Reviews of Niagara Eye Associates (Ophthalmologist)

1801 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505

Average Rating:


We have all the reviews of people who know the products and services of Niagara Eye Associates (Ophthalmologist) in the state of Pennsylvania.

To this day the business receives a rating of 4.8 stars over 5 and that rating was based on 103 reviews.

As you can see it reaches an opinions average is almost the best one, and it's founded on a very high number of feddbacks, so we can think that the evaluation is very credible. If people have bothered to rate when they've done well with the business, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually stop to put feddbacks when they are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Ophthalmologist is included in the category of Eye care center.

Where is Niagara Eye Associates?

REVIEWS OF Niagara Eye Associates IN Pennsylvania

Patty Lagner

I have been a patient of Dr. Gary Brotherson for many years. All the members of my immediate family are also his patients. Dr. Brotherson is extremely knowledgeable and explains things in an easy to understand manner. His office is well-run, mostly very efficiently. His staff is very helpful. The office is very pleasant, decorated nicely and comfortable. I have used the optical part of the practice to get contact lenses and it was very easy and efficient. I would not hesitate to recommend Niagara Eye Associates.

Loretta Nesselhauf

The staff was extremely helpful and friendly. There was almost no waiting and I was confident in Dr. Brotherson’s explanation of all my testing. He answered all my questions and explained everything so I understood all the results of my exam and all my test results.

George Strohmeyer


Dr Botherson is fantastic

Damian T. Siggia

I could not ask for any better care than I receive at Niagara Eye Associates. Wonderful staff and the best customer service. Thanks!

djjoe2506 Schmitt

Kelly Forne

Everyone is welcoming, and personable. I was very impressed, they all lived up to my expectations based on other 5 star reviews. Dr. Hetrick is wonderful. I am very pleased with the entire visit, and picking out frames with Cindy was great fun !

Fred Regal

Everyone were so friendly and helpful, put my mind at ease. Everything turned out fantastic . Super job.

Mark Kubeja

Excellent Care. Great Staff and Dr. Brotherson saved my sight by his care. Put your faith in the facility.

James Hamilton

On Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday I was experiencing bright flashes and occasional floaters in my right eye for a very brief amount of time. I had not experienced this sensation before and I was worried. On Monday morning I went to Dr. Brotherson 's office without an appointment and I explained my experience to Dr. Brotherson's staff and they said they could see me at 11:00 AM the same day. I was very much relieved. I showed up for my appointment and his staff took me through a series of tests and Dr. Brotherson examined my eyes and gave me a clear bill of health explaining what was going on with my eye is related to the aging process which we all go through. He said " he would like to see me in 3 months to check everything out". The Doctor and his staff were very courteous, efficient and professional and provided a very relaxing office visit.

Tom Shelow

My visits to Niagara Eye Associates are events I look forward to. Not only are all the staff competent, friendly, professional but willing to take time to talk with me and answer questions in vocabularies I understand. They seem glad to do this. It is always a pleasant experience.

John Seber

Latest equipment, great staff, dr brotherson the best

C Bright

Paul Miller

randy nyberg


Jean Farkas

Love the doctors & staff at Niagara Eye Associates! They are all so friendly, yet professional! I wouldn’t go anywhere else!

Mary Hembrow Snyder

Dr. Brotherson and the entire staff at Niagara Eye Associates are remarkable professionals. I have total confidence in their expertise and the uncommon personal care they give time and time again to their patients. I highly recommend Dr. Brotherson and his colleagues at NEA.

Erin Adams

Jo Gustafson

Sandra Myers

The office staff are wonderful, very polite and professional. Dr. Fatica is awesome, he takes time to answer all my concerns. Highly recommend this office!

Art Kuholski

Michael Koncewicz

Michael Hale

Thorough exam, would be helpful if you took insurance for the frames and lenses.

wendy trask

Dr. Brotherson AND his staff are great!

Debra Gamble

Friendly helpful staff. I've never experienced a wait longer than 5 minutes like I do with other Dr. visits. Dr. Brotherson listens to concerns, is very thorough, and I never feel like he is rushed.

Tara Velez

The office staff is very nice and friendly. I saw Dr. Fatica and he was really great and would recommend him and the office to anyone who would need an Ophthalmologist. Dr. Brotherson is awesome an a great dr!

Lori Honard

Bill Welch

I had a nasty, tiny object stuck on my cornea that was causing me much aggravation. Dr. Fatica found it and removed it easily and painlessly.

logan popoff

All around great tratment and care. Dr.Brotherson is the best.

Patricia Bailey

They are so professional. They care about my needs. Won't go any place else.

Jonathan Moser

Brenda Bennett

Pat Trapani

The entire staff at Niagara Eye Associates deserve a 5 star rating. They are very professional, courteous and friendly. Dr. Gary Brotherson is amazing!

