Reviews of Pizza Plaza (Restaurant)

Troy Bloxom

Always and I do mean ALWAYS the best food from a wonderful family owned business.

Mark Christenson

Best pizza and service in Anchorage. They should find 5 more heidis. Very friendly.

David Gillich

Warning! VERY LARGE portions. Seriously the calzone my wife got was big enough for 2, with still enough left over for a decent lunch the next day. Italian Chicken fed my college age daughter twice. Fettuccine Alfredo, same thing for my high school age daughter. I have a big appetite and couldn't finish the Manicotti Florendina, but I got close! Shelby, our server was wonderful! Flavors were good overall. Planning to go back again. Beautiful interior design such a surprise given the strip mall style row of shops it's in. Don’t let the outside appearance dissuade you!

Carrollynn Peterson

Very quiet place, not too busy on a Saturday, late afternoon... The food servings were huge!! We also tried a tasty Lemon chicken soup.

Ashley Booker

Pizza Plaza has some of the best Italian cuisine and the staff are super friendly.

J Edsall

Excellent food. Good service. Delivery is fast. Clean restrooms.

Jeremy Swartwood

Ordered a chicken gyro, ended up just being a bread sandwich

Lakisha Evans

My family has been coming here for years, delicious food, great service and consistant, dont think we've ever had an issue with them.

Sheila Reed

Best fettuccine!!! 1st place I go when I visit Anchorage. Love it. Great service also.

Thomas Brunner

Pizza was not as good as it was in the past!

Peter Alward

Passable pasta and pizza.

Mark Deady

Over all ok. I had hair in my soup and was told they could give me a salid insted. No attempt to rectify the issue. The came out a few min later and surved the same soup to some other customers. For the price I would say go some were else. Could be a nice restaurant if the put some effort into customer service.

Yoon Bahn

Their Scallop a la Plaza is amazing! Love the quiet & relaxed feel this place has. Me & my fiance have been coming here for years, and have always been pleased with them overall. Their portions are very generous, too ;-)

Alan Zamo

They messed up the order, and the food was horrible, bland and very disgusting. A huge disappointment.

Kortney Redick

Love the french dip sandwich! also the stuffed shrimp are amazing! Beware the portion sizes are huge! Seriously my husband and I can't even finish one dinner together.

Mighty Mackinac

Food was top notch. Service was fast. I got the meat calzone and it came fully loaded. The Greek Delight is absolutely amazing. Warm crispy pita bread with the best Tzatziki sauce I have found in Anchorage.

Robert Wilkens

Wonderful, quiet evening. The food was great and service exceptional.

G.C Mone

Cozy dining room. Italian menu has many options. Proprio Italiano anche Americano. Torneremo!

Dessa Dickerson

Had better food there...must have a different cook

DaunMichelle GREGG

We love to go here for a more elegant dining experience than the local pizza joint! Not only do they serve great pizzas, they have a nice variety of both Greek & Italian cuisine! Definitely delicious!

Lynda G Cazort

We have eaten here on occasion for over 20 years and have enjoyed our meals. We arrived early last night and were quickly given water and had our order taken by a friendly and professional waitress. Our salad arrived and we were dismayed to find the lettuce unwashed with visible dirt on the leaves. The waitress apologized and offered the soup instead which we declined. Our main meal was delivered and mine had the wrong sauce on it. Again the waitress apologized and reordered my meal and it was delivered correctly. The broccoli alfredo and the manicotti were not as flavorful as we expected. No offer of a discount was given to us at the end of our meal. I cannot in good conscience recommended this restaurant.

D W

One of our favorite places to eat!

Paula Graber

Love the Pizza Plaza sub with salad for lunch.

Mark Ortega

The best food.

Sophia York

SO AMAZING!!!!!!! Great customer service, and the food was absolutely delicious. I would reccomend this restaurant to anyone, and try the calzones. They are so massive and cheesy. Hope you have the same experience I did.

Kenneth I

We went there for lunch and when they brought us our salads they were seasoned in flies. When I complained to the staff, could have been the owner, she told us we could pay for the beers she would pay for the food and to get out. This place has a disgusting attitude and I wouldn't recommend going there.

Steve Haynes

This has been one of our favorite places to eat for over 40 years and we've recommended it to many friends but we've noticed a problem with their delivery service. Twice now we've ordered and they've sent the wrong food/pizza and when we called to complain we had to argue with the owner about what they did or didn't convey in the conversation. The only concession they offered was to replace the food IF would return the incorrect food! We waited over an hour for our food, we're hungry, and while I'm certainly willing to send you a snapshot of the incorrect order, I'm not willing to wait another hour to eat! We find the owner to be completely unreasonable and made claims that were false about what she told us over the phone and feel that no true attempt was made to correct the problem. I don't like dealing with this lack of integrity so i'm afraid our dining dollars will have to be spent elsewhere.

