

Wonderful place! Husband had the pancakes - WOW I had the French toast. I have never had anything SO AMAZING! Give this place a try you will not be disappointed.

Christine Bellport

Very good food selection and an extensive wine menu. The atmosphere is terrific as well.

Pang Yang

No more truffle fries!

Moriah S

Friday evening my guy and I enjoyed a wonderful meal at the Bonfyre American Grille. The atmosphere was warm and slightly rustic with romantic balance. The service was surprisingly fast for a sit down restaurant and the food was delicious! Our server, Bridget was very friendly, and knowledgeable when asked for suggestions. We both highly recommend Bonfyre American Grille. Thank you all for a wonderful experience

Jack Melvin

The food is always excellent. Great comfort food, plenty of healthy food choices. The restaurant has great ambiance, smells, lighting, etc. I always leave full and satisfied.

Marina Pavon

Eat birthday dinner cooked to perfection

Roland Halverson

Good food food servicr

Alan Stahl

Great place for a date night!

Joe O.

Great food, great service

Mehran Mehrabi

Always great food and service.

Ada Lai

Great food and excellent service

Grant Armbruster

Upscale sports bar.

Morgan Bostwick

This has become our new favorite spot out for date night! The atmosphere is a perfect blend of casual and upscale. Prices are a little higher, but I have yet to eat something that wasn't delicious and totally worth it there! I've only had "poor" service here one time (we sat for 15+ minutes without being greeted, while the waiter walked past us over and over) but we just moved to the bar and told the bartender, and she comped our first round of drinks which made up for it.

John Shea

Highly recommend for brunch. Good selection of traditional dishes and breakfast options. Breakfast jambalaya was excellent. Fire and ice bloody Mary was impressive 32+ oz with all the fixings bacon, veggies, cheese and sausage. Food portions should be bigger for the price but I'll always return here

Judith Rodriguez

Have been here many times and we love the food. Consistently good food and service, and their take out service is fast. The butternut squash soup is amazing and the flatbreads are big enough for two to share. For appetizers try the truffle fries and the coconut curry mussels, you will likely not be disappointed.

Jina Patton

We have been planning on trying this place for a while, and we lamented not going sooner! The atmosphere was lovely, beautiful decor, not to many televisions. The food was stunning, the curds had a beer stout batter, the blue cheese and pepper jack sauce was amazing with the curds. We ordered two smaller plates and the portions were plenty and then some. The steak was so so good we both probably had a bit to much but it was so good we didn't want to put the forks down. Will be back here!

Eric Breitbach

Wonderful food and amazing service! This place screams first date if you want to impress with the ambience. I cannot stress enough how good the food is and how responsive the service was the last time we were there. The drinks were a little light on the alcohol but were very well made. I highly recommended Bonfyre.

Wendy Andrews

Oohhh so good! Can't wait to go back. Service wasn't good, but the food made up for it.

Curt Wilber

Nice and classy place, my steak was one of the best I ever had and so was the twice baked potato. I will definitely go back again.

Barbara Novick

WOW!!! Probably my favorite place to eat on a city FULL of great places to eat. Great atmosphere. Wonderful menu.

Cami Torres

Service was great! They were friendly we ended up meeting 2 friends that were already there and they allowed us to move tables. Wasn't super impressed by the food. I ordered the ribeye it was $38 and not as good as I expected it to be. My partner ordered the ribs and they were really good not too sauced and not under sauced. We will try it again but I wont be ordering the ribeye

2BSwanky

Always a great atmosphere and good food. The lobster ravioli was good, the scallops were great, cheese curds are soft and the batter is amazing... and if you've never had the grilled romaine salad..it's a must! Trust me. The calamari was different, not what I'm used to. They were really thick and actually reminded me of mozzarella sticks..with the batter and marinara. I only ate a few. I had a great glass of Pinot Nior called Rainbow.. It was wonderful. They also were gracious enough to customize a meal for me that wasn't on the menu. Will definitely be back.

LAURA REATEGUI

Beet & Berry salad!! YUM ~ SO DELICIOUS!! I could eat this twice a day every day. And its healthy so, it's cool

Judy Bunge

We had a wonderful company holiday dinner party there. Food was great and service was wonderful!!

Jessica Jackson

Breath taking food and beautiful atmosphere that has a high-end feel, great for intimate celebrations or romantic evenings. Service is also top notch! I didn't have to flag anybody down for anything or wait around for the check or a drink refill. I've been there twice now with my husband and its our new favorite!

Sam Lancaster

Most of the time this place is on top of their menu items. Why 4 stars, this restaurant is loud. If they were to invest in sound deadening materials, the ambience would be much better.

