Reviews of Dr. Theodore Gerstle (Plastic Surgery)

Rylan Marks

This staff is so nice and professional. They do everything they can to make sure you’re comfortable. And they also let you make payments up until two weeks before your surgery, which I found really helpful. Highly recommend.

Janice Ingram

Dr. Gerstle did an outstanding job on my 3 surgeries. He went far and beyond what I expected of him. He is very passionate about his practice and his Patients. I would go to him over anything. Very compassionate caring guy! I would highly recommend him to any of my loved ones

Carla Harrod

I am extremely pleased with the results from my sclerotherapy, breast lift and augmentation. Dr.. Gerstle and his staff are amazing,

Lyda Mitchell

One year ago today, Dr. Gerstle performed surgery on me. He was the only one that could target the problem, and was able to immediately give me relief that I hadnt had in months. He is an amazing doctor, suregeon and i would go back to him without any hestitation and would refer him to any family and friends, which I have. He cares about his patients, and goes over and beyond to make them feel their best and accomplish their needs and wants. A very compassionate doctor, and an excellant surgeon. With a great staff backing him up! Five stars hands down!

Arun Motilal

A life changer. Finally no longer living with the shame of a regrettable tattoo! Dr. Gerstle is the man!

Lindsey T

I HIGHLY recommend Dr. Gerstle! He goes above and beyond. My son had an emergency on a Saturday and with one quick phone call Dr. Gerstle had us in office within 30 minutes. Thank you so much Dr. Gerstle for saving my son from lifetime damage! You are a blessing!

Thea Smith

I had a breast reduction a week ago and so far I am very pleased with my outcome. The staff is super sweet and I absolutely love every single one of them. Especially amber. She is so nice. Overall I had a great experience here.

Robin Mullins

Great experience would definitely recommend.

Rebecca Johnson

I've been seeing Dr. Gerstle and his staff over the past several months for some in-office procedures, as well as one surgical procedure, and other surgeries scheduled to follow. I couldn't be more pleased with the results I'm seeing! Also, the treatment I've recieved as a patient makes me feel like I'm the number one priority of the office whenever I am there. Dr. Gerstle is far more personable and thorough about communicating with me, than I've come to a expect from a highly skilled surgeon! I feel that he is passionate about his profession, and it shows! The results are AMAZING! I highly recommend Dr. Theo Gerstle and his very friendly, professional and accommodating staff for all your cosmetic surgery needs!

FRANCHESCA HOCKENSMITH

I would Highly suggest Dr. Gerstle for all your plastic surgery needs. He is very professional, knowledgeable and caring. Your more than just a number in his office. He gets to know his patients on a personal level and meets your needs and works with what you want or are looking for. Personally his education and work speaks for itself. I would recommend him any day of the week over anyone in the Kentucky and surrounding areas. I am still a work in progress but i am highly pleased.

Tammie Smith

He did a breast reduction on me and he did a great job....his team and staff are super friendly, especially Amber, they are genuine about the care they give....I have recommended him to a friend.. Dr Gerstle is a down to earth doc who walks you through the whole procedure, along with his nurse Glenda. They did a great job

Chelsea Satterly

Dr. Gerstle is the best! He fixed my severely broken nose... I’m so happy to be able to breathe again. He also did a difficult scar revision for my eyebrow which looks amazing now! Dr. Gerstle is top notch. Staff is super friendly and they made me feel so comfortable. Every office visit was quick and efficient. So grateful this place exists!

Niko Venancio

The staff was beyond professional and the doctor took the time to answer all my questions beforehand. Would highly recommend!

Tammy Wilson-Evans

5 star review. Very professional and great results.

dan ferst

Dr Gerstle was the best!!! So caring and attentive. His staff is awesome!!! I was scared to have the surgery and they all made me feel so relax! They all did a great job!!!!

James Kavathas

This man did an amazing job on me. I had previously had surgery from another plastic surgeon and he TRULY BOTCHED my chest up. Not only did dr gerstle fix my chest he also made me feel better about myself. I was truly depressed when I seen dr gerstle because of what the other surgeon had done to me. So if anyone needs plastic surgery please go see him and let him do the surgery.

