Reviews of Gennaro's Italian Restaurant & Tomato Pies (Restaurant)

4613 Nottingham Way, Hamilton Township, NJ 08690

Average Rating:


We have all the information of real people like you who know the services of Gennaro\'s Italian Restaurant & Tomato Pies (Restaurant) in New Jersey.

As of day this business has a score of 4.4 stars over 5 and this score has been calculated on 189 reviews.

As you can read, its rating is quite high, and it is based on a very large number of scores, so we can think that the assessment is very faithful. If many people have bothered to value when they've done well, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually stop to give feddbacks when they are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or issue...

This Restaurant is classified in the category of Italian restaurant.

Where is Gennaro's Italian Restaurant & Tomato Pies?

REVIEWS OF Gennaro's Italian Restaurant & Tomato Pies IN New Jersey

John Lammond

Very good food and fair prices

Jim Poinsett

Delicious food, nice atmosphere and great service


Really great pizza, among the best in Hamilton, dining area nice with seating out side as well.

Bob Mule

Fantastic! From pizza to any veal dish!


Had only a plain cheese pizza, nothing seemingly exceptional about it.

dani a

Great Food... close to home and a byob. They really knock it out of the park here!

Rosemarie Malespina

Ordered Pasta Carbanar today and it was amazing the food is always fresh and delicious ♥️ keep up the good work

Vincent Mancuso Jr.

The food here is delicious. My favorite is the pork roast sandwich with broccoli rabe and long hots. Pizza is good as well as there entrees. The restaurant is always clean and has outside seating. The owner and workers address extremely friendly. Highly recommend trying out out.

Douglas Forman

Best food and great service. I think the pizza is much better than any around.

Roberta Goldberg

Service has been great, food was good and plentiful

Joseph Mason

Great specials!

Troy Hillery


Andrea D White

Great food and atmosphere

Annette D'Amico

I just ordered 2 antipasta salads for delivery. Before ordering, I asked what was in the antipasta. It sounded authentic, so I placed my order. The total was $22.90. I I thought it seemed pricy, but figured it would be worth it!! Major disappointment! Gennaro's s should be embarrassed to send that poor quality of food on a delivery to a customer! I looked on line to see the menu.... no fresh mozzarella, tid bit bites of provolone, salami and I think there was 1 or 2 small bits of mortadella?!!! Then to add insult to injury, the price for antipasta was $9.00 each. Do the math, $18.00 with 7% sales tax... $19.26! So if a delivery charge was added on, I wan't informed, and definately wouldn't have given a $4.00 tip to the driver!!! Very small salad, with very few ingredients for over the top money! Didn't win me over!! I'll stick with the Pizza place down the road...much more reputable!!!!

Antoinette Frost

Excellent food, friendly service, warm ambiance! You have to try it. You will not be disappointed!

Horacio Castillo

Awesome pasta with amazing service.

Mallory Salay

I used to really like their pizza but I don't think I can ever order from them again after receiving a slice of cake tonight with a giant hair in it. Disgusting.

Maggie Gallagher

Just recently there for a private party. Excellent service excellent food. Highly recommended. Will be back for dinner.

Joseph Caruso

BYOB and great food.

Skip Gamache

Food is good the prices are good service is excellent

Mo Moe

Best pies around. Jerry and his staff do an excellent job!

Maryjo Fiordaliso

Awesome. Excellent place to eat. Try the cod fish. A must.


Good food and nice environment

William Welsh

A very elegant place to eat! The owner jerry is a great person that always keeps the food well above par! Never once had a bad experience there!

Frank Davis

Wow what a great restaurant. I had the pork chops and it was fantastic. This was my second time eating here. I don't remember what I ate on my first visit but I remember leaving with a happy taste.

Heather Cammarata-Seale

One Saturday my husband and I were seriously craving some pizza. We planned on visiting DeLorenzo's Tomato Pies but discovered that they are not open for lunch on Saturdays. That is where Gennaro's came in!! We visited on a whim and we were pleasantly surprised. The restaurant itself is clean and cozy with warm yet modern decor. The salads are very large (the beet salad and cesar salad are great options) and the pizza is great. We have tried the regular and the brooklyn style and enjoyed both very much.


Pizza delivered quickly but all mush...terrible!

jimmy Henrikson

Very nice service,, and the whole staff were terrific,,, thank you so much for a fantastic family time,,,

Joe Bella

The food reminds me of some my favorite restaurants in the burg back in the old days

Jean Barone

Good food and very relaxed atmosphere. Staff is very friendly and accommodating.

Lu Hern

Good pizza and service

Paul Evans

Went there for dinner. The meal was average at best but the noise level was outrageous. People drinking,screaming and kids running around. When we asked the host to ask them to be a little quieter we were ignored. Young mothers drinking out of control then leaving to drive off with young kids. It was like being at a concert you could not hold a conversation with the people at your own table. Since the people there would rather accept this behavior I know four families that will not be returning

John Exedaktilos


John Wilbert

Service and food excellent highly recommended

Catherine Mitch

Ok, this place is a jewel. I had something called a tower of eggplant parmesan and it was incredibly delicious. Reasonable prices. I will definitely return.