Tina Williams

This is the best place ever, Everytime I have been there I have received exceptional service!!

Linda Gidos

Mimi Sherwin

Jan Van Gorder

Charlie Heffner

Jacob Scotch

Ann W

Charles Haise

Professional office but easy going. Dr's are very knowledgeable and seem to really care about the Pt. My wife also is a pt and her care has been exceptional. Nice to know we are in good hands.

kathie groney

Been going hear for years. love all the staff!! Can't imagine going to another eye Dr.!!

Skip h

Really like Dr. Brotherson. The staff is very friendly and helpful.

Paula Wakeley

The entire staff starting with the doctor are friendly and knowledgable. I would recommend them to everyone!

Anna Aicher

Love the glasses and the eyeglass staff is awesome.

Debbie Anderson

Dr Brotherson and staff are very professional and make you feel at ease. He was the only eye doctor that found my husbands problem. We are very thankful!

RH Erie

Excellent eye care. Highly recommended

Julie Maguire

Everyone at Niagara Eye Associates is very friendly and professional. Dr. Brotherson is very thorough and explains his findings in an easy-to-understand manner.

Jo Rouse

Thomas Cassano

Very professional. Dr. Fatica is the best!

Lisa English

Patrick Delaney

Henry Scholz

It's been too many years since I've had a comprehensive eye exam. I chose the right place with Niagara Eye Associates. They were very professional, courteous and used state of the art technology. It was the most thorough eye exam I ever had and they explained the results very thoroughly. Highly recommended.

Naomi Jacobitz

I am thankful that a good friend recommended Niagara Eye Associates to me when I first moved to Erie, and I have continued to be a patient there ever since. They have a wonderful staff of helpful people, and the care given by the doctors is thorough and professional. It's good to be a part of a group like theirs, who you can trust to give your eyes the best care possible. Thank you Niagara! Sincerely, Naomi Jacobitz

sharon w

Always pleasant, happy office and professional staff. Says a lot for practicing eye doctor, Dr. Brother son. Good experience time after time. I’m comfortable and feel that I’m in good, competent hands.

Charles Cornfield

Dane Charlton

Dr. Brotherson is saving my sight with knowledge of WHAT to prescribe for my situations!

Sheryl Hoetzel

You always feel like you are the only patient they take their time with you and care. Dr Fatica ROCKS!!

Mary Morgan

Dennis Michalak

Visited Dr Brotherson's office for a second opinion.From the beginning all of the staff were extremely cordial and knowledgeable.Explanations were clear and concise. Not only did I get my second opinion.Dr Brotherson stated emphatically that I didn't need surgery, but after he recommended changes in my prescription and made a few changes in the line of site on my lenses, I was able to read easily again with no other treatment required.He and his staff were very reassuring.Even the optician who fitted my new lenses was very knowledgeable and caring. I would have no Reservations about taking any further care from Dr Brotherson's and his staff in the future.

Shane Wohlrabe

Carlene Bolla

My office experience over the past 20 years has always been excellent. The staff is thorough and knowledgable. I became a patient when I had a problem that other specialists couldn't diagnose. Dr. Brotherson recognized instantly what the condition was and confirmed it with his exam. Under his care, it was treated and controlled. I have complete faith in his ability and knowledge to care for all of my ophthalmology needs.

Carol Weiser

Very friendly and efficient, I wouldn't think of going anywhere else. Love them!

Michael Ponsford

Jan Berlin

Michelee Curtze

Tony Oprendek

Shaun Akin

I have been going to Niagara Eye Associates and treated by Dr. Brotherson since I was just two years old (I'm now 30). I cannot say enough about him or the practice, they are simply the best!

Tamara Wawrzyniak

Niagara Eye Associates are the best their staff are very prompt to assist you as soon as you get there. From the receptionist to the doctor they are very informative and thorough in caring for the patient's needs. I was also very impressed with their attractive office. Most definitely a five star rating.

Daniel Ore

The best group of people you will ever meet. I have been a patient for over 30 years. There is a reason they are always busy.


The staff are all wonderful. They take their time & explain what they are going to do. Dr. Brotherson I can't say enough about. A real person who takes what questions & fears you have and puts them to rest.

Lin Antoun

My 1st visit and not knowing what to expect but I was at ease once I walked thru the doors and was greeted. The staff and Doctor was so so friendly and explained. everything.. I would recommend these Doctors and meeting the staff. All my visits were pleasant

Tom Snyder

Brenda Moski

Bill Sopp

Care and service was perfect as always. For eye Care this is the place to be.


