Reviews of Isthmus Eye Care (Ophthalmologist)

7601 University Ave #102, Middleton, WI 53562

Average Rating:


Here we offer you all the opinions of real people like you who are buying the services of Isthmus Eye Care (Ophthalmologist) around Wisconsin area.

Now this firm gets a score of 4.5 stars out of 5 and that rating was based on 45 reviews.

As you can read, it reaches an feddbacks average is basically the highest, and it is founded on a very large number of reviews, so we can say that the evaluation is quite reliable. If there are many people who bothered to leave their review when they are pleased with the business, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually bother to set evaluations when they are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Ophthalmologist corresponds to the category of Eye care center.

Where is Isthmus Eye Care?

REVIEWS OF Isthmus Eye Care IN Wisconsin

Jan Maas

Very knowledgable staff. One on one care. Quality products. Bought two pair of eyeglasses from them. They were exactly what I was looking for. Someone greets you right away. I walked in and out of several places before finding Isthmus. They were like a breath of fresh air.

Savage USAF Scott

They're always friendly and understanding.They have their top priorities set to help you and your family find the best solutions for your eye care needs. They are a smaller business so the amount of selected frames are not the same as others but the ones they have are top notched. They have advanced equipment and use clinical knowledge combined with skills that we all think insurance should be considered as part of the care they provide. Their prices are less than others for glasses and sunglasses after what my insurance coverage is. That is just some of the reasons I keep going back to them as my hometown favorite.

Jason Hurwitz

An extremely friendly and thorough staff took me through an efficient system that, all told, made for a very pleasant eye exam experience. Their online appointment scheduling system is easy to use, and their online vision records system is extremely convenient.

Gordon Mancuso

Very nice eye care center. The people were very friendly. Now that I found it, I wish I weren't moving away.

Jenna Simon

The staff was very friendly. Dee Dee was especially helpful finding the right frames for my face. I love my new glasses!

Lori Dalrymple

Each time I visit I’m impressed with the friendliness of all the staff and I’m pleased with the quality of my eye exams. I also like the amount of time spent explaining to me what is being done and the results.

Dana Langreck

I’ve never had a bad experience at Isthmus; everyone is so professional!

Sadie Nelson

Kyle Wilson

Allen Hambrecht

An excellent full service place for eye exams and frames.

Sasha Aranow

The staff here was calm and patient. They answered all of my questions and took the time to explain everything to me quite thuroughly. I felt well cared for.

Catherine Nelson

Emily Haas

Staff was super friendly and helpful. They made sure I understood every step of my exam. And they helped me pick out frames that I love. Love isthmus eye care!

Thaadd Powell

Cheryl Agen

I was referred to Isthmus Eye Care a few years ago after having so many problems with eye care in the Dells/Baraboo/Reedsburg area. I have never had a problem until this year when my new eyewear lenses came back wrong. They figure out the problem and fixed it hassle free. The staff are all such a terrific bunch, and they go out of their way to make sure you have what you need to see. Thank you to all the staff, I would drive 100 mile to have the care you have given to me.

dean giorgetti

Great service throughout visit from front desk, to eye exam to checkout. Friendly people with smiling faces who know their stuff.

Dillon Weerasinghe

Good for VISION TESTS only - not medical emergencies! - no OPHTHALMOLOGISTS only OPTOMETRISTS here. My spouse was diagnosed with Anterior Uveitis in October 2018 and in panic we rushed here as her eye was red and she couldn't touch it and was very light sensitive. Dr. Colin V Connors started steroid use and asked us to come in EVERY WEEK to monitor it. We ended up having 9 visits with no improvement, and had I not pushed for a solution and question, we could still be visiting Isthmus and returning with the same diagnosis. That was $450 in co-pays. We went to an ophthalmologist on our own decision (once Dr. Colin, was asked several times what's going on, he then suggested we could visit a specialist for an opinion) This was after 8 visits to Isthmus Eye Care. At this point Dr. Colin, asked us to double the dose of the strongest steroid which was available, WHICH WE DIDNT DO, UNTIL WE MET THE SPECIALIST. The specialist, only asked us to return in a MONTH, and to continue same dose of steroid (not the suggested double dose earlier). We have had 3 specialist visits and they were requested in MONTHLY durations. It was clear that the WEEKLY VISITS above to no avail was a waste of money. They will try to make every attempt to loot you. Even during eye exams, additional tests are done, without advising you of added costs.

Benjamin Radue

Absolutely scummy business, avoid at all cost. Charged and took unnecessary test that they did not ask us if we wanted. Straight up lied to us regarding our coverage on our insurance and tried to trick my wife to buy items that were absolutely covered. If you can go anywhere else, I am never coming back.

