Reviews of Antonio's Italian Restaurant (Restaurant)

Sam Miller

Wow. First time here. I have found a new favorite place for Italian food!!! Definitely will be returning.

Abby Howell

We squeaked in early, without a reservation, but next time we'lldefinitely make one. The food is incredible and the waitstaff was wonderful. One of our favorite places for a nice dinner out.

Susan Wettergren

Really good Italian and they give you time to enjoy each course. Relaxed atmosphere and family friendly.

Austin Bitting

Amazing Pizza! Great food and service! We will be back!

devin andrew

Good place. Good place for pizza... Service is good.

Clara McPherson

Absolutely love this restaurant.. the night we were there.. the power went out for a while.. the staff was great... when we did get our food.. it was delicious!

Markus C.

It's been along time since we have been here. We went on a Friday night with friends that go often. The food was great. Both dishes were absolutely delicious. The sausage stuffed pasta dish with spicy sauce was great but not too spicy. The Pope's chicken was really good also. Chicken was moist and the sauce was delicious. The service was very good, knowledgeable and friendly. This is now our Italian place to go.

Jennifer Coffel

Wow! Amazing dishes. Fresh produce and made from scratch. Will come again!!

Deanna Michael

Great little place! The ambience was very Italian garden and food was amazing!

David Letro

Food was great and Desiree was awesome for allowing us to change from patio to inside.

Amy Kemp

Excellent food, good atmosphere and great customer service.

David B Miller

Antonio's always comes through with wonderful food!

Jeannie Kanaby

I ordered calamari and salmon. Did not care for batter on calamari (onion ring batter) and it was a little rubbery. Salmon was plated nice but was a little over cooked. Pizza and pasta looked amazing so will try that next time. Guy making pizzas actually used a rolling pin for each pizza and tossed in air. Fun to watch. No I did not let server know as it was carry out.

Jack Blankenbaker

The best italian cuisine in elkhart county.

Melissa Shaffer

Excellent experience all around. Great selection of mixed cocktails and wine. The food was very good. Great pizza and pasta dishes. The appetizers are so tasty, I could go there just for that. I'll definitely be going back, so hard to find a restaurant that has great service and consistent food!

Richard Watkins

First time there Good food Good service Will be back Thank you

Desiree Rice

Beautiful property, the restaurant is very upscale and has a very modern look to it. Stopped in on NYE for their oyster $1 special but alas they were not serving them due to the holiday. However they were kind enough to give us 1/2 oysters at full menu price which was great (no sarcasm here). They had a prefix menu for the holiday so I didn't think they would do that. We ordered drinks, vodka and soda with a lime. The drinks were tasty, they measured the shot so we didn't get more than what we paid for. I always appreciate a heavy pour but don't expect one here. My one criticism on this place is the crass and vulgar bartender. It was actually off putting how freely he dropped the F-bomb. Now I have no qualms regarding profanity but when in an upscale restaurant there's a point where conversations overhear from across the bar with "F you you Fing POS". He was speaking to I assume a friend but still not appropriate in a nice establishment such as this. Nonetheless very nice place and will hit up happy hours soon.

Jon Grimes

Great food great pricing and the service is always friendly.

Anna Jordan

Really yummy frozen wine and pizza!

Rachael Hall

Always a favorite for a wonderful, authentic Italian dining experience.

Gerald Huntington

I went here for a wedding reception for Marsha and George Wright. The lasagna was really good...hot and fresh. The grilled veggies were awesome! The appetizers were great also. The bartenders worked hard and deserved their tips and pay. Would i come back for a meal here? Definitely! Everyone was professional yet fun and i could tell they probably wanted to be with their families tonight. Thank you all for your hard work and dedication!

Kenny Eaton

The stuff pizza is to die for its out of this world its that good

Benjamin Gonzalez

Great pizza! Delicious marinara!

