Reviews of Sugarfire Smoke House - Indy (Restaurant)

24 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States

Average Rating:

DESCRIPTION

We've got the reviews of real people like you who are purchasing the products and services of Sugarfire Smoke House - Indy (Restaurant) in Indiana.

At present this business has a score of 4.5 stars over 5 and this score has been calculated on 460 reviews.

You may have noticed that it reaches an feddbacks average is basically the best one, and it's founded on a very high number of scores, so we may conclude that the rating is quite credible. If people have bothered to give their review when they are pleased, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually stop to set reviews when these are positive and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Restaurant belongs to the category of Barbecue restaurant.

Where is Sugarfire Smoke House - Indy?

REVIEWS OF Sugarfire Smoke House - Indy IN Indiana

Errin Davis

Met my BF here for lunch. Cool atmosphere, food is ready to go which helps with short lunch breaks and it is good. I had to 6oz smoked turkey sandwich and couldn't eat it all. Wonderful, friendly service, with a cool decor. I will definitely be back!

Sonya Tyler

When you're looking for that little hole in the wall that the locals go to... Look no further than this awesome BBQ joint. They hand make everything, and when it's out, it's out. At 7pm, we were too late for the ribs, which I know must have been awesome. But the pulled pork and brisket were amazing. They also have a selection of locals beers and homemade sodas (which are also great).

Sarah Morris

LOVED this place. We were in town for a convention and I must say the bbq was delish. I would highly recommend this place as a must go to.

Derek Wheeler

I love the food

Gregg Salyers

Why 5 stars? I took my 13 year old son there last Saturday and he has asked to go back everyday since. It’s that good.

Chris Boyd

Good food but expensive to eat. The coleslaw sucks don't get has no flavor. Taste like a salad with no dressing.

T J

Brisket is tasty, like the different sauce options. Red beans and rice also good.

Scott Metz

Food was great. Staff was great. Menu is almost overwhelming.

Richard Puckett

Beef brisket very good however soda selection sucks

mixay s

Bbq meat was nice but not best. Friendly staff and cleN restaurant.

Reid Mcnally

The bbq was great. Loved it. Had the pulled pork and the brisket both were excellent. The staff was friendly and courteous. The place was clean from top to bottom.

Brian Taylor

I got the special which was a burger with shredded smoked pork, fried jalepenos, fried onion straws, and hot sauce.... Top 5 burgers I have ever had.

Carlos Rodriguez

Food was good just a little pricey. The key lime time was yummy.

brian kalinowski

I smoke/cook myself for my family so I'm always inquisitive about others .Great food and people working there.

Oralia Ahmad

Great food, but the staff werent very friendly and we felt rushed so they could clean up and close up

Ransford Walker

They make their own bbq sauces and sodas. Great place to eat.

Kenneth Abbott

It wasn't what I would call bad. The ribs and brisket were just on the dry side. The sauces were good, as well as the squash and horseradish potato salad. Unfortunately, for the price, I don't recommend it.

Ian Marrs

Great food, but if you're in a party and someone orders a burger they're going to be in for a wait while others get their food right out of some hot plates.

Marc Mott

The turkey was nice, and the brisket was moist.

Johannes Setiabudi

Awesome ribs, flavorful hush puppies, and good sauces!

Alisa Schwartz

People were friendly food was Good. Had the ribs. They were a little bit to spicey for my taste. Added some of their sweet sauce and it helped some. Husband had Brisket and it was delicious! Beans, fries and coleslaw was also good.

Jordan Lawrence

Delicious food with a cozy vibe

Travis Briggs

This was such good BBQ I returned the next day, I enjoyed the choice of sauce and thought the Brisket was amazing

Lachele Jones

The brisket was tender and delicious, the pulled pork was smokey and flavorful. There was a great variety of BBQ sauces. The pecan pie alone was phenomenal... nothing but pecans. Highly recommend. Did I mention the pecan pie???