Dani Phelps

The service,food, environment,all first class everything you expect and more from them.

Nancie Merkouris

I always order the French dip. Most of the things in the menu are pricey. But if you go, try the French dip. They are famous for it.

Melissa Morse

awful service, awful food, awful atmosphere. couldn't even get the chicken parm right!

Heather McIntosh

We ordered for our first time last week for delivery. 1 spaghetti dish and 1 lasagna dish. I would of loved a little more sauce with the spaghetti, but It was excellent! We ordered again last night, a french dip and a gyro pizza. The pizza was great! The french dip is for lunch today. From never eating there before and ordering twice in one week that does say a lot. We will order again and we are excited to try their seafood dishes.

Isaac Perrien

Good pizza and Italian food.

Racheal Bates

Food and service from Michael, is always just perfect !!

Michael Spear

Great french dip

Spenard Alaska

The best Italian food in the city. I have had several dishes, and I've never had anything bad, or bad service. The same waiter has been there for years and it's always nice to see they staff doesn't have a big turnover.

Nelson Montalvo

Awesome place to go to eat

kenny gallahorn

Great Sub Sandwich

Nichole Perry

Seriously the best salads EVER. And a big plus is they deliver! Also the best french dip i've ever had. I havent had a bad meal from here, and the atmosphere is cozy and comfortable. I've always thought of it as a little hole in the wall place. I definitely recommend.

Katie Portlock

My family has eaten here for years, excellent food. My favorite is the stuffed mushrooms and scampi fra diavolo.

aarti ajmera

Yak

Sam Fortier

The finest french dips in all of Alaska. Great minnestrone soup. And a fantastic atmosphere, all at a reasonable price.

Mikayla Stanford

I wish I could give it zero Stars the food was awful the service was awful. There were so many flies A flie landed in my drink it was so gross. Never ever go there.

JP Griffin

We enjoyed the service and the portions are plentiful. We had the lasagna, eggplant parmesan and a pizza, and it was all good. I would say that there wasn’t much “WOW” but I would have no problem going back.

Stephanie Freitag

There's a reason they've been open so long, they are the best kept secret for Italian food in Alaska.

Ken Weiss

Not the best location but a very nice dining room that feels spacious yet intimate. The staff were quiet and plesant. So many choices on the menu you could dine often and never have the same items. We opened with a nice salad with a potent flavorful dressing. I had the sicilian steak which was tender and flavorful, the alfredo was light and sweet. My partner had a meat calzone with a good selection of meats. The sauce was not overpowering which allowed for the flavors of the meats to come out. The pepperoni was tasty and very little oil. The side of marinara allows you to decide how much is enough. A very pleasant comfortable dining experience.

Susie Russell

the owner is nuts i have ordered from her for 20 years she has lost my bussiness she is nasty and rude they made a mistake my food was not delievered i paid ahead they did not get my information right even tho i made sure that everything was done right she yelled at me for her staff not deliving my food some how it became my fault i asked for my money back on my card and she yelled i no steal from anyone in 40 years lol

Scott Graves

Ate here a couple months ago.... For a restaurant with pizza in the name, the pizza was completely underwhelming - it was ok but really lacked flavor. The cannelloni was not worth taking leftovers home. The garlic bread was good. The service was inconsistent. The furniture and the atmosphere was dated, though the restaurant was clean.

Matthew Benedetti

Wonderful lunch menu, very nice and peaceful during the lunch rush

Trasi Crawford

Great food and wonderful owner's and staff!

Scott Whitney

Pizza was tasty and service was great. The atmosphere is lacking however.

Mike wheeler

they have great pizza. we get it for my office often. I also LOVE the stuffed mushrooms

John Dubois

Great food, great service. The Diana Roma sauce is to die for!

Dawn Hansen

Outstanding food with a nice atmosphere.

Craig Mishler

Consistently great Italian. Service may be a bit slow but well worth the wait. Love the ambience, quiet enough for good conversation. We’ve been going here since the early 1990s. My wife thinks their lemon chicken soup is superb!

Jon Anderson

Very pleasant surprise. Food was first rate. Service was fantastic. Will be back soon.

Mama Rora

The best Italian place in town. Authentic, great, Italian food in one fab spot. Plus they deliver.

