Reviews of Sully's Irish Pub (Restaurant)

Cindy Cole

Had a great time listening to BFF and music by Faith outside at Sully's. Had a few beers and soft pretzels with beer cheese dip. Service was excellent.

Karen Mastrippolito

Great food and brews. Music was great.

Matthewseven13 .

Great place to eat and drink, very friendly staff. Felt like my hometown pub.

Leonard Aguilar

Great Friendly Atmosphere

Chris Bonney

Staff friendly, nice old building, A/C not working, had the fish and chips, haddock was nice meal a little pricey

Randy Dawson

Best food and beer selection around.

Corrie Robinson

Warm and friendly

Elizabeth McElroy

Staff is awesone! New appetizer. ..BOOM BOOM SHRIMP.... FANTASTIC!

Matt Sanderson

Service was excellent. Megan and Michelle took good care of us even though they were quite busy. A nice young man brought out our food and a cheesesteak that had fried onions which shouldn't have and it was replaced so quick it was amazing. The fried shrimp was fantastic with a very light batter I really liked. Atmosphere on the patio was very cool. This place just has a good vibe and I would highly recommend it.

son guy

Coolies

Jack B

Food was excellent!

Bjoern Oleson

Good food, but very loud. A conversation is almost impossible. You have to fight your way out through all the smokers in front of the door.

Wesley Finneyfrock

Small town pub

Akinkunmi akinyombo

Great burgers

Ian Smith

New to the area. Went for an early lunch and were very happy with our food. Bangers and Mash, fish and chips, and a pulled pork sandwich were all excellent. Good beer selection too. Definitely going back.

A H

Awesome Irish pub with great food

Edam Colon

Try the Boxty with hot peppers. I believe It was the owner who recommended it and it was amazing!! Nice chill place to come by and enjoy a bite to eat and a cold beer.

Louise LLOYD

GREAT SHRIMP

Philip Mallet-Prevost

Great crowd, always fun..... excellent food!

1badpiper

Good Irish bar, Guinness on tap

D.L. Deryous

Super fun! Wednesday Night Karaoke Night!!

Karen Romecki

Fun place. Great food.

Ronald Prescott

Went to Sully's for the first time with my wife last night. The live music was awesome and the large breaded shrimp meal was one of the best I ever had! The servers were very attentive to us even though the outside was very crowded. We cant wait to go again!!

Danny Wiener

First time here. Wait staff very friendly.

Jay Berkman

The fish and chips is a large fillet of beer battered haddock with crisp chips.

Charles Nichols Jr

Great food, awesome bartenders, never a bad Guinness pour

Robert Sporay

Could use more tables

Steven C Wilson

Great Ruben!!!!!

jb Myers

friendly atmosphere, good drinks and staff.

Kathleen Norman

Great service, good prices.

DJ Kelly

Good food. Not friendly except to the obvious regulars.

jenikeeley Keeley

A very comfortable atmosphere. Bartenders are very friendly and congenial. The food arrived timely and hot! I do not recommend the crab cake...it was mostly filler and very little meat.... Although, I was disappointed in the facilities, only having 1 womens disheveled bathroom, with a line waiting, for a packed house on a Saturday night! It doesn't represent the establishment well.

Sumer Dyer

Always dirty drinks are not made properly and the staff is everything less than professional

Yohana Wichess

Love their pot pie!

MionnieGamerTV Castro

Right now was only outside seating because remodeling,was fine for me in long pants but husband was in shorts so mosquitoes were bothering his legs.Had crab fries for appetizer,we both liked,but waitress misunderstood that my husband wanted the wings and steamed shrimp for his meal and also brought the wings with the crab fries,so wings sat and got cold but just took home as leftovers.He liked the shrimp,I had the Reuben,was very good corned beef except if ever got again would order with light dressing and sauerkraut so I could taste the cheese.All in all we liked and will probably go back again when full menu available.No big deal but server should of explained up front charge for water,and would of loved if she offered me something in place of more fries with my Reuben :-)!also,glad didn't take grandson,he would not have eaten with such limited menu

Shemeria Gibbs

Awsome

Robbie Bass

I don't recommend this bar my opinions on the owner is to vulgar for public internet. Take your hard earned money elsewhere

Chris Hamilton

Awesome pub to hang out and have a drink

Caitlyn Conly

Always a good time!

Ted Hinderer

Best place in Middletown great service and the food is always over the top.

Nancy Heller

We had the Irish corned beef sandwich with chunks of corned beef! It was about 2 inches thick and warm and wonderful. We enjoyed a perfectly poured black and tan, with the fries. Service was prompt and friendly.

Melissa Crouser

Love it!!

Brittany Fox

Great bar, friendly staff, great prices and love the atmosphere

Jim Cummings

Regular neighborhood watering hole

Sarah Unruh

Good service, with good happy hour prices.

Brent Evans

Great location, beer selection, and while we only had the pretzels appetizer, it was excellent

William White

A lot of great apps

Deidre Hairston

Fun service, good apps.

Glenn Wolfe

The remodeling is complete and it is a great improvement

Eric G

I don't get here enough. Good... Better than good food and a nice selection of booze. America. Nice staff as well.

