Reviews of Mitchell's Fish Market (Fish Shop)

Aaron Gesicki

Great food, excellent service. Definitely a place we'll frequent.

Darlene Sligar

The espresso machine has been broken for years the staff keeps trying to make it work.

George Pappas

Food was not great. Had filet and shrimp scampi. Average. Server was nice.

Vinny Smarra

Prices are way too high the fish was way too small it was a square like the size of a McDonald's fish but my girl like turn me on but I don't remember what it was but the bill was over $100

Brian Beverage

I typically get the same thing yellow Fin Tuna grilled. I have been several times. It seems that the fillets were consistently sized or I just happen to always get a similar fillet cut. Lately, the fillets vary drastically in shape and thickness. The consistency of the cook vary greatly. It seems when the fillets are the normal 1.5" cut the cook is closer to my medium likeing but when it's the 2.5" "fillet mignon" shaped cut it's really on the raw side. Like maybe 1/8th inch cooked on each side. I do not mind 1/8th inch red center with the majority of each side cooked. I also do not like to send food back so I will just eat it. One of the servers I had was trying to recommend the rare cook. I do not mind a medium rare with a lean towards the medium side but rare on a 2.5" cut seems to be sushi for the most part. He claimed they prefer rare for yellow Fin. I get that you do not want to over cook the fish .... But it would be nice for it to just be consistent.

Nate Chertack

Get your seafood fix after a long day of shopping. The food was delicious, highly recommend the cedar plank salmon.

pallawat@gmail.com Luckey1

Excellent food and service

Tim Sherrer

Pleasantly surprised! Went for our anniversary dinner, was actually a second choice because first place was overbooked. We'll be back again, food was amazing as was our waitress.

Deena Crouch

Wonderful food and good service! Will be back soon!

Kristin Hix

We popped in around an hour before closing. We sat at a booth in the bar. Our waiter, John, was really great. He was very knowledgeable about the menu. My steak came out a bit raw for my taste and I sent it back. chef came out to ensure how I wanted my state cooked and brought it back within just a few minutes perfectly cooked. The dinner was lovely.

JALane0101 .

Efficient and fast friendly service

Mark Sansait

Surprised they were open on the eve of Christmas Day (open 365 apparently)! Great atosphere and bar area. Only downside is that the fish entree I ordered was under cooked. If it wasn't for that it would definitely be 5 stars.

Robin Quagliesi

We love this place! Service is always great and so is the food! However we were there last night and I got my usual shrimp scampi. It was good However used to be better. There was a ton of shrimp however the sauce was a little bland and they changed the noodle from what used to be angel hair now to more of a fettuccine noodle which changed the whole dish. Guess I’ll have to try something else next time.

Steven Sexton

Excellent food with a wide variety to choose from. The service is always great as well. I love the lobster tails! They also have very good steaks and great bread to come with the meal. This is definitely a restaurant that stands out from most!

Alissa Andersen

We love this place. Their oysters and entrees are delicious. We're obsessed with the sour dough type bagette you get when you order dinner

John Toth

Great food...staff there is very efficient and friendly...

Charles Coomer

Had a very nice experience on my first visit. Staff friendly. Food was great. Definitely recommend this restaurant

Michael Manno

The seafood salad was awesome

Vanessa Shelby

Food was very good. Customer service is great. I would definitely go again.

Stacey Nunez

Wonderful good. Great service!

Scott Humpfer

Very good and filling great place to have a good lunch/dinner.

Edward Rybicki

Our main reason to travel to Brookfield,Wisconsin! Bar food drinks dinner and desserts are hard to beat! On top of that service is grand!

Gary Burant

Have been a few time. I've tried something different each time and have never been disappointed. The appetizers, fish, stake, desserts, all fantastic. The nautical theme atmosphere is amazing. I love the swordfish sculpture just inside the main entrance. A little pricey for a weekly family outing but not so bad that once and awhile would break you. All in all, definitely worth the money.

Matthew Payne

Supposed to be the best fish in chip it was not.

Sam H.

Terrible name. I expected dead but as-yet inedible fish when I looked it up. Will not get hooked again.

quadwilliams Williams

Great food, great service

chris gima

The food is good but the service is awful this is the 2nd time we have been here I sat for 30 mins and they came to tell me that what I ordered they were out of I feel like we could have been told sooner as we have been here for a hour and still no food our waitress took forever to get our bread I jus don't think we will be comin back here they need to improve on the service here ive done server before and the amount of ppl our waitress had was no excuse for how terrible she was we were her 3rd table and the others were small as well

Jacklyn of all Master of none

Food was not worth the price. I feel I got half the food I paid for. Service was slow. Would not recommend this place

Cathy Wilk

We had a great meal.

David Brown

Great selection.

Gregg Kriegel

Great special for club members. 49 dollar date night with steak and desert for 2 people. Waited longer than expected given club perknof preferred seating and reservation.

Lara Rahman

Super slow service. I was sitting with my Friend at a different table than our parents. The waiters kept skipping over us, it was like we didn’t exist. They took our orders 10 minutes later than everyone elses. They give us kids menus just because we are short (5 foot). The fish tasted like it was from McDonald’s. The pasta was ok. They didn’t ask for our orders for desert, so we tried to hunt down people. They walked past us and ignored my voice. We had to ask someone else to hunt down the waiters. When she came, she didn’t care. The dessert was the best part although there was a hair in it. Very disappointed and don’t plan on coming back.

J Adams

We had dinner this past Tuesday and very disappointed in the service. We waited more than an hour to receive our meal and then mine was incorrect. I ate it anyway because I did not want to wait another hour to get it corrected. The staff apologized for the poor service more than once but did not offer any compensation for our wait. I realize that there was a party off in a separate room but the rest of the restaurant was not real busy. If you can’t handle having large groups, why offer it with a separate room. Mitchell’s is an upscale restaurant or at least try’s to be and this type of experience should not occur at that type of restaurant.

Jay Sisson

Great Food at a reasonable price

Mojo

Disappointed. Used to frequent this restaurant until year ago, tried it recently and food was overcooked, service in the bar area was not good, and drink pours are horrible, sent my mixed drink back for a beer, couldn't taste any alcohol. I expect more the the price

Travel for a Buck

My fiancé and I love oysters so we’re very pleased to find this place a couple of weeks ago. While there we tried the clam chowder and lobster bisque. Everything was so good we decided to get to-go last night. We ordered more of the soup and a few other things. To our surprise the soup container were less than half full. When contacting the restaurant to explain this I just had 2 different people trying to explain to me why I’m incapable of determining the size of an order, you know not like I’ve had it before.