Carl segias

This place deserves 5 stars! outstanding service and food definitely leaving you fulled and satisfied! Highly recommend.

Michael Sullivan

Nice place. Called in to check on wait time and put our name on the list. 30 minutes for a party of 5 on a Friday evening at 6:30 was pretty good. I had the Togarashi crusted salmon sandwich and it was outstanding. My daughter kept raving about the Tai Chicken flatbread, as well.

Dale Anderson

The food and service was outstanding. Had a couple IPA's after dinner at the bar and was charged different amounts for the same tap beer beer. $9.00 for 1 and $8.00 for the other. Bartender is skimming......

Paul Roach

A great meal while visiting Madison. Try the Irish margarita.

Josh Pap

Out for daughters birthday all of us ordered steak, the rib eye was so salty I could not eat it. Told the waitress, she got the manager, he came over and was as rude as he could be then walked away. No re-fire the steak because he said I ate some of it. So don't try it before you send it back apparently. I have been here many times and had great service and food but this will be the last time we come here! I will be calling corp to let them know how their staff treats their customers after a $200 dinner!

Arber Agushi

This place would get a 5 star rating because overall the staff is very friendly and orders always on time. The only thing I always notice is the Hosts.. they never greet you and always look sad to be there.

Daniel Freiburger

Pretty standard steakhouse. I got a great cocktail and there's a relatively large menu. My waitress was awesome as well. The food was just a little lacking. My steak was kind of tough and the sauce was just okay.

Anna Anna

I have yet to have a bad experience here. Everything I have tried here is amazing and wait staff is always friendly. Amazing place to go to for lunch or dinner.

Darren Wacker

We only here to celebrate my son's graduation from college. Very good service, excellent food and a great atmosphere. I highly recommend.

Bobby Gruss

No sauce on vegetables. No lemon In water Sometimes awkard seatingShould of had a choice of vegetables offered. High quality steak wood fired is excellent Pot roast good Help should be better trained in a restaurant this expensive.

Jason Buehrle

Enjoyable lunch. Tried the fish tacos and was very pleased.

Carol

The drink and food were very good. Wait staff are nice.

Randy Bollig

The food and beverages were excellent, but one disappointment. It was my 60th Birthday with 10 family members and after eating we like going outside and sit around the

Mike Burmesch

Great lunch selection, great spot for business or casual lunches/dinners.

Michelle Neuendorf

Service was fine, but there were some big flaws with the food. While my entree was fine, the toast served with it had mold on one of the crusts. The mold was about the size of a pencil eraser. So while, not a huge, certainly noticeable, and irregardless...mold! I also had a piece of eggshell in my entree (a hash). If this had been a small piece of eggshell, I would not have given it any thought, as I know that can happen, but this was a piece of eggshell the size of a quarter. I set both the moldy piece of bread and the eggshell on a plate to show the server. After seeing them, and without a comment on either, she asked if she could take the plate. I assumed she was going to show the manager, but I have no way of knowing for sure, as nothing was said about it after she took it. I sure do hope they threw that bread away though. UPDATE 2/28: Bonfyre reached out to me immediately after my review and promised to make the situation right. A month has now passed and they never did what they said they would do. I have emailed them twice (thinking that a mistake had been made), but have gotten no response to either email. UPDATE 3/12: The promised certificate arrived. Thanks.

Madison Mayer

Good food but not worth the higher prices. Haven't had the steak, but if you're coming here for anything else, I'd say the quality isn't that much better than a run of the mill American sit down restaurant to warrant the extra expense. I came here with a family member who was paying for our group, but if you're the one footing the bill, I'd say it's not worth it. With that said, I ordered the Crab Cakes appetizer as my entree. They were delicious, and I would recommend them -- except that for two crab cakes, it was $17. Plus higher end on cocktail prices. Overall, if you choose to eat here, it's easy to find pretty good food.

Meghann Heindl

Wonderful atmosphere, our Waitress Jordyn was fantastic.

Derek Bickhart

Very good food, but fairly high prices. The steaks are good, but I find that the non-steak menu offers better value. Avoid the jambalaya and go for the mixed grille instead. The Moscow mules are also great.

Kane Wong

Favorite bar on earth

Kelly McCann

I love the atmosphere, the food was OK and we were excited to come back several more times to try different meals and apps, however our server was ridiculous. We are a server friendly group, tipping generously because we have several servers in our family, but this young woman was unpleasant from the moment we walked in, borderline hostile at times. We were a pretty straight forward group, simple orders, no extras. She let us know that she was doing us a favor by serving us. Wow, I don't think that I have EVER had a server like her.