James Renna

Dr. Gerstle was very professional and personable. My results were above and beyond my expectations. His expertise was amazing! He and his staff were caring, attentive and friendly. I give them my highest recommendation!

MJK Burnett

Spent most of my time waiting for months to get my procedure done and going through many loopholes only to be dissapointed. But he is a nice guy

Daryl Hammond

Dr. Gerstle and his team have been fantastic throughout my whole process! They truly provide a level of customer service that you usually don't experience in the medical community. Dr. Gerstle made himself available for emergency follow-ups if needed and he always answered calls about an issue or promptly called back. He also made calls to check on recovery following the procedure. Definitely a concierge level of medical service. I would highly recommend!

Anonymous Reviewer

I had botox here, and he did an excellent job. All of the staff was welcoming and friendly. They provided a thorough exam; temperature check, blood pressure, weight, etc. that I didn't ask for , but I greatly appreciated.

Cynthia Auterson

Staff is super friendly, there's a relaxing setting, and its very clean. Dr. Gerstle does an amazing job!

Devinn Winkler

I have met with different surgeons and have had one previous cosmetic surgery. For this time I very much appreciated the staff and Dr. Gerstle not just focusing on what I wanted done but they also kept in mind the concerns around my child. Dr. Gerstle also had no issue pausing and taking a step back if I seemed hesitant in any way. While I am still healing, I could not be happier.

Travis Buchanan

If you are looking for a Plastic Surgeon who has an eye for detail, actually listens to you and doesn't make you feel rushed during an appointment and has a track record of happy and satisfied patients, Dr. Gerstle is who you need to see! I saw Dr. Gerstle for an alopecia (fancy way of saying I am balding) consult and with his technology available at his office, he was able to show me what I would look like with hair on my head where I haven't seen it in years. Being able to see the end result of treatment is a huge bonus when being treated by Dr. Gerstle.

Jennifer Hanson

I had a nice vertigo tumble and gashed my head open. Didn’t want to deal with an ER “ surgeon” Called Dr Theo and he and his staff waited for me and took care of it ASAP. I am so greatful for them. Steve and I both are more confident that my scar will heal nicely due to his attention to detail. 2nd emergency he has come to my family’s rescue. Gracie had smithereens for a nose and he rebuilt perfectly. She’s a scuba diver and hasn’t had one issue. Perfection !

Robin Johnson

Dr. Gertsle performed my tummy tuck procedure and I am so happy! He is easy to talk to and gave me the high quality attention and level of care that I thought only famous people get. He checked on me often during my recovery and really cared about details during my healing process. I have had other doctors look at my stomach and they all are amazed at his work. It’s perfection. My results turned out way better than my friends who had same procedure by other providers. #harvard

Katie Hoeveler

Dr. Gerstle is professional, competent, and gives an unbelievable result. I look 10 years younger!!

Shane Nicholson

Super nice man. Amazing doctor. Professional staff.

Travis Hupp

Dr. Gerstle has done all of my surgical tattoo removals. He is an amazing doctor filled with passion and care for his patients. He will answer any questions or concerns you may have and give you comfort. Even though I had pulled my stitches multiple times Dr. Gerstle still takes time to stitch me back up and never blames the patient. I have recommended multiple friends to his practice and will continue to do so. Staff is amazing always. No matter what your surgery recommend Dr. Gerstle.

Tonya Jones

Dr Gerstle and his staff are wonderful! Everyone was professional, knowledgeable and caring. Dr Gerstle even followed up the next day, with a call, to make sure i was doing well.

Jeffrey Shafer

I received excellent care and customer service from Dr Gerstle and his staff. They were friendly and worked around my schedule to give me the care that I need. Dr Gerstle is very skilled and I would recommend him to anyone.

Leslie E Beavers

Compassionate and competent Surgeon. Takes time to explain procedures and gives full attention to post op follow up. Creates trust and care for the patient.