Dan Davis

Seafood very good but portions small. Sourdough bread is the worst. Waited a long time for a cocktail. Wait staff a little dense.

Georgie McCarty

My Lobster Bisque was yummy! My Salmon and rice was very good. Asparagus was a bit under cooked. The appetizers... Calamari was ok, a small portion and dry, and the Artichoke dip was great. Everyone else seemed satisfied with the food overall. A salad was sent back. Happy hour was advertised on the board as you entered, but none available. It was very busy, Mother's Day, at the dinner hour.

Cro Boy

Very seldomly do I have a bad meal here but tonight was the night! Long wait for our food and the meal was not worth $100. I'm not a bad cook and could've prepared a better meal even my sons garlic butter pasta wasn't prepared well

Richard Dedomenico

Went for a quiet lunch. Service and food was excellent. I’ve been to this location often and have never been disappointed with the quality of food and attention to detail. Our lunch was on Thursday May 30th the restaurant was empty, but we were treated like gold.

Howard Bienstock

The service was terrible, the shrimp cocktail was very over cooked and was not devained. The waiter was MIA most of the night charged us for a meal we did not have the manager response was well maybe he was busy I had to ask her to take the meal we did not have off our bill and still waited for the correct check 25 minutes and still no waiter. Just A very Very bad night of good and service. To end on a positive the weather was fantastic for a August night in Indiana.

Cheryl Janda

Food was great. Service was good though a tad slow

George Murphy

Ok but pricey

Andy Nordin

I need to come back for a dinner here because the appetizers I had during a happy hour were really amazing. It’s not cheap, but a return trip is definitely on the menu.

Andrea Whitman

Seafood is not as.freah as they claim. Over priced. Kroger has a better selection of fish. Deserts are great. Employees are treated badly especially in the kitchen. Overheard a chef yelling at employee over a minor problem

Wayne Ok 1

We had a wonderful time at Mitchell's today. We celebrated mother's day with my wife and and our youngest daughter, who both happened to be absolutely incredible mothers. The food at Mitchell's was excellent and the service was impeccable. A young gentleman named Collin was our server today. He knew his job extremely well he could explain everything on the menu and check several times to be certain he had answered all of our questions. Collin knew everything about the desert menu also, which was extremely handy when all the ladies decided they would have dessert. Including our very loquacious 4 year old granddaughter. I hope we're lucky enough to have Collin as our server on our next visit.

Jessica Haertel

Food wasn't up to par as usual. Salad tasted funny and they served a second salad on a very evident chipped bowl.

Brian Caulfield

Always have a good meal here. The crab legs were very dry this time which was shocking. But the Shark Fin makes up for it.

Jason Whitaker

I liked the flavor on all of the food. When you're in a fish market, well, it will smell like a fish market. And will likely have very few other options that are not fish. So if you're considering bringing someone that does not like fish, there will be no appetizers and limited selections for non-fish entrees. The service and staff were fantastic. Also, because the fish is fresh caught, it will taste amazing, but portion sizes are going to be smaller than what you might see at a place that serves farm raised fish. If you love seafood, you'll love Mitchell's.

Joe Zignego

The fish fry and blackened Mahi Mahi was great.

Steve Brooks

The staff was wonderful and very helpful, the food was delicious we WOULD definitely go back!!!

Becky Curran Kekula

The food is exceptional. Jennifer was a great server. I highly recommend the ahi tuna rice bowl.

Richard Ealum

Food was decent but over priced for the quality. Servce was attiquate, but not spectacular. Waitress has several good tips that boosted the experiences. Primary issue was at payment for the bill. I attempted to use a $25 gift card towards the bill I received a few years back. The gift card does not have a expiration date. It is for Mitchell's. The manager would not honor the card as their parent company has changed hands, per the waitress . I paid for our meal and vowed never to spend any more of my money with this company. I find this policy to be unacceptable.

Pete White

Lobster mac & cheese. Nothing more needs to be said. Service was pretty awesome too.

Ozias Burnett

It was very expensive but the food was delicious.

Paula Roberts

Great service but menu is misleading. Be careful when ordering.

Robin Sartore

Food and service was great on Christmas Eve just as it was on my first visit!

Mark Neff

My date and I set down at about 9pm, which is an hour before closing. Our waiter was very knowledgeable of the menu and did not leave us to feel rushed. I appreciate the options provided customers for how the fish will be prepared either by pan sear, blackened, Caribbean, broiled, grilled or cedar plank. The variety of preparations come with set menu sides for each style preparation. I think it's fun to try variation in preparation to complement the dining experience. Ambiance is inviting with dark wood colors, plenty of space and dim lighting. I did find the booth seating to be a bit worn on the ends where people apparently normally sit and found myself moving closer against the wall where the booth padded booth seating was a little more firm. The food was tasty. Service was a little bit slow but nothing unacceptable, yet surprising given it was a Wednesday evening, not crowded and late. I'm certain to return to sample another one of the many interesting and delicious sounding options on the menu.

Marissa Lastrilla

Really good ocean Cobb salad

Nathan Young

Routinely enjoy the food and atmosphere. Wide variety of seafood choices.

April Frohardt

How sad is it that we could have had better service and better food at Red Lobster? It is VERY sad, I expect so much more from Mitchells. Tasteless calamari, rubbery shrimp, asparagus so tough I needed a steak knife to cut it. The crab stuffing in my flounderwas horrible. We saw the waitress twice after she took our order. Once to bring us bread (great bread!). And the other to take our check. No one ever came and checked to see if our food was okay. Yes we could have flagged someone down but didn't. Instead we'll just take our $$ to Bonefish.

Be Chego

Mitchell’s Fish Market does not disappoint. I was there for a quick lunch, so I just had the Salmon, Shrimp and Scallops combination as well as a house salad. Everything was delicious and looked great. The staff is very accommodating and friendly. The place is clean and was not too busy when I was there. I imagine it gets busy for dinner, so reservations might be a good idea on special nights. Recommended. Bechego #bechego

Michael G. Mulligan

Great Food & Service ..

Jim Starck

Food was decent, but service was beyond bad. Waited 15 minutes to get a waiter. Another 10 minutes for drinks to come out. Restaurant wasn't busy. Wife ordered steak and lobster. 15 minutes after meals came out and lobster was already eaten they brought out butter for the lobster and a steak knife. Then, paid cash and was short changed. Definitely won't be a returning customer. Not sure about the 4 star rating they received.

Donnika Green

Very delicious , I would definitely recommend this restaurant..