Shane H

If you know Pappys, then you need to know sugarfire. Easily up there w the best

Aron Parker

Very friendly service. Delicious ribs

Aiman Siddique

I order briskets cheese steak and i got a portion size difficult to finish. Taste was good too

Kevin Perkins

Was impressed with food especially the brisket. They did forget my fry however and the pulled pork hush puppies were over cooked. But overall really good. I will go back.

Brian Fedje

Excellent puked pork sandwich with either Honey Badger or Sweet St. Louie sauce. The Southwest corn and beans side was also good.

Ed Kloppenburg

Brisket and pulled pork was very good. Had the beans and Cole slaw for sides. The beans were great. The cole slaw was like eating raw cabbage no taste or dressing too weak. They give you a lot of food.

jacob eve

The food here is amazing,the drinks are even better. I love this place and would like t ok come more often.

Tom Empie

I am typically a brisket lover but this brisket was sort of dry. Flavor was just ok, and dry. Another issue I experienced was the temperature in the restaurant.. I am normally the person in the group that likes it cooler than everyone else. This time it was so cold in there I was even uncomfortably cold and this also made my meal cold very quickly. The first few bites of my meal (brisket, mac n cheese, green beans) were warm, after that, stone cold. I have eaten at a sugarfire in St. Louis, much better experience there.

Joe Johnson

This is one of the best BBQ restaurants I've eaten at in a while...super clean, very friendly staff. In fact I was undecided on what to order and the manager gave me samples of everything I was considering. Would recommend to anyone, oh yeah, the sauces!!! Tons of different sauces to try!! Also, all the pickles and peppers you care to eat. My only complaint is I wish there was one in Plainfield where I live...I'll be back many more times...cool music too!

Megan Rittenhouse

Delicious food. The sandwiches are huge! Also their sodas are amazing. Cant wait to go back and try the pie milkshakes and other smoked meats.

felderpetra

Always a pleasure to eat here! They are big on satisfaction; and they deliver just that! The taste and quality of the food will not disappoint!

Lauren Simmons

Great food. Good environment

N Brothers

I thought their service was top notch and the food was amazing. Super accommodating to families. If you like comfort food, I can’t think of a better spot.

Carl Schuett

It's awesome BBQ. Prices aren't bad. The pulled pork was good, but the brisket was a slam dunk. The chicken hash was another standout side.

John Petelle

Great atmosphere, friendly staff, delish food

Rojen Jacob

Love the food. Love the atmosphere, awesome service.

jomo cole

Their ribs were very tender like I fix my ribs and I haven't tasted rib's like theirs since King Ribs when they first hit the seen in Indianapolis! Less rub on the ribs would have given them a 5 Star rating for me, but it was a little salty for my taste, cause I don't use salt on any of my food! I will be going back for more real soon! Thanks Sugarfire Ribs for a wonderful experience!

Carol Sylvester

We had great food and raccoon red beer. The staff was AWESOME!!! Such a good experience.

Angel Warman

Awesome food, Brisket Cheesesteak,fries.Cherry cobbler. Fish Sandwich, greens.

Jeff Reynolds

We were in town for the NRA convention and set out from the hotel to find something to eat on Friday evening. I'm always in the market for someone else's take on BBQ so this seemed to be an excellent choice. The line was out the door when we got there so that was a good sign. After our part of the line made it inside, they put a sign on the door stating that they were out of everything. The portions were huge and the BBQ and sides were good but not spectacular. The soda fountain was either some type of local stuff or generic, I'm not sure which. I can't drink beer but I probably would have enjoyed that more than the sodas that they had. All in all, pretty good BBQ and I was definitely satisfied when I left.

Jill Clark

Love it! Pecan, blue cheese, bacon slaw a must, but everything is terrific and the staff are friendly and helpful. If you are visiting dont miss this place.

nishe abellana

Staff was great. I ordered the salmon but was undercooked. Staff solved the issue immediately and was very apologetic. Things happen, I get it. The manager personally apologized and made sure they gave me a fresh order. He also gave me 2 free meals for next time.