Dorothy Norris

I ordered a combo and a cheese pizza at 7:00 pm. TWO HOURS later I received two cold, burnt pizzas with the wrong toppings. When I called to ask for a refund the manager told me they don't do refunds unless I bring the pizzas back to the restaurant. HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE AND HORRIBLE FOOD.

Bill Balazs

What the heck happened to their pizza's. Been a previous customer for 20+ years when Steve ran the place. Got their XL meat lovers and its smaller. Looks and tastes like Papa Murphys pizza. WTH

Stephanie Bissland

Excellent steak...better than most; love the do Roma sauce. Friendly servers who remember our favorites. Pleasant atmosphere.

NK Cline

Great pizza, cozy atmosphere, and a friendly staff. Note that the Canadian bacon is not actually Canadian bacon, it's ham ;)

Dave Rittenberg

Cheesy Italian restaraunt. I love it.

Stephan Hill

Freaking awesome food

Matt Moore

Great sandwiches and salads. Lasagna got rave reviews from our table! Hot subs and calzones are more than filling.

Desiree Starry

Best easy yummmy food and I’m a satisfied customer get the gyro pizza or stuffed mushrooms delicious

Darrell Helton

Very pleased. Had the Chicken Parm dinner and a side of meatballs. The meatballs were homemade, not those shipped up from out of state frozen one's loaded with fillers and preservatives. Highly recommend.

Liz Dubyak

Overpriced, food was mediocre at best, and I found a bug in my salad. I will not eat here again.

Tee L

This girl they had working the phones tonight was perfect! She got my order perfect ! Absolutely nothing went wrong. She was kind, and made sure everything was right! And it was right on time and perfect!

phillip philemonoff

I think its the best pie place in town... The Mama Mia is so delicious. Enjoy!!!!

Chrysti Leigh

The stuffed mushrooms are super amazing! All of the food is great, atmosphere is charming, and service is fantastic!

Shannan Sasa

manicotti seems like its from a can or something else pre-made. Very bland for 20 bucks and the pizza was expensive for being worse than domino's. Waste of 40 dollars. Will never order again

Christy Parker

Food is outstanding! Had the lemon chicken and rice soup and shared a large Greek salad with my friend.... So, so, so good! Our first waitress was rude but our second waitress was super great! Love the atmosphere also!

Mary Ann Moeller

Delish

Jacoline Gregg

Horrible place ! Do not order from here , we ordered pizza and my nephew . Stated that he bit on something hard!!! He spit it out and it was a screw !!! Reporting them to the better business bureau on monday for sure . #norefund #dontcare

Brian Smith

A family favourite.

W McDonald

One of Anchorage tucked away secrets.

Marcia Million

Great Italian food calm relaxed atmosphere.

Denise Allen

Food is fabulous. Great atmosphere and wonderful staff. Just had our 35th anniversary dinner here. LOVE this place!

micheal vaughn

We love the pizza, calzon, & Greek Salad.

donna hill

My favorite place to eat

Mersadez Meneses

Such great service. Very nice for couples

James Stone

Great Italian and pizzas.

Pauly Bagoy

Good food

Tammy Michaels-Jimenez

You got to try the gyros or gyro pizza! Omg

Adan Garcia

Great portion sized meals. Price is what is expected but the service was very slow. I think they needed way more staff than what was there.

Jacob Harmonious

Huge portions. Authentic gyros. Delicious flatbread. Great service!

Aris V

Had excellent steak, mushrooms, Greek salad, broccoli, and fresh bread. I was overjoyed with the preparation and presentation, I will eat again without hesitation

Anne Ward

POOR service

Travis B

Awesome

Carl Jacobs

Good food, not many vegan options for obvious reasons. Kitchen is accommodating though.

Chris Hamilton

If you like pizza, you've gotta try Pizza Plaza

CHRISTOPHER Z

The food is mediocre. It's not the worst. But that is not why they get 1 star from me. They robbed me, for almost nothing. The short female server with the short-ish haircut stole 2$ from me. I called in a pickup order. I came in when they said it would be ready. It wasn't ready. It was about 20 minutes late. When it was ready and sitting on the counter the lady saw it and tended to her tables and collected her tips before cashing me out. It was a little rude of her but everyone has a bad day. When she did get around to cashing me out she printed the receipt and handed it to me and said "Can you 'fill' this out and sign it?" I thought she was barking mad expecting a tip on not only a carry-out but a very late one at that. So I drew a line through the section with the tip and signed it. I didn't think I had to write more than that since I had my copy. Well the wife got the bank statement and she wrote in a 2$ tip for herself. We thought about calling the bank, but if they are willing to rob a local for 2$ then they will never get my business again. I'll save myself 2$ and eat somewhere else.