Nathan Harling

Food was ok, not as good as I expected for the price. Service was slow, orders were incorrect multiple times. Server was never around to fix them. Manager did little to solve the problem.

Monica Simmons

Service and atmosphere was excellent, food was great, great selection of fish. My only negative would be the hushpuppy were not crunchy enough. But all and all very enjoyable evening.

wing Man

It was awesome. Our server Lauren took care of us for valentines dinner

Joe Trusnik

I love seafood, and Mitchell's delivers a fantastic meal. Easily one of my favorite places to get food. It's just a little pricey.

Joanne Grebner

Smelled "fishy" when we entered. The shrimp and scallops we're good but the cod was fishy ( not tasting fresh). The hush puppies were great. The service was good. This was a restaurant I really enjoyed years past, not so much now

Adrian Marie Flink

Excellent food, well prepared. Very congenial wait Staff.

Linda Miller

My husband and I were in this past Saturday. It was really busy so we decided to sit at the bar to eat. We could tell that the bartenders were very busy and seemed a bit overwhelmed but they said they would be with us in a minute and the were. They were friendly and helped us decide what we should try, we had only been there one other time. We were not disappointed. The food, our drinks and service were fantastic, we will definitely be back to see them!

Doug Hamilton

Lunch menu was a nice selection. Food was not hot when it was served.

Kenny Lam

Quiet on a saturday lunch. Food and service is average.

Garrett Yim

Service was great. Food was overpriced for what you get. The standouts were the clam chowder and Shark fin pie.... So you're better off going to the public market for fresh clams and dessert for a quarter of the price you'd pay here.

Bonnie Licklider

Poor food quality. Loud atmosphere. Non tentative wait staff. Will not return and it's a shame.

Brandon Whitfield

Gonna miss that place

chris spyra

Very good food. Service was impeccable! I will be back

Perry Bennett

Very good food, kinda pricey especially for the area, but upscale and nice atmosphere

Suzanne Baczanski

Always excellent service and food

Mike S

Wow! This place is the only reason you need to visit one the last remaining malls in this world. Everything is about 1-3$ more than I would expect. But it’s worth it. Everyone from the hostess to our awesome waitress Hiedi were great. The swordfish was very very good. Blackened. The Seafood Sampler was good, but the scallops were a little more sandy than I’ve experienced ever before. Id still get it again. And the Angels Manhattan, holy cow. Get that. Go there just for that. We live super far away, and can’t wait to go back. Ha. We went for lunch and were able to get out of there for less than 90$, with desert drinks and cocktail. Worth it. I really hope this place stays around and I regret taking this long to find it.

Patricia Guzman Rojas

Good food. Good quality and the creme brulee was great!

Tony Martin

Great lunch menu and top rate service.

Jonathan Neal

Sat in the bar on thanksgiving day and the service was great. Friendly bartender, and good support staff to take care of everything we needed. We love that they are open on holidays and will probably return for Christmas dinner.

Jan Gruber

Wonderful atmosphere, super friendly staff and the food was amazing!

Donna Hawkins

Great food and service. Reasonable happy hour prices

Denise Johnson-Sherard

My seared Chilean seabass was buttery good!

Alan Winter

Great food, nice servers and great atmosphere. Little expensive, but seafood done right isn't cheap.

Bharathram Rajaraman

The seafood options are decent. Slightly overpriced though. Stay away from anything other than seafood though. Unknowingly ordered a chicken Parmesan once and it was just ... horrendous!!

John Byerly

Love this place. Have never had a bad meal here. They know how customer service should be as well. Other restaurants should use their customer service as training. They are the total package. Great food and great service. Always a pleasure.

Jonathan Minucci

The food is amazeballs...but save room for the shark fin pie or you have wasted your life

J Sullivan

Mitchell's Market Trio is broiled Sixty South Antarctic salmon, grilled shrimp, crab cake, roasted corn sauté andouille-jambalaya rice and asparagus. Small but nice sized portions of everything so it is okay by yourself if you are hungry. My drink was similar to Irish Coffee but is Luxury 9 (I think). It is scrumptious. Look for it on the drink menu. By the way, the bread is tasty too.

Robert Sch

Service and food was sub-par. We have been frequent visitors and at best we have had marginal food and service. We will not be back. They were even out of oysters on Father's day.

Mariano Floro

As a Landry's Select Club member we have enjoyed our previous engagements. However, today was far from the standards of what we expect from this establishment. We sat down got drinks and never saw our waiter again for 36 min. We asked for him but no one paid any attention because a large party was being seated. So we got up and left. We expressed our dissatisfaction to the manager and probably will never come back. Very disappointing.

steve held

This place is terrible! I should’ve know something was off when I went into the open table app the same day as the reservation and every slot was open. With this be a Landry’s restaurant and modest reviews on open table we decided to give it a shot. Walking in this place looks and feels dirty; it’s not the decor but actual filth ; and they attempt to hide this filth by lowering the lights. Friendly staff seated us to our dirty table and dirty seats(still Dirty from previous diners) and handed us food stained menus. Please note that if we were at Red Lobster(which is- unbelievably better(yes I shudder when I speak those words, Red Lobster is like the Capital Grill to Denny’s compared to this place). I ordered the gumbo- which came out in a consistently of tomato paste directly from the can- horrible- not sure how many days that has been sitting around. Next I ordered a $30 shrimp, scallop and salmon entree- this delicious entree came out as 3 boiled tasteless shrimp, 3 boiled tasteless scallops and a raw(yes raw and cold) piece of salmon drenched in soy sauce to cover the mess up. My wife ordered the $45 king crab entree- when it arrived the crab was soo dry not only did it not come out, but the butter barely made it palatable. My son enjoyed the bowl of plain buttered noodles and the bread, which I why I’m giving this place 2 stars. When the waitress realized part of my dinner was raw- she told me she would send the manager over and comp the entree- the manager never came over to talk to us- I assume they were embarrassed on the quality and price of what they were serving; while at the same time depreciating the Landry’s brand and validity of open tables rating system. Do yourself a favor and visit one of the other many fantastic restaurants in the immediate area. STAY AWAY!

Valosar

Service was top of the line, never had a more professional waiter in my life. My fish was on par with something that comes out of a yellow box with a fisherman on the front however everyone else at my table received amazing food. I will definitely give it a second chance

Zoe N

Really great. Friendly service, good food

Derrick Kelly

Everything is always fresh. Staff I can't say enough good things about. Always nice always joking in a good mood. Your Chefs are off the charts. The place is always clean and organized. Thank you so much for a great place to eat. Always going back.