Ariella Tunstill

This food was amazing!! They have different specials and sides that change, and other choices that are always available. I got the smoked pork belly and they let me try it before I got it. It was melt in your mouth tender but crispy ends.They are really friendly, fast, and delicious. Will be returning and recommending!

Timothy M Schwenk

Second visit. First wasn't what I was expecting with an Indiana tenderloin. Was good but do not believe it classifies as a typical Indiana tenderloin. On this trip, got a half rack. Good flavor and love the sauce. With the temperature was just a bit warmer. I know it can't sit on heat as it will dry out but a few seconds over open flame may have made the difference.

travis roland

Some of the best ribs I've ever had. Wife and I got the baby daddy with ribs brisket and pork. Meats and sides are awesome bbq sauces and drinks are great too. Highly recommend

Donna Long

Awesome BBQ. Small place, but good service.

fish man

I will definitely be back for more. Very good food. All 7 of my kids loved it too.

Michael Canton

Neat place for a quick bbq fix. The menu here is massive with something for everyone ranging from smoked turkey to ribs. We tried the brisket, ribs, pulled pork and sausage. Excellent smoke flavor. They offer a wide variety of sides and numerous sauces if you must. Will definitely come back soon. Highly recommended.

Nick S

The BBQ is great. Tender pulled pork with some good sauce selections to try. Mac and cheese is amazing. You get good portions for the money. Also have some unique sodas on tap.

S Plekker

Juicy pulled pork and the Turkey was moist. Hard to find places that really do up Turkey without drying it out. A bit on the pricey side for the size of their portions. All and all it was tasty.

Adam Dixon

I've been twice, deliberately getting different items each time and everything has been great except the pork belly hush puppies. No pork belly at all inside them and no extra flavor there either. They were just hushpuppies.

Kalamity Deschain

I walked over for lunch today after being mesmerized by the chicken biscuit on the online menu. It certainly came to me looking exactly as pictured on the menu - which is a huge plus. I loved the fried chicken, light and airy but really crunchy. Seasoning was good, but I felt the sauce was a little lackluster. I loved the flavor, but it was missing some oomph, I really wanted it to have more of a kick. The biscuit was yummy and short in texture like a biscuit should be. The honey butter... mmmmmm. Very good compliment to the chicken and sauce. I felt a tad uncomfortable after I ordered because staff seemed to be upset - or something - after I ordered the biscuit. The front line cook called back for the biscuit and then a flurry of "really, come on" and other similar reactions came through. I may have misinterpreted what this meant and maybe they were talking about something else, but I didn't enjoy feeling like my order was a burden. I will be back, though, because this was my first visit and I enjoyed the food. Edit: Thanks to the owner for a very kind response back. I appreciate the clarification :)

Kelvin Miliner

Decent food nice friendly service

aaron hurley

Walked over on lunch. The special was the Cuban Reuben, and it was an amazing sandwich - the buns were two grilled cheese sandwiches, and they stuffed different kinds of meat between. It was amazing! It was also huge. It came with a side. The beans were okay compared to the sandwich. I could only eat half because of the size... Lunch tomorrow! This makes the cost better. It is on the pricey side, but divided over two lunches, and it's not too bad.

elizabeth morin

We were there around 1 pm July 3/19 The fellow working was very rude no customer service skills.After spending over $200 I will never come back.Our friends were in shock of our treatment. Please send your employees to training.

Erin Davidson

Awesome staff and equally awesome food! Ribs are excellent and chicken biscuit is hot fire. All sides are excellent and they even through in an extra dessert! Highly recommend!

Jim P

Had lunch here on a Saturday and ordered the large sampler plate. The meats were all well prepared and the sauces made for a nice mix of options. I wasn't impressed by the side dishes I tried which included the green beans and the hash browns.

