Reviews of Piloni's Italian Restaurant (Restaurant)

1733 Lafayette Ave, Terre Haute, IN 47804

Average Rating:


We have all the reviews of people who are consuming the products of Piloni\'s Italian Restaurant (Restaurant) in Indiana.

As of day this business receives a score of 4.6 stars out of 5 and this score is based on 528 reviews.

As you can read, the average score it has is almost the best one, and it is founded on a very high number of scores, so we can conclude that the assessment is very accurate. If people have bothered to give their opinion when they've done well, it works.

You know that we do not usually stop to put tatings when these are positive and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Restaurant corresponds to the category of Italian restaurant.

Where is Piloni's Italian Restaurant?

REVIEWS OF Piloni's Italian Restaurant IN Indiana

Mike Russell

Food was awesome, great service too!!

No Bull

Cozy atmosphere. Professional wait staff. My Spaghetti with Meat Sauce and Meatballs was dry. Lots of meat though.The Caesar Salad and Tuxedo Cake were both great. The sweetened iced tea, not so much. I would eat here again.

Deb Stephens

Great lunch menu. Priced right for the ambience and food..The service was prompt and professional

Ben Rice

Some of the best Italian food I've ever had. No need to go to the "big city" to get great food.

Debbie Martin

Found this really good restaurant off the beaten path. On our way back from a conference, we took a chance on this place and it was well worth it. Great food and great service. I will be back!

Yang Zhang

Best food in terre haute

Andrew Zamani

Great atmosphere, great food, great service.

katelyn kidwell

Was so amazing!! The fettuccine was KILLER. Highly recommend! Also my waiter Cameron was such a delight. Definitely deserves a bonus check for such good work! Favorite restaurant in Terre Haute no doubt.

Luke Knight

Great place for a date or any special occasion.


Delicious homemade Italian food. Inexpensive and delicious! Better than Olive Garden BY FAR!!!

Robert Job

The food was amazing. It was our first time there, but we definitely plan on returning. Everyone was raving about their meal

cole {rocksalt}

Always a family favorite and brings such great memories

Mark Arndt

Recommend eating in the bar if you can - more atmosphere. Ate in dining room which was not nearly as nice. Food good.

Sharon Hathaway

We had the eggplant parmesan sandwich with homemade potato chips and the ravioli spinachi in a creamy tomato sauce and tuxedo cake for dessert ...Delicious meal

Michael Clarey

Great service and great food. We all like our food choices. Prices are reasonable.

Christine Funk

Food and service were great!

Sandy Davis

The service was a bit snobby, the food was about to a medium to bland.

Denise Dages

Randomly close restaurant the entire family would enjoy at the end of day trip to Terre Haute. Amazingly polite, accommodating, prompt service, food was amazing, portions were large especially for the price.

Ryan Breen

All four of us ordered different things and all entrees were excellent! Great authentic Italian food.

Angie Lewis Mccarter

Great people. Great Italian food. Highly recommend


This Place Get's A Much Deserved 5

David Floyd

Best Italian food in the city....can not recommended highly enough

Josh Singer

Me and both the friends that came with me had a pretty awful experience. The food tastes great, but within about an hour of eating it we were all very sick from it. Probably will give them one more try.

Chris Hawley

Great service but the food was terrible, spaghetti tasted like beefaroni outta a can!

Kurt Heintz

In my opinion Piloni's has the best Italian food in Terre Haute. The atmosphere is wonderful and the service is friendly and attentive. Plenty of parking to. I would feel comfortable in jeans or a suit and the prices are very reasonable. Every visit has been a pleasant experience.

James Dantuma

The food is a reasonable price. The marinara is delicious. Waiting is fast. 5 stars!!!

Taya Dianna

Good family restaurant. Smaller menu. Quick service. A little pricey.

Jan Day

We had dinner here last night and it was maybe one of the best meals I have ever had. We all had different specials. We ate and wanted to clean our plates, it just wasn’t possible. The atmosphere and the authentic dishes were fabulous.

Mike L

Good Italian food for the local area, with fairly large portions. Wide selection of drinks, and very good desserts. Some more unique Italian dishes and several specials to choose from. Good service and friendly staff.

Denise Knezevich

Great office Christmas party! We were a group of 20 and the service was right on. The food, Mmmm, delicious.


Ok kind of pricy average food

LuAnn Carpenter

Food is pretty good. Service is good.

Cathie Pantoja Price RN

From the moment you enter you are enmeshed in smells, taste and are welcomed into the Piloni’s family. The staff is knowledgeable on the cuisine, wines and offer first class service to complete your dining experience. Pedro and his family treat you like family but better. Everything is made to order and from only the freshest ingredients. You can order from the menu, or family style. Reservations accepted. Open for lunch and dinner.

Tracy Lee

Food is amazing and it's so romantic excellent service

Adam Dixon

The noodles are homemade and the sauces were delicious. But that was the only great thing I could say about this place. The atmosphere is lacking. The place felt dingy, though I couldn't figure out why. And the breadsticks that are free to the table were bland and looked like they were purchased from a food supplier, not made fresh.