Crystal Coryn

Loved everything about our experience tonight at Antonio's.... The staff and the food are fantastic! We will definitely recommend Antonio's to our friends and family !

The Lawson

The food is great. My favorite place to eat. Can't wait to go back.

Penny Horth

Excellent food and service! Will definitely return for future visits! Highly recommend

Phyllis Hamilton

Went for the happy hour on a dodger game day, because we were in the neighborhood and it seemed to have good reviews. Got the chicken nachos and the sliders from the happy hour menu. Price was definitely awesome! Our waiter was really good too! But the food itself was average. Burger seemed to be a bit dry. Nachos seemed to have been microwaved for the cheese to melt. Probably would not go back to eat, maybe for happy hour drinks only.

Brian Caplinger

Great service. Excellent food and drinks

Michael McCrorey

Excellent service, very good food. We had a very enjoyable experience.

Derick Burkheart

Had the Italian Stallion pizza, and tried a large pepperoni, and the sausage saccottini pasta. Everything we tried was fantastic. The Copper Cosmo is a fantastic cocktail to go with the meal. Finished with a canoli and it was great as well. Would absolutely recommend Antonio's and will definitely eat there anytime I am in Elkhart.

Lighting inks

Food best service not so much

Cathy M.

We just moved here from a Texas and stopped in purely by accident while we were out house hunting. We had a drink at the bar while we waited for our pizza to go. The restaurant was very clean and nice and the pizza was delicious, we will definitely be back!

Kim Rodgers

Hello this is are 2nd visit 4-28-2019. Our first visit 2 weeks ago the visits get better. We brought another family member . Antonios you did not let us down again we went with the pizza (The Vegas }. Awesome.And deserts Awesome. Our server was Monica she was the best. Like we said before YOU REALLY CARE IT SHOWS.. To anyone who reads this you will not go wrong visiting Antonios...Our score A++++++. Military score 4.0. Do Not Change anything. Our new favorite spot the table in the bar section in the corner {4 person table } near the restroom..Also call and get a reservation... reservation. Beware you to will fall in LOVE with ANTONIOS.....

Stephen Armet

Excellent menu and service. Paul Cataldo really does feed us like family. Delicious food and really reasonable prices. I can't wait to go again.

kmkali

Great service. Food was great. Nice environment.

Mckinley Mccann

Delicious food and amazing service

Ron Hout

Awsome food, and great service!!! Love that place would recommend to anyone.

Bethany Kubina

Best Italian in the area. Family-owned business that really takes pride in their food, drinks & service.

Bat Baker

Worth every penny of the $35 I paid. Ordered an 18inch pizza with 6 toppings Absolutely 100% would recommend. New favorite place for pizza...fair price, excellent flavor and quality. If their other menu items are half as good as the pizza I would give this place 6/5 stars. I ate 2 slices of my 18inch pizza and was quite full. Great place fir a date, celebration, or mother's day/father's day dinner

Kevin Bradley Kline

Exceptional Italian cuisine. I had the Salmon, my wife had Chicken Parmesan. Both were excellent. The service was outstanding, the manager even checked in on us a few times. Reasonably priced as well. I would recommend this place to anybody, especially those who like Italian.

Audrey Wood

My daughter took me here for mother's day. What a wonderful experience! Fantastic ambience, the people were terrific, and the food was very good. Would definitely come back. Don't miss the artichoke dip. It went very well with the wine that I picked, a very nice German reisling which was a very good find. We both enjoyed our main course, and the dessert was out of this world. Thank you. Antonio's for a wonderful time.

Jessica Ellsworth-Foster

Loved the decor in the restaurant area! The atmosphere was very enjoyable. We were satisfied with our food. Will definitely return and recommend.

Caleb Aardsma

Definitely would recommend for the best of sit down Italian food!

Tina Pfeiffer

Great food and wonderful staff. Family owned. They care about their customers and make every effort to make customers happy.

