Reviews of Matteo's Ristorante Italiano (Restaurant)

40 N 9th St, Noblesville, IN 46060

Average Rating:

DESCRIPTION

Here you will see all the feddbacks of real people like you who buy the products and services of Matteo\'s Ristorante Italiano (Restaurant) in Indiana.

At present this firm gets a score of 4.4 stars over 5 and the score has been based on 393 reviews.

As you can see the average of ratings is quite good, and it is based on a large number of reviews, so we can conclude that the evaluation is very credible. If there are many people who bothered to rate when they are pleased, is that it works.

You know that we don't usually stop to put scores when these are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Restaurant is classified in the category of Italian restaurant.

Where is Matteo's Ristorante Italiano?

REVIEWS OF Matteo's Ristorante Italiano IN Indiana

Molly Keating

Matteo's is one of my go-to restaurants! Not only is there food amazing... but the customer service is the best! Highly recommend the ravioli!

Jordan Smith

I know they just had a wedding in there but gosh. They were really understaffed. It took HOURS to get our food that was then cold and it was flavorless. Too expensive to be so bland! The desert was good though and the mascoto i had (that made waiting for hours bearable). The waiter did pay for a desert because she left one of our foods in the kitchen. So that was proper edict on her part. They need better food and better management.

Steven Sexton

Went here for the first time and it was excellent. Doug our waiter was outstanding and very courteous. They were extremely busy and it took a very long time to get our food but the wait was well worth it. The bread is excellent and I loved the penne pasta with Italian sausage. For the long wait they gave us dessert for free. The overall experience was exceptional. We'll definitely be back.

charles dale

came on a busy night but wait staff was friendly and working their butts off. cocktails were mixed great dinner wonderful.

Paul Reynolds

Fantastic food. Wonderful service.

Jeff Bender

The Best ! Our Server knew exactly how and when to pay attention to us.. Excellent ! Fantastic Food

Susan Weibley

My cocktail was delicious but my dates' was far too sweet for a bourbon drink. The bartender was nice but totally discombobulated and understocked at the very small bar. I'll give it another try but this visit was a fail.

James Ashley

Been there several times - usually for special occasions. Food is super delicious, service is excellent. Never a bad experience.

John Dearman

Good chow.

Cara Vetor

The food is fabulous. My favorites are their Olive All'Ascolana appetizer and Tagliatella Alla Tarantella. Don't forget to try the limoncello soaked lady fingers layered with mascarpone for dessert!

Ry Wake

Good authentic Italian food, better than that place called Olive Garden. Food was delicious and i would recommend this place to anyone interested in trying it.

Holly Dunn Pendleton

Delicious food and great service.

Oliver Gomez

Best Italian food.

jamie Murphy

Great Italian food at a great price

Tina Sargent

A very nice Italian restaurant. Generous portions. Great service!

Nakuma Stone

The lasagna resembled cat food and tasted aweful. The service was poor and everything was over priced. Not returning.

Jack J

Matteo's always has, and I firmly believe always will, be the best authentic Italian restaurant I've ever been to. The owners are wonderful and the nicest men I've ever met in my life. The food is always outstanding and the Servers are phenomenal!

Emily Laskowski

This is a little hidden gem! The vintage atmosphere combined with the elite poise of the waiters and management made for a wonderful birthday experience. The people here take an extra step at making guests feel special and comfortable. The food is AMAZING!!!! We look forward to having our rehearsal dinner here!

Edward Coleman

Very nice ambiance and food is delicious. Wait staff is courteous and knowledgeable. Highly recommend.

Lisa D.

This restaurant is supposed to be "business casual" but I was surprised how people came in inappropriate attire. The service was great... until the restaurant got a little busier. The "olive oil" that came with the bread had a lot of seasonings in it and WAY too much pepper! The entrees were very good, though. I did love the sauce with my eggplant parmesan!

Diane Faux

Love this place! It like being in Italy. The good is so good, But price to high.

Michael Thomas

Excellent food; wait staff are friendly and efficient. Gluten-free pasta & bread available. Worth the trip!

Gail P

Awesome place!

