Reviews of Costello's Market (Fish Shop)

99 Maple St, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States

Average Rating:


We've got all the feddbacks of people like you who consume the services and products of Costello\'s Market (Fish Shop) in Vermont area.

To this day the firm has a score of 4.6 stars over 5 and the score has been calculated on 57 reviews.

As you can read, the average score it has is nearly the top, and it is founded on a very high number of reviews, so we may conclude that the assessment is very reliable. If many people have bothered to leave their feddback when they've done well with the service, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually bother to place tatings when they are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Fish Shop belongs to the category of Seafood.

Where is Costello's Market?

REVIEWS OF Costello's Market IN Vermont


Jaden Collier

Haley Bushey

Amazing food, wonderful, friendly staff. Theres a huge variety of pastas, meats, seafood and other authentic Italian treats.

Rob Life

Benjamin Ramcharitar

Monica Bailey

Great food, generous portions. Love the daily specials and seeing the owners every time I go in!

Adam Foster

A true hidden gem in Middlebury. Fantastic food and great service

Roy Minton

The food was great

Andrea Olson

Maya Urbanowicz

Great place for sandwiches, specialty Italian food items, or to special order your favorite cut of fish- caught in the morning, delivered same day. No wonder they are still around after all these years.

Jon Sullivan

Amazing food

heather kerr

Such a great spot for food. I real hidden gem. Service was so nice.

Mary Jane Simpson

This place makes incredible sandwiches and cannoli. No seating, though, so make sure the weather is nice for a picnic by the falls.

Nicholas Perzanoski

The best place in Middlebury to get food to go. Their deli sandwiches are delicious and on great fresh bread. The antipasto salad features a lot of excellent marinated items. I love the fish tacos. And the place is extremely clean!

Allison Sawyer

Dana R

Old fashioned local Italian deli and market. Amazing sandwiches, not the fastest so if you are in a hurry order ahead.

John Coburn

Amazing sandwiches and meats!

Peter Longchamp

Great Food

Eileen Leach

Awesome food, nice conversation, I'll definitely go back soon!

Jon Kraeuter

Visited this market while in Middlebury for a wedding. Ordered the fish & chips, a turkey sub, and a locally bottled orange soda and it was excellent.

Sam Cutting

Will Rockell

Nice love the fish taco.

cvrg kvt

Best food in town! No seating.

Owen Marsh

Tim Carney

Great place!

Paul Smith

Good place to stop by and get a quick bite to eat!

Dakota Miller

Consistently delicious food. I loved Costello's when I was studying at Middlebury and their quality of food has only gotten better upon returning. This is where you get the best sandwich in Middlebury.

Shannon Edson

Fresh and delicious

Nathan Ayer

Super Tax Genius

Outstanding cured meats that they turn into great sandwiches.

Neil Steiner

Micah Raymond

Super friendly staff, great good, decent prices. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu.

Molly Dora

Can't go wrong with Costello's for take out Italian.

Tom Cusack

Very friendly service, food is outstanding !!!

Andy Hooper

The hidden gem of Middlebury's food offerings. Without a doubt the best sandwiches in town, as great for reasonably-priced large-group catering as well [lasagna, risotto and sandwich platters all excellent]. The fresh fish offerings are the best in town, and the specialty grocery products are all great.

Eli Madden

Great food, fast and friendly service.

rachael burmania

This is the best place to get a fresh sandwich in Addison county!! Always delicious, and always very fresh. Wonderful prices.

Dean Pierce

The sandwiches--and the service--are amazingly good.

Tom Wiegleb

Great food good people. It isn't fast but good food takes time.

Jackson Burnham

Middlebury has one "must have" foodie experience, and this is it. Costellos Market is a counter service seafood and italian ingredients food market which includes a gourmet soup and sandwich menu, a deli style display cooler full of Italian cuisine prepared dishes, and a full size chalkboard menu of off-the-boat seafood; everything from PEI mussels to swordfish. Some people may feel CM's prices are high, and they would be right. If you prefer dollar meats there's a Subway and a McDonalds in town, and you'll get... dollar meats. Costellos offers only the finest ingredients in all their handmade ready-to-eat items. If you value what you pay for, there's no better sandwich shop in all of New England (confirmed by Yankee Magazine) than Costello's Market.

Robert Munson

Relief Quinn

ahlam hammad

Smithi Skunnawat

would be 5 stars for the amazing food if it wasnt so expensive

slightlysublimed .

Jed Malcolm

Roger Scholten

You can't go wrong coming to this gem and you can order anything because it's all amazing. Great job !!!

Carolyn Costello

Laura Napolitano

Great food and service! Their prices are a bit high but worth it for the occasional meal. The location works despite it being small and a bit crowded during busy rush hours for lunch and dinner.

Michael Simpson

This is a wonderful hole in the wall. The sandwiches are amazing.

walter stone

Excellent subs, and the only place to get a good bottle of wine in Middlebury!

Joao Rocha

Incredible italian delicatessen. You can’t go wrong with whichever sandwich you get. My personal favorite is the Bondie, a secret menu option!! The best service and it will leave you wanting to go back.

Gregg Miller

Amazing food and fast friendly service. The subs are the best I've ever had, salads are delicious. Excellent fish, perfectly cooked.


The best food in Middlebury in my opinion

david Devine

Italian and euro foods, along with some wonderful prepared dishes.

Bill B

A wonderful fresh fish market! During my last stop they had a nice selection of fish and shellfish . I would call ahead if looking for something special or specific.

David Grotton

Super friendly service and the food is delicious. Very fresh sandwiches with many homemade ingredients.

Business Hours of Costello's Market in Vermont



Costello's Market en Vermont
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Costello's Market
Costello's Market
Fish Shop - Vermont


The Butchery
The Butchery
Fish Shop - Vermont

Butcher shop

One Stop Country Pet Supply Berlin VT
One Stop Country Pet Supp...
Fish Shop - Vermont

Pet store

Simon Pearce
Simon Pearce
Fish Shop - Vermont

American restaurant

All American Angels & Discus
All American Angels & Discus
Fish Shop - Vermont

Tropical fish store