Adam Gartner

Excellent Calamari and Seafood Ravioli Alfredo. Great service. Only disappointment was in the portion size of the Ravioli. For the price I expected more than 6 raviolis, but man were they good.

Karen Werbianskyj

Best Italian Restaurant in town! Great food good people, awesome atmosphere makes Antonio's the best.

Barbara Pietraszewski

Positively delightful, as always. The staff are so warm and genuinely kind. They care about a good experience for you, and you can feel that. And the food... well... fantastic! You just cannot go wrong here.

David Schmidt

Amazing food, staff was so delightful. Weather was perfect for outdoor seating. If you sit indoors, bring a jacket as it is a bit chilly.

John Brasseur

The Ambiance is true Italian and the food was Incredible at a good price making it a great value! Menu is very diverse with items you don't see everywhere.

Britta Copeland

Great food and atmosphere

Paula Leavy

Amazing food.. can't wait to go back

R Richardson

Great food as ALWAYS. This restaurant is always offering GREAT service.

Bonnie Carlson

We have only been there once, But I'll tell you, when we are back in town. We will be there forsure. ❤❤

Scott Noyes

Great service, great menu....really, really good Italian food! Nice selection of spirits,too.

L S

Tiffany was our server and made excellent recommendations. We ate on the patio and had a lovely dinner. Highly recommend trying (or returning to) Antonio's and ask for Tiffany.

Jim Hin

Some of the best food I've had in a long time. Great service for our group event also.

Patti C

Pizza was excellent. Calamari was predictable. Service was adequate. Got off I80 to avoid rollaway food.

Lafaun Davenport

The pizza is awesome! Great staff

Joseph Nietupski

Authentic Italian food, nice staff.

Bruce Velthouse

Inviting atmosphere. Friendly staff. Absolutely great food and drinks. Worth the wait anytime. This was my first time. I will be a repeat customer. I'm definitely going back to try the "Vegas Pizza" I was told about when I was here tonight. House salad, margharita pizza, sausage and pepperoni pizza, Moscow mule and a few Moscato's are what we enjoyed tonight. And Alissa... or Allison

Diana Engle

Awesome food! The Pope's Chicken is my personal favorite!

Ron Halfman

The basis for my review of an Italian restaurant is on chicken parmesan, only. Antonio's is 5 star all the way. The chicken was seasoned well, the sauce was delicious, and the pasta was al dente. So many Italian restaurants fry a chicken breast and slap some ragu over the top and call it chicken parm, Antonio's did not. I can not wait to go back and try the pizza

Eric Tomlinson

Love the deep dish pizza!

Bob Foley

Food was really good. I was disappointed with the Service. We were there at 4:00 and it was slow. Didnt get our appetizer that we ordered and we felt as if we didn't matter. We love Paul and the food, so we will probably be back. Hope next time is better.

Debbie Bosler

Phenomenal service, excellent stuffed crust pizza I don't have to go to Chicago for a pie any more. The spinach artichoke dip is awesome and the make it with large pieces of artichoke heart!!

Tim Rushenberg

Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. I enjoy the food and experience very much!

paula mischanko

My employer took me here for my birthday it was my second time coming here. I LOVE the bread they bring to the table, the dishes are served beautifully. Their wait staff are very friendly. The salmon looks great and I plan to try it on my next visit. Had a great experience here and enjoyed my birthday!

Stephen Cripe

The delight that keeps on coming. I have driven past this restaurant many times and had no idea of the delicacies within. Walking through the front door, one is immediately taken into a Mediterranean decor with walls and ceilings painted as a European restaurant, spot and gentle lighting, the pizza oven to the left. The building is much larger on the inside and includes large party sized rooms. At our table of eight, we started with warm bread, crackling crust on the outside, soft on the inside, almost melting in the mouth with the high grade butter. The tasty nights reminded me of the artisan breads of Europe. A shared dish of meats, Italian cheese, firm but not hard, nor too much crumble. I had a sizzling pasta with peppers, tomatoes, Italian sausage and washed it with a Blue Moon beer. They have tap beers, mixed drinks, wine. Others enjoyed pasta dishes with chicken or lobster. Perfectly cooked al dente with a well paired sauce. A local mentioned he has never had a plate he did not like and the pizza is delicious. They had three eye pleasing fresh deserts, though the main dish was enough to satisfy in itself. I will return with my spouse on date night. There are plenty of cozy nooks for two that entice one to settle in for good food and conversation. A hidden treasure that will not disapoint.