Hillary Katz

great drinks and fun atmosphere

Debra Stewart

Great food and atmosphere, outdoor seating available next to town square. Excellent drinks and service.

Margaret Moor-Orth

What a great place to spend the evening over dinner. The owner was great like we've known him for years, even though we just met. Would recommend Sully's for a warm and refreshing evening out.

Dennis Kerns

Good selection of draught beer and unique cocktails.

Christopher Glenn

Friendly staff with good service and a nice patio

Bernie Lederer

I honestly started losing hope in Middletown of getting decent food. There's a difference between pre-portioned heated microwaved food and Sully's Irish Pub. Although they have a limited menu their food is always fresh they're not afraid to make it big and they're not afraid to make it tasty. The bartenders and wait staff for great very personable lots of fun. Had a chance to speak to the owner a couple times super nice guy. At the end of the day it's one of my first choices when we want to go grab something to eat. I highly recommend Sully's Irish Pub

Christopher Donahue

Beer is super cold, music is fun and card games are great

Tom Williams

Good food. Great service.

Charles Robinson

Really loved the roast beef boxty!

Gary Schall

Really don't like what they did during the remodel of this place. It just feels dysfunctional with the seating arrangements for dining-in worse than before. This place used to have a good vibe but that is gone now.

T.J

We ALWAYS love coming here for trivia with our friends! The food's "to die for", and the Staff's AWESOME! It's a bit pricey, but it's definitely worth it! Speaking of Monday Night Trivia, the first place team wins a $20 GIFT CARD to Sully's. Second place earns a $10 GIFT CARD.

Kathie Billmire

Met family members here on a Sunday cold night. While they don't have Shepherd Pie on the menu the Gensis stew was delicious.

Sharon Poisson

Waited close to 10 minutes to get a beverage. We were completely ignored.

Greg Marcozzi

Traditional Irish pub with a decent selection of beers, good food and friendly bartenders. I had the bangers and mash -- quite tasty!

Sean Loewy

Cool vibe and top notch pub food offerings, best wings in Middletown I have found in past 2 years. Thoroughly enjoy offerings on tap as well as knowledgable bartender of those beers. Give it a try with the guys.

Chad Fenstermaker

Decent crowd, 3/4 of the staff is great, the rest shouldn't work with people

Karen Riehm

Just a good meeting place to catch up with friends & have a drink and lite bite

James Thaw

Great place ! Good food !

a moser

The food is good. The atmosphere and staff are very welcoming. My only complaint is that they have to find a way to make the deck area more usable. Ceiling or large fans of some kind and move the tables away from the ac units, it blows hot air onto the patrons sitting at the table next to it.

Wayne Hutchison

To loud. Food. Fair

Emily Konzelmann

Really great bar, loved the food, however, owner was drunk and threatened to call the police on us and kicked us out.

Anna Jewett

The food is great and the staff sre very nice.

Jeffrey Wrobel

good food

Alan C. Emsley

Great spot, excellent service, friendly staff, good food

Nigel O'Connell

Was commuting from a friend's wedding in Tilghman Island back up to New York and stopped in here for a cold one and some food. Was great local American grub and really enjoyed the seafood they had on offer. Seemed like a charming little town and a slice right out of textbook Americana. Found it funny the amount of stares I got in there though in all fairness I think it has been awhile since someone with such a thick Aussie accent had been through.

JD Mc

Great draft beer selection including some solid craft beers. Just did a bunch of appetizers and they were all very good. Service was great and the downtown location was cool. Outside seating available along the street.

Joyce Smith

Food is good... but the owner is not friendly- quite abrupt. Atmosphere changes when he enters.

Jam Morales

Lovely waiters! The seafood here is excellent! Big shrimps!

Sally Ball

Fun

Daniel Crouser

Stopped in on a whim and really enjoyed it. The reuben I ordered was great and the Guinness was poured perfectly. The bartendresses were great and very accommodating. Definitely plan to making return visits to Sully's.

G White

Delicious fried shrimp!!!

Michael

Classic Irish bar. Good drinks and bar menu.

Joe Bennett

The service and food is terrible. Went once and won’t return.

Don Rees

Guinness Irish Stew was unbelievable along with the steamed shrimp. Staff super friendly and made sure you felt welcome. Highly recommend to stop for a bite and a beer.

Gregory Desgrosseilliers

Cool neighborhood spot. Great location. Right on the town square the perfect place to grab a quick bite to eat on a cool evening.

steven schofield

Local and awesome people.

Brett Sabbato

Could be a good spot, but the owner is a tool. Flyers in a playoff game, but he wouldn’t put it on as he was sitting at the bar watching golf.... not a big tournament, just golf... couldn’t accommodate a customer for a playoff game. Really? Who does that?

James J

Good food & nice atmosphere I've had their Shepard's Pie and their Beef Tips, and both were fantastic. The staff is extremely friendly, except for the big guy behind the bar. Nice outdoor patio too. But, what's going on with management? The unfriendly guy apparently is the owner, and what happened to their web-site?