Susan Conk

Friendly servers, upscale dining room, fantastic food. We were able to sit and eat without being rushed.

Eugene Bigham

Well I went here for lunch today probably around 4pm. Upon entering I could feel this unpleasant vibe. I asked for a cheesesteak. The lady that took my order appeared like she didn't even want to speak to me nor give me any service. I asked where is the dining area. Her response was you're not taking that to go. I asked am I not welcomed to eat here. She ignored my question So I went to have a seat and greeted by more unfriendly staff. I get my steak and of course my order was wrong. If the staff wasn't so stuck up and snobby they may have gotten my order correct. For 12.00 I would expected a better quality sandwich. I had better quality cheesesteaks from a local Bodega that cost 3.00 my whole experience was terrible. I highly recommend you stay clear of this place at all cost.

Renee Sapnar

Dinner was very good. Service was excellent. Very nice outdoor patio. Would go again with friends.

John Zucchetti

Pleasant surroundings! Delicious food. Moderately priced. Beautiful outdoor patio eating area. Pizza takeout is separate from Dining Room creating a comfortable dining experience!

C. Saad _

Amazing pizza! My wife and I loved the classic cheese pizza. Plenty of delicious tomato sauce, and very good quality cheese.

John S

The food is awesome the dinners are delicious you also have to try the pizza.

Mike F

I ordered a tray of chicken francese for a party at my home and I have to tell you in my 56 years it's the best I've ever had. Didn't need a knife melted in your mouth. More than enough for the amount of people I had. I hope my Italian mother-in-law doesn't see this post.

Dave Minotti

Amazing pie

Gordon Christie

Cozy atmosphere, great and balance menu and daily specials. Excellent service staff, reservations needed if large party during busy times suggested.

lex que

White Pizzia with broccoli, black olives NS garlic. Jackie had soup of the day, sausage escarole and beans. Finished it off with torturo, very good food and friendly waiter.

Manny Corti

We had Jennifer as our waitress and she was awesome along with the food!


ALways a good time - always good food. We like to eat outside. Limited number of tables so can't always get a seat.

Mark Mercurio

Zucchini appetizers were delicious the calamari was wonderful and the stuffed mushrooms I enjoyed very much!

Andy Bishop

Great Italian food...Whether you take out pizza or eat in, this place is worth a visit...I had the veal specialty dish, very good and decent portions...the price is reasonable too as our group of 6 ordered three appetizers to go along with our entre...the price was under $35 pp...overall, this restaurant offers excellent daily specials and great tomato pies...Finally a bit of NY bought to Hamilton!...only downside, the servers/busers appeared overwhelmed...our server had to be reminded more frequently than expected.

Andrea Wiener

Beautiful ambiance on the patio, terrific service and fabulous food. Looking forward to my next dinner there

Donald Peck

, loved it great food great service friendly atmosphere recommend it to anybody

Alexander King

Had an excellent time with my family over some great food at Gennaro's. Our server was very attentive and our food came in a timely manner. Can't really ask for more on a summer night on the patio here.

Garry Koch

Friendly staff, great pizza. Enjoyed it .

Kabir Aziz

Went for lunch: thumbs up.

William Feliciano

Always great food here. It's my wife's favorite! We always get the clams casino this time got this special appetizer,.it was phenomenal. It's BYO.


Excellent entrees in this hidden gem in Hamilton. Tomato pies are on point, and the homemade side chips that come with sandwiches are excellent. A bit pricey but definately worth it. Best in area by far

David Horton

Menu and specials are very good. Service is quick, efficient and friendly. BYOB. Dining area is on the small side and tends to be very noisy.

Arun Meena

Delicious pizza pies that reminds me of NYC pizzarias

Pete Donlon

Staff is always pleasant. Buffalo pizza is very good. Covered outside dining area is great.

Robert Guagliardo

Great food excellent service beautiful esthetics and you never wait long for your food either beautiful outdoor section if the weather s right never had a bad meal there the food is fresh and they have no problem if you alter a dish I always tweek the meal change ingredients

Jon Coscio

Dinner was terrific and our Server was friendly and attentive. This place is a byob.

Todd Shulman

The food was very good. The waiter didn't come over to ask if everything was alright until we were completely finished with our meal. Some waiters come over too often, this one was to standoffish.

Lisa Pichtel

Food and service were good...not enough room between tables

Brenda Lyons

A great place to enjoy dinner with friends. Being a bring your own bottle suits us just fine. Food has always been great.

Lyhanna Lopez

Great food and salads. Side of bread always seems to be stale.

Diane Dunphy

Food and service always great. Love the outside patio when weather permits.

