Reviews of Smithfield Hall NYC (Restaurant)

Nidhish D

If you're a United fan then don't miss out this place to watch live football matches. Amazing ambiance and vibe. Definitely going to come again.

josephine Ralph

Great place friendly staff

Roe Palermo

Nice place to have drinks with friends

Theo Goodman

Great place for any fan of any soccer team to come watch a game. This place was packed during the World Cup. I highly recommend trying the chicken katsu burger if you're looking to get something to eat.

Gavin Li

Watched Poland Columbia world cup game and it was really fun. Bar was packed, great atmosphere, food looked good

Craig Avena

Cool bar, good beer selection. Plenty of tv’s

Gihan Taha

I recommend, we spent nice time.

No One

Food is pretty good. Only reason not five stars, is because I feel like they cut the sweet potato fries pretty thin.

ant 2419

I love this bar. It is a manchester united bar. The people are friendly, the food and beer are good and the environment is just a good fun time. If your a united fan in ny you must visit this place

Naga Prakash Danda

Go there if you don't want to cry by yourself watching a Giants game. You will find a shoulder everywhere in the bar. Side note: they got good veggie burger

Vince PeGan

One of my favorite sports bars in NYC

Manu Dominguez

OFFICIAL BAR FOR BARCELONA FÚTBOL CLUB FANS. In this bar you always can watch the Barcelona games. It doesn't matter the hour and also they pass a lot of soccer games. There are a lot of Barcelona fans and you feel great there. In this occasion I ate this Phillly cheese steak sandwich with fries, it was ok you can eat their food without complain understanding you are in a bar to enjoy a game and maybe drink not for special food. The service was Good. The hit to the wallet for this sandwich is 10$. ... ---- See you soon in the another review @elmanudominguez (Instagram)

LBFBWN News

The food is great, great service, friendly staff just saw the Canelo vs GGG fight and an awesome place. Definitely recommend

Tony Clomax

The bartender was very nice, however the long delay of my dry wings and seasonless onion rings hurts this rating. Drink beer, but skip the food. Trust me.

Geoffrey Si

Bar has European football games, cheap booze, and plenty of seating. All in all a really great combination of things.

Hampton Brown

Great place to watch live sports and as a Manchester United fan it's great to be in a place with other supporters like me

Sammy Sanandres

Good place, having two big bars is always great food is good also. Great place to watch sports!

Joseph Coleman

Great game atmosphere but the service isn't up to par

Karthik Srinivasan

Great space for Manchester United games. Absolute scenes

sedrick vanisi

We're all 50 friends having fun and memorable time after marching for our lives on world pride. Service could be better but we still had a blast.

Gigi Moore

Get the chicken & waffles! It’s delicious

Nathan Connor

Best place for futbol (soccer)

Babak

Nowhere else to go as a United fan in New York! Last time I had been was over a year before and there was such a long queue to get in. However, to my surprise the bouncer recognised me and told me to wait and he'd make sure I got in. I always plan my trips to New York around catching a game here!

Jason M

Meh. Reasonably priced food. Cool atmosphere. Great sports TVs. Bar service was pretty bad.

Faraz Hyder

We came here to watch a World Cup match and had to show up at 8:30am for a 10am match if you wanted a seat but the environment was excellent. It was a packed house and the breakfast food was pretty good too. I would definitely recommend!

Starlet Greene

The steak taste perfect and perfectly cook an has an amazing flavor. They had 2 waitresses that was not pleasant by the way. Overall the location is nice and good comfort.

Paul Kemper

Good if you are a soccer fan who wants to watch specific games. They even broadcast the Dutch League from time to time.

Alisha’s World

The fries are amazing! The service was great too!!

Joseph Solfaro

Hit or miss for lunch. The kitchen seems quite slow. Good spot to catch a game and grab a beer. The staff is friendly and work there best. Good and large salad options!

Caleb Harris

I arrived a little after 2 pm on a Saturday. It was fairly empty at first, but more people came in as a soccer match was about to start. The service was absolutely atrocious. It took maybe 25-30 minutes to get our food (2 brunch items), and the server did not check on us during that entire period (not even a water refill). The food was mediocre. I had chicken and waffles. Portion size was a bit below average, which is fine for me, but I would expect it at least to taste pretty good. Anyway, it’s probably a fine place to watch a game and have a drink at the bar, but I don’t recommend brunch or other meals here with table service.