Jared Staudenmeier

Sugarfire has an atmosphere and decor that is best describe as retro. Their food, similarly, should have stayed in the past. Or, maybe, in the trash with the burned hush puppies. The food isn’t competitively priced to other BBQ places in Indy for what is, all in all, a similar quality. The presentation of any given dish can be hit or miss at best. Let’s also not start on the broken soda machine with two choices out of order, a third that you have to manually stop by pulling the plunger back forward, and only offers non-traditional off brands that don’t taste quite right. And perhaps the most agregious offense. Why in the would you cover smoked, slow cooked brisket in processed, nacho cheese that coalesces into a congealed mess, soaking into every part of an untoasted, broken hoagie after mere minutes?

Jason Bowers

For a BBQ themed restaurant the burger was way better than expected. It does feel like the business model is trying to profit as much $ from you as possible if you look for the clues.

Tim Poole

Real good food and service

Leighanne Heidlebaugh

Best BBQ in Indy and their sides are fire too

Beverly Kersey

Awesome! Classy facility and top of the line menu. I look forward to my return visit.

Travis Stone

Got there just as they were closing. Still made my family good food and was fairly friendly. The meats are wonderful and flavorful with a good range of BBQ sauces. Cafeteria style ordering. Pretty expensive for what you get though. Overall, clean place with neat atmosphere and good food, though a bit over priced.

Duane Merchant

I am normally in direct opposition to Chain Barbecue. HOWEVER, this appears to be that exception, a place which crafts it's BBQ, and has sides that are like my Aunts in Va., WVa., or Detroit would put out. (Really Good.) Their Brisket is very good!

Brittney

Super yummy BBQ! It's a quick stop downtown Indy. The menu has a wide selection without being overwhelming. You order and pay first, then find your table. The sauce bottles on the table are unique and if you like them, you can buy a bottle for $5. I got a pulled pork sandwich (granted my picture only shows half of it as I ate half before taking the picture). The fries were fried right after I ordered. I will definitely go back to try more food!

Tony Grenat

Very cool location! The best bbq in Indy!

Dan Dripps

Finally made a trip here to give this place a try. The food was fantastic. I had a Brisket Cheesesteak sandwich that was absolutely delicious. It was very messy (which I expected), I ended up eating with a fork because the bread was not much help. Hey also have a great selection of BBQ sauces on the table to choose from. The Coffee BBQ sauce and the Cherry Berry BBQ sauce were my favorite. Really different options. The reason I give them 4 stars is for two main reasons: 1) The price was a bit high for most items. The sandwich I got was $12 and didn’t come with a side, which I didn’t realize until after I ordered. 2) It was slightly confusing to order and know what to do from there. It was a bit hectic up front so I ended up standing awkwardly for a minute or two along with a couple other patrons who had no idea what to do as well. Overall, it was well worth the visit and I would recommend it to anyone.

Geoff lawson

Great food... The ribs are amazing

Brad Bryant

Loved it!! Food was great! Staff was friendly and you definitely won't leave hungry!! I can't wait to get back to Indianapolis again so I can try some of the other stuff!

Christina Niles

Staff is very friendly. Place is nice... But food is meh... Ribs were really difficult to eat. Had to struggle to get the meat off the bone... And taste wasn't really worth the work. Got scalloped potatoes and green beans.... Both sides weren't great. I'd maybe go back to try something new... But completely underwhelmed with the food I got.

Keith Jones

The manager, and his staff go all out to make the experience is a good one. An unexpected glut in business caused him not to have a whole pie to sell. He did allow me to buy two half pies for the whole pie price.

Darlene Hooks

The food was amazing. The atmosphere was pleasant and the staff was very friendly.

Eric Jenkins

Very good Food and nice portions. You will enjoy this place. Staff was very friendly as well

Niko

We tried four St. Louis ribs just as a teaser and we were blown away.

t9190kp

Grew up in Texas so I'm kinda picky about my 'Que but this place and Hank's on MLK (He's from Texas!) has the best brisket I've had in Naptown!

