Reviews of Nonna's Pizza & Italian Restaurant (Restaurant)

eric abramovich

First pizza place in this area of NJ that's actually good. I've been told that it is the water that makes great pizza. Or if the pizza throwers are Italian... Whatever it is, this place is the best in this area. Engaging and good staff. Delicious pizza and my favorite: good zepolles. I have tried zepolles in a dozen different places but these taste like they should. Any time I'm in the vicinity I make sure to get some zepolles here.

L Guerra

This place simply knows how to satisfy their customers. Regularly with a super friendly approach. The food is conveniently priced, constantly tasty and neat.

TutorialsByKennedie

Very unsatisfied with our take out order. We ordered a meat ball sub, raviolis with vodka sauce, and a small salad. My salad was completely opened in the bag, my raviolis were in a very soupy sauce that tasted like milk it had no flavor, …

bso grady

good food but long wait

Brian Wade

Awesome pizza and zeppoles! I go with the grandma, the grandpa and the margherita pizzas, best pizza in Morris County...make sure to try the zeppoles!

P.C K

My husband and I ate lunch there today. We each had a slice of eggplant rollatini pizza and a spinach wheel. I'm 67 years old. I've eaten a lot of pizza in my life. This was the best slice of pizza I have ever eaten. Amazing!

Dominick Sandelli

Had 2 slices - white and meat lovers. Delicious!

Kevin Dillon

Absolutely phenomenal pizza. The sauce is the secret - tastes delicious. I highly recommend the margarita. The guys that work there are also awesome, always making customers laugh and ensuring the customer is getting a high quality slice. Highly recommend.

Juan Rojas

We order a pizza from here a few times a month but we recently went in for a lunch this past weekend. Our waitress was friendly, attentive and even played with our 3 year old for a few minutes. The food, as always was excellent and the …

Drew

Its very good don't get me wrong. However because it is good there are a lot of customers with little server to table ratio which can be an inconvenience if you don't want to wait long. I am deducting two stars: 1 for slow service and the other for the parking situation. Parking lot is insanely hard to find a spot with the trader Joe's and other stores nearby.

Jack Black

Holy Pizza!! I have been here a few times and the pizza is awesome! Not only do they have a wide variety of types of slice pies, but they also have a lot of entree choices from chicken, beef, eggplant, and pastas! There is a delicious salad with roasted pears and balsamic dressing. The wait staff is incredibly pleasant and the guys in the front who do the pizza and slices are really friendly and polite! There is a lot of seating and the Resturant is very comfortable and clean.

Daniel S. Abrahamian

Out of this world pizza... Local hot spot

Brenden Myers

This spot is awesome! Convenient prices, considerable portions and the employees are regularly helpful.

Ellen Watson

Nonno's is a staple in our house. Consistently great food, wish they would open Nonno's 2 in Randolph.

Shelley Weisholtz

Had a takeout chicken parm sandwich..great bread..lots of cheese...and an amount of chicken that was barely enough to make a half sandwich..hidden inside LOTS OF BREAD AND CHEESE

Tieyana Samuels

You do not put change in the counter! As I stand with my hand out! Because I put the cash into your hands directly! Unacceptable! I haven't even left the establishment as I write this because I am appalled.

Chad Hooker

Awesome pizza and service!

Anthony Chan

My wife and I were in the area and after a day of shopping, stopped in to grab a quick bite to eat. My wife noticed that the guy who took our order was abrupt and abrasive and seemed to rush her when she was trying to decide what to order. We figured he was having a bad day. While waiting for our order I asked if I could use their restroom. The same guy turns to me and said they "don't have restrooms they only have an outhouse". Everyone turned and looked at us when he said this. We cancelled our order and immediately left. We will never go there again.

Ivette Serrano

Our company orders there sometimes and recommended it to us, went there for first time and it was very busy, and even with it being busy the service, the food and the atmosphere was awesome, everything was fresh and tasteful, and even if it wasn't that servers table the others all made sure our drinks were full and asked if everything was ok or needed anything. Now its our turn to recommend! Great Job Nonnas!!

Brian S

Great good and staff. Always a good meal every time we go there.

Dan S.

Food is good but service is clumsy at best. Have to ask for silverware, then it's slammed, unwrapped, onto table by hostess who is busy texting, and not helping server at all. Hiring these days is tough, but regardless of who is selected... training/coaching them is essential.

David Park

Got there at the beginning of the dinner rush on Sunday evening and my family of 5 was seated immediately. Food is pretty good and and my kids devoured the garlic knots & buffalo wings. Did not like that the appetizers and entrees came out at almost the same time though. Our waiter was very friendly. A little surprised they gave us all bottled beverages instead of fountain drinks. There was a big crowd waiting for seats when we headed out around 6PM.