Mislene

I LOVE Matteo's! I think the food there is amazing! My favorite food is tortellini and my favorite dessert is tiramisu. I totally recommend people to go there! The service was incredible, they really put there customers in first place! (I can't wait until November to go to their new location that's gonna be close to us.)

Scott Carter

Very cool place and totally unexpected in Noblesville! Great atmosphere, menu, and service, this place was great!

Cindy Lopez

Made reservations for shop Christmas dinner a week in advance. They lost the reservation and said they would seat us. Over heared another group of people complain that they had been waiting too. We left after standing there for over 25 minutes.

Sheri Stohler

Excellent. The garden salad was fabulous. Great service. Truely a great evening out, and fabulous restrauant. Love the fact it is in a quiet town, sometimes has car shows on the sqare. Very quaint, away from the "hustle bustle".

brenda surbey

This is my absolute favorite Italian restaurant in the Indianapolis area. Noblesville is a quaint town with plenty to see on the courthouse square, in which Matteo’s is located. It is well worth the drive. I have two go-to favorites on the menu. You can’t go wrong with the Lasagna which is easily 2 to 3 inches high. My other favorite is Diablo shrimp, warm to the taste. “The Devil” is always hot! I always have dessert with a drink of the bartenders recommendation to go along with my choice of dessert!

Joshua Howard

Top notch Italian food, service is definitely a high priority at this place. Very comfortable Italian setting, great specials, and very generous portions. Would highly recommend to anyone in the area of a Matteo's Ristorante in Noblesville

Kate Thomas

Atmosphere was nice, but service and food were lacking. Vegetables were cold and certainly not a portion for two as described in the menu. Main dish was nothing to write home about, with underdone pasta... husband's rice pilaf was still crunchy. Overall just a disappointing experience...

Charles Stevenson

A very pleasant change for higher end Italian. Not the same old chain meal.

Brian Fuerst

The owner sent an email that said half off any pasta dish. I took my mother for her birthday along with two friends. I tried to use the email and was told it was only for dinner. The email never said that. After the server asked one of the four managers they finally let me use the email. A manager never came by our table to apologize. I won’t be going back. I advise other people to do the same.

Maureen Davidson

Seated away from everyone else rushed to place an order and salad came right away 3 bites of my salad followed immediately by dinner which means everything was precooked no fresh ground pepper for my salad no fresh Parmesan for my spaghetti no refills on drinks didn’t come by table till we were done with our dinners and then asked if we wanted refills instead of bringing it with him was ready with check right away and returned 30 seconds later for payment after we got the bill came back 1 minute later to get the payment For a fine dining restaurant experience was not worth the money I will not recommend this felt more like fast food

Tari Blevins

Excellent food, atmosphere. I attended a private event upstairs. Mark, our server was amazing!! Bar drinks were good. Prom groups were there.Very reasonable.Nice and roomy. Easy drive from Indy. Parking is a small issue. You may need to walk a block, but very safe and picturesque!

Ann Galloway

The Noblesville Matteo's is consistently wonderful. Year after year, we choose Matteo's. We go there for special events, date night, and had them cater my fathers retirement party. Gotta love great food and great service!

Joanna Wood

Excellent as usual! Thank you for the awesome food, service, and atmosphere!

Amber Callaway

Delicious! Decided to try Mateo's on my birthday. I was absolutely delighted. Bring your appetites as there is plenty to share. Started with drinks and bread that was accompanied by olive oil with a little kick. Our table shared a Caesar salad and we each ordered and entree that were extremely filling and we have left overs! Then came the dessert. I always order Tiramisu whenever it is available and Mateo's slayed It! Phenomenal! It is a bit pricey but it is absolutely worth it!

David De Reu

A classic Italian restaurant and an enjoyable dining experience.

Carol Goul

Wonderful dining! Highly recommended! Awesome food and great service.