Prasad Iyer

Best place for Barcelona fans. You will enjoy it to the core. I was there for Bacelona vs Real Madrid and it was amazing. Bdw keep in mind that whenever there is a big match of Barcelona they usually take in only the penya Barcelona nyc members. It's a 35 dollar membership fee for a season but it is totally worth it. The place was very crowded instead of that the orders came in very fast. Do try the Smith hall lager it's subtle in taste.

David E Alfaro Barboza

The security guard at the door was quite disrespectful. It is a shame. I was about to enter with my wife to watch a game. There are other ways to talk to the customer that the place have reached its maximum capacity. I will necer go back to this place.

Des Brownlie

Great location to watch fitba (soccer) and the Jameson wings are worth trying

Darin Simpson

Drinks were good.Great service.

Roberto Poo

Great place for watching soccer games. Food is not that good though and service is slow even before it's full.

Jonathan Deasy

Great sports bar nice breakfast nd d chicken wings r so good

Andrew Shiah

Cool sports bar with a good atmosphere, great spot to catch a game. It’s most lively for soccer, but watching anything here doesn’t disappoint. Awesome selection of beer, good food, and great service. Bartenders and hostesses are all very friendly and helpful, and great to chat with when it’s not as busy.

Wesly Gagerie

Watched Haiti defeat Costa Rica 2-1 there. Awesome. Had a blast.

mike olsen

I had never been here before and only went for a New York Red bulls even for rivalry week. Outside of all of the event decorations and other going on, which were nice, the bar itself is pretty solid. They had a good selection of bar eats, the beer selection was solid and the bartender was knowledgeable about the in house beers and friendly. I will be sure to go back again when I am in the area and need a drink or if I am not in the area but close enough and need a drink.

Margaret

Great food and drinks but the best thing is the way they take care of their regulars and fan groups here. Bayern fans especially will feel at home here

Ian Zlatkin

This classic Irish pub is second incarnation of Smithfield. When they had to close their doors at the original location it was a sad day. But this “new” location brought most of the amazing food with it minus the foie gras burger but nothing on the menu is bad. Chopped salad, quinoa burger, regular burger, chicken and waffles, it’s all great. Plenty of space and not pretentious at all compared to some of the other bars in this area. Not many GF options but what you can eat is amazing!!! Wish they carried GF buns, it would make a world of difference for me at least

Appy Ammer

Great place to watch football / soccer (especially if a west ham fan)

Richard Nash

Watched United beat Spurs and got high as a kite with fellow reds! United!

Michael Hall

Nothing but memories are made here. Fast service and fair prices.

Porscha Clark

Great for bar food, but not for family. The food was good.

Lance Lennie

If you’re a united fan, and it’s a match day... it’s a absolute no brainier. Big shoutout to Brendan, who was a great barman.

Bryan Hill

Thought this would be a good place to watch football. It was not. There were TVs that no one was watching that they wouldn’t change to another game. Unless you happen to be a fan of a random team that they lock a TV onto, I would try to find another place to watch football.

Shaswat Rao

Great for enjoying football (soccer) with fellow fans.

Kadis Ositny

Great veggie burgers & service

Robert Landry

I wandered in here looking for brunch with my fiancé. Saw the brunch menu and it looked good. We had no clue it was a soccer pub until we walked in. It was Saturday at 10 and premier league matches were on. What a great time! Really fun and somewhat rowdy crowd. The brunch was delicious and quick considering how crowded it was.

Ryan

Nice bartender and fair drink prices.

Tapan Desai

Good atmosphere for football/soccer fans. Very friendly serving staff and some really tasty food. Definitely worth a visit again.

Roger Ho-Yen

Great bar and the official supporters bar for the American outlaws NYC chapter. Came to see a US game and they had it playing on all the TV's. Be sure to get the candied bacon as it's a must! We also had the Jameson wings and they were great too!

Loraine Kelly

Great food, friendly service, nice atmosphere, good for watching sport

Carla T

The food was good the atmosphere was great

Jeremy O

Decent food and beer selection. Service also good. Typical pub grub selection. Would definitely recommend the chicken Katsu burger. Super unique and tasty! Had the Mac and cheese as well and it was average.

David Tattersall

Great place to watch a football match on a Saturday morning. They do British bacon sandwiches. Happy hour after work is pretty good too - plenty of space to sit.

Dale Trzebiatowski

Large bar, good drink selection, decent food. Overall great evenojg

Luis Lithgow

Great staff and good drinks I usually come here to watch the FC Barcelona games and the food and drinks are served quickly without losing it's quality

Yishay Mansour

great brunch!