Adam O'Bara

Menu is great.. service was mediocre.. mistakes were made, waited a long time and food still came out cold..

Eric Fialkovich

Decent happy hour food menu 5-7 ! But they have a fruit fly problem, and a blue moon at happy hour is still like $5. They could earn a

Kid ClutchJr

The food was mediocre. The server Lauren got upset and I received dirty looks as I'm leaving the restaurant and the server Lauren was complaining about the tip amount how very rude. We will not be returning here. This is the first and last visit. Train this particular server on better customer service cause you all just lost customers.

Carla Brown

Let me start at we use to love Mitchell's when it was landry's my Husband and I would go faithfully often it was our to go place and we would always have great service and meal. I would celebrate my birthday there almost every year there as well accompanied by the rest of my family members either getting one of their rooms or a few tables were set up. But the pass few visits have not been the same. Mitchell's fish Market in Homestead are always out of something on the menu is out every time we order. Very disappointing and we are tired of this happening!! So I haven't been in about 5 months... I decide call in and ordered a togo fish and chips Dinner meal NOT lunch but dinner. This pass Friday. I didn't get a chance to look at my meal until I was ready to sit down to eat. Boy oh boy what a difference in meals. I was soooo dissatisfied and upset. I called the manager to say why did I recieve 3 fish nuggets very,very small portion in coleslaw and even the hush puppies were little grapes size. She had the nerve to said the Dinner servings are not big like Lunch fish and chips. Lunch is cheaper& bigger in size and DINNER fish are smaller in size like nuggets size that's crazy WOW!! I JUST PAID $20.00 FOR NUGGETS MEAL

Donna Brungo

Always delicious....great service by Paul!! Thanks so much.

Clifton Robinson

Fresh seafood and a great staff. Will definitely go again.

Fred Krawczyk

Overpriced for what you get, the service was really slow. The food was good

Darcy Rainbow

Fresh seafood with unique plates. A little chain like

Scott Kimball

Stuck in the middle of a strip mall, I wasn't expecting much. Being part of the Landry's empire, I wasn't expecting much. But the place took me by suprise with it's professional sevice and fine food. The clam chowder was some of the best I've had outside the bay area. The salmon cooked perfectly and tasted as though it came off the boat minutes before. It's pricey, but worth the price. I look forward to going back.

Craig Upton

Love this place. Staff does a good job.

Maria White

First time ever after ordering the Chilean sea bass that both diners were fishy. Mentioned it to server and manager. Manager dos not offer any type of discount. Disappointing after going for many years.

Marshall Dixon

Food was excellent! Server great also

Edwin Gardner Jr

Slow service, shrimp and scallops were not fresh.

Candie Johnson

We decided to give this place a try even after the negative reviews. I was very disappointed in the quality of the food compared to the locatio in Ohio. Guess that explains why it was empty. Food was served fast and our hostess was very nice. I don't like complaining or giving bad reviews, but I had to be honest for others

Ron DeFoe

The food was good but it seemed like an off night with numerous items not available for example the Peruvian mashed potatoes. Service was good ,will try again.

Matt Szalankiewicz

Don't bother. We didn't. Website says happy hour on patio (see attached screenshot). Hostesses confirms this on the phone. We arrive and sit in the patio area. Server advises no happy hour on patio, the website is wrong and hostess is new. Asked if could honor it due to the error. Server consults manager. Manager sends server back to us (instead of coming to us personally) and says still can't do it because "we don't have the buttons for that." We go to Bar Louie down the street. We have a wonderful evening there instead.

Bud Ware

Insanely b it st on s Friday night during Lent.

Kieffer Patfenus

Great visit. Enjoyed the seafood slot. Will visit again.

Kate Thompson

Nice and quiet, not loud and food and staff excellent in this area of town that people think they are special and privileged.

Linda Rouch

Very nice. Good food and service.

Jeffrey Bakota

Server was distracted.Food was average and incorrect. Overall disappointed.

Rick Matherly

Gr8 food!!

Michelle Oja

Tonight was my first time there. There's a great selection of seafood options, and I really like that they have a seasonal aspect to the menu.

Andrea Arndt

I love eating at Mitchell's Fish Market. The food is excellent, the people are very friendly and the atmosphere is great. Easy to have a good conversation - no loud echoing sounds like other restaurants I have been to.

A Trout

Good seafood. Service is good.

Ronald Maglin

it aint like it used be.rumor their closing?

Cynthia Jackson

Pretty expensive, but the food was good.

Luis Oms

Always love coming here for lunch. Prices are easier to swallow. But either way, the food is obviously made fresh. Love seeing new vegetarian options too.

Heidi Olson

We love Mitchell's Fish Market! I always get the Salmon on a cedar plank and my husband has had Blue Marlon and Lobster stuffed Cod. Everything is always great. We've had the crab cakes, calamari, pico spinach dip and Lobster Mac and cheese--all delicious. Most recently our waitress, Michele was phenomenal. She was super friendly, funny and attentive.

Scott Campen

Once seated, loooong wait for service, and initial drink order (mistake on 1 of 4 drinks, took 10 minutes to get out), looong wait on appetizer. The only thing that balanced it out to 3 stars was the food...delicious, all around the table. So, 2 star service, 4 star food.

Victoria Pua

Food is great but expensive (around $25-$50). Great location and ample parking.

James Huff,

Excellent food great price and atmosphere highly recommend

Dawn

This has always been one of my favorite restaurants. Until today I have never eaten there and not been happy. The food is always tasty and presented well. My husband had the fried seafood plate which he enjoyed with the exception of the hush puppies. Fried yuck with no flavor. I ordered the double stack burger. It was absolutely the worst hamburger I have ever had. It was old and tasteless. They really need to re-think that one. Service was pretty good and our waiter Collin was pretty attentive and friendly. It was a wee bit slow considering we and another couple were the only ones there. Kick it up a notch Mitchell's you are starting to disappoint.

Judy Klauer

Only 4 scallops on a 22 dollar menu item, not worth it.

J.A. Santi

Not good and not cheap. Go somewhere else, if possible

Laura Lee

Always delicious, fresh seafood. Great service.

Mary Floulis

I've always been satisfied with the service and food, had to organize a funeral luncheon on short notice, Mitchell's was extremely accommodating, the food was excellent, drinks are wonderful, staff went far and above to accommodate a grieving family, I recommend this place for lunch, drinks, dinner or large gatherings, the attention to the details showed , as the family and friends were very pleased from time of arrival, and thru out the day. Thank you for making a sad day a little better.