Ken Murray

Have been going here with decreasing frequency over the past couple of years. Bar service has turned very poor, in my opinion. A second drink takes too long, no silverware served with meal, etc. Even the sizes of the apps seems to have shrunk. I really want to like this place, though it is difficult based solely on the bar service.

Andrea Adkins

Fast service, good drinks and a great cheese board. Also try the truffle fries and the meat trio.

Ambar Colon

Yumi, yumi! Its so good!!Excellent!

patricia achilli

Excellent food...small portions..a little pricey

Josh Pap

Out for daughters birthday all of us ordered steak, the rib eye was so salty I could not eat it. Told the waitress, she got the manager, he came over and was as rude as he could be then walked away. No re-fire the steak because he said I ate some of it. So don't try it before you send it back apparently. I have been here many times and had great service and food but this will be the last time we come here! I will be calling corp to let them know how their staff treats their customers after a $200 dinner!

Roy Normington

Great brunch!

Arber Agushi

This place would get a 5 star rating because overall the staff is very friendly and orders always on time. The only thing I always notice is the Hosts.. they never greet you and always look sad to be there.

Sandy Olson

Love this place! Great atmosphere and delicious food and drinks.

Alicia Stensberg

Great restaurant that never disappoints! The atmosphere is modern and casual. It’s great for lunch, dinner and happy hour! The food is fantastic and you can’t really make a wrong choice - from spinach and artichoke dip, kale salad with chicken, ahi tuna, steak and seafood - it’s all delicious! Service is quick and very friendly. Great selection of wine, beer and cocktails.

Shirley Minser

Good food, good service.

Frank Burns

It's a little on the pricier side. Food is good. Accommodating for larger groups. Other note: It's a stop that hotels in Verona mention by name since it is the furthest their shuttles will take you towards Madison.

Abuela Mickey

First time for brunch: bountiful, nutritious, and attentive service.

Chris Pokrzywa

Excellent service, food, and atmosphere

Nick Pichette

Came here for some afternoon cocktails on a Saturday. The cocktails were very good as well as the atmosphere. The bar tender was a bit aloof and not very attentive. I thought that was strange given how quiet the restaurant was at the time.

Jacob Harley

Excellent food and service. Can't really go wrong with anything on the menu. I had the vegetable risotto and a creme brulee. Will definitely be going back for a date night in the future.

Christian Pankow

It was a beautiful restaurant from what I could tell (it’s a pretty dim setting, but it sets a decent ambience). However, we had 8:00PM reservations, showed up at 7:45PM and waited until 8:25PM to sit. We weren’t exactly rewarded for our wait, either. The food was decent, but failed to meet the lofty expectations set by themselves and local critics alike. It was also rather expensive for the quality of the ingredients, maybe 10-15% in excess cost. They might benefit from reducing the size of the menu in order to put more focus into the quality and flavor of their food.

Roy W Holston Jr

I was drawn to Bonfyre by the sweet smell of the barbecue. I went in and ordered the full slab. The most delicious and tender ribs I've had in recent memory. I'd rate it a 10.

Andrea Farrell

This place is hit or miss. Service is either great or horrible. Atmosphere is either nice or filled with flies. Food is either great or nothing special. I recommend the fish stew and truffle fries on a good day, but just not going on a bad day. Problem is, you never know what kind of day they are having until after you're there.

michelle schnacky

Everything from the appetizer to the main course was amazing! Throughly enjoyed every bite!

Andrea Brown

Had the Beet & Berry Salad. It was delicious.

Âmanda Hornung

Love the atmosphere. Food is excellent.

Don Wadyka

We've been there several times. Only the Holiday menu was offered so a couple favorite choices weren't available but everything we chose was well prepared and very good. Nice atmosphere too. We'll be back.

Business Hours of Bonfyre American Grille in Wisconsin

SUNDAY
10AM–9PM
MONDAY
11AM–10PM
TUESDAY
11AM–10PM
WEDNESDAY
11AM–10PM
THURSDAY
11AM–10PM
FRIDAY
11AM–10PM
SATURDAY
10AM–10PM

PHONE & WEBPAGE

Bonfyre American Grille en Wisconsin
View Phone Number
View WebPage

PICTURES






Others also saw
Skippy's Burger Bar
Skippy's Burger Bar
Restaurant - Wisconsin

Restaurant

Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch
Restaurant - Wisconsin

Buffet restaurant

Mackinaws Grill & Spirits
Mackinaws Grill & Spirits
Restaurant - Wisconsin

Bar & grill

Sobelmans on St. Paul
Sobelmans on St. Paul
Restaurant - Wisconsin

Bar & grill

Point Burger Bar Pewaukee
Point Burger Bar Pewaukee
Restaurant - Wisconsin

Hamburger restaurant