Mary Goonan

David Hoang

Great service! I’ve thoroughly enjoyed coming here for the past several years. Justin and Fara (spelling?) were very helpful today and Dr. Jun was a blast to interact with! Keep up the great work!

Rachel Holschbach

The staff members are knowledgeable and thorough. I have been a patient during my need of glasses and contacts, and I continue annual check-ups here seven years post-LASIK; I highly recommend this office!

James Walker

Was in this past week for a quick follow-up visit. I appreciate Amanda's patience and good-humor during as I blinked my way through a eye scan. I also appreciate Dr. Connors' relaxed manner and ability his to answer questions completely in terms that I understand.

Alex Langkau

My recent appointment was very good. Everything was on time and I was able to get back to work. The staff did a good job explaining my options in respect of how my Rx changed. The Middleton location is very convenient since I work on the westside.

Ron Rgo

Doctor Wilson is excellent, but two out of three techs we dealt with lately were rushed, unfriendly, pushy, and just unpleasant. I have been going there for years, but something has changed, and I think it's time to switch eye doctors.

Asadullah Mahmood

Very friendly staff and atmosphere. I saw Dr. Connors there. He is superb very friendly and courteous.

Tricia Michaels

Julianne Lenz

Extremely friendly staff! They are knowledgable, caring and patient!


Taylor Norton

Marissa McConnell

The doctors are great, but the billing and selling eyewear side is very frustrating. If I didn't like the 2 people I worked with so much, I definitely wouldn't go there.

Barb Spruill

Very thorough eye exam. Time was taken to explain the findings of the exam & to answer any questions that I had. Very helpful finding frames & great customer service from start to finish!

Abby Riesen

My favorite eye care clinic by far. Staff is always friendly and efficient. Great with kids too!


Nice staff and (almost painfully) thorough exam. They fail to mention their Optomap Retinal Eye Exam is $40, and not covered by insurance (not mine anyway), until the end of the exam. So be sure to decline this if you wish (they should ask). YMMV.

Amanda Montoya

Today was my first visit and I could not have been more impressed! Receptionist was super welcoming and the waiting room was complete with beverages for my toddler and me. The technician was personable and patient as having my daughter with me provided an extra challenge. The doctor was great! He was attentive and took the time to explain to me the exam, the results, my images, and various options for eye wear and care. I will most definitely be going back!

Meri DeGarmo

Lynn Entine

Thoughtful, helpful, responsive , professional and thorough.

kowjue vang

Great friendly staffing and Dr. Wilson was awesome.

JR Info

Our family were long time customers. Back in the day when salesperson Ken was still around, it was actually fun going to their office. The doctors are still great and the exams are thorough. However, the assistant staff and the sales personnel are not always friendly and often quite pushy. Very unpleasant, because you always know it is coming - the sales gig. Back in the day the assistants use to warn you upfront about everything what is not covered by insurance (Optomap Retinal Eye Exam is $40). Now (as a part of the sales gig?) this information is not even being mentioned. And you always feel pushed towards that exam. After your appointment the sales staff tries really hard to sell you glasses and almost gets angry if you don't - it's crazy! If you ask to print out your prescription without buying, you might get an eye-roll (I did!). Just really no fun going there anymore. I don't deal well with pushy people. Hope it will change in the future, but for now our family will be going some place else.

Andrea Newkirk

I am so grateful for Isthmus Eye Care. They have the most thorough exams. They treat their patients with the utmost care and respect. As the Reading Specialist of my school district, I have recommended them to the parents of a few of my students that I feel may have vision difficulties. These parents have been so relieved to find answers for their child. Thank you Isthmus Eye Care Staff!!!

Ehi Okoene

Great group of people ... very energetic, lively and positive. They care all about your well being.

Amanda Forrest

Best Eye Exam Ever! Everyone was so polite and helpful! Eye Dr. actually explained what looked good in my eyes and what they look for. Explained the whole process as he was doing it. Would highly recommend.

Jeremy Linley

Stacy Mower

Always friendly and professional.

Kris Jason

My husband went a month ago for glasses and has still not received them. He has called multiple times with no answers given. We will not be going here again. I am editing my review as Isthmus Eye Care has worked with us, rectifying the situation. We will, in fact, return.

Business Hours of Isthmus Eye Care in Wisconsin



Isthmus Eye Care en Wisconsin
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Isthmus Eye Care
Isthmus Eye Care
Ophthalmologist - Wisconsin

Eye care center

Michael C. Struck, MD
Michael C. Struck, MD
Ophthalmologist - Wisconsin

Pediatric ophthalmologist

Heather A. Potter, MD
Heather A. Potter, MD
Ophthalmologist - Wisconsin


Marc D. Hirsch, MD
Marc D. Hirsch, MD
Ophthalmologist - Wisconsin


Optivision Eye Care
Optivision Eye Care
Ophthalmologist - Wisconsin