Timothy Vogel

Good fresh fish and service. Somewhat expensive

C Heil

Very good food

Moses Nettles Jr.

Love this place! Fantastic food and amazing service! Highly recommend!

Bandits gameing

It was great sword fish but the steak was a little under seasoned but cooked perfectly

Raj Lahari Reddy

Great food ,they offer wide variety of fish

Jon Stendebach

Good sea food. Menu changes frequently. Part of the Landry's restuarant collection. Staff is pleasant and good happy hour prices.

Brad Ruggles

Wonderful seafood selection. Some of the best scallops I've had! Delicious!

thomas gilchrist

Place fell off bigtime

Alfonso Cruz

Great food and fresh fish. The scallops are awesome. Great service and plenty of parking.

William Perkins Jr.

Good food! Excellent service! Nice atmosphere!

Dionne Denise NRCDA

The menu seems to be lacking as of 2019 in my opinion but the staff is always friendly.

Anna Kharitonov

Great place

Catherine Gray

Excellent wedding rehearsal dinner venue!

Jessica Smith

Food was great and service was very attentive. Never had to ask for refills. They even brought a free dessert for my son for being so patient during a very busy dinner time while we waited to be seated. We don't go to the restaurant very often because it can be a bit pricey, but it was worth it this time. Seafood Pasta was delicious!

Joel Hawthorne

Always s good meal here. Good service...they dont rush you, and the food is good. I've had many dishes....love the oysters an DC the lobster roll.

Sharon Hopkins

Due to my food allergies, I was unable to get dinner at this restaurant! Mashed potatoes have garlic in them, server actually suggested rice to have with lobster!!

Mark Kline

Our dinners were delicious and the service was outstanding!

paul terhune

Beautiful restaurant with great staff, But our crab legs were very poor.

James Miller

Excellent and fresh seafood. Casual atmosphere and convenient location.

Karen Menzel

Great food. Love the lobster bisque soup. Wonderful

Southern Indiana Explorers

I got a hair in my shrimp appetizer so that's as far as I got I left imediately.

Derrik Anker

Great atmosphere, good food, only negative was they fry the scallops.

Brian Fuerst

Service is so so. Most of the food is good. $3.35 for iced tea is outrageous.

Sriram Srinivasan

The salmon just melts in your mouth. Everything was cooked really nicely and it was all flavorful. However, be prepared to pay the price that comes with this food.

adBidtise

Great place for delicious seafood if you are out in the burbs! Lunch is a must no waiting, friendly staff and great good!

Tony Perry

We like Mitchell’s. Wherever we’ve visited the food has been good to great. Service has been good to great as well. For an upscale restaurant they could be a bit more focused on both consistently attentive and professional service and consistent food quality. They could achieve 5 stars with a little effort.

Sean Skelly

Food was good. Super overpriced though. Everyone in my party ordered drinks that ended up being super strong. The bartender needs to go back to school. Service from your waiter or waitress will be excellent. They made sure you are well taken care of. The atmosphere is casual and intimate with down lighting.

Emgee Speaks

10 start menu. Great service always

Erin

Great happy hour! Even better martinis.

James Krim

Great seafood but for the prices service should be at a higher level

Jewel Garrison

I had the shrimp Alfredo and it was very tasty.

Susan Backes

Clam Chowder is outstanding...really outstanding and the smashed loaded mashed potatoes were perfection at it's best!

DeWayne Griffith

Atmosphere and service was great. I ordered Mahi Mahi blackened. I believe it came out grilled. I could not taste any Cajun seasoning on it at all.

Scott Morris

Mitchell's Fish Market consistently exceeds our expectations for seafood in Carmel. With patio seating as well as a cool open dining room, you will be made to feel most welcome. Choose fresh fish from the market display and it will be prepared as you like it. Chef's selections and daily specials to choose from. All this plus a great bar. You can't go wrong.

Ashley Newcom

I got the burger. Was not a fan

Lindal Romano

First time there, i had a gift card, i had the Sea Scallops delicious, my full meal was good..alittle expensive, but i would go back again..our server was very nice & polite, you get what you pay for....

Vic Miller

Fantastic loved the cowboy ribeye. Sometimes you get the best steaks in a fine fish restaurant

Lisa Cummings

Great food, great service, very expensive!!!

alex f

Went in for a snack and a beer at lunch. Empty, clean, good food, good service.

Darlene Sligar

The espresso machine has been broken for years the staff keeps trying to make it work.

Brian Beverage

I typically get the same thing yellow Fin Tuna grilled. I have been several times. It seems that the fillets were consistently sized or I just happen to always get a similar fillet cut. Lately, the fillets vary drastically in shape and thickness. The consistency of the cook vary greatly. It seems when the fillets are the normal 1.5" cut the cook is closer to my medium likeing but when it's the 2.5" "fillet mignon" shaped cut it's really on the raw side. Like maybe 1/8th inch cooked on each side. I do not mind 1/8th inch red center with the majority of each side cooked. I also do not like to send food back so I will just eat it. One of the servers I had was trying to recommend the rare cook. I do not mind a medium rare with a lean towards the medium side but rare on a 2.5" cut seems to be sushi for the most part. He claimed they prefer rare for yellow Fin. I get that you do not want to over cook the fish .... But it would be nice for it to just be consistent.

Jaime Evans

Great food even better atmosphere!

Melinda Jones

Great foods

Kat Kealy

I'm so glad Mitchell's participated in restaurant week. I'd never been to either location and we didn't know the location closer to us existed until Bryan noticed them on restaurant week. The food was AMAZING. Bryan warned me to save room for the shark fin pie, thankfully. I don't eat dessert at restaurants often, but the shark fin pie is worth it! I tried the gumbo and tuna bowl, which were both good. I loved my jambalaya and the asparagus took a while to get used to (a bit softer than I prefer), but it was good. The shark fin pie was beyond amazing, but I'd recommend getting the SMALLER portion unless you have a table of 4 or more. Splitting the big one with two people was too much. Delicious, but too much - even when I saved half my jambalaya for lunch. The service was wonderful. Our waitress, Lisa, was so fast & stealthy that I didn't always realize she'd filled my water until I'd look down and see that it was full. The manager was also very friendly. We'll definitely be repeat customers and look forward to many more delicious meals at Mitchell's. I wanted to try almost everything on the menu, so I'm sure I'll eat there many times before repeating a dish (other than getting the mini shark fin pie to share).

Marcia Gilbert

Great food and service

Alexander Stewart

Fantastic service with our server Julia. Every need was met despite a busy section and an impromptu 15 person party. Food was fantastic. Very good creme brule.