Henry Lo

Great place to have a beer and watch a soccer game. Food is decent, the selection of beers however, is quite nice.

Jessie C

Nice place to watch sport games, however the music get really really loud on the evening and it gets hard to have a conversation. Food was great and copious though

Brian Landy

Great place to watch utd in New York

Peter Salem

I had an awesome time stopping here to watch the West Ham game during my trip to NYC, the NYC Hammers group definitely helped with the atmosphere since we were the biggest fan group in the place. Great atmosphere, if you are passing through town and want you see your team on the weekend, stop by here.

Smart Design

amazing place well done food one amazing night!

julie dearson

Great pub with plenty of atmosphere, good food, friendly staff with

Edson Segovia

Came here to catch a Barcelona game and I'm definitely coming back. The environment was lively and energetic. Plenty of TVs and space to move around. Great atmosphere overall and good selection of beers.

rohith rao

Some of my favorite wings in the city. Comes with a whiskey hot sauce. Has all the sports packages as well

Henning Stumm

Best place to watch soccer in New York City. They show all the games from all the leagues world wide! All lot of the teams fan clubs have their home here. Always a great atmosphere.

Erika Suarez

We chose this to watch the US world cup game. As vegans, it's hard to find sports bars that serve food that we can eat besides fries or a plain veggie burger (without the cheese). They really delivered!! There were a ton of options--the maple glaze tofu burger I had was super good. The atmosphere was great. Certainly a place we'll be coming back to for subsequent games or other meetups. Keep up the good work!!

Ray Hudson

MAGESSSSSTEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERIAL PLACE & EVEN BETTER PEOPLE. THIS PLACE IS VALHALLA FOR PROPER FUTBOL FANS.

Konstantine Kobalia

Awesome sports bar, friendly stuff

Santiago Estrada

One of the best places to watch football (or soccer if you're American). Nice crowd, beers, and chicken wings

Juan Figueroa

Perhaps one of the best places to watch a soccer game. This place is massive in contrast to other manhattan-neighboring bars. Their food is not the best, as would be expected from a bar scene. But the atmosphere is always fun, you can almost expect a tone of general understanding and appreciation for the game from anyone who comes to Smithfield Hall. It’s a place where all fans are welcomed and without penalty of exclusivity.

Kim

I ordered a Maker's Mark old fashioned and it was perfect. Service was prompt too.

Kim Purser

Went here to meet up with the NYC Hammer's⚒️to watch the game made to feel welcome by everyone there. Had a great time and enjoyed the game. We opted for coffee as it was before noon, the coffee was good and hot☕ great place to watch The Irons play. #COYI

Ian Smith

Best bar I've been anywhere in the world to watch European football. This place deserves more than 5 stars. Kevin is a top barman. This is also a great place for coffee and breakfast for the afternoon kick offs (3pm kick off is 10am in NYC). They have so many games on, I even managed to watch Wigan Athletic Vs Nottingham Forest here. Up the 'tics!

Gilad Samuels

Came there to watch a Barcelona match and had a great time! The beers are a bit expensive but the experience was a lot of fun

Kevin Holmes

Great spot to catch the Raptors game in NYC. The food is surprisingly good, the service was decent aside from a long wait for our food order. I would certainly go back, not too crowded and a lot of TV's to catch a game.

Angela Tejada

Amazing service.

Brad Murdick

Great bar! Bartender was awesome

Arion Ramsey

Can't beat this place as far as the football games go. Highly recommended.

Barbara Roldan

Nice large space with accessibility. Great place to watch UFC, boxing, etc. Staff are friendly and attentive. The food is delicious too.

Mark

Good sports bar, really helpful staff. Recommended.

Travis W Keyes

We had a holiday party here and they couldn't be more accommodating and the space was great

riccardo liotta

Definitely one of the best bars in New York. And if you like to watch football, this is the place!!!

Dave Thomas

Great sports bar... Food is good, beer selection is incredible. The hostess was awesome, didn't get her name but she had a British Accent. Our server Hannah was the best. Ask for her she is amazing and an incredibly nice young lady.

Pratheep Sevanthinathan

Best soccer bar I've been to. There are two sides divded by a wall with bars on both sides. One side had EPL the other had Bundesliga. But both sides had plenty of games on including other leagues.