Ken Mcnaughton

Good food , horrible service. Seems like you have to be a regular to get noticed

Carl Owens

Good local feel

levin deshields

Excellent

Joan Carter

Don't try the Rubin sandwich. If you do you will die frm Joy!!!!!!!!!

CC Da'Man

Not impressed, loud locals and poor bar service from young gals on their cell phones

JJ Harrison

Had cheesesteak and fries on the outside patio. Love the look of the renovation of the bar!

Lisa Warren

Good food and drinks!

Teresa Cooper

Live the new bar..more light is great. More room for tables. First time since bar has been put it. Seafood stew was great. Thank yoi.

Bruce Honaker

Small place but very friendly staff food was awesome plenty of food came out hot waitress was friendly and took care of our group

william falkner

Amazing spot. Chuck the owner does a great job. Great food and great staff!

Emma Biederman

Would never have eaten here (outside) if I'd walked through the door first...

Looney Lulu

I went for a drink the bartenders were very nice and caring definitely I'll go again

78harleydave .

Very nice, sat outside enjoyed the town and all the cars driving by on a beautiful day. Very helpful wait staff.

Cristina Lambiase

Reasonable drink prices, traditional cozy pub feel. The live band was excellent, but way too loud. You know it's loud when 25 year olds AND the bar staff are complaining! Everyone said Friday night, although always a live music night, isn't typically THAT loud. Had a good time with an age spread from, just old enough to drink-up to people in their 60s. I'll definitely try another Friday night.

Sue Mitchell

Great service, food very good!!

Bob Pinnola

Good food. Interesting menu. Cold beer. Many choices. Comfortable atmosphere. Quick service. Reasonable prices. Had an excellent lunch there. Will be back.

Mary Jo Graham

Great staff!

Jennifer Haldas

Look no further for your friendly corner pub! Absolute top notch staff and huge bonus the delicious menu... Definitely not your average pub food.... It leans more towards gourmet!

Julius Kemenes

Great place

Lynda Hrycak

Have been here several times but didn't really appreciate them till St Patrick's day. They know how to handle a crowd. Chesapeake City should take notes!

Scott R.

The owner is a POS!

Mike Weber

Nice place for a drink. Outdoor seating is very pleasant in the evening. There will be live music on the first and third Friday’s,May through September, so it will be something we go back for again!

Richard Schieke

Okay Irish Pub. Wait staff friendly ,then decided to text and hang out with friends . While they were doing that they closed the kitchen before they took my food order. Not impressed.

Chris Zamami

Great food Awesome bartender Fran

j Carey

Great place, very inviting! Center of Middletown.

Eric Ray

Worst place in town

Ken M

Damn, that was a pretty good burger. Great tomato for December.

RM Lunday

Great food, great service, and great beer selection. Is there anything else?

Gerald Wardrop

Good food and beer

Brian Brown

I've been coast to coast and I've never tasted Seafood that was so clean and refreshing and the Finish after each bite makes you want to go back for another bite it's hard to leave. Brian from Anthony Sylvan pools

Keith Webb

The menu needs to be updated, it never gets changed it's the same old thing week after week

Justin dixon

Great food.

Samantha Baranowski

Went to Sully's for the first time last night and I wasn't impressed. The bar was basically empty but the bartender was distant and sat with her boyfriend the entire time. She never called last call but her boyfriend was sure to turn up the lights at 12:44 and cut of the TV and music. Just bad business practices and poor work ethic. I'm sure that's the norm there because the boyfriend knew exactly what to do to close the bar while we were still sitting there

Joe Taylor

Had the loaded burger. Very tasty. Wife had the fish and chips. Fish was in the fryer too long but the meat was good.

Tina Sturgis

Food is delicious. Staff friendly and attentive. Not expensive and they have a great selection of beers available.

Anthony Gonzalez

Espectacular !!!! Lo recomiendo 100%

Steve H

Food was very good, we dinned at the outside tables which is nice on a warm night but there were two problems, the flies were annoying and because they allowed smoking at the tables it ruined the dinning experience.

Northside Fin

Great friendly atmosphere... Awesome food

Crystal Lofland

Great staff, great food, enjoyed very much,

Janine Grossnickle

Good food and wonderful service

Sukhmeet Khalar

Their food is amazing! Service could be a little better. Messed up order, however, the mess up was still amazing.

Blair Hickman

Nice little local bar. Great beer selection.

Eugene Griffith

This is an excellent Irish Pub!! Authentic food and music! Very cold beer and numerous selections! The staff makes you feel like a local!! Brie, the head bartender with keep you entertained and thirst free! I was able to drink beer with the owner, Chuck Sullivan!! If you want to watch sports they have multiple TVs playing hockey, baseball, basketball, football, soccer!! Live music every weekend! Look for music on the square on the first and third Fridays of the month! Inside and outside seating with a huge horse shoe bar inside! I had the beef stew and it was very authentic! The building was a hotel that was built in 1761! If you are in the area I would definitely check this place out, you will not be disappointed! Enjoy!!

tommysmallss

Nothing impressive. It's Middletown.

gilbert vega

Great bartenders and great service couldn't ask for more they were polite and super helpful