Reviews of Kinsey's Italian Cafe (Restaurant)

6383 W Broadway, McCordsville, IN 46055

Average Rating:


You will be able to see all the information of people like you who purchase the products and services of Kinsey\'s Italian Cafe (Restaurant) in the area close to the state of Indiana.

At present the business gets a score of 4.6 stars out of 5 and that score was based on 420 reviews.

As you can read, the average score it has is basically the best, and it is based on a very large number of reviews, so we can conclude that the assessment is quite credible. If people have bothered to rate when they've done well, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to give feddbacks when they are positive and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Restaurant corresponds to the category of Italian restaurant.

Where is Kinsey's Italian Cafe?

REVIEWS OF Kinsey's Italian Cafe IN Indiana

David Weiss

Great food and a great staff.

Ouida Norris

The hostess had a friendly smile and seated me close to the buffet. I stopped in for the buffet that was advertised. Really good hot thin crust pizza and the usual salad bar. The building wad rough looking inside and out but clean. The ordered dishes going to other tables looked good and generous. I will come back.

Brandy Lee

I have now tried this place twice and both times have been bad experiences. The first time I waited almost an hour after ordering my food, for the server to come tell us our order ticket never went through. He was friendly and comped our meal, and when it finally arrived it was good. So I decided to give it another chance today and try their lunch "buffet". The buffet was underwhelming to say the least, a couple of cold pizzas and basic salad is all it consisted of. But I gave it a shot, as stated the pizza was COLD, but it gets better...I found a HAIR in my pizza. I informed the server and he took my plate, didnt apologize, and never came back to my table. Obviously my appetite was over with but I had to call another server over to bring me my check. Definitely won't be back and don't recommend spending your money on the hairy cold pizza "buffet". Chicagos is up the road and has a much better selection.

Jeffrey K McCrocklin

Shared a pizza last evening with a friend. Nice atmosphere and friendly service. I definitely want to go back and try other menu items.

Sharen Simmons

Great Italian food. Love eating there

Robert Perkins JR.

Fast and friendly servers

Gayle Burris

Very friendly staff, great food. Good selection of beer and wine.

Roger Holder

Good food and plenty for the price... don't sit close to the door when it is cold.

Machelle Poindexter

Great food and quick service

b hickman

Awesome service and Pizza

Mark & Beth Loveless

Great food. Great Service. Fair Prices and Local not Chain. Will definitely go back.

John Englert

Generous portions of good food with a smile.

Lyle Teter

Excellent food and service. Very generous portions.

BellaRyan 89

Small Italian restaurant with amazing food. I mean delicious! I highly suggest the Panzerotti, The Tenderloin and Double cheeseburger. Everything is reasonably priced for the amount of food you get. I order from here at least once a week …

Nicole Dunlap

We ordered take out. Pizza looked and tasted delicious! Pasta was amazing too! We ordered salad and it was fresh and their Italian dressing is perfect! Already told two couples about this place!

Jason Woodruff

The food is amazing and the staff are well versed at customer service and attention to detail. The dining room is small and cozy. If you're looking for a small dining experience with big flavor, then this Italian eatery is definitely to be considered!

Marcy Commons

Great food! Great service! Friendly staff. Will definitely recommend!!

Judy Goodwin

Always the best food and service here and enough food for leftovers. Love Kinsey's!

Ronald Mitchell

Good food and friendly service

Timothy Chan

Greeted with excellent service! Food was phenomenal and the prices, especially for the lunch buffet is the ultimate bang for your buck! 7.95 for that buffet, which includes a drink. Would highly recommended! Will definitely come back!

Ryan Davis

By far the best I've had yet. The food is soooo good I mean absolutely mouth watering. The tenderloin is extra large and juicy. The fries are hot and just what you'd expect them to be. We called in to pick our order up and they were so pleasant to speak with. I also recommend the Panzerotti. It's a calzone that's stuffed to the brim with deliciousness. Definitely go if you haven't yet, you won't be disappointed.

Pam Sullivan

Nice, simple menu and great!

Nick Wilcox

Blink and you miss it location is worth the visit. Portions are huge and cheese is grated fresh inhouse. The salads and bread knots are awesome. Any main entre I've tried has been excellent. Staff is attentive and helpful. I highly recommend!