Tim Sherrer

Pleasantly surprised! Went for our anniversary dinner, was actually a second choice because first place was overbooked. We'll be back again, food was amazing as was our waitress.

David Rosensteel

Always good food and good service

J 1 M

My favorite sea food and fish restaurant around hands down for years and still is! The losber bisque is my favorite and there portions are a nice size. You pay top dollar but, you also get top dollar service and food. Bone appetite.

Kristin Hix

We popped in around an hour before closing. We sat at a booth in the bar. Our waiter, John, was really great. He was very knowledgeable about the menu. My steak came out a bit raw for my taste and I sent it back. chef came out to ensure how I wanted my state cooked and brought it back within just a few minutes perfectly cooked. The dinner was lovely.

Ed Chodkowski

Our fish was perfectly prepared. I was also impressed with their signature cocktails.

Christina S.

The lobster and shrimp stuffed cod was delicious!!

Goblue Polsgrove

Great food most of the time. But inconsistent.

hwileyiii

We've never had a bad meal or bad service. They are an Open Table restaurant. Great seafood

Charles Coomer

Had a very nice experience on my first visit. Staff friendly. Food was great. Definitely recommend this restaurant

Holly Joy

Sunday evening...empty place. Slow and disinterested service. Burned, not simple grilled, bacon wrapped shrimp appetizers, the worst lobster bisque... it was all just bad. veer

Chris Canfield

When you walk into the dining room the stale musty fish smell makes it very off putting. We had the calamari and a couple of there Martinez the Martinez were good, the Calamari ...not so much very bready and dry. Our service was good but slow coming. Background music, distracting. Opdid not to get lunch. However did get soups Lobster biscuit very good!! New England Clam Chowder also very good. The smell and music really were distracting and off-putting. The dining room very nice decor.

jonda prather

Awesome service and the Food was Great

Melissa Grivois

The service was great! Our waitress was very nice, and personable. The food was delicious as well. Would recommend.

Robert Eder

Good and pricey but could be a little better.

Elisa Richardson

Visited Mitchell's fish market in West Chester Ohio July of this year my waitress was very good I did have a problem with the serving size I ordered the gumbo a cup which a cup is normally 8 oz it was very good I ordered one for my husband to go I ask for a bowl the bowl should have been 12 ouses when the waitress brought it out for me in a container it was the size of the cup which was 8 oz so I asked her is this a bowl or a cup she says this is our bowl so then she goes back the manager comes out and specifically tells me that this was a bowl that she reassured me that it was 12 oz I said OK now the cup is $6 the bowl is $8 they charged me 8 dollar for cup we measured it when I got home beware of the fools tail this should be on John matterease don't waste your money (christen) manager you should be terminated

Stacey Nunez

Wonderful good. Great service!

Kevin Coleman

Fast service and good food.

Elizabeth Kennedy

Everything from beginning to end was flawless.

Beverly Baldwin

The Seafood is Delicious I had broiled Shrimp and an appetizer Shrimp with a bacon wrap and barbecue is was very good

shalawn knox

I remember why I haven't been back in a while

Monika Haver

I love Mitchell‘s

Sandra Stewart

I love this place food great service excellent

Richard Stewart

Quiet corner to talk about the day & great seafood just right.

Chris Brown

Let me start with the good. Our server was excellent. Knowledgeable about the menu and extremely patient with my mom and mother-in-law, always smiling and friendly. The food was good. There are better seafood places in Pittsburgh. The salmon was excellent. The shrimp was dry. The crab cakes were good. The sides were average. The taste of the clam chowder and lobster bisque was very good but there was very little seafood in the chowder. Now, what was really bad. We were seated outside the restaurant in the mall. People watching us eat, loud echoing music from the mall P.A. system, cold drafts from the door to the outside. We ate on patio furniture with metal tables. This is fine for lunch at a burger joint, but not at a higher end seafood place where the tab was over $175. This with reservations made well in advance. I had a much better experience last Christmas. I will be looking somewhere else next year.

Steve Thecato

It's a decent seafood place, albeit pricey. The crab cakes are delicious, as are the fish and chips. The house salads are fresh and large. The seafood gumbo was awesome with large chunks of fish. The service is adequate and the it seems clean. There is a weird smell that I've noticed there every time I've gone. It's like a moldy, old building smell, but it's not distracting enough to effect the visit. The only concern is the price, and that wouldn't be that big of deal if the quantity matched the dollars spent.

Georgie McCarty

My Lobster Bisque was yummy! My Salmon and rice was very good. Asparagus was a bit under cooked. The appetizers... Calamari was ok, a small portion and dry, and the Artichoke dip was great. Everyone else seemed satisfied with the food overall. A salad was sent back. Happy hour was advertised on the board as you entered, but none available. It was very busy, Mother's Day, at the dinner hour.

Daniel perla

Good food

Beverly Roumph

Great good

Greg Jagst

Worth a stop if you like seafood.

James Wiswell

How dare this...this fish market support Breamteam, I will never return until they agree to kick them off the list. It is time to stand up against Breamteam, those bastards will pay for there actions. Also the titanic wedge iceberg was just awful. Ah vote for Mitch is ah vote for Mitch.

Cynthia Matthys

Great service ...great food helped us celebrate my sons 30th birthday

Andrea Whitman

Seafood is not as.freah as they claim. Over priced. Kroger has a better selection of fish. Deserts are great. Employees are treated badly especially in the kitchen. Overheard a chef yelling at employee over a minor problem

Eric manley

Best seafood in town, hands down. The sales manager, Kelsi Holden, makes the private dining experience absolutely amazing.

Brian Caulfield

Always have a good meal here. The crab legs were very dry this time which was shocking. But the Shark Fin makes up for it.

James Malone

Mmmm! Seafood like you want it to be, excellent! Nice change of pace. Friendly staff.

bobscaping

Pleasant dining experience. Our favorite waiter's name is Christian.

Mike Daley

Good service good food nice good atmosphere

John Cornwall

We love Terry and J at the bar!

Lubna Rahman

Very nice food, we go there very often and never get a bad meal. Service is very good, with very nice and responsive people working there.

Jessica P. Hernandez

Great servers! From the beginning the staff was attentive and willing to help however possible. I was here for a work meeting and appreciated the attention we were provided while there. The food was delicious and very filling! There are many options to choose from on the menu, we had a smaller menu to select from due to time constraints. Overall great time here!

Rashid Williams

They don't really have vegan options on the menu, but we called a few days ahead and the chef accommodated us...and the food was pretty good.