Heather Spaw

First time at this awesome little gem! Hands down some of the best comfort food I've had in years. Worth the price and portions are big enough the cost isn't even a factor. I got the three meat plater and mac and cheese. Also save room for the smoked chocolate chip cookies. Definitely worth the drive downtown!

David Dozier

Good bbq, wasn't a fan of the sides (fritters and grits), fries will be my go to on my return.

Laura Horstkamp

Creative food. Fabulous flavors.

Thomas Rosario

It is a chain, but it is worth going for, they do offer meals or meats only, sold by weight. Toppings are free but sides are extra. They change thier sides daily, go for the cornbread which is amazing. They also have thier own sodas and iced teas which is a great difference form the standard Coke or Pepsi everywhere. All their sauces are on each table so you can try them all.

L Wilson

The mac n cheese is to die for! Great service, awesome atmosphere and amazing food! Cant wait to return.

Tiger Woodz

Love Sugarfire, excellent meats. Had pulled pork sandwich which was on point. This is the first time eating at this location in Indy. Comparable to the one in St. Louis , but STL takes the cake on desert. Sides are good especially the baked beans and corn bread. It's a must if you like smokey flavors.

Beverley Holeman

We ordered the salmon plate and the two meat platter. Good food and good side dishes. The four sauce choices were on the table. Staff was friendly and helpful. Prices are between $10-$20. Will come again.

Urbane Streets

Good brisket. Wish the 8oz plate came with a bit of bread or corn bread. The raved about collards were good & bad, just depended on on level of salt they added to the pot but did not mix well today. Amazing pecan pie, so many nuts it crumbled at my bite. And do get the smazzle fruit sauce side its tasty.

Shane Vaughan

Overall very good BBQ. The pork was 5-star. The ribs were 4 star. The brisket was 3 or 4 star. Brisket is hit it miss, it is good but needs better crust and moister control. The brisket was a bit dry and lacking the classic smoke, fat and bark. They do know how to cook brisket b/c some days it is better than others. Great atmosphere! Overall highly recommended.

Steve Kupitz

Good restaurant. The interior is really cool and the location is great. The only reason for not giving five stars was because the ribs are just okay. I think they might have been sitting in the heat rack for a little while so they were fairly tough. I would go back to try the brisket or pulled pork because it looks really good.

Nora Jaramillo

Great bbq, wine maybe 6 kind of beers, lemonade yummy cornbread also

Philip Wickline

Great brisket. My wife and I got the Carolina style and loved it.

Aaron Makaiwi

We ordered the Meat Daddy and shared. Amazing platter with the right amount of smoke! Great establishment! Good vibe

Root User

A solid 4 stars. A bit disappinted with the food served a bit cool on two different occasions.

AwesomeDiamond

Great food... great environment... very happy we decided to try it

Amber Toomer

Decent food, amazing sauce, good service but a bit overpriced.

S L

Visiting from Cleveland and man this Bbq is amazing!! Had the turkey and ribs, so tender. Sides were great and the sauce ... I need to take some home! Open one in Cleveland PLEASE!! Locals are lucky to have his gem!!

Shawn Spiva

Great food right in the heart of downtown

Jessica Davis

The best BBQ AROUND! GREAT MEAT

John Dorning

Authentic St Louis BBQ and it’s fantastic! The atmosphere is fun and the service is spot on. Highly recommend SugareFire

Paul Gaddie

Very good brisket and ribs and pulled pork. Great sides and a great staff. Very helpful and friendly. Would definitely come back for more.

Norma Grimaldo

In the heart of downtown Indianapolis is a great location. I felt it was a bit pricey. BBQ meats taste really good but I feel they are served cold, would have preferred hot. Side dishes are better than others.