Storm Alexus

I’m not a big fan of pizza I’m from Baltimore and rarely eat pizza here the taste is just not it so I mainly eat pizza when I got jersey or New York this was so tasteful I would totally come back for more

Cameron Fiddes

I hadn't had pizza in a couple of months and was craving it so I drove 25 min specifically to come to what I consider the best pizza within reasonable distance from me. I ordered a large half pepperoni half plain pizza. I got the pizza and walked out the door when I noticed the box seemed very light and small for a large pizza box. I opened the box and noticed that all the slices were very small. I went back and asked if it was a full size pizza, which they said it was. I asked for a refund and they gave it without question. They did mock me a little in disbelief that I wouldn't accept the size of the pizza. I don't know if I am crazy or something, but I have worked at pizza places and ordered pizza enough times to know what a normal large pizza looks like and this was definitely smaller. Maybe my whole life I have been ordering from places that make larger pizza but who knows. For the approximately $16 dollar price I felt that the pizza was certainly not worth the money. I am giving 5 stars because they have a fantastic product and staff. I'm honestly just confused as to how a large pizza was so small.

Patricia Thomas

Delicious food great service I highly recommend it I just wish instead of take out we could have sat there lively atmosphere!

Jennifer Stern

Great food and friendly staff

Davey Anthony

These guys work hard and fast. It is the busiest pizzeria in town and the lines may sometimes get long but your order will always be ready in a good amount of time. The pizza is of amazing quality, one of the best in town. I always get the chicken pizza, just a mouth full of flavor in every bite. There is plenty of parking because it is in the plaza. Parking is free and handicap parking is no more than 8 feet from the restaurant. I have never dinned in but I've always done take out, never had a complaint about anything. Very nice staff and respectful. If you are going to eat pizza anywhere in town, eat here. Take my word for it. And if you love chicken parm sandwiches, well... you're going to really love theirs, I always ask for extra sauce on the side because I like a lot of sauce in mine.

Michael Hrisca

Slices are tasty, enormous and affordable. Will return and will highly recommend.

Arlene B

Amazing food amazing people

Ken Ohern

Good food and friendly service

Lando Cruissian

This place very good. I am from out of town and a solo eater but the staff was super helpful in helping me to decide dinner options. The waitress was so nice she let me try some of their famous pizza and I can see why the place was packed very good thin and regular crust pizza. I ended up getting the recommended meal which was penne, sausage, meatballs and stuffed pork. The sauce was made in house it was absolutely delicious. I am in town for a couple of more days and I plan on stopping by for one more dinner before I head home.

Sanjay Kumar

Friendly staff and amazing food! Will definitely visit again when in town.

Tyhiame Curry

Love the pizza here and the staff is very friendly to great customer service

Deborah Robinson

I just left this restaurant and I had to sit in my car and write this review before I drove home. I am wiping the tears from my face now, due to the unfair treatment my daughter and I have just received. When I walked in, we felt the lack of professional presence in the restaurant, causing us to feel uncomfortable and not wanted. We stood at the "please wait to be seated" sign for ten minutes before we were seated. Ironically, we were immediately seated when another family stood behind us. Once seated, it took a while before we saw our server. Being that she was busy we gave her the benefit of the doubt. She took our drink orders, then left us time to look over the menu. She then handled and put orders in for all of the rest of her tables (including the tables that came after us). Again being that it was busy we said nothing. She took our food orders and we felt rushed. This feeling continued throughout our whole meal experience. We also only saw our server when she dropped our drinks and our bill off. Meanwhile we were constantly asked for plates to be removed when we were not finished with our meal. We also continued to receive looks from other servers as well as management. We felt incredibly rushed and uncomfortable. I'm not sure whether or not the employees were instructed to stand behind and beside our table and watch us eat, because no other patrons had employees at their tables watching them. After continuously being watched while eating, we packed up our food and asked another employee for the bill. (We still hadn't seen our waitress since she dropped the drinks) I have never experienced having my table cleaned before I paid the bill, therefore enhancing the feeling of being rushed. Until this establishment stops profiling its customers, I will not be eating here again. Neither will my friends nor family. I will be seeking out advice whether this is reportable to the Better Business Bureau.

Marty Roden

It was a nice place to bring a large group.

Peter F Bartelli

Very nice overall. Attentive staff. Large portions.

Paloma Lima Mayland

Best pizza! Great to celebrate birthday parties - sometimes they get really busy!

Destiny Williams

Really great pizza and customer service. My friends and I are from different places (Virginia Beach, Kansas, and D.C) so it was cool that although they don't serve alcohol, they give you the number of the liquor store across the street and you can have stuff delivered.

Nickolas Juliano

Fast service, good slices, sit down part of the restaurant is fine but you're just as good carrying out your pie

Shawna Mobley

Love the place. Great food.

Brian Boegs

best pizza i had in a long time. they told me 15 minutes for 3 pies during rush hour. i got there in 15 minutes and it was ready.

Joanna Santana

We drive almost an hr to have their award winning margarita pizza. I’ve never tasted sauce so good in my life!!

Sheldon Wilensky

A great place to dine. BYOB. Have been a. Regular for 10 years.