Docial Porter

Pasta is good

Joshua Bear

Great service. Nice atmosphere. Incredible food. Will most definitely be going back.

lincoln peterson

Fantastic food, great service. Definitely worth a visit!! Try the Tomato Pesto!

Jason Hoggatt

Very good homemade pasta and recipes. Small family seating area outside the lounge but usually not too crowded. Interesting seafood options.

Perry Lewin

Absolutely, the most authentic, hand-made Italian food around. This place is such a treasure for Terre Haute, IN. It’s always a treat to visit our daughter at ISU and enjoy a great meal together. You won’t be disappointed.

Jack Tift

Always amazing food with generous portions at reasonable prices. Try the limoncello gelato! It's unbelievable.

Sandra Boswell

Delicious food. Can always count on a great meal. Staff always takes such good care of diners!

Ryan Bose

This is the best restaurant in Terre Haute.

Gordon Simpson

Great atmosphere! Food was pretty good and service was good. Only a small mixup on a sauce with no meat. A bit pricey but overall ok.

Brenda Homburg

Best Italian food in Terre Haute! Always enjoy dining here!

Tricia Cain

Always a great meal no matter what i choose. I got the tortellini this time and loved it. Portions are large, and meal comes with free breadsticks. Service is great, atmosphere is nice, overall a good experience. Prices are a little on the high side, but well worth it. We will be back!

Jennifer Hills

My husband and I went here for first time. Excellent service and food. I have never had homemade pasta and it was delicious. The limoncello gelato was soo good! We will be going back for sure .

Pastor Ronald Myers

It is awesome place to eat I’d recommend it to anyone

Alan Sosa

A Diamond in the ruff It stands out tall with the quality of food and service. This isn't just a Pizza place its a Restaurant. That says it all .

Taylor Kusterman

Amazing food and service as always


Wonderful food. Huge portions that are authentic Italian. All the pasta is handmade except the penne. Wait staff was courteous and well versed in the menu. Over all great place. Only complaint is the location. Would do better closer to I-70.

Ellen Wrin

The food here is fantastic, and the service is great, even when they are very busy. All of the pasta is hand-made, and you can definitely taste the difference! I would highly recommend the tortellini, but you really can't go wrong with anything on the menu.


THE best Italian restaurant in town. The waitress, Brigitte, provided excellent service every time we visited. Food was great, highly recommend their lamb chop, cod, shrimp cocktail, calamari, and tiramisu. Ask for their daily special. Visit them every week, totally worthy of the price.

Bonnie Lawson

We enjoyed our visit. Food was very good and service was good.

Ellis Lindsey

The service is excellent allow with the food. Reasonable priced.

ze ro

The dinning room was uncomfortably warm. The shrimp was over cooked and alfrado was bland.

Lindsay Hull

My favorite restaurant in Terre Haute! The food is always delicious and the service is fantastic. I highly recommend the Fettuccine Alfredo and the Ravioli! If your group is all 21 and older, I recommend setting in the back. Go see them soon!

Dave White

Food was good and priced right.

ash s

Great food and. Service

Lindsay Bowlin

Hands down the best Italian I've had and definitely a top contender for best meal! Service was awesome, food was obviously to die for, and the Margaritas were great! Will be making the 2 1/2 hr drive to come back that's for sure!

Cynthia Miller

Waitress was excellent

Cathy Brummett

Good but what kind of Italian restaurant doesn't serve cappuccino???

Betsy K

Excellent food. If it is a holiday, you MUST get reservations but it is definitely a fine dining experience on any day. Lunch is reasonable and appropriately portioned. Dinner? Well come hungry!

Carmen Warnick

The BEST Fried Calamari I have ever tasted!!! We also had lasagna which was awesome too... Service was outstanding. Our server Hunter was very pleasant, friendly and polite. This was our first time visiting this restaurant and everything it was beyond our expectations. Will definitely go back and recommend it as it was recommended to us.

Christian Askew

Nasty stuff the breadsticks looked like hotdog buns with Italian seasoning and the chicken marsala had the strangest taste. It was empty af and the only ones that were in there were old people.

Olivia Farrington

Absolutely amazing food. I've never eaten here and been disappointed. (Good vegan options as well!)

Michael Morton

Absolutely delicious everything here. I'm lucky my wife didn't like the fried ravioli because it meant more for me! She had the spaghetti and meatballs, and loved every bit of it, so she did end up getting her fill. Very polite staff. Unusual atmosphere compared to anything else in area, however that isn't a bad thing, just nothing I've ever experienced. I liked it greatly over all!

Doug Elia

The pasta is home made and the service is excellent.

Hannah Marchand

We dont usually visit Terre Haute. But each time we do we want to try new places. Last time we visited we tried THIS PLACE! Oh my gosh some of the best pasta dishes I've ever had. And the fried raviolis are to die for. I miss them already. We will definitely be coming back. Staff is nice too.