Helen Brent

Omg, the sauces are fantastic and the baked beans are the bomb. Wish I lived closer!

D. H.

It is exactly alright. In Indy it's the best barbeque but that's an easy achievement. Their restaurant offers a wide variety of sauces at the table. Their meats are smoked on premise. The serving sizes are big and their staff is friendly. However, their prices are high after you add a side and drink, their smoked meats have little to no smoke flavor, and their pork tenderloin is the worst I've ever had (too thick, heavy pork flavor, and literally dripping in oil).

Gene Strother

Good stuff for not-Texas BBQ.

Christina Carroll

Overwhelmingly Underwhelming. The decor is great, but it is a City BBQ walk up joint. They picked the chicken off my ceasar salad (I ordered sans chicken ... Thank goodness I don't have an allergy) and forgot the croutons. Also forgot the jalapeno sauce for the hush puppies (the part most excited to try). The staff was dressed in basically pajamas. Husband's food was good (cheese steak). Turkey sandwich was good. Glazed carrots were horrible. Nerds milkshake rocked but honestly $8 is higway robbery. Would I eat there again ... Yes. Was I disappointed in the high price, the tip being preset to 25%. (insulting when they don't serve you and I had take out), and the forgetfulness of items in my order ... Yes, Yes, Yes

Tyler Gassman

This place is DOPE. I miss Austin barbecue like a long lost sibling, and this is the closest I've come to filling that Texas sized barbecue hole since being back in Indiana. You should go, and you should take me with you. Also - the manager, Greg, is awesome, and this restaurant is now known in my office as "Greg's place"

R. B.

Sweet baby jesus this place is good! I had their brisket and pulled pork with fries, coleslaw, and key lime pie. ZERO COMPLAINTS. Slap your mamma good. It is delicious southern bbq. LOVE.

Scott Knechtel

Great food, only downside was that they were out of fries during lunch hour. Not a real complaint cause other sides are great

Dave Smith

They serve an excellent pulled pork sandwich.

A.J. Johnson

This place is a hip joint that has a unique spin on bbq. It is busy during lunchtime, but you will enjoy the food and the many different sauces provided. The smoked cookie was good as well.

Gritch Lew

Hands down THE BEST Salmon I have ever tasted in my life!!! If this inspires you to try their Salmon Sandwich, you won't be dissapointed. I think it went marvelously well with the Honey Badger sauce.

Ken Groen

Super tasty, all three meats I tried were fantastic. Great smoke, quality meat. Sides were delicious. Expected a little more for the $ in quantity only, but it didn't detract from the experience. Will definitely go again.

Diane McKern

Very good food! Very delicious! Staff very friendly!

Andrew Ragland

Good service, great food. Nice selection of options for people who cannot eat beef or pork (I have weird food allergies). Decent draft beer selection. No frills seating and amenities, like a barbecue joint ought to be. A little pricey but the location must be costing them a fortune.

Ольга Демидова

The brisket was too dry, but the turkey was unexpectedly perfect. Long line, nice staff, a bit cold inside.

Allan McNabb

Amazing BBQ in an outstanding setting.

Steven Wolk

Amazing BBQ - Maybe the best I've had!

Jamie Gregory

Great food. Served fresh and hot. All sides are amazing. Brisket and ribs are a forever personal favorite

Nolynn Reese

Get the Matt Meat you wont be dissappointed

Richard Greathouse

Not really into spicy/ BBQ type foods but, food was really good there. Staff was friendly and place was very clean. Really enjoyed it!

Katrina Starks

Best BBQ I have had in a long time!!

Gary Bishop

The brisket had a good smoke ring and flavor. I had the white BBQ sauce. The sauce was a bit vinegar forward and you could only taste a hint of the horseradish, but it still had a good flavor profile that paired well with the brisket. The place does not have coke or Pepsi, instead there are sodas from the smaller soda makers. I was also impressed how the menu of sides changes everyday.