Patty Baraty

Dr Gerstle was amazing I first saw him about 3 yrs ago to get botox but I also had a dry patch on my face it was growing. He took patch of right next to my nose about the size of a nickel had it biopsied for skin cancer. No cancer No scare either. I would recommend Dr. Gerstle not only for saving me a large scar but for his knowledge on Cranial Facial Birth Defects. Which was unbelievable because most physians do not have any education on. In 1989 my daughter Ran was born with FRONTAL NASUAL DYSPLASIA .CLEFT FACE . We lived in Maryland in 1990 back then and even today there are so so many doctor's her and I had to educate on her condition which is so hard reliving over her 20 surgeries. So you can just imagine that a doctor here in Kentucky know about immediately .Finally and he also gave us even more information he educated us .Thank God. Besides her Amazing doctors back east Dr. Carson and Dr Dufresne he has been the only doctor that understood what a hard journey Ran and and I have had.....To this day I can call him or Amber with help in new problems that Ran incurres. So like I said he's Amazing.

Ahmad Rayan

Great doctor very nice staff

Laura Franze

I am so delighted with the result from Dr. Theo Gerstle removal of a precancerous growth on my cheek. It was a sunken dark spot and now it is gone. My cheeks are the same now. This was an eyesore to me. I always turned my head for pictures. At the age of 72. Iwas concerned about the results and having plastic surgery but Dr. Gerstle’s explained everything very well and did a fine job. I thank him and his office staff for being so helpful.

Mary Sadowski

Dr Gerstle is a kind caring surgeon. He explains all procedures in an way that is easy to understand. He never rushes and spends the time to make you feel comfortable. He is available both after hours and on weekends. I highly recommend him for all procedures. I am very pleased with my results.

Kyleigh Wright

Dr. Gerstle is truly an amazing doctor. From his education, bedside manner, expertise, and comfortable office. He made me feel right at home and saved my arm from not only the ugly scar but from preventing a frightening medical emergency. He acted fast on my situation from the moment I reached out to him and he took the time to contact me after his normal hours due to his genuine concern of my health. You don’t find that very often and I could not think of going to anything else for my wellness and my reconstructive needs. I highly recommend him and his team to everyone in need. His team represents him well and invites you in as family. I personally work in a specialized dental office who takes patient care as first priority and find my standards to be higher than most, he exceeds all areas when it comes from the moment you call his office to every follow up visit. Thanks for all you do & I look forward to seeing you in a few months.

Karen Hensley

Dr. Gerstle and his staff are incredible! He made sure my son and I understood the options, walked through the procedure, and followed up with phone calls to make sure my son was doing fine. He is a perfectionist and is so skilled, it was amazing!!

Ana Cruz

If I sit here to tell you exactly how I feel about the doctor and his staff, I will be here for awhile and possibly write a book. Dr. Gerstle is the best doctor ever! He makes sure that you are okay at all times. He will even talk with you after hours if you need him. I feel like I’m a friend and not just another patient. I’ve had a horrible life threatening medical history in the past, but Dr. Gerstle has taken away all my insecurities with what he’s done so far. There’s still a few more steps for completion, but I’m confident enough to know that the outcome will be amazing. Let me also add that Amber, his office staff, is so sweet as well. Thank you guys for making this experience as smooth and comfortable as it can be. I have already recommended my friends and family to him. All my future imperfections will definitely be taken care of with Dr. Gerstle. I wouldn’t think of having it any other way. Love you guys.

patti bush

Had a great experience with Dr. Theo. He very personable n easy to talk with. He asks questions n does what you ask.. has a great staff n I will go back n recommend him to my friends.

Anonymous Name

I reached out to Dr. Gerstle for a breast augmentation complicated by tuberous breast constriction. I wasn't an easy case for him yet he did a phenomenal job. His attention to detail and follow up care are remarkable. My surgery was nine months ago so I have had ample experience communicating with both him and his staff. All are friendly, professional, and prompt. I wouldn't hesitate to go back to Dr. Gerstle for any future needs and have recommended him to a few friends for various reasons. Schedule your consultation today!

Stephanie Sauter

Dr Gerstle’s professional manner was refreshing! He spent time with me to explain the procedure clearly, so I knew what to expect. He was also extremely attentive with follow-up calls to check on my progress after the surgery. I was totally satisfied with the entire surgical experience, as well as extremely pleased with its outcome. I definitely feel comfortable highly recommending Dr Gerstle to my friends.