Sharon Roudebush

Atmosphere was wonderful and our server, Floyd, was stupendous. Informative, accomodating, and a great personality. This was the first time our family had visited and we will be back! Excellent food and excellent service! Thank you Floyd and Matteo's.

matt hullinger

Very nice, service was beyond fabulous. Had a party of 40 upstairs. Everything was perfect

Lovoni Walker

I don't like to leave a below average review but this deserves it. I had one of the worst meals last night for my husband's & my wedding anniversary. Don't believe the 4.4 star rating - it has to be bogus. There was nothing about this meal that was good, or even passable. From the olive & veal appetizer that was heated in the microwave, soggy with fat & not even hot, the calamari that was so chewy & also lukewarm. The mains were worse. My husband had marsala chicken with a watery sauce that hadn't had the alcohol cooked off it so it was harsh tasting & once again, it was lukewarm. I had the steak in pastry with gorgonzola sauce. The pastry was wet & soggy, the steak - which I ordered medium-rare, was overcooked & tough & neither of us could taste the gorgonzola in the sauce. Our server, who started okay, then became distracted with two other tables & totally forgot us. Didn't bring us bread, forgot my husband's drink order. The list goes on. What a total letdown of a meal. We were so hungry because we'd been saving ourselves for an agreeable meal. I gave my husband my steak in soggy pastry because he couldn't eat his nasty marsala chicken. Maybe their usual chef has Sundays off because the whole experience was just awful & totally wrecked our wedding anniversary. Do yourself a favor, pick a different restaurant.

Jasmine Dong

I’ve only been at place once. To be honest the lasagna was a bit over cooked. The other plate was a bit greasy...

Janet smith

A nice and intimate restaurant with good food, nice wines, delicious desserts and excellent customer service. A "Must" visit!Thank you, Dustin!

Jon Fader

Delicious.

Chris Daggy

Food and environment was great. They seemed to he short staff based on wait time and the rush all the staff seemed to he in. The food made it worth the wait.

cliff redding

The food is great. Decor is awesome. Love this place.

Edward Fox

Good service oil needs a lil more flavor and food a little to done

Scott Vowels

We took some friends visiting from out of town. This was honestly the best Italian food we've had anywhere and our friends were just as impressed. The Italian sausage lasagna was amazing and my wife loves their gnocchi. If the quality of the food wasn't enough, the service was outstanding. Thanks for a great experience!

Joe Coleman

Was there about three weeks ago. Heard great things about it. No reservations made. 20-30 minute wait. We gave our names and went to the bar. Floyd was awesome. After an hour with no touches from the host staff we paid our bar tab and said good-bye.

abigail c.

Fabulous overall. Beautiful interior. Very nice staff. Love a place where youre able to dress up & go out. The veal meatballs were delicious. I would love to visit again.

Thomas Ziffrin

They never miss. Always a great meal and great service.

jtscaddy jts

Loved this place great food great service. Top-notch for sure thank you

Lisa Moyer

Excellent food, excellent service - reminded me of how restaurants used to be

Kathie Votra

$35.00 for spaghetti and meatballs is a bit much; after all it just noodles and sauce!

Jeremy Long

Great food in a welcoming environment. Plan to spend some time, as the service is casual and friendly, so it is not speedy. But with the right dining partners, it does not matter. Taste and selection were very appealing.

Cherri Kellum

Italian food here was just truly delicious, worth the trip if your in town there

Tracy Barta

So glad to find good food and a private room for 40 diners to hold our wedding rehearsal dinner. Definitely would recommend!

Jenny Cozad

My husband and I went for our anniversary. Wonderful food, Service, and ambience. I had a seafood pasta dish and he had a ribeye cooked perfectly. A must try.

Camnick C

Excellent restaurant. We have been there a few times and are never disappointed.

Madeleine L

Yummmmy pasta dishes that are more traditional and unique.

john cary

The caprese was nothing special really, the filter was wonderful but doesn't come with any sides and even through the menu probably started this, the waiter should have explained it or offered side dishes .I workw rather have smaller entrees with sides . Didn't feel there was anything particularly different or special about the food or the service.

Beehive Promotions

Food was good, nice ambiance. Service was slow and bread a bit overdone, but I would go back.

Rick Fox

Went for early dinner just after opening on a Saturday. There was no wait. I ordered the special (Lasagna) which was well prepared, tasty, fast, and the server was attentive and friendly.

Patricia Brown

Best Italian food, outside of Italy!!! Was there for a rehearsal dinner downstairs on Aug. 31, 2018. Everything was delicious, from the appetizers to desserts. I received an email from Matteo's stating I only gave it one star recently. That was a typo error! So sorry. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. The food and service was outstanding!!!

