Reviews of Scatori's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant (Restaurant)

John Joy

This place was amazing. Waitress Adriana was amazing and very personable. Food was as good and actually better than in NY. Definitely a must go to when in Myrtle Beach. Would give them more stars if it let me.

Beth Cevasco

Best Italian restaurant in the Grand Strand! The portions are huge, ingredients both authentic and super fresh. And the risotto... I’m going to dream about it. Adriana, our server was awesome. She guided us to the right choices. Definitely going back.

Mary

Have only been for lunch and pizza so far and both were very good. Will be back for dinner.

Pat Duggan

The service was great we had the special. The wings and knots were good my friend liked the pizza I thought it was a little dry. Just a preference. But a nice place

Mike Knipp

Stopped in for lunch and got the lunch pizza. It's one slice but it's large. Also came with a salad. Both were good.

Nick Howard

Consistently been getting worse food every time we go. Previous trip we had take out and the Stromboli we got was not cooked all the way. Pizza use to be good but it’s nothing special anymore. Fries have always been either wet noodles or hard as a brick. Went in there today on Sat 6-22-19 and the left side of the “restaurant” was empty at 1pm. Fries we got were so over cooked or just reheated from last week sometime. Last visit for us.

Trav Boi

Its is amazing.The pizza is one of the best i ever had.it has grease that runs down the arm and the flavors are great.The garlic wings were crispy on the out side and nice and soft on the inside.The Italian sausage was not desired. But the meatball was more of a spherical meatloaf,it is insane that you can 2.The house salad was great with there ranch

Dan G

Great Italian food. I would have given 5 stars, but the steak special was small and a little tough for $26.

Nickolas Hicks

It's the best pizza I've ever had

Niki Howard

Fantastic food. Try the spaghetti and Meatball! So delicious

Bill Romash

Food was delicious! Waitress was awesome. Great NY style pizza. Garlic knots were really good. We'll go again.

Leslie Armstrong

Amazing! Chef Kevin is absolutely the best!

Wayne Leis

Great food, great price. The soup tonight was amazing. We brought home more food than we ate.

madison jacquemin

Just ordered food for delivery so don’t know how it tastes, but I was on hold for EIGHT minutes and they told me it was going to be an HOUR AND FOURTY MINUTE WAIT!!! Hope the food is good

LeRoy Herd

The servings were huge and the food was great

Deborah Brown

We had the chicken piccata and the veal picatta, it was wonderful. The salads were also great with cold plates, chopped lettuce with lots of olives

Kevin McGrath

Went with a large group (11) on Mother’s Day. We had a 05:30 reservation and were seated promptly and they took our drink orders right away. We ordered a few apps to,share with the table but they took a long time to arrive. They were pretty quick with the drink refills but they messed up my second vodka tonic order by adding something other than tonic. The rest of the meals were served very slowly and a few in our party had to wait extra long for their entrees to be served. We didn’t finally get out of there until around 07:45. The food was generally fine and the servers were trying but the kitchen was very slow in getting the food out. Went to the bathroom on the way out and it smelled really bad like a sewer was backing up. Don’t think we will be going back any time soon.

Steve Houpt

Great food, great service

Nick Hicks

Best pizza i've ever had

Linda Peek

Fantastic food with a great staff

KATVOU studios

Great food, not too expensive. Service was also great.

Aaron Van

Go left when you hit the door.

Phillip Mangiaracina

Really tasty veal, some of the best I've had in Myrtle Beach. The eggplant rollatini is definitely probably the best I ever had. Really top shelf Italian food. The veal Scatori is my favorite.

Blake Rine Blue ACES

Kevin is the ultimate restaurant owner. We were traveling and stumbled upon his establishment and he acted like we have been regulars for 20 years. The food speaks for itself. Fresh, local ingredients, made to order and in a timely fashion. I don’t know when we will be back this way but we will make sure we visit again.