Ace Di Vo

He Is Very Reasonable, Understanding, & Does Great Work (Pictures Coming Soon). He Cares About His Patients, Listens To Any Concerns You May Have, & Available Via-Text/Phone At All Hours Of The Day In Case Of An Emergency... I Would Recommend Him To Anyone...

Molly K

I was very pleased with my experience and treatment. She was very professional and completed a very thorough service.

Legacy Thone

I had a bbl/fat transfer/mini tummy tuck with Dr Gerstle. I was very apprehensive and nervous because of getting work done once prior with a different Dr that turned out not so great but couldn’t be happier I made the right choice this time. Not only did he do an amazing job but a Drs bedside manner couldn’t have been better. It has been almost 3 yrs and I am still always getting asked who did this work... I will always recommend him to anyone for anything. It was an amazing experience to be treated like a real person throughout the entire process and not like a dollar sign. I can’t thank him and his staff enough.

Lillian Osborn

Dr. Gerstle's artistic approach performing fat transfer to my face was phenomenal. It took 8 years off & looks so natural. He listened to all my concerns and took them into consideration while I was under his care. His approachable and kind personality made my experience enjoyable. I would highly recommend him to others considering fat transfer.

ItsYoBoiDeontae

Worst doc I have ever meet I would not let anyone like this cut on me he’s way to stuck up and very rude waste of my time ...

Wesley Asher

Dr. Gerstle and his staff are all amazing, genuine people to work with and the most respectful staff I've ever personally dealt with. The most exciting time of my weeks post op are my follow up appointments because they treat every patient like family. I've heard of other top surgeons just chopping and leaving, but Gerstle is true to his word and even offers to fix anything that may have gone wrong so you're getting what you're paying for. As a trans guy, I can say I wouldn't go to any other surgeon nearby. Cheap in price, amazing results, and so dedicated to you that he even replies out of business hours (which almost no one ever does, not even general family doctors.) What more could you ask for?

Leslie Carroll

Dr. Gerstle is a caring and thorough physician. He reviewed all my medical problems prescriptions and personal concerns prior to my surgery. I have recommended him to my family members.

David Ehl

Dr. Gerstle did some work on my eyelids. The results look fabulous. He's very personable and caring. I recommend him highly

Natalie Toulouse

Labiaplasty has me looking amazing. Highly recommend this simple (but very impactful) procedure to all my ladies!

Thatcher Ozum

Performed an absolutely brilliant surgery. Wonderful staff and excellent follow up!

Vickie

I just had the following procedures done by Dr. Gerstle, a face & neck lift with fat transfer and also a slight chin reduction. His staff is wonderful, CJ and Amber are easy to get to know and are kind and willing to help you in anyway they can. Dr. Gerstle is there to take good care of you and it doesn't matter if it's after hours or not. I felt like he put 100% effort in getting me the results that I wanted. I LOVE the results. He is an amazing surgeon as I think he took at least 15 years off of my appearance. He is the only plastic surgeon I will ever go to again.

Joshua Hensley

Dr. Gerstle is one of the finest surgeons I’ve had the pleasure to meet. From his excellent bed side manner, his superior medical knowledge and surgical skill, and his caring demeanor, I will always go to him for my plastic surgery needs.

Tara Lewis

Dr. Gerstle did an amazing job for me, and I highly recommend him to all of my friends and family for cosmetic procedures. His experience shows and I couldn't be more pleased with my results. I will be a customer for life!

Dan chesser

Great doctor, very knowledgeable and patient in explaining the services and what to expect in layman's terms. The work he performed was amazing and has been complimented by others in his field. Staff and facilities are top notch!!!

Amethyst Davis

There aren’t enough words to express how grateful I am for Dr. Gerstles expertise, attention to detail, and most of all the perfection obtained from my surgery. You, Amber, and your entire staff are absolutely wonderful. I highly recommend Dr. Gerstle as he is thorough in his assessments, understanding, very knowledgeable, and available for his patients at any given time. The level of attention in this office is incredible.

sharam abbott

Dr. Gerstle is an amazing surgeon. Even better than that, he has a great bed side manner, something that is rare to come by.