Robin Sartore

Food and service was great on Christmas Eve just as it was on my first visit!

Mark Neff

My date and I set down at about 9pm, which is an hour before closing. Our waiter was very knowledgeable of the menu and did not leave us to feel rushed. I appreciate the options provided customers for how the fish will be prepared either by pan sear, blackened, Caribbean, broiled, grilled or cedar plank. The variety of preparations come with set menu sides for each style preparation. I think it's fun to try variation in preparation to complement the dining experience. Ambiance is inviting with dark wood colors, plenty of space and dim lighting. I did find the booth seating to be a bit worn on the ends where people apparently normally sit and found myself moving closer against the wall where the booth padded booth seating was a little more firm. The food was tasty. Service was a little bit slow but nothing unacceptable, yet surprising given it was a Wednesday evening, not crowded and late. I'm certain to return to sample another one of the many interesting and delicious sounding options on the menu.

Matt Poljak

Great happy hour.

Ed Hoffmann

Good raw bar selections, very fresh fish, with appetizers and sides well above average. Tuna poke bowl was very fresh with excellent sticky rice and vegetables. Low key service (the good kind) and big welcoming bar area.

April Frohardt

How sad is it that we could have had better service and better food at Red Lobster? It is VERY sad, I expect so much more from Mitchells. Tasteless calamari, rubbery shrimp, asparagus so tough I needed a steak knife to cut it. The crab stuffing in my flounderwas horrible. We saw the waitress twice after she took our order. Once to bring us bread (great bread!). And the other to take our check. No one ever came and checked to see if our food was okay. Yes we could have flagged someone down but didn't. Instead we'll just take our $$ to Bonefish.

Zella Cook

We had a wonderful anniversary dinner at this lovely restaurant. The food was delicious and our waitress was amazing!! We will return.

Denise Kuntz

An excellent restaurant to go eat at!

Jim Starck

Food was decent, but service was beyond bad. Waited 15 minutes to get a waiter. Another 10 minutes for drinks to come out. Restaurant wasn't busy. Wife ordered steak and lobster. 15 minutes after meals came out and lobster was already eaten they brought out butter for the lobster and a steak knife. Then, paid cash and was short changed. Definitely won't be a returning customer. Not sure about the 4 star rating they received.

Darlene Grubor

Food is awesome. Service courteous and prompt!

Sherri Vizzuett

So tired of dissatisfaction. I don't know why I continue to frequent chain establishments. First off we questioned the clueless hostess as to whether a substitute could be made with soba noodles ex. Vegetable being my friend is gluten free. Answer...I don't think so. It was just so dismissive that I said..."can you check with the chef?" After an eyeball roll, she went and came back stating, "just as I said, we cannot substitute because vegetables are more expensive. Are you kidding me? We were more than willing to pay for the change. We then asked if a rice could be a substitution but not sticky rice. She said that was the only kind they had. We then discovered a carribean rice listed. Like I said clueless and seemingly annoyed by our questions. I finally said....it doesn't look like anyone is breaking down the door to get in here, you should be a little accommodating to customers. She apologized when realizing that I may bust her with the manager as the next step. We were seated and ordered the super bowl with shrimp which we joking said in agreement was this the appetizer before the real dish? So extremely small, even smaller than a panera bowl another chain that is overrated. For a bill of $20 for this pitiful 5 shrimp salad, well Only a fool would return. I had eaten years ago in the waterfront location which was a larger meal, average and pricey but for a quick lunch, you can fool me once, maybe twice, third time...it will never happen.

Judy Amos

Not what it used to be--- poor service, very few customers and had to track down server for service. I had called and asked if they had oysters Rockefeller - not listed on their web menu. Hostess said, yes, they can serve them. NOT! Server said not available - doubtful that he asked chef. Weak cosmopolitan- big disappointment.

Dawn Hickenbottom

Highly overpriced for what you get. Food was average at best. Service was nice but didn't overcompensate for the cost/taste ratio. If you're a seafood rookie you may enjoy but I expected more from a "fish market".

Bob Sharkey

Almost 5 stars. Great food and service. Prices are a little higher than at Bonefish which is probably their closest competitor. Seafood is very fresh. Good for a "special" night out.

Jillian Gilliam

Real nice and classy seafood place to go out with a loved one. Chilean sea bass, best fish on the menu.

Andy Gurley

This place used to be good. The crab legs were awful/ split open, halved to be exact. 2 crab legs split to look like 4 for $36. Come on! Red lobster doesn't even do that. Veggies were way under cooked...

Trae L

Nice place to dine. Able to have a conversation without excessive noise. Every attentive waiter bit not hovering which was good.

Ben Thurman

Overpriced, overrated, overcrowded and a waste of time. Menu was underwhelming. My lobster bisque was cold and gummy. How do you screw up a Caesar salad? My Screwdriver taste like it was made w "tang" or orange drink as opposed to orange juice!!!!! NEVER AGAIN. Save both your $ and your time.

Rae Jane Araujo

Wonderful Christmas dinner. I loved my crab legs.

Susan Dolinar

Food was great and waiter was friendly and informative

Lori C

This restaurant has the most ignorant hostesses. My elderly parents went for dinner at 4:15 and the hostesses were rude, obnoxious and complete snobs. Not only did they not seat my parents but they laughed at them for not having a reservation....for 4:15!!!! Epic fail. Apparently this is not the first time something like this has happened with their staff. My parents and my family will NEVER go back and I urge others to think twice about patronizing a restaurant that treats customers so badly. Thank you for ruining my father's birthday.

Maryanne Michele

Good food. Pricey. Service was just ok. Waiter did not come back to check.

d plutko

Quick quality friendly service always!

Koris Fromuo

Chilean sea bass!!

Patricia Guzman Rojas

Good food. Good quality and the creme brulee was great!

The Humble Lion Motivates

When you go, sit at the bar. Kirsten or Ryan are wonderful, and will take great care of you!

Adam Schwartz

Great food, great service. You can't go wrong.

Nevsky

Great clam chowder

Erika Muir

Ahi bowl was excellent

Filthyfoxx

Overpriced in my personal opinion for mediocre food, mostly lacking in flavor & seasoning. Waiter wasn't much of one; we had 3 different people attend our table.

Jonathan Minucci

The food is amazeballs...but save room for the shark fin pie or you have wasted your life

Sunni Schroeder

Great experience! Food was fantastic as well as the service!

Robert Sch

Service and food was sub-par. We have been frequent visitors and at best we have had marginal food and service. We will not be back. They were even out of oysters on Father's day.