Kristi Dillman

Went here last night and had the mozzarella appetizer and garlic knots. Both were fabulous! These are not your average mozzarella sticks, they were legit pieces of mozzarella cheese breaded and then in crushed tomatoes. Yum!!!! The garlic knots were fresh and easy to pull apart and in a garlic butter sauce. Much better than the ones I’ve gotten at home. We followed this with a 16” pizza for four of us. Was more than enough food for all of us and even had some leftover. Loved the sauce and chewy crust. Sausage was just like we do it in Chicago. (Sometimes we get weird sausage when outside the Chicago limits!) Some of the best pizza we’ve had on vacation! The only thing I felt was odd was that there are two sides to this restaurant. The air conditioned side you can’t order pizza, the server said that side was for dinner. (Where we come from, Chicago, pizza counts as dinner!!) The pizza side was a little hot, even with the fans going. The pizza side you must walk in and can’t make reservations.

Virginia Binder

Love..love..love..cant wait to take my Italian son in law here!!

samantha davis aka heavenly skys

Not best the dinning area is nice but food is more like cheap

Peter Struble

Food was good service not so much. Came with a party of three adults and four children ages from 3 to 11 years old . (who were very well behaved) wanted to sit on the restaurant side of business where they had tables that could accomadate seating for up to ten people in stead was forced to seat in the pizzeria side where sitting was ment for at best five people. I had to use the restroom half way through our meal and low and behold all the large tables were still vacant My meal cost me in excess of one hundred and thirty dollars and was rushed to finish it. While being crammed into an unsuitable seating arramgment.

Anna Henry

Delicious dinners - I've had something different each time & everything has been wonderful!

Mike Bentley

Used to be good, but couldn't get what we wanted to eat and when we ordered something else, it was terrible. We complained about the meal, to management but got no reimbursement for meal or a apology. Don't recommend it to anyone.

Michael Cherry

Quick, friendly service. Great food!

matt vane

The food is delicious the pizza, garlic knots and chicken parmigiana hero are the best at the beach The service is top notch

Alexandra Evans

Pizza is very good. Service is spotty...very nice servers, they just seem stressed... maybe they get yelled at by kitchen staff?

Cindi Ester

First of im sure more dinners from here very friendly staff and food is amazing!!!

Debbie Shepard

Food was delicious!! Service was fantastic! We had the lunch special. Pizza, wings and garlic knots. Everything was so delicious!! We will definitely be back there soon. The waiter was really good too!! Very enjoyable lunch

Kathy Wagner

We come here every summer when we're vacationing!!! Most amazing food ever!!!!! We love their special...pizza, garlic knots, and 10 wings!!!!! It's always perfection!!!!

BgDog

I have been coming here for about 2 years and the food was good up until recently. Just picked up an order as we always order the typically the same thing and the garlic knots were raw in the middle, the chicken wings were over cooked and very dry and the pizza was downright awful. Quality of product has significantly dropped for sure - it is clear to see that as I am in the food industry myself. Lastly, they have this really dumb process/rule that when you enter the dining room on the left it is for pizza consumption only (no joke). The dining room on the right is for larger entrees-don’t even try to order pizza on the right as we were told we would have to move to the other dining room. I simply told them NO! And they said that we had to order a $20.00 entree. Again, the most ridiculous process. Was willing to look past this, but again the food quality has suffered significantly.

Patty Blum

Big size ...not sure of sauce taste...ok but very heavy

R.Trevor Ferraro

It was very good i had the eggplant parmesan with angel hair pasta very good size portions go back again for sure

Sharon Leis

The soup was fantastic and the spaghetti and meatballs (size of a softball) was enough food for a second meal. Good value.

Dennis Hart

Amazing place. A must visit for a meal if you are in town.

Courtney

The food is so authentic and flavorful. I was so satisfied with the price.

Jeff Taylor

Great appetizers, bread, chopped salad, and entrees.

derreck martin

For sure recommend for any pizza lovers.

Sheila Beram

New waitress assigned to our table was the best. Took care of our every need. Patient , pleasant and tried in every way to make us happy. ..and she did.Food was good too.