The Critical J

PROS: Nonnas had a nice atmosphere and good set up where you had a restaurant in the back and a grab and eat section in front. Lots of parking cause it's in a shopping center as well. The pizza was good, and there was a lot to choose from on the menu all for an affordable price. The staff is also very friendly. CONS: The pizzas crust was to thin and didn't fill me. Also, the tables were not cleaned after being used. OVERALL: I think this is a very nice, upscale pizzeria. Much better than others in the area! They aren't that sanitary but they have good quality food at a low price and nice staff to serve it!!

Anne Manganelli

The food is great but the help are not pleasant. This is not the first time i have been there. It was the same before. They should not make remarks.

Ted Johnson

Magnifico! Want the real taste of Italy? Look no further this place is fantastic and authentic. These guys are very good and take pride in their work. Like Arnold says "I'll be back"! Again and again...

Edward Coscia

Great Italian food and great service

Frank Nelson

Great food. Large portions with griendly staff.

Braiden Larsen

I really enjoyed their dishes. I always get awesome service there. The place is well organised and the cashiers are always very nice. Will come visit again.

steven lubow

Ordered chicken parm with penne pasta. Chicken and pasta were okay. Tomato sauce was cooked too long. Tasted burnt. Didn't finish (ate about 1/4) and had them toss the leftovers.

Manish Gala

Why didn't we come here earlier!! Best pizza in town. Awesome experience!!

Abel Rodriguez

Treat you like family even on the first visit. Food is phenomenal. Top off your meal with zepolis for sure.

Edward Sullivan

BYOB pizza / Italian clean , friendly service, good value.

mindy rosen

Their Margaretta pie is amazing! Crispynon bottom not too thick or thin. We taken many people there 4 pizza & dinner and everyone loves it

fierce maiden

def great pizza and a great value. only 4 stars because the azzholz who own the plaza there have six restaurants all vying for parking spaces at lunch and dinner. A FIASCO! NO PARKING SPACES! so CARPOOL if you go.

Lyndsey Q

We just moved to Florham Park/New Jersey two weeks ago. In the last two weeks we have been to Nonna’s 4-5 times due to getting settled in. Every time we came here (carry out or dine in) the entire staff was so inviting and friendly. They made us feel at home though we are so far away and made us feel so welcomed (even though they were incredibly busy). Their pizza is WONDERFUL and voted best in 21 County’s according to the signs and it shows. I had the Caprese Pizza, my husband had the Chicken Parm and we had a few other pizzas and a calzone tonight. We indulged in a wonderful local dessert which reminded me of home (the taste of beignets from NO). I love reading reviews, it’s how I base my decisions on where to eat. I noticed a review from a few days ago stating they made her cry and that they were showing favoritism and rushing her through her meal. I felt compelled to write a review due to me KNOWING that the statement is just ridiculous. There was so much diversity tonight and we were all treated with the same respect. I purposely sat back and watched their wait staff take care of their customers looking for something. I have been here before and never have I seen the behavior that this other customer is claiming to have experienced. This place is awesome and you need to try it for yourself! Keep serving your customers the way you are, you can’t please everyone but if you take care of your customers they way you did tonight then your business will be open for many years to come.

Tom Dente

Always Excellent food and service.

Lukas Nichols

Would definitely recommend trying this spot. Exceptional atmosphere, flavorful dishes, awesome service. They never disappoint.

Vanessa Rey

Delicious food. Clean, quick friendly service.

Jasmine K

I am giving this place two stars, not because of the pizza, the pizza is adequate not great but adequate. My problem is the atmosphere it is something very energetically icky about this place and to be honest when I walked in I almost walked out but of the many people and I mean many from what I can see there were at least 10 people if not more behind the counter which looked chaotic but one of them asked could I be help but the reception is not pleasant the atmosphere is not pleasant and I was in hurry to get out. I could never see myself sitting down enjoying a meal in this place because I would be too uncomfortable and this is not the first time I felt this way it is just the first time I chose to write a review and the last time I will step foot in here.

Barbara C. Walsh

Food is always great, portion sizes are just right, and prices are very good. Just once I would like to go in and use my coupon for my meal. The total cost always falls a few dollars below the minimum purchase requirement. Not worth it to pay $3 more to get $5 back.

Claudine mossberg

Delicious. Great service.

William Freeman

Terrific pasta and really great pizza. Friendly , well trained staff.

Anthony Love

OMG, best pizza and food for miles around! I stumbled on this place after a Dr appointment that's about 45 minutes from my house. I wish I lived here just so I could eat here Every day! Food is so delicious and portions very generous. A food lover's dream :)

mabel moore

Great Nonna's pizza...had 2 slices!

Parker Tanner

Awesome food, welcoming staff, consistently excellent vibes. They charge reasonable prices and the food quality is good. Fantastic work.

Janice Arterburn

Excellent food. Staff friendly. Atmosphere charming and extremely clean. Extensive menu. You won't be disappointed.

Toni Airaksinen

I didn't visit the restaurant itself, but a friend of mine picked up some pasta and pizza from Nonna's in Florham Park for us today. Overall, you usually can't go wrong with Italian food, so no complaints at all. 10/10 on the penne vodka. Good portions too.