Robert Gevedon

Very professional and friendly front desk staff. Dr Gerstle took the time to explain my procedure thoroughly and gave me ample opportunity to ask questions. Very comfortable atmosphere.

Rema Martin

Beautiful office, wonderful staff! Had emergency surgery to close a open incision and Dr. Gerstle took great care of me. Thanks Doc!

Belinda Locke

Amazing surgeon, absolutely worked a miracle on my severe facial injury. He and his team are wonderful, honest and caring and I will recommend Dr Gerstle to anyone needing a talented plastic surgeon. I will forever be grateful to him and his skill.

Jim Evans

Great freindly staff. Dr Gerstler is outstanding.

Janelle B

Let me start off with this 2 star rating by saying that the staff is friendly and everything is clean. But let's get down to the nitty gritty.... I went in for a Brazilian wax but the lady that was waxing me didn't seem like she knew what she was doing. Constantly re-waxing my areas because she couldn't get the hair. And I mean re-waxing the areas 3-4 times. At the end I was in so much pain. There was patches of hair left that she told me I could come back at a later time but then at the end told me to come back in a month.... So I had to wait around with patches of hair I guess? I've had these done before and never had an experience like this.... Today marks 1 week since getting it done and I look freaking ridiculous. I'm honestly so upset with the way it turned out. Didn't complete the wax and very painful after doing the same areas over and over. The lady herself was super nice and was talking to me the entire time until I started getting irritated.... Again I've had this done a few times before and it never took me this long nor have any issues during or after. Definitely not happy with the service. I wouldn't recommend this place unless they get better waxers. Other then wasting your money, it's a pretty place with snacks and drinks in the waiting area.

tammy foley

Dr Gerstle is a great plastic surgeon. Just got a neck lift, facelift, lower eyelid lift and fat grafting during one procedure. Love the results. Highly recommend.

Brittany Ashby

He's the best! I've had so many compliments on the work that he's done! Wouldn't recommend anyone but!

Christina Muncie

Dr. Gerstle and staff are amazing. I have been going to see him since he removed a cancerous spot above my lip 4 years ago (which you can't see at all). He has helped me with a breast reduction all the way to botox and chemicals peels. I wouldn't go anywhere else, he makes you feel comfortable and takes the time to explain everything you need to know about the procedure your interested in.

Asheesh Gupta

I had a lump in my back and Dr. Gerstle took care of it and it went away within couple of days. Hats off to him. Thank you

Amalia Davies

I have nothing but praises for this gifted surgeon. When he works with you, he is both empathetic and compassionate. I presented him with quite a task. My breast implants from years prior were both encapsulated. The right breast surrounded by scar tissue due to radiation after a lumpectomy. The left breast had started to droop. The results of his artistry and skill is that I have back a beautiful bustline that I am very proud of. In addition his staff is delightful. From the moment you enter his office, the experience is top notch. I highly recommend this surgeon and remain so grateful to both he and his staff.

Melissa Taylor Dresler

Very thoughtful, observant and excellent.

Angela Kestner

Dr. Gerstle is a wonderful doctor. He sincerely cares about his patients. His knowledge and staff are top notch. I look forward to being his patient in the future. I would highly recommend if you want a doctor that genuinely cares for you.

Brandi Lewis

Dr. Gerstle goes above and beyond for all of his patients.

David Monson DMD

Our daughter was unfortunately bitten by a dog. We were asked in the ER if we would like to wait for a Plastic Surgeon. Thank goodness we did. Dr. Gerstle was amazing. He did a fantastic job with our daughter. She has no scarring . He is the BEST!!!

4rankly Candid

Had a great experience with Dr. Gerstle. He did a facelift along with a lower bioplasty. Results took 10 years off my looks.

Kendra Patton

Dr Gerstle did a outstanding job on my hand December 2017. He is a very professional, caring and knowledgeable surgeon. I would highly recommend to all my family and friends no matter what your surgical needs are. Thanks again Dr Gerstle your the Best!