Debra Weiss

This started as a 5 star review. Their food is amazing. I frequent for lunches, always satisfied. A couple weeks ago we ordered a pie special for pick up, which was an hour late. So tonight I thought I would call my order in an hour before pick up. The young lady on the phone was excellent. I explained last time I waited an hour and she assured it would be ready at 6pm. I arrived at 5:45 explaining I was early but wanted to confirm when it would be ready since last time I waited an hour. They checked and said 6. We went shopping and returned at 6:15. But it wasn't ready. The lady went to check on it but never returned. After 2 minutes I asked when it would be ready. They told me I had come 15 minutes early before. Yes but I am now 15 minutes late, when will it be ready. The pizza chef decided to yell up the same. Again I told her, well now I'm 15 minutes late when will it be done. The gentleman at the counter decided to start mocking me, saying maybe 30 seconds, 5 minutes, then proceeded to announce with a full restaurant, ahhh poor you (by name) you had to wait 5 minutes, so sad. REPEATEDLY..I said pardon me??? And he continued. I reminded him he is in a service business and might try to be kinder. But he continued. I asked for a refund. Which he gave me after more demeaning comments. I hope is isn't the owner. I will find out tomorrow. So disappointed in their behavior.

Andrew Lanford

Fabulous anniversary celebration!! Would highly recommend. Hard to beat for a night out. Split into two restaurants. One as a pizzeria is you are there with the kids, one as an Italian restaurant if you are there without.

Rachel Pedersen

First time here! The food was excellent - rich and delicious alfredo sauce, soft fresh bread with garlic & herb butter AND seasoned olive oil. The lunch service was fast too. It's a little pricey, so I won't go often, but I'd definitely recommend it for a nice quiet Italian experience.

Brenda Smith

Friendly atmosphere and waitress very efficient and friendly. Food was prepared to perfection Prices fare, restaurant very clean. Never had a bad meal or experience here. Highly recommend

Christina is human

Amazing food and atmosphere. Would definitely recommend, especially of you are looking for authentic Italian food.

Margaret Lee

The best PIZZA in the Myrtle Beach area, Huge slices with lots of cheese. Can't believe I have found a place to compare with NJ Pizza. Very nice dining area also for great Italian foods..

Maleea Brooks

My favorite restaurant! Excellent pizza, but also amazing entrees and specials! Kevin is an amazing chef!

Donna Norris

Excellent food and service!! Will visit again!

John Smith

Great service evellent food must try

baby girl

Amazing garlic knots and pizza

Charlene Jones

Great chicken parm. Dinner specials are excellent; the chef often comes out to serve it and then check their instagram for a picture of your plate.

Don Hansen

Love the special with pizza, garlic knot rolls & wings - parmesan garlic our fave! Very budget friendly way to feed family of 4. Small dining area gets crowded Fri PM. Thurs PM no wait!!

woodstock 1969

Excellent food, all home made! Must try the mozzarella sticks, best I ever had and freshly made!! Excellent staff!!

Linda Bailey

Great food, good prices & good service..

John Chanaca

We were basically ignored! We sat there for an hour and 15 minutes before we were served! Even the bread and drinks took a long time getting there. The food was only fair when we got it.

John Brock

This is not a 3 star rating because of the food necessarily. I'm a local and have eat inside the restaurant and completely enjoyed it. I have also had several to go orders and this is where my complaint comes from. I like the traditional lasagna. That's what I normally order. Eating inside was great, but the issue that can be easily corrected is they use a to go tray that is way too big and the entrée spreads out leaving the meat and pasta in the middle and all the cheese and most of the sauce on the side. This spoils the delight of the meal. Lastly, the last order the bread was a BIG BUMMER! It was flat and hard! It was a toasted hamburger bun...Or appeared to be! Why not the traditional nice soft bread sticks (roll)? If you were out then it should have been expressed and the other bread just not included at all! We ordered 3 lasagna entrées and After a meal like this I think the next 3 should be free and they should work on redeeming themselves. In The future to go preps and containers should be improved!