Prateek Pawar

This is a good smokehouse BBQ place. We had the chicken sandwich, the ribs and the salmon. The ribs stood out. The corn was great...soaked in butter but still yummy. The Mac and cheese looked great, will try next time.

Jake Valdez

It was ok, has some cool sides that I have never had before in a barbq restuarant before however the pulled pork was extremely dry and flavorless. Maybe it was just a bad day for them. Neat environment tho. Good prices on meals.

Reed Woll

Great food and great atmosphere. Smoked turkey was the best. Rootbeer floats are amazing too! The vanilla ice cream was incredible.

Lloyd

Pretty tasty barbecue. Not the best I've ever had, but definitely worth multiple visits. I also had the fried artichoke, those were a very tasty alternative to fries. There wasn't much room for sitting but that is probably a testament to the popularity of the the place.

Pam Doremus

This place is great! As a vegan in the Midwest, it can be hard to find good food that is not a selection of side dishes. This place has the best, most thoughtful vegan sandwich I've ever eaten . The mushrooms are smoked (which I've never had before), onions caramelized, fresh lettuce pickles and tomatoes . I'm not a big fan of dressing and can't eat cheese, so I omitted those ingredients. The sandwich was sloppy and the absolute best meal I ate in my four days in Indianapolis. The staff was friendly and really made my day . My lunch companions had other, meatier dishes, but all of us thought I won the best order prize.

Tarita Segers

Fantastic! Great food and customer service.

Chris Schenck

This is one of the best barbecue places I've been. It's a must-stop restaurant whenever I'm in Indianapolis.

Todd Klingerman

The brisket is amazing! I also highly recommend the jalapeño cheddar sausage link. I was kinda skeptical about cheddar inside the sausage, as I have never liked the hot dogs with cheese inside them, but they have an awesome sausage! This one of my top 5 bbq restaurants in Indy!!!

Oscar Tipton

Very dissatisfied. I spent about 80 dollars for some good bbq. I have seen the guy on put Masters and beat Bobby flay so I thought this would be awesome. Brisket was dry and they tried to cut very thick slices so it would not fall apart. Ribs were not good. Sausage was ok. But the turkey was actually the best I ever had. And the potatoe salad taste like they got it in a container at Krogers. But the service was really nice. I did ask the cutter for some fatty brisket and he had no idea what I was talking about.

Vanessa Daniels

Good service and good food

K Stephens

Brisket was tender. Pulled pork was juicy & smoky. Mac & cheese was exceptionally good in the peach cobbler was clearly made from fresh peaches and not canned so it was delicious. Highly recommended.

Jennifer Manterfield

Really delicious BBQ! The staff were great and helpful too.

Amy Gilleland

My husband and I split the Meat Daddy platter. It comes with brisket, turkey, pork, ribs, and a jalapeño cheddar smoked sausage. We had green beans and hash brown casserole. The brisket was amazing!!! The smoked turkey was also really good. My husband loved the pork. We both liked the sausage. The ribs had good flavor, but they were not overly tender. The hash browns were amazing! The green beans would’ve been better without the bbq sauce and maybe some other flavors instead. Nice dining experience. The staff was good.

Charles B. Hamlyn

Great food, fast service.

Ryan McBride

Nice staff. Good food. The sides are great.

Mike Wainwright

Good atmosphere, good service. The food is good. THEY HAVE SWEET TEA YAWL!!

David Merris

Bit pricy if you get a desert, and the sweet tea is super sweet, but excellent food.

William Barnett

Amazing experience! That Brisket is something special! Mac N Cheese & Baked Beans are both great as well!

Mike Gibson

Eat some delicious meat!! Great sides! Lovely place.

Rob Horton

Today was New Years day, and we expected that anywhere we went we would get inferior service or quality. Then we decided to try a new BBQ place that we had never been to. Sugarfure has GREAT food! Everything was tasty, I suspect they were a bit understaffed, but they got the food out faster than anyone could have expected. They have neat varieties of soft drinks, and the BBQ sauce was great as well. We will definately be back, our family is so glad we found this spot. Eveyone in my picky family gave a thumbs up.