Tyler Balding

Great service and ambiance, but lackluster food(I had the fettuccine Alfredo)

Kevin Sluyter

Had a great dinner this evening. Food and see rvice are always wonderful here at Poloni's

marcela alonso

Great family restaurant. Staff was upbeat and attentive. The food was good too. I believe it's all homemade too. I got the stuffed pasta and some pieces of pasta we're a little crunchy. But for the most part, I enjoyed my meal.

Borky Forky

Always top notch food and service. None better! For adults, I suggest eating in the lounge. Very cozy and very cool.

Brandy Walker

We came in at 3pm, the family room side. We had been in town for state gymnastics competition. There wasn't very many people there, but the food was excellent. Thought it might have been "old" but everything was fresh and delicious!! Pleasantly surprised. Server was great, too!! Thanks for a great meal.

April Stewart-Fryman

Best kept secret! If you love Italian must visit here. I can’t say enough good things about the food.

Penny Polk

Excellent Italian food. Bruschetta was FANTASTIC

kenneth mattsey

Great food,service and atmosphere

Jake Rappa

Good Italian food at a cheap price. I had a great veal parm last time Iate there

Ed C

Service = excellent Food = Rack of Lamb, Chicken Marsala and Spinach Ravioli was perfect with the exception of overly cooked spaghetti noodles but flavors were exceptional Decor could use some updating but was quaint Would indefinitely go there again

Sasha Nicol3

Amazing Italian restaurant! Has two different sides on the building. Originally walked in the main part. More ideal for families. Went to the lounge which was smaller but liked the atmosphere alot better (was on a date). Friendly staff, food was GREAT and service was quick! Will be returning

Alyssa Mariasy

It was good, and they said they made sure everything was gluten free, but I still got sick. That could have been a variety of things, and the rest of my party had a great time :)

Donna Safford

The food and server was absolutely the best I have ever had. 5

L Strick

Excellent Italian menu restaurant, great service and reasonable pricing.

Gretchen Lawrence

They house make their pasta! That is so rare these days so I greatly appreciated this.

Rob Thomas

Hidden gem of Terre Haute. Food is great. Ambiance very nice. Service is terrific. Highly recommend

christine griffin

Great Food! Great service! Great prices!

chad flynn

Breadsticks were eh but everything else was amaizing. Had Calamari, ravioli, tortellini and chicken carbonara. I not a fan of ravioli but it was really good. The bacon gave the tortellini a nice kinda smoke flavor along with the mushrooms it was my favorite. Staff was friendly and welcoming had a good dinner. It is almost a 2 hour drive from me but I would go back and try more of the menu for sure

Terrie Wiese

Great fresh home made pasta. Really good food. Service is good too.

Jerrilynn Bayless

I always get something on the specials menu. Excellent.

john oneal

Great food. Large servings. Great wait staff.

Dusty Higgins

Family owned town favorite authentic cuisine its just amazing i highly recoment you visit at least once!!!

Tsali Lough

One of the best in fine dining you can find in Terre Haute. The owners are some of the most wonderful people you'll ever meet and the food is delicious. If you go in and ask for Kenzie as your server, she is very attentive and knowledgable! Take the whole family and enjoy a wonderful atmosphere with those you love.

Brad Jewett

The food was some of THE BEST Italian food I've EVER eaten. We didn't have reservations on a holiday but the server graciously fit us in. All the staff was very polite and professional. This is BY FAR the BEST restaurant in town! If you haven't eaten here yet you are only punishing yourself! I would give this place a 10 star if they had it.

Brad Zahn

I've had Incredible meals here and some that were very so-so. If they have the short ribs or the Veal Osso Buco as a special, get them, they are delicious!! The risotto with truffle oil is excellent also. I had one dish that was very salty and another dish that was kind of bland but my buddy loves it so maybe it's just my taste. I will definitely go back but I will make sure one of those specials is on the menu before I go.

Darla Washburn

Visited Pilonis Restaurant on Mothers Day. It's a wonderful little escape on the north side of Terre Haute. Authentic Italian food. Ask what the specials are! I prefer the bar entrance where you can dine , relax and enjoy your meal. And don't forget aglass of wine!

Marc Tartaglia

Good food, service, and love the look of the place.

Jared England

This place is a hidden gem. From the toasted ravioli to the house made blue cheese salad dressing to the homemade spaghetti to the steak, our dinner was delicious!

EWC Home Services And Interior Design

Had a wonderful lunch! Fresh homemade pasta's wonderful local resturant that does Italian right! We will be back...

Business Hours of Piloni's Italian Restaurant in Indiana



Piloni's Italian Restaurant en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Fresh Indian Grill
Fresh Indian Grill
Restaurant - Indiana

Indian restaurant

Between the Bun - Burgers, Dogs and More
Between the Bun - Burgers...
Restaurant - Indiana

Hamburger restaurant

Kinsey's Italian Cafe
Kinsey's Italian Cafe
Restaurant - Indiana

Italian restaurant

Kobe Japanese Steakhouse
Kobe Japanese Steakhouse
Restaurant - Indiana

Japanese restaurant

Iozzo's Garden of Italy
Iozzo's Garden of Italy
Restaurant - Indiana

Italian restaurant