Briana Johnson

Came here with Family & Friends for a Luncheon after a dear friend of the family funeral & the food was the best Italian Food I have ever tasted ❤️ Delicious!!! Will definitely be coming back!

Sharon Clarke

Wonderful food, atmosphere and service. Dine inside or out on covered patio. BYOB. Gluten and dairy-free options. Our favorite "in-town" restaurant for a romantic dinner or to bring guests.

john krolikowski

Just enjoyed my birthday dinner @ Gennaros! Awesome food, staff is fantastic!

Jackie B.

We went there today for lunch. Had the most amazing Lentil soup I have ever had. So good. Pizza with mushrooms & sausage. Everything was superb, especially the service. Prices are very reasonable. Atmosphere is great! We will be back!!!

Placido Mondello

Pizza suck broccoli rabe and pork sandwiches no taste very much not satisfied never come back

Melu Marsa

Nice family restaurant.

Carey H

Ate here with friends recently. Really good food but a limited menu & the portions were kinda small.

Carolyn Pridgeon

5 star

Aaron Brown

Pizza was great but the food when we went there wasn't so good. Not good and not bad will try again

Stephen Kapuscinski

Outstanding service and food waiters and waitresses ste very pleasant and courteous

Margaret Kelly

Lunch with friends. Private room yummy food and exceptional service.

Edward Cunningham

Not bad, but when you eat outside the service is a lot slower and foot traffic seems to walk through for some reason

Lyn D

One of Mercer County’s finest Italian dining gems! If you are craving authentic Italian dishes (their eggplant parm is truly out of this world), pasta or pizza to die for (their tomato sauce alone will leave your mouth watering), then look no further. And did I mention their meatballs...impeccable service and an outstanding menu. Do yourself a favor...check out Gennaro’s...take-out or dine in their cozy eating area. You will be in heaven. AMAZING!!

Marc Carlton

Amazing Fresh Food!

Carla C

I had Gennaro's cater a few items; the vodka rigatoni, eggplant rollatini, and chicken parm for my family. Everything was delicious! So thankful to Gennaro and his staff for providing the best food and service! I highly recommend Gennaro's!

Kimberly C

Never disappoints !

Tyler Hepburn

Staff was friendly and food was good my girlfriend and I will definitely be back.

Lisa Lewis

Great place very pleasant. Food is awesome

Mary Lonzetta

Great grilled octopus. Stuffed pork chop was deicious!

J Crowell

Went to this restaurant for the first time tonight. Food was fantastic (impressive, actually). Everything tasted delicious. I especially really liked the variety of specials they had to offer. I also enjoyed the decor, style, and ambiance. Not to mention, BYOB is great! The only downside was two major problems: 1. The waitress my party had was too intense and pushy to take our order. We didn't even have a chance to sit down, relax for a few minutes, decompress, socialize a little, and look over the menu before she was suddenly all over us and already on top of us, shoving the list of specials down our throats so quickly before our minds could even catch up and comprehend the information she was feeding us. She also jumped at the opportunity to open both our bottles of wine without asking and before even giving us a chance to decide which bottle we wanted opened. I had to stop her before it was too late. Calm down girl! Pump the breaks! Don't get carried away. Not everyone is in such a hurry and wants to be rushed through their dinner service. You don't need to turn over our table to the next guests that badly. 2. It was extraordinarily hot and humid outside today. We were looking forward to eating inside, where we thought there would be air conditioning to provide us with the relief we needed and a refreshing atmosphere. Well unfortunately, the temperature was just as uncomfortable inside as it was outside because all the windows were open. We inquired why and found out that their air conditioning is broken! Seriously?! On Memorial Day Weekend, which is the beginning of Summer heat?! Temperatures are obviously only going to get worse. So PLEASE do yourselves and your guests a favor by getting your air conditioning fixed ASAP. Customers can't fully enjoy the experience of a meal, while sitting and sweating inside of a sauna. And your kitchen staff were probably in agony as well, so I'm sure they would appreciate a functioning HVAC system. I look forward to going back and eating here again, but hopefully with a different server and only with working AC.

Robin Adams

Gennaro's is one of our family's favorite places to go. The food is great and always friendly staff. I recommend giving it a try.

Bill Tauriello

Good menu, nice atmosphere.

Business Hours of Gennaro's Italian Restaurant & Tomato Pies in New Jersey



Gennaro's Italian Restaurant & Tomato Pies en New Jersey
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Restaurant - New Jersey

Sports bar

Jeju Noodle Bar
Jeju Noodle Bar
Restaurant - New Jersey

Korean restaurant

Koja Cuisine Korean BBQ and Sushi
Koja Cuisine Korean BBQ a...
Restaurant - New Jersey

Korean barbecue restaurant

Mack's American Bar & Grill
Mack's American Bar & Grill
Restaurant - New Jersey

Bar & grill

Town Bar + Kitchen
Town Bar + Kitchen
Restaurant - New Jersey