S K

Great place to watch big UFC events. Lots of good ppl will turn up. Wide variety of beers as well

Andrew Vatier

if you are a huge soccer fan this place is probably a dream. They open early for the games and place is packed with people very passionate for their teams. Bar is a nice size and lots of seating available. Gets packed for big games as expected

Joel Velez

Food here is above average, as far as bar food goes. Bar is really spacious and not crowded. Drinks are inexpensive by NY standards. Overall, I enjoyed it more than some posh, overpriced places I've been to. More of a dive than a sports bar, this is a great place to meet friends and just chill. Excellent!

The giant diamond Salmon

What an amazing environment to watch sports. The food is always good.

Christian

The staff is very friendly, however, the drinks are way too expensive for what they offer. I got served juice one time, got charged like $21, it was literally orange juice with .0001% vodka. Great people though.

Theodore Sispoidis

Ordered a burger, with fries and they were both fantastic.

Shannon Luker

Food was yummy... Irish bartender was super funny and likeable. Only reason they dont get the extra star is bc we waited awhile bc the kitchen was backed up!

Marissa Rasmussen

Food is okay, typical bar food. The service we had wasn't the best, but if you're not in a rush, it's fine.

Mathurin Meillon

Spacious, nice food, great service.

Robert Salazar

Nice spot for the beer + sports crowd. Especially if you’re a soccer fan.

Prasanna Joglekar

Great food, great atmosphere and The place to watch Manchester United games.

Aaryn Vivian

From start to finish, this was an amazing pub experience. My bartender Tom introduced me to some locals and kept the drinks flowing. Will be back if I'm ever in NYC again!

Paul Rivot

Good bar. Great service ... nice clientele.

Benji Portwin

Good bar to watch sports, pretty bro-y though

Corey Johnson

Great bar, fun vibe. It is an English bar, so be prepared for a very crowded bar if there is a football match going

Camila Gómez Cualla

Great bar to watch games, great food too

Jason Lee

Mediocre food, terrible service. So many bars in the area, why waste your time here?

fabian zapata

Great spot for watch soccer The bartenders and prices are very nice

Les Richardson

If your a Mufc fan in NYC this is the place to go great atmosphere, and Kevin the barman fantastic host funny guy.

Jason Shepard

A great sports bar and the "go to" for soccer. Great drinks. Great people. I am here at least a few times a month. Prices are okay for what you get. Good lunch time vibe.

Joel S.G.

Watched NCAA tournament there. Great atmosphere and massive draft beer selection

matthew. E

Saw Man U rek Chelsea. 5/5 would watch again. However, some broad kept talking about Liverpool but I won't rate the bar on her taste in teams.

Nicholas Delzingaro

Great English/sports bar located between Chelsea and Flat Iron. Go there all the time for happy hour after work and it is a perfect spot for beer and pub food

Volker Detering

They respond to the weirdest request and show games on the screen in front of you.

Eric Lituchy

Good local bar. Lots of screens. The food is good and drinks are quench thirsting.

Rick Zhang

Place was awesome to watch the game, the food is great and the customer service is also great. Recommend the fries, calimari, and onion rings if you're looking for some good foods to share.

Harish Natarajan

Best place in NYC to catch a soccer game.

Esteban Cuesta

Unless you’re a manc, don’t go to this pub. I’ve been to Carragher’s and other Liverpool bars and they’ve allowed opposition fans to come in. However, this establishment will not let you in due to “security” reasons because the mancs they attract are unable to behave themselves. First of, we’re across the pond, so there’s no need to act like an idiot over a football match. Second, you’re missing out on a lot of customers.

Christine Alemany

This is for the bar side only The space quickly gets cramped and loud. This makes it hard to have a conversation so I always lose my voice when I come. The restaurant side seems much less annoying, though.

Bill Dukes

Very good food and friendly staff.

Phil Shaw

Great. Top beer with friendly staff and punters.

Olga Munoz

The right-after-work bar. It's dark and bar-e if you're looking for a place to watch a baseball, futbol or football game then this is the best place to go. It's conveniently located in Chelsea close to all office spaces around. The food is pretty good. The sweet potato fries are my favorite.

Juan Cruz Romera

If you love soccer you gotta come here. Passionate fans from all around the world. I went to see Copa Libertadores, but they also played other leagues. Would come back!!

oscar melo

Here is the location for the official Penya Del Barça in NYC. Best place to watch any soccer games. It has more than 30 TVs so you won't miss a thing.

Kenneth Cheatham

This isn’t our first time coming here. The first time we went to the bar and the bartender was really nice. Second time we came in we sat at the table. No waitress came to us until we said something to the bartender. So when the waitress finally came in. The tune of her voice was really rude and she doesn’t give no eye contact. She seem like she was in the hunger even thought it was fairly dead. (She is short long hair and somewhat chubby, big eyes) we went there yesterday 7/19 at 5:30pm. I feel like customer service is very important specially if you work as a waitress. The food was good, we got fries and pizza but less ketchup.