Debbie Lane

I'm not a big fish food lover, but they have the best smoked salmon that I've ever tasted. They also make fresh pork rinds and they are delicious.

Alex Rutkowski

Just like the location in St. Louis - Amazing barbecue. I got the meat daddy and man, it did not disappoint. The pulled pork was probably the star of the meat quintet, but all were excellent and super smoky. They have a great variety of sauces at the table and you can vary things up depending on the meat or your mood. I prefer the sweet and smoky BBQ sauce, but my friends enjoyed the hotter varieties.

Mark M

Good Solid BBQ restaurant. 2 Meat Combo + 2 sides and a soda is only $17. Portions are big enough but not huge. The taste was spot on. Only reason for a 4 star review was the soda was not great. The Real sugar Cane Cola does not taste like Pepsi / Coke. The other Soda Options didn't look great either.

Richard Blanke

My favorite BBQ outside of Texas! Great quality, variety and service.

Michelle Bush

Delicious

Karen Mears

Excellent food and very reasonably priced. Great staff!

Clarence Jones

Portabello mushroom burger slid all over the place. The smoky flavor was legit. The chicken biscuit was okay.

Zach Bailey

Food is excellent quality and staff are always friendly. The prices are a bit expensive but overall not that much more compared to other similar restaurants.

Charles Fitts

Best smokehouse in Indy. Make sure you get there before they run out

Marcus Moore

So the wife brought home some pulled pork and brisket yesterday. Damn, that's how bbq is done If I had some of that on my forehead I'd probably beat my brains out with my tongue trying to get it.

Chase Sillery

Always so, so good and well worth the money spent and 10 minute wait in line. Highly recommend the Mac n' Cheese, probably the best available downtown and the pulled pork sandwich. They have 6 ounce and 8 ounce sandwich portion options and I always leave super stuffed. Was only $22 for 2 combos with a side and drink each, so a good deal for a great lunch. They have several sauces at the table and they have their own line of soda, so you won't find a Coke or Mountain Dew, but their root beer and cherry cola soda is really good.

Robert Cox

Great food! Thank you for supporting Law Enforcement.

Howard Griffith

Has to resort to using employees under fake names to attack competition. Trolling Facebook to attack competitions customers. Sad way to get your name out there. Will not risk eating here.

Derick Eberbach

Most of the time it has been pretty good. You need to ensure if you ask for the brisket to ensure it is 'trim cut.' Otherwise you'll get a truckload of fat. Last time I was there it was 40% fat, not what I want to spend my money on.

savanah brown

Awesome food. Nice staff

Jeremy Hawkins

Everything was amazing. Discovered my new favorite soda. Will be back.

Business Hours of Sugarfire Smoke House - Indy in Indiana

SUNDAY
11AM–9PM
MONDAY
(COLUMBUS DAY) 11AM–9PM HOURS MIGHT DIFFER
TUESDAY
11AM–9PM
WEDNESDAY
11AM–9PM
THURSDAY
11AM–9PM
FRIDAY
11AM–9PM
SATURDAY
11AM–9PM

PHONE & WEBPAGE

Sugarfire Smoke House - Indy en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage

PICTURES






Others also saw
Kobe Japanese Steakhouse
Kobe Japanese Steakhouse
Restaurant - Indiana

Japanese restaurant

Meridian Restaurant & Bar
Meridian Restaurant & Bar
Restaurant - Indiana

New American restaurant

Howl at the Moon Indianapolis
Howl at the Moon Indianap...
Restaurant - Indiana

Bar

Amar India Restaurant
Amar India Restaurant
Restaurant - Indiana

Indian restaurant

Piloni's Italian Restaurant
Piloni's Italian Restaurant
Restaurant - Indiana

Italian restaurant