Michael Reed

Had a injury at work that happened from falling off a ladder that broke my nose and cut my lip. Had it stitched late from er that left it looking bad. Found Dr Gerstle and he said he would make it look better and he did what he said. Looks totally different after seeing him. Would highly recommend him to anyone and if I ever need something like this done again he will be my first call. Will highly recommend him to anyone that needs something done.

Shelley Butler

I have had several procedures performed by Dr Gerstle and each time it has been an excellent experience and result. I have never had any doctor spend more time with me to explain things and be certain that I was comfortable with the planned treatment. He and his team communicated with me as much and as often as I needed before and after my procedures. An excellent experience!

Michele Lannum

I am very impressed with Dr Gerstle . His staff is friendly and very accommodating . He offers a wide variety of services . His work is impeccable.

Grenda Sanders

Dr.Gerstle and his staff are professional and friendly. Dr. Gerstle removed some pre cancerous lesions from my skin and after I inquired about fat grafting, he educated me about the process. After viewing enhanced photos of what the results should be, I had the fat grafting done by. Dr.Gerstle, as well as reconstruction of my left ear lobe. The results are LOVELY. Dr. Gerstle called me personally at home the day following surgery to see how I was doing. I have never had a doctor do that before. I am very pleased with Dr.Gerstle. I recommend him to my family and friends.

Hockeydoc57

Excellent and caring physician and staff. Experienced and well trained. Takes the time to explain everything thoroughly and discusses various options to help you choose what is best for your individual needs

Devin Mosley

I had to have a tattoo removed to join the Navy. Dr. Gerstle removed my tattoo by doing an excision. The surgery went great. I was very pleased with the results. Staff is friendly and make you feel comfortable.

Garland May

A phenomenal Doctor! Definitely goes above and beyond a typical DR. patient experience. Truly takes pride in what he does.

Jay Thomas

Transman who had top surgery with Dr. Gerstle and Dr. Bass, amazing staff. Will go above and beyond for their patients. I could've have asked for a better group of people working for me and on me. Trans guys and gals check Dr. Gerstle out for sure!

Noa Quecksilber

Had a wonderful experience with Dr. Gerstle and his staff, he is truly caring and thoughtful. A master blepheroplastician!

Melissa Gordon

Dr Gerstle was extremely helpful and knowledgeable. He took his time with me and delivered the best results I’ve had. I’m thankful a friend referred me and so is my skin!

Kristy Sharp

Dr. Gerstle is fantastic! He really explains the process and goes over options really well. His staff is very kind as well. I scheduled my appointment and needed to change the time. I called the day before my scheduled appointment to have it moved to my lunch hour and they were very flexible. When I arrived the office was very nicely decorated, clean, and comfortable. The staff was welcoming as soon as I walked in! When Dr. Gerstle sit down with me, he was very patient and informative about any procedures I had questions about. I will be a returning patient of his from now on!!

Lauren Dean

I had a GREAT experience with GREAT results from my procedure! I would 100% recommend Dr. Gerstle to anyone! Dr. Gerstle was the most personable doctor that I have ever known. He said to me, “I treat my patients the way I would want someone to treat my family”. His secretary, Amber and his assistant, Grenda were so welcoming and down to earth. Grenda made my procedure so much more enjoyable because she was by my side the whole time, making jokes, and getting me anything I needed. It would be a mistake to not chose Dr. Gerstle!

L Maynard Designs

Dr Gerstle and his staff are amazing, they make you feel at home as soon as you walk into the beautiful new office suite. I recently visited the office for a follow up to procedures I had a year ago. We discussed the transformation of the before and after, results are unbelievable. I would highly recommend Dr Gerstle and his practice.

Sandy Tipton

Dr. Gerstle is an amazing plastic surgeon. He is caring and compassionate about his patients. My experience with him has been life changing and I am forever grateful to him. I would not hesitate to go to him in the future or refer any family or friends to him. Thank you Dr. Gerstle!!

Dawn Hobbs

Very caring physician.

Jennifer Hogg

Great experience! I would definetely recommend! Dr. Gerstle and his staff were very welcoming, informative and professional. Thank you Dr. Gerstle!