Steve Crell

Great food and get friendly servers!

Matt Green

We had a great experience. The house made noodles and sauces are to die for! I’m not Italian so I can’t speak to how authentic it is, but I’ve heard even the Italians love this place. I had a wonderful Old Fashion with my meal!

Gregory Forsthoefel

Good Italian food.

Ryan Jung

Food was good and service friendly. It's a nice local place to go for in house made Italian. Servings were large.

John Serban

Best Italian kitchen

Sonny Mcelfresh

This was our first time eating here. We went for Father's Day. Food and service was wonderful! Their Alfredo sauce is the best I've ever had! It's a bit expensive but worth it for the quality of food you receive. I would definitely recommend this place!

Aaron Smith

Excellent service no wait on appetizers or food....would definitely recommend

Don Masten

We visited the Noblesville restaurant and the atmosphere was great along with the food. Service was very good. Will definitely go again!

Jerry Allen

My wife and I both had penne pasta dishes. They gave us heathy portions, that required doggy bags. We do recommend this restaurant. And we will visit again. Everyone that we came in contact with was nice and helpful. Mark was a excellent server!

Heather Lofton

Great first experience at Matteo’s! We went on a busy Saturday night with reservations. We showed up maybe 10 minutes early and the staff was able to seat us after a few minutes. While our server was busy with two large parties, the host provided us with drinks while we waited. (I’ve been a server before so I totally understand being swamped & trying to greet a new table while taking care of your other ones.) This gave us time to pick out a nice Chianti wine and the calamari appetizer. Our server was very knowledgeable and friendly and we did not feel rushed at all during our meal. I had the gnocchi and my date had the veal special. Everything we tried there that night was delicious. Please try out this wonderful restaurant!

Maurice Golay

Great food

Barby Suffield

Oh so romantic! Wonderful food and perfect service . Simply one of the very best authentic Italian restaurants in central Indiana. For a special evening this is an outstanding choice:)

Christina Duthie

We ate lunch here today to celebrate a family milestone. The staff could not have been more accommodating, and the service and food were both excellent. We were all so glad we chose to celebrate our special day at Matteo's!

Matthew Faux

Had a great experience. Service was wonderful, recommendations were spot on, the food was absolutely amazing. Looking forward to exploring the menu in the future. Nice setting, and was rather quiet which was nice to be able to have a conversation over dinner.

Raz Rasmussen

Nice place, good food $$

Patricia Greenfield Brown

Was here for a rehearsal dinner. The food was amazing. Everything was delicious. Service excellent for our crowd of about 30. Definitely would return again if I lived closer.

Barry Hanna

Excellent place for a romantic dinner with your sweetheart!

Robert Weinkauf

The salmon was spectacular A flavor explosion in my mouth.

Vickie Whitson

The first time I have eaten lunch there. What the waitress suggested wasn't that good. Slow service.

Linda Cichocky

Absolutely the best Italian food!

David Gafford

Huge fan of Matteo's! Love bringing the family and it's perfect for a date night. The wait staff always has great recommendations, and hasn't steered us wrong yet. Great Italian dining experience.

Haley Myrick

Great staff and the food was delicious.

Craig Ryan McIntyre

We had a meeting upstairs tonight, it was my first time there. I could not have been more excited about discovering this place after we left. All the food was exceptional! The house salad is amazing as well as the tortellini! You will NOT be disappointed. A++

Paul Crouse

Always an amazing venue to enjoy the most mouth watering pasta imaginable. For me though, the service makes the food even more enjoyable!

Jason Siebeneck

Matteos is a great place to have lunch. Food is incredible at reasonable price. BEST!!! Authentic Italian food in Hamilton county.

Linda Lawrence

Delightful. Excellent service. Delicious food.

Sean Sorrell

Unique atmosphere with delicious food choices.

Cory Parsons

Great restaurant my brother and sister-in-law go often. We went with them while visiting. Great food in really large portions. Very authentic pasta and drinks are very good also. I believe they make some of their own Liquors. Waiter was awesome and even gave us complimentary chocolate covered strawberries.