Chris Miller

Great local pizzeria. Fantastic food.

L Mack

The best Italian restaurant on the strand. Didn’t try the pizza, but the eggplant parmigiana was outstanding.

Deb Cunningham

Overall food & service was good. Veal parm was excellent. Summer vegetable medley was mediocre; no flavor, over-priced, will not order again.

Rich Bailey

Food is delicious! Never had a bad meal there.

ceily arnone

" The meals are made fresh as we order.

Joe Riccardi

Sicilian Pie is $21 plus tax. That's almost $24 for a pie! Absolutely ridiculous! No thanks!

Howie Davis

Hidden gem of an Italian restaurant. Take your choice of fast and tasty or an elegant sit down dining experience. Very well prepared and you will get more than you are expecting.

Yroc Sivras

Very friendly service great atmosphere and the food was spectacular. And my mom loves it!

Thomas Marshall

Fresh ingredients is the real key to what makes everything so delicious here. My family and I have collectively had almost every item on the menu and it’s consistently the best.

David Cook

We had delivery and the two spaghetti dinners that cost $35 and threw them away. Meatball just bland and just not good. Won’t eat here anymore

Beach Bum

Updated* returned and had a better experience

Norman Turner

Love the spaghetti and meatballs

Christine C

The chicken alfredo was amazing and so is the pizza. I will be ordering the pasta again very soon.

Benetta Sumpter-Allen

The pizza was great, they forgot to add the mushroom topping I paid extra for, but corrected it. The calzone was tasty, but cost more n smaller than the other places I visited. I will visit again.

James Lecours

Enjoyed , food was old style Italian. Tasty ,good quantity, service was very good would , will go back when in town. Only suggestion dust a little better. Going today to try pizza

Chris Bianco

I have vacationed in the Horry County area for 25 years. My one concern about a permanent move was not locating a good Italian restaurant. Scatori's has satisfied that need. Atmosphere is very nice, food is excellent, service is great. The chef and owner is a very hard working individual who absolutely is concered with your experience being great. I have had three meals thus far and all were superb. The absolute best part is the meatballs. Can't wait to bring my NJ family soon.

Bob Teague

The restaurant side has excellent Italian food. Prices are mid-range, a nice place to have a meal and talk. Service is great.

Ray Chapman

Way over priced for a mediocre Pizza.. We bought pizza for six people, five out of the six said they would have rather eaten Gino's Pizza instead. I bought a large pepperoni and sliced Italian sausage. They were really skimpy on the toppings, the crust was crunchy almost burnt, the sausage was chewy, and the pizza was so greasy everyone didn't want a second slice. the best part of the whole meal the garlic knots, which would you can get anywhere. A waste of $28.00... Never again.

Estelle Demeglio

Nice but chairs to sit on

Jeanne Baker

Absolutely amazing food!! We moved here from NY and have not found better Italian anywhere else. The chef, Kevin, is highly skilled and prepares the most creative and delicious dishes !! And you must try the soups as they are delicious!!

Victor Cotoia

We ordered the the Keto daily special for carryout. Food was delicious. Portion was perfect.

Christal Collins

Good food very nice staff

Tom Garofano

Food was excellent, service was great. Overall highly recommend

Denise DeLellis

This place used to be great, however, the quality of food does NOT match the price. The bad attitudes of the servers are really amusing to watch!!

Heather Rine

This place is fantastic and the service was amazing!!!! We will be back again next year on our family vacation.

Casey Jenkins

The food has always been amazing. My mom and I have been coming for years. It’s 45 minutes away from us and well worth the drive. It’s my favorite Italian restaurant, period! I highly recommend their manicotti!

Carina Cesarano

Loved this place. They have a pizza only side to the restaurant, and a full dining side. Food is delicious on either side. Aside from consistently being very good to excellent, the serving sizes are ridiculously plentiful. My friends and I order separate entrees and then share family style. I have no reservations in recommending Scatori's to anyone looking for a great pizza or fine dining under the same roof.