Unbelievably rude staff in optical. Came into to get a nose piece replaced and a lense tightened and the girl that took my glasses scratched one lens up so badly I couldn’t wear my glasses anymore. I had to go spend $450 at EyeGlass world and get same day glasses made because I can’t drive without them. Then I came into Niagara later that week to get my replacement lenses and the office Manager was extremely rude and said they “replaced my lenses multiple times”. They replaced them one time before because they shattered when she tried to put them in and had to order tri-vex because she said the frame required them. Maybe heating them up or tightening the fish string caused this to happen to my lense but no one will admit fault so they blame the customer. The office manager told me “I was dispensed” after being extremely rude to me. Shouldn’t hire your sister in law to be the office manager. She thinks she can do whatever the hell she wants.

Robert Nipper

Care was good . Time was taken with me to explain my eye conditions. So I am satisfied.

Pat Duke

Niagara eye associates is a wonderful place to go when you need help with one of your most important parts of your body. All of the staff is courteous, helpful and friendly. The doctor is so knowledgeable and takes time to explain things to you so you understand it. He only recommends treatment when you need it and does not complicate your choices. It is the best place to go for eye care

JoAnne Lenart-Weary

I began using Niagara Eye Care about 20 years ago. Dr. Brotherson has a very friendly approach with his patients but most importantly, he knows his stuff. I recently had my first Cataract surgery with him and am delighted by the results. The office staff is also very warm and helpful.

Jean Hardner

Today's apt. went well; very little wait time between testing and visit with Dr. Brotherson!

Patricia Weidner

Eileen Cullen

Gary Shiel

I’ve been seeing Dr. Fatica for a few years now and find him and his staff to be very pleasant and very concerned about my eye care that I’ve received there.

Ron Ecke

Was experiencing an issue with my vision that could not be solved by my Optometrist I have been seeing for the past 12 years. I felt that I needed another opinion and wanted to go up a level beyond my regular Optometrists knowledge base. I thoroughly searched online and asked friends whom they would suggest. Finally after reading reviews, and looking at affiliations with health care organizations, plus an overall good instinctual feeling, I made an appointment at Niagara Eye Associates. I asked for soonest available with any one of the three doctors there, and was assured by reception that all three were highly experienced professionals and would be in very good hands with any of them. My first appointment was with Dr. Fatica, and left the appointment with the feeling I definitely came to the right place, excellent physician, staff, and will undoubtedly make this my permanent eye care facility now. My long time Optometrist did a great job, but when my particular issue with vision began, she just didn't have the knowledge to give me any answers, and was unable to give me a diagnosis. Hence stepping up to an Opthamologist. I had a diagnosis and questions were answered within minutes of Dr Fatica's examination, and found it is something fairly common, not unusual. My eyesight is something I am extremely attuned to and being a diabetic for 12 years now I won't take chances with. I highly recommend Niagara Eye Associates, 5 stars here. !!!

Michael Bishop

Latonya Walker

I Love the staff of Niagara Eye Associates. Dr Brotherson told me he was gonna save my eye sight and he has. Thank You from Me & my Family keep up the GOOD Work.

Bob Esser

Nadine Guzik

Dawn Schaaf

Donna Vistrand

Dr Brotherson and the entire staff are awesome. Any problems that is the place to go.

david nesselhauf

Greg Smith

Great staff and doctors, always a pleasure .

Edward DeLeo Sr

Larry Burton

Pat Koloskee

Very professional and welcoming staff. Current sophisticated equipment and very competent staff

Trish Hurley

Dr. Brotherson's staff are friendly and professional. The testing and examination were very thorough. Dr. Brotherson is very personable. He spent time explaining his recommendations for treatment and answering my questions. I was impressed with my first office visit and look forward to my follow-up appointment.

Michael Volk

Gary Wilson

Been going there for years. Very pleased with Dr & staff. Highly recommended in my book. Gary Wilson

Sarah Holland

Kevin Macaluso

My wife sees Dr Brotherson, and I go to Dr Fatica. In my humble opinion Niagara Eye Associates is simply the premier eye care facility in Northwest Pennsylvania. Friendly knowledgeable staff, beautiful facility with state-of-the-art equipment, and best of all is, they treat you with respect and dignity and you never feel like you're being rushed through. I would give them more than five stars but that's all I had to choose from.

Karen Zimmerman

Business Hours of Niagara Eye Associates in Pennsylvania



Niagara Eye Associates en Pennsylvania
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Levin Luminais Chronister Eye Associates
Levin Luminais Chronister...
Ophthalmologist - Pennsylvania


Dr. Steven B. Siepser, MD
Dr. Steven B. Siepser, MD
Ophthalmologist - Pennsylvania


Century Eye Care
Century Eye Care
Ophthalmologist - Pennsylvania

Ophthalmology clinic

Carim Eye & Retina Center
Carim Eye & Retina Center
Ophthalmologist - Pennsylvania


Christianne Schoedel, MD
Christianne Schoedel, MD
Ophthalmologist - Pennsylvania