4646000545

I am a doordash driver but I will stay if they treated me like this as a customer I would never have came here and I do not recommend anybody coming to this restaurant Forgot to add that I was waiting there for over an hour and was an hour late to deliver the food.

Jim G

Very nice Italian restaurant. Huge selection, reasonable price, pleasant staff. Would go again

Patti Arvin

Excellent food, excellent service, excellent atmosphere. Will definitely be back!

Zach Purcell

I've been I think 4 times now and it's been fantastic every time. The prices are fair for the fanciness of the place and I'd say you get more food in an order than an average fine dining restaurant.

Don Wettrick

Wow! I had no idea how awesome this hidden gem is!

Alex Axsom

My wife and I went to dine here on 6/12/19 for our 20th anniversary. It was our first visit to Matteo's. This is also my first negative Google review. The food and atmosphere was great. The service was horrible and was certainly not what we expected on such a special occasion. Our waiter, William H., was not personable and lacked general etiquette that a server at an "upscale" restaurant should show. We were there for a late dinner around 8:30pm and there were approximately 3 tables of customers being served at that time. Once we sat down, he asked us if we wanted a salad or appetizer. We declined, which seems to set the tone for our level of service. We had to ask about the specials, which there were several choices. Fortunately the meal was good. As I finished my meal, he came and took both of our plates away - my wife was not done with her meal. William then asked if we were ready for our check, there was no ask if we wanted dessert (which my wife said, "looked fabulous") or anything else. When he brought the check, he stood there waiting for me to fill it out. I asked him to give us a minute so i could fill out the bill without him standing over me. The food was good but I cannot see us returning only to be treated so poorly. Unfortunate.

Keith Corbin

Stopped in for an early dinner with my wife. It had been a few years since eating there. It has always been a 4 star experience but unfortunately not this time. We both ordered a dish with sausage in it. The sausage was grisly. My order was a special of the day and the creamy white sauce was more like soup. Overall this meal was a 2 star experience but I gave 3 stars because of excellent past visits. When $100 is paid for a meal, I certainly expect better quality. A shame, really.

Steve thunder

The best Italian around

Todd Harter

Excellent food and service. We will return again.

Mikkal Hodge

Amazing food, high quality service. Will most certainly return in the future.

marge bill

Wonderful Italian restaurant in beautiful downtown Noblesville

That Gamer Guy

Ever since the new owner took over a couple years ago the food has been okay. When we went last time to see if it was going to be any better, they told us that they had run out of scallops when they weren't busy at all. The waiter we had delivered scallops to the table next to us, this is when we have already been waiting for food for 30 minutes and then they tell us. Food wasn't worth the price or the time.

Chris Dewing

Absolutely incredible experience! Great food complemented with great service! Would recommend to anyone

Jacqueline Graham

This is a Great restaurant. The two owners really work hard to make sure you have a great night. They even gave us a specialty cocktail that they make so we could try it. Fantastic food. Nice locally run restaurant. You feel like home here. Cute small intimate bar..great for date night.

Dave O. Alvarez

Everything was delicious, excellent service and great place for couples

L Ellis

☆Premier food, atmosphere, owners & staff.☆ While I reside in another state, I specifically came to Noblesville to attend a party held in their upstairs private dining room. From the authentic, mouth watering, Italian cuisine, to the pleasant and accommodating owners and staff, I could not have been more impressed. If you're considering an intimate dinner for two, an evening out with family and friends or, hosting the perfect party, I highly recommend Matteo's.

jacob moss

Great food and atmosphere! And the house bread is delicious.

Frank Shetterly

Good food but took 35 minutes to order and 55 minutes to bring bread to the table. We were there two hours without eating dessert. Maybe they were just having a bad night.

Matthew Risk

Did not appreciate not receiving any drink service for 15 minutes after being seated. 5 tables full in the whole restaurant at the time. 2 tables received water after being seated after we were seated. If you are asking this amount for the food you better have your service on par. Don't think you are going to survive in the business asking those prices for sub par dinning experiences. Will not return( life long resident to the area).

Justin Hexamer

The food was delicious. Service was fine and the atmosphere is OK.