Mary Shatt

Excellent Italian Dinner! Professional staff and very accommodating. We highly recommend Antonio's. We both had the Pope's Chicken and it was very, very good. Nice wine list too!

Ridge Morrison

One of the best resteraunts I have eaten at in the area. Customer service is top notch! Manager is amazing! Very good quality food! First experience left us craving more. Authentic Italian, with an upscale expirience with a decent price tag. Highly recommend.

Maribel Segui

Great People and Great Food

David Miller

Perhaps one of the finest authentic Italian restaurants anywhere in north America. Antonio's competes in the world pizza contest bringing back trophies and recipes. Great staff and ambiance. They are geniuses. Worth the visit.

Austin Durling

It was a great experience! Sensible portions and a good presentation on the plates. Our waitress was very professional and attentive, the holiday decor and music was festive yet tasteful, and the restaurant had a welcoming atmosphere. They have a bar area too if you're looking for a more casual setting. I highly recommend Antonio's.

Blackie Blackerson

4-14-19 Today was our first visit at Antonios what an AWESOME visit. From Taylor our server to Paul Pizza Champion of the world thank you. When I say pizza champion of the world he really is he won championships at Las Vegas recently and been to Italy to compete and what a down home guy I got to shake his hand an honor.. The restaurant is the nicest place and clean and very friendly thank everybody on Antonios team. The food is great the deserts are to die for. You get A+++ or on a military scale 4.0. Today was our first visit but now we are Life Long customers it was worth the 28 mile drive from {Niles Michigan} to find this gem. I have been hearing about Antonios on 95.3 MNC for years . I am 58 years old and kind of do not believe in anything to much but Antonios I believe in you. P.S. we had the Margaritta pizza we left nothing and it was So Good we got another to go and the bread sticks are the best bread sticks we ever had they are AWESOME. Antonios really cares it shows.. Chuck and Kim Rodgers

Jody Divjak

Great place..good pizza and good service

Helen Schooley

Great pizza love it had a great time kids took us out !!!

Scott Gruver

We had a Birthday party and the staff was great!! Food was awesome as usual!

Joe Black

Great food, great staff,very niece place to eat.

Marty Miller

My wife and I have been coming here for years. This is the best Italian restaurant in northern Indiana. My wife lived in Chicago for 18 years, Antonio’s beats anything she had while living there. Keep up the good work!!!!!!

Ken Hanson

The best Italian food around!!

Angela Scott

Was good, but i exspected better, after i read reviews.

Rick Copenhaver

This is fantastic. Every person in the area should go here. I love this place

Stanley Gordon

Was there on Friday night and it is way too noisy, we had trouble hearing the waitress. The food is good although my lasagna could have been a little hotter. Service was good and quick considering how busy it was. Definitely need reservations, call early. Portions are bigger than the bill

Beth Scarbrough

Great food and service

SuperMetalmaniacs

Best pizza on the planet hands down. Italian Stallion pizza is amazing.

Stephen Wiebe-Johnson

We enjoy a quiet supper of salmon salad and rib eye steak. Very pleasant evening.

Mary Jo & Dave Sheedy

Great! First time at rest.

Michael Crabill

Outdoor patio is wonderful. A couple of craft beers on the taplist. My wife loved the Vegas award winning pizza, it was OK to me. The round sausage is pretty spicy, might want to pick some of it off if you want a milder taste.