Reviews of Old Yellowstone Garage - Jackson (Night Club)

Cade Olson

Great fast friendly service and delicious food!!!

Monika Gilmore

This place has great food and a nice atmosphere. The service was a little strange when we were standing at the front desk for several minutes with servers and managers walking around and not making eye contact with us. I'd rate the service as a 3, but the food is a 4.5.

Saila Buser

the hot chocolate was basically hot milk, slow service when it wasn’t that crowded, the burger bun was falling apart and the forgot the goat cheese on the goat cheese salad. Not worth it.

Jonathan S

Good food. The staff was nice. They seem to put garlic on everything. Price was a bit high but expected here

Payal Gandhi

We are vegetarian and ordered the Hippie! Best pizza ever. Period. Little on the expensive side but all the places here are expensive! Loved the ambience too.

Jennifer Thuermer

We had a phenomenal experience... appetizers were fantastic, service was excellent and the meals were incredible. Heading back soon with guests...

William Reiland

We stayed at the Caldera for a week and ended up eating here multiple times (B,L&D, all good). The food is well-executed and interesting (especially the pizzas and pastas), and it is the best Italian in the area (avoid Il Villagio Osteria, a far distant second place in terms of execution and missing the mark on several key aspects). The wine list is superb, with a list of wonderful Italians worthy of a NYC list (surprisingly knowledgeable staff can direct you to the best bottles and good values). The vibe is cool and relaxed - no antlers..... The cafe outside is good for a quick bite while taking a ski break.

Steve Shibuya

I was late getting there and most everyone had already ordered. Even though my order went in very late, it came out just a little bit later than the others. What a nice surprise. The park and lobster slider was excellent. The burger was tasty, but similar to most other restaurants, a bit too salty for me. However, I did not hear anyone else with the same comment. So for most people, it is probably OK. Looking forward to trying other items on the menu.

Michael Fiorillo

Located within walking distance of anywhere in Teton Village. The staff were really nice and the place looked new. Happened to walk in during pizza night and the food was good. $35 pp for pizza was not so good, but you have to expect some of that at a ski resort.

Brendan Kavanagh

Very cool place for lunch or dinner. Great menu. Terrible wine pours from bartender. 4 ounces maybe. $10 glass of wine. Charge me $15 but please give me a good pour.

Chris Laine

Prices comparable to what you pay at the cafeteria. Try the chicken parm

Jennifer Boyman

Amazing food, had the best salad I've ever had!

Martin and Emily Benning

Really bad service

Andrew Tippie

Great food, decent prices for the area it's in. Warm, friendly service. Maybe a coat rack or ten?

Ken Hill

Would advise against pizza night

Jody Kaufman

A really refreshing spot in Teton Village - they offer fresh options, a nice change from typical side of the mountain fare. Friendly staff, particularly our bartender Janice - nice, smiling while not being over solicitous. The area in the bar has a few circular tables with mid century modern chairs around for an easy spot to hang out with friends.

Ernesto Cervantes

Food in this place was amazing! The wine availability was limited but they did let us know in advance and advised a wine shipment was coming in. Chef Paul O'Connor was very friendly and came over to talk about what we had. The Allen Brothers bone-in filet was perfectly prepared. Kudos to the chef!

Patrick Chen

Very good restaurant. Nice decor, great food and good service. Food came out in great presentation and tasted good. As common as Idaho Trout, they made it better with interesting choice of ingredients and mix of tastes. Highly recommend.

John Moran

OYG is one of my new favorites in Teton Village/Jackson Hole. The prices are reasonable, the ambiance is great and the staff is friendly. I highly reccomend the lasagna and the “not your grandmother’s spaghetti”

Amir Shevat

Fantastic Italian restaurant in the middle of the wilderness of Wyoming. The prices are more aligned with San Francisco but it's totally worth it. The service was fast and friendly. My favorite dish was La dolce Vita which was salmon pizza.

Jie Peng

Delicious authentic food, good atmosphere, good service .

Terri Maguire

The Monday all you can eat pizza is BAR NONE! We're talking GOURMET pizza slices until you die. The Old fashioneds are as good as I've had anywhere!!

Loren Villano

We were in the Village for a a show that got out around 9:15pm. We looked every where for food. at 9:45 we finally stumbled upon OYG. They welcomed us immediately. Our Server Reed was amazing. he served well beyond closing and did it very very well. I was very impressed with the level of customer service i received. On to the food. It was AMAZING !! i wont even look for a different restaurant next time im in the village. Thank you for a great dining experience!!

Emmett Ross

Definitely not a cheap place to get a bite to eat. Not good at reservations. I called in, was instructed to leave a message. I asked for a reservation for 8 pm, 830 is OK too. They called back, didn't leave a message. I had to call them a second time and they gave me a reservation for 915 and said "maybe". If this is the service from the host, I doubt it gets better. Hard pass.

Paul Olcese

Pizza and good atmosphere

Trevor Evenson

Great decor, friendly staff, good food!

Jason Rushin

Great food, friendly staff.

Alex Forsythe

So cool

Nikol Marie

Not sure why there are such good reviews on this place. I came for new years eve dinner. The drinks are not well balanced or even made with proper ingredients. The food isn't anything to the go home about, got the pizzaand the chicken. The service was pretty slow but nice atmosphere. The best part about eating here was honestly the bread...would not recommend this place.

Michael Harvey

Great dining option in Teton Village. We sat at the bar and enjoyed starters and mains. The barkeep was genial and attentive. The bread to start was delicious. The burger was one of the best I've had. Looking forward to returning to try the pizza.

Tim Kilkenny

So happy that OYG is back! I hope you (and I) love this incarnation as much as we loved the old yg.

220162354 Lynch

Amazing food and fantastic service. Highly recommend this for families.

Karen Mcfall

Friendly staff, yummy aps and pizza. Will try dinner next time.

Frederick Howard

What a delight to have such an exquisite restaurant so conveniently located in the Jackson Hole Mountain Resort. Paul and his staff never cease to deliver exemplary authentic Italian cuisine. The food, cocktails, and wine list are stellar. The OYG is definitely a crown jewel if Jackson Hole!

Julia Bourlakov

Exceptional place! Food was outstanding: we had barramundi and filet mignon and both were cooked to perfection! Service was outstanding. Ambiance very soothing. I was pleasantly surprised that menu had so many great choices besides pizzas and pastas. Cannoli is the one thing that I’ve had better. Highly recommend this place!

Kit Parker

I really great place to eat. Appetizers are okay but the entrees are much much better. Prices are a bit high but that's what you expect from Jackson Hole and a ski resort.

Xavier Lebrija

Terrible service. +1 hour for drinks, 2 for main course.

Russ Tomevi

Outstanding!

Brian

Good drinks. Were told wait was 45min. 2hrs later we left.