Greg Greg

I have had bad experiences before but never left a review. This guy and place deserve it though. I wouldn't give 1 star if I didn't have to. If you are open your kitchen should be open and please clean your dirty floors. Terrible first experience so there won't be a second chance.

Mary Hessel

Wonderful meal everytime we go.

Natasha Croy

Worst dinner, do not waste your money. Food is mediocre and is over priced for the lack of taste and execution of the meal. On a Saturday night this place was a ghost town. Best part is the Service staff, did a great job. Tiramisu and coffee was the best part of the entire meal.

Steve Stage

Dinner for 8 last night. Wonderful setting. Live music and excellent service by Patrick. Most entrees were very well prepared however the fettuccine Alfredo was a bit runny and tasteless according to the couple who ordered it. Nice venue for a quiet dinner when you want to be able to converse.

Loni Plack

The food was really subpar. The bread was good but I don't know anyone who goes somewhere just for the bread. The calamari didn't have much flavor so I'm guessing it was frozen. The meal I had was linguine frute de mar. The scallops, clams and shrimp were all pretty flavorless. And it literally tasted like canned tomato soup and store bought linguini. My husband got the tortellini. It had some ham which didn't make a lot of sense and uncooked red onions. My husband had them send it back and he got antipasto salad. That being said the antipasta salad and the tortellini were removed from our bill. Everyone was extremely nice and the service was good. But ultimately you go there to eat. And at 28.75 for the part I paid was just outrageously overpriced, frozen and tasteless. This isn't about the wonderful servers, the caring manager and the hosts. This is the chef. It's like the chef doesn't care at all.

John Palmer

Good food and atmosphere, attentive and fun staff. A special thanks to Tina.

Sunny Lu Williams

Great Italian! Excellent homemade bread. Veal parm is excellent and seafood pasta is hearty portion with generous amount of shrimp, scallops and mussels.

Dean Boucouras

Great food and superb service

Zo Nunez

Very expensive! Everything is a la cart. 2 dinners with a shared vegetable, 2 soft drinks and a shared dessert will rack up close to 90 to $100! Everyone is nice, and they accommodate gluten allergies. Ambiance is great and food is good. Just not $100 good in my opinion. If I'm going to spend that kind of money, I'd rather go to Capital Grille!

Bill Farrington

We were there for a company Christmas party. We were very well taken care of. Everyone enjoyed the food and atmosphere.

Ben McCann

Very rich authentic Italian food with atmosphere to boot. Loved the lasagna. Mama mia it was good!

Bay Lovett

Truly can not remember the last time I had food this good.

robin duckham

Being a New Yorker living in Indiana, it's very difficult to find good Italian food! Matteos does a great job closing that gap for us! Very tasty food from start to finish!

Harvey Feinberg

The food was excellent. The service was 5 star as well. We had the mushroom Appertiser. Veal Oso Buco was tender and tasty. A chicken dish plus desert. Our first time at Matteo’s it won’t be our last.

Paul Wood

I'm not an Italian fan but I love this restaurant.

Business Hours of Matteo's Ristorante Italiano in Indiana

SUNDAY
3–9PM
MONDAY
11AM–2PM 5–10PM
TUESDAY
11AM–2PM 5–10PM
WEDNESDAY
11AM–2PM 5–10PM
THURSDAY
11AM–2PM 5–10PM
FRIDAY
11AM–2PM 5–10:30PM
SATURDAY
3–10:30PM

PHONE & WEBPAGE

Matteo's Ristorante Italiano en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage

PICTURES






Others also saw
Amol India Carry Out Restaurant
Amol India Carry Out Rest...
Restaurant - Indiana

Indian restaurant

Sapporo Japanese Steak House and Sushi
Sapporo Japanese Steak Ho...
Restaurant - Indiana

Japanese restaurant

Luciana's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina
Luciana's Mexican Restaur...
Restaurant - Indiana

Mexican restaurant

Fujiyama Steak House of Japan
Fujiyama Steak House of J...
Restaurant - Indiana

Japanese steakhouse

Flamme Burger Keystone
Flamme Burger Keystone
Restaurant - Indiana

Hamburger restaurant