Jason Olshawsky

Fish and chips was great

norden millikenag

Great spot to watch a game, especially soccer games. I usually come here for some beers and to watch champions league games. Great atmosphere and quick service even during busy times.

Omar Antonio Del Rio Cardona

Awesome place. The staff is always trying to help you. Recommended 100%

Brumeilde _

I can't talk about the atmosphere during sport events because I went there when it was almost empty in the middle of the afternoon for lunch. But I have to say the food is awesome and the staff is really sweet and helping. I had ribs tacos which were absolutely delicious. I was astonished by how tasty it was! Same for the burgers. The quantity is also perfect (as a French I am not used to American huge portions). Prices are alright, I would even say rather cheap for NYC. It really was a nice surprise!

Krista Thoman

Great spot! We came for the NBA finals. The food is great, the service is good, and there are TVs everywhere! We recommend it.

Kaylon Tuttle

Fun place to watch some EPL

DigBick Jamaica

If you are a Liverpool fan..dont spend your time and money here. We were turned away before the champions league semifinals vs Barcelona.

Paul Springs

Big and loud sports bar. The drafts and bottles are a bit better than average, cocktails unimpressive. The food was decent, especially the Pat LaFrieda burgers and simple but surprisingly good guacamole. Good prices were a bit high for what you get though. Totally fine, but not my thing. I don't think I'll go back.

David Lee

Good G&T, well balanced.

Felix Boehme

Great soccer bar. Bayern Munich fanclub watches games here.

Sebastian Seydak

Best Sportsbar in town. And home of NYC FC Bayern Fanclub.

Samara Riviera

Great sports bar. Fun ambiance. Youthful people. Delicious fries and good drinks. Really enjoyed it for a Wednesday night.

James

The food was delicious, and the service was good, but it was so loud in there that I couldn't have a conversation inside. Probably great for anyone looking for a rowdy time, but it's not for me

David Chen

Great place if you want to hang out at a nice pub, watch some sport and grab some grub at a reasonable price.

Richard Braamburg

Place to be if you want to watch football (yeah that's soccer according some people) in a nice bar with some good beers.

Milind Singh

Brilliant atmosphere. I came all the way from New Haven. Missed a train. Cancelled three ubers. Finally got here. I am die hard United supporter. Even though we lost this trip was worth it. Ive finally found a decent place to watch matches.

judi jewell

Bartenders are the best - find Kevin

Emeka Okafor

Great space. The wings here are A1. 10/10

Gernot Amberg

Awesome place. And THE place if you’re Bayern Fan to watch soccer

Chaunice Chapman

Awesome bar, friendly and knowledgeable staff, Delicious food. Great place to watch Fútbol.

Tanya Rullan

Good bar food but pricey. I loved the sweet potato fries. Fried perfectly crisp and tender inside.

Jordan Lapid

They have a great DJ on Thursdays and Fridays.

Terry Hsiao

Great location if you are a Bayern fan !! Need more German beer and food option

Hector Segura, PhD

Friendly environment, good service, affordable prices and Barcelona games!

Bill Moore

Service was slow...took 10 minutes to get served at a table...draft beer tasted funny...experience did not meet expectations.

Chris Candreva

Excellent food and service.

Gilles Heber-Suffrin

Barmaid (pregnant) not a smile, not any good advice, seriously...

carlito ro

Food was great quinoa mushrooms burger. Guacamole and chips was served tp me so fast waitress barely assisted me didnt even getnwater nor napkins .I was done on a sunday afternoon of football super fast ..makes me wonder about the food

Paul Kavanagh

Great beer choices. Good, varied food. Amusing friendly bartender. Good crowd. Europa cup games. A really good time

Ellie Day

Met up with some friends and got some cheese fries and wings. The fries were good but the wings could have been better. Also, good if you’re looking for a sports bar where it doesn’t matter if it’s loud.

Eder Montero

Is a marvelous place to watch games.

Sam Mamedov

Great Service, Good beer and food selection, great sport bar

Kelly Mueller

Perfect spot to watch a game, so many TVs and the menu looked good also.

William Clarke

Great atmosphere for a united game, plenty of screens and a good choice of beers on tap.

Brian Ivory

One if the better sports bars in NY for Monday Night Football