Mariano Floro

As a Landry's Select Club member we have enjoyed our previous engagements. However, today was far from the standards of what we expect from this establishment. We sat down got drinks and never saw our waiter again for 36 min. We asked for him but no one paid any attention because a large party was being seated. So we got up and left. We expressed our dissatisfaction to the manager and probably will never come back. Very disappointing.

Valosar

Service was top of the line, never had a more professional waiter in my life. My fish was on par with something that comes out of a yellow box with a fisherman on the front however everyone else at my table received amazing food. I will definitely give it a second chance

Daniel Borsodi

The prices are high, the service is superb. However, the restaurant is made to look like a fish market. So, it's loud and smells like fish. The food was very big box-ish, and was not worth the money; we will not be returning.

Todd Smith

Wife and I stopped for a light meal in the afternoon after we saw a movie. Got fish & chips and calamari and shared. Food was very good. Also had interesting drinks on the drink menu.

Cassandra Williams

Salmon and asparagus was the best

Scott Kimball

Stuck in the middle of a strip mall, I wasn't expecting much. Being part of the Landry's empire, I wasn't expecting much. But the place took me by suprise with it's professional sevice and fine food. The clam chowder was some of the best I've had outside the bay area. The salmon cooked perfectly and tasted as though it came off the boat minutes before. It's pricey, but worth the price. I look forward to going back.

Scoti Clayton

This was my first visit and I wasn't too impressed. Bread was under done, butter was bland. I had lobster bisque that wasn't even hot but decent. My niece had the ahi tuna bowl and it was adequate. I ordered the twin lobster tails. They're wasn't enough drawn butter and my 3 asparagus Spears were barely cooked and still had the inedible ends on them?? For desert we both had the creme Brulee. The custard lacked flavor and the sugar could've been better caramelized. Our waitress barely glanced at our table every time she flew by. When I tried to approach her off to the side about my nieces bday she mistook me for a different table. That's how little attention she paid to us. I wouldn't drive from Milford to go there again but it was good enough once.

Marybeth Jewell

Excellent food and great service. Had the stuffed cod was perfect.

Robert McMullen

The cod was cooked perfect so were the green beans and redskin potatoes. The staff and waiters are great. But if you want that 5 stars either add another bread selection or improve the sourdough you offer.

Helda Saad

The food was great and the service was excellent!

Naor Wallach

Bad day in the kitchen. Scallops rubbery; Shrimp overcooked; Salmon raw; Chicken was tiny. Long wait time also. Not the norm in this place!

William Daly

Greasy food with ok taste. Been there once, doubt if there will be a second.

Ron DeFoe

The food was good but it seemed like an off night with numerous items not available for example the Peruvian mashed potatoes. Service was good ,will try again.

Bud Ware

Insanely b it st on s Friday night during Lent.

Rick taylor

Good food you can not get everywhere and service always good.

Meredith Patterson

Overcooked shrimp. Undercooked rice. Delicious sea bass with a horrible sauce that fortunately came on the side. $92 sans tip and we aren't drinkers. We expected so much more. Don't really see a reason to go back.

Jessica Williams

Just OK. Very pricey for just OK. Bench seats in booths were broken down. Lobster bisque was not good. Capital Grill bisque the best. Lobster and shrimp BLT weak. Have had better in New England little stands. But coleslaw very good.

Stephen Torain

Fabulous dinner. The spinach / green apple salad is a must. Then, all the fish preparations are excellent.

Eric Jason

We ate at the West Chester location 9/21/2017. The host was awesome and friendly so we thought it was going to be awesome lunch. The food was good but we will never return to this location. I eat really fast I was done in three mins with my meal it takes her longer to eat. The server came over took my bowl and asked if she wanted to him to box her food while she was still eating. She said no thank you he took the food away anyway in a hurry. Cleary if she is still eating while your asking she is not done. She only was able to eat 1/4 of her food. This was the craziest thing I have ever seen. Also the restroom were a mess and bar is missing tiles. Never been now will never go back.

Kate Thompson

Nice and quiet, not loud and food and staff excellent in this area of town that people think they are special and privileged.

Nathan B.

We go here a lot for work lunches. Great place to eat if you like fish and need a nice sit down meal. It can get a bit pricy for the amount of food you get, but the quality of the food is excellent. I gave it a 4 star because service can be a bit slow at times. But overall it's a great place to go for lunch and dinner.

Ian Lane

Very good seafood. (I had the Chilean sea bass) good unobtrusive service. Quiet Ambience

Joseph Timmerman

Pretty good, great Lobster bisque

Kelvin Sanders

Food was delicious, service was very accommodating from host to waitstaff.

Marcia Vannet

I had tilapia from the Prie Fixe menu. Excellent. Substantial portion, enough for lunch the next day.

Karyn Carpenter

Delicious food, good service.

Paolo Calza

Very good American fish... And not only! Good Quality/cost ratio!

Lori Angliss

Love the food. Really enjoyed the revamped atmosphere.

Chris Owens

Absolutely horrible experience. We have frequent this business many times...the food was cold . no service...my adult children from out of state colleges were home for the holiday and my daughter didn't even receive her meal after numerous attempts....until we were all finished eating our cold meal. Unfortunately, we will never return and I would advise no one to patron this business.

Luis Oms

Always love coming here for lunch. Prices are easier to swallow. But either way, the food is obviously made fresh. Love seeing new vegetarian options too.

Scott Campen

Once seated, loooong wait for service, and initial drink order (mistake on 1 of 4 drinks, took 10 minutes to get out), looong wait on appetizer. The only thing that balanced it out to 3 stars was the food...delicious, all around the table. So, 2 star service, 4 star food.

Laura Lee

Always delicious, fresh seafood. Great service.

Glenn Moots

Excellent prompt service from Justin despite our being "small spenders" and sitting outside on a 93 degree summer day. Wonderful three course special prepared and presented expertly. Bread delicious and fresh. Salads perfect for a summer day. Drinks continually refilled. Ice cream pie always to die for. Thanks for another great experience!

Bill Lung

It was wonderful, both meals were delicious. One was shrimp with fries, the other one was cod and fries. The cole slaw was great. But they had these hush puppies. That were the best, inside was cheese and some onions. They were delicious, along with the drinks. A wonderful place,and a great time. Also try the creme brulee for dessert. It was excellent, more than enough to share!

James A. Brown

Trio shrimp platter is a must try - Ryan the bartender was awesome

Timothy Vogel

Good fresh fish and service. Somewhat expensive

Vee