T Had

Service and food was good. I had spicy bbq bone wings they came hot and very good. Waitress was great very pleasant. Was here about a year ago and the food was terrible. So we decided to try again. Glad we did. Enjoy

Dennis Miller

Atmosphere isn't much but the food is outstanding. Good service.

Jenn Evans

On our way through Indy from Minnesota to Kentucky. Such a GEM! Don't let the unassuming outside fool you. Lots of tasty house made food. Our server Madi did a great job on suggesting items and being super knowledgeable on the menu... in addition to being a great server in general. Pictures are the housemade lasagna and the stromboli calzone. Great food. Great service. Great prices.

Tonya Becker

Delicious food! Awesome service!!

LaDonna Morelock-GOLDEN

Fantastic Italian Spagetti and Meatballs

mike battista

Great food and service with a smile

Matt Allanson

Delicious food in an unassuming place! The wait staff did an excellent job and made for a great dining experience for my large bday party.

Randy Mohr

Excellent food prepared with care and served by a customer focused staff. The facility is serviceable, but basic. What arrives on your plate (or carry out box) will insure your return visit!

Mark Strater

Nice little place, food was good, large portions, very friendly and very helpful staff, no Budweiser but, bud light.

Randi Kiefer

We love this place! We found it by accident a few years ago and now make the hour drive up a few times a year to eat it. The chicken Alfredo is AMAZING.

William Bolander

Always a great experience! Great food and service

Jodi gehl

Side salad big enough for a meal and very tasty! Large portions. Had the lasagna very good, my husband had the chicken caccitoire, the chicken was not great, seem ed prepared. Allover a very good meal.

Matt Vogt

Awesome staff, good food, kind service. We had a great lunch and will be sure to return again soon!

Andrew Williams

Fantastic customer service, awesome food, timely with appetizers, salads, & entrees. Definitely recommend to anyone wanting small town Italian food & pizza.

Megan Butler

The food was excellent! I will definitely be back!!

Dave Thompson

We went there last night and had an overall good experience being the third time we’ve been there. However, the reason I’m only giving three stars is because we tried using our ‘Buy one - Get one free’ coupon that we purchased for $5 on the Dining Advantage app. Unfortunately, Kinsey’s only accepts the printed version of the coupon. I redeemed the coupon using the mobile version and once it’s redeemed you can’t go back to change your option to printed. It ultimately cost me $5 plus having to pay for the meal we would have gotten for free. Other than that, the food was great and the staff was friendly.

Godsgirlie J

Never been Google sucks I have so many.places that pop up for reviews that o have never been too

Mark Browning

Probably the best lasagna I've EVER eaten i would suggest anybody an everybody to go try there food i HIGHLY RECOMMEND THEM

William Spangler

This is by far the best down to earth Italian diner in the area. The food is outstanding, the service is great. The decor is simple but efficient. I would recommend this diner to everyone.

Jane Bischof

We enjoyed a pizza at Kinsey's. We always enjoy whatever we order. The food is great and we always have very good service!

Paul Dewey

Great stromboli calzone. Will be back next time in Indy

Bree Burris

Great food, great service! Would definitely come back again and again!

Richard Downey

Food was great and server made excellent small talk. Would reccomend their Italian sausage.

Zachary Armitage

Not much selection on buffet. Kind of a joke lol. Couple slices i had were ok though!

Tom Mackall

Good food and service. Great value!

Rachelle Owen

Excellent food! Great service

Jacob Crouch

Great food and service. The lasagna is AMAZING

Kameron Kenny

The food is fantastic! The restaurant interior leaves a lot to be desired, but don't let that scare you away. Ordering carryout is painless, as the staff is very friendly and double checks to make sure your order is correct. The only thing that keeps me from being a regular is the prices. While the food is good, they're prices are more aligned with a more upscale place.

Erin Wigger

My kids pounded the food!!! That double stuffed pizza...DELISH!! The server we so sweet and gave the kids Halloween treats! Cozy, yummy, and down to earth spot!!! We will be back!!!

Donna Mounts

I had the double the stuff pizza and it was awesome! The sausage on the pizza I couldn't get enough of it! I would recommend this establishment to eat at.

Brian Terhune

Good food and service. I will be back

Jay Lee

They always hav great food & vry friendly Staff & Employees. I need 2 try more of their varied foods. But I don't drink sodas. I asked 4 lemonade & thought I was gettng some fresh made frm real lemons. Found out it was lemonade flavored soda. Tht lie upsetted me a bit. So I will eat there, but likely not ovr drink anything frm there anymore.

Ned Harris

It was good. Loved the buffett!!! Five stars. May go there again some other time

Tracy bills

Incredible food. Stephanie is awesome! Makes going there even more enjoyable!

Caitlyn Anderson

The staff were very friendly and our pizza was very delicious. I would reccommend coming here any day. They have a great selection of food and we had the deep dish crust pizza. It was just amazing. 10/10 would reccommend.

grant williams

Good place, pizza crust in middle was kind of weak, pizza would slump over. Taste was superb though, very delicious, very hospitable. A great local eat.

Edward Brown

I've been here about a half dozen times. I like their pizza more than the pasta dishes (although the trio combo of lasagna, ravioli, and spaghetti was pretty good). However, I wasn't able to use my Entertainment (BOGO entre) discount for the pizza. The portions are ample and usually result in me taking some home. I didn't rate it 5/5 because the Alfredo sauce was tasty but not the texture or appearance I'd expect, it was separating and had some translucency. I've always had prompt and friendly service and have even been visited by the owner while dining. I shall return...

Emily Musgrave

Pizza was cold at the buffet. However. Staff was more than kind and friendly.

Dianna Knox

Absolutely delicious food, reasonable prices, and friendly service. This was a great choice for our lunch stop today while in town for a meeting.

Bobby Vibbert

We had the Spaghetti and meatballs and it was great. We.loved the atmosphere and the service. Will definitely come here again.

Rickie Bellany

The food wasn't that good, the menu was not informative enough .My wife order an entree and it was too spicy . The menu didn't inform that it was spicy. When my wife informed the waitress that she cannot eat spicy food . My wife reorder from the menu but the spicy entree was not removed from our bill . I will not come back for that reason nor will I recommend anyone to this restaurant!!!!!!

Armando P

Friendly service, kids love the pizza and pasta options, prices are reasonable. Calzones are good too. Fried cheese sticks look to be hand breaded which is a good sign of their standards as that would be super easy to just get frozen from a wholesaler. Thumbs up.

Candler Goss

if youre in the area, you have to stop in. we got the house salad, mozarella sticks, meatball sub and a calzone. everything was hot and delicious. the service was wonderful, and the place was in excellent shape/cleanliness.

Craig Barboza

Cute and quaint. More room. Inside than parking will allow. Do not let a full parking lot stop you from going in.

Amy Hans

I think best ever. Big potions and you can split..bread knots Yummy

Andrew Hertenstein

Kinsey's... All I can say is how on earth do they make a profit? This is NOT at all a negative thing for us patrons!!! My comment is that their portion sizes are huge and their prices are very low. If your hungry, you won't leave here that way. The meat trio is amazing and love their lasagna is great! We get takeout all the time and have had doordash a few times from Kinsey's. The restaurant itself is not memorable but that's not why you go here (that is the ONLY reason I took a star off). Its for the food!

Keith Smith

Recently we had a death in the family and needed last minute bulk pasta order. Randy and his staff did an excellent job taking care of our needs. Kinsey's always comes though with great food and home town feel. Thanks again Randy........Customer for Life

Christoper Bush

Excellent food and service would recommend anytime

Duke Drummond

Great food good service

Linda Sutt

Yummy, authentic Italian food, friendly and felt at home.

Brad Anderson

An unexpected treat in Mccordsville. Real Italian food with excellent service by Stephanie. We weren't expecting the meat balls to be made with a medium spicy Italian sausage, quite a pleasant surprise. A very large portion, too. The fettuccine tasted fresh made as did the alfredo sauce. Maybe a touch too much garlic for my taste but it must not have been too bad since I cleaned my plate, err, bowl. We definitely plan to return and well done Stephanie!

James Ferge

Great food .nice people

Jeff Young

The food is always outstanding! Our waitress Stephanie had great customer service, for the second time! I will definitely be back...5 stars

Chels CookieLand

This place is a definite must try. Servers are attentive and personable. A lot of food for a reasonable price. The pizza buffet is delicious. They have the best calzones I've ever had! Great wings, fish, tenderloins, pizza, and pasta. Really the food is just stellar. A good selection of wine and beer. Their sweet tea is also very good. Let me not forget they perfect, and I mean perfect, garlic knots!

Becki Gibson

Friendly service, huge portions. Great local place :)

Lauran Sattler

I look forward to the chicken parmigiana whenever I visit the area. Nice family and friends vibe. We usually split the entree and get extra salads and we are always served with a smile.

Kay Crouch

Second time I have eaten here. The food is scrumptious. The servers have been friendly and attentive to our needs. This quaint restaurant will be added to our favorite spots.

rebel case

It was great the people there are awesome the food was amazing

Dean May

A very nice local place. My son had Philly cheese steak and I had same with chicken. Both were delicious. Very friendly staff.

Dave Phillips

Food was very good.

David Eastes

Wish this tasty Italian eatery was closer to home. Excellent calzones, unequalled Cubano sandwich. Not fancy, but satisfying in every other way. Marinara top notch, their dough is perfection. Yum.

Chris Sears

Amazing lunch! Christy and Amy are awesome! Will be back❤

matt okerson

The wait staff were really nice and the lunch buffet was well worth the money! The only thing I would work on is greeting guests as they walk in. The current setup makes it feel as though you walked into the wrong door.

Jeremy Frederickson

I have only had this place for pizza carryout. We always get the double stuffed pizza. This pizza is loaded with toppings and has an upper crust to hold it all in. My whole extended family loves the pizza and we usually get two or three when we go. Be careful how many slices you eat or you will be in a food coma. This is a real fork and knife type pizza. The cost seems a little high to some but I feel the value is actually great. I believe they said the pizza weighs 13lbs

Desiree Staton

Best calzone I've had in Forever. Yummmo

Dave Philpott

Had an 8pm dinner here and we had the chicken salad and then followed up with some chicken wings. It might have been the best Italian salad I've had in awhile. The chicken was fantastic in the Italian dressing just wonderful. The chicken wings are also incredible. Last but not least our server was wonderfully friendly and helpful.

Jerry Gygi

The food is always delicious, and the staff is always very friendly! Sometimes it seems to take a long time to get your food, especially this time. I highly recommend this place, but don't be in a hurry.

Greg Wheeler

Good service good food

Matthew Spencer

Now, don't be put off by the initial appearance of the interior decor. This was our first time at Kinsey's. We were taken care of by a lovely lady named Stephanie. She is charming, witty, and has a great sense of humor. We started with some mozzarella sticks. Tasted like they were hand breaded...pretty good! My wife ordered the Panzerotti and I ordered the Seafood Pasta. Both dishes were quite tasty and there was plenty to bring home for later. We'll definitely visit again!

Kurt Auzins

Doesn't look like much on the outside, but it is what is on the inside tha counts. Everyting is good. THey make a lot of stuff from scratch. All around nice family owned and operated business!

Kim Burris

7/3 - If your looking for a local restaurant with that home town feel, try this place out. The place is located in one of the older strip shopping areas in town. Went for the first time (been a local resident for over 10 years) on Tuesday and was pleasantly surprised to find a well updated and modern looking restaurant. We were immediately greeted by the friendly staff and seated next to a window. The waitress (Stephanie) was a joy to have as our server. She was knowledgable on the items on the menu and smiled the whole time. She was attentive and noticed when our drinks were low and visited us frequently, just to check on us. We will definitely be back to this place, as it felt good knowing that we provided our business to a local establishment. PS - Be prepared to ask for a box, the portions are generous.

Don Waymire

Waiters to busy flirting with each other stromboli was burnt spaghetti was over cooked floors filthy very overpriced

Sue Smitha

We love Kinsey's, service and food consistently good.

R.David Adkison

This place reminds me of a family Cafe in Italy my grandmother God rest her soul would have eaten every meal at this place

David Wiley

Best Italian food around.

Business Hours of Kinsey's Italian Cafe in Indiana



Kinsey's Italian Cafe en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Lotus Garden Restaurant
Lotus Garden Restaurant
Restaurant - Indiana

Chinese restaurant

La Costenita
La Costenita
Restaurant - Indiana

Mexican restaurant

Great Wall Chinese Buffet
Great Wall Chinese Buffet
Restaurant - Indiana

Chinese restaurant

Restaurant - Indiana

Japanese restaurant

China Dragon
China Dragon
Restaurant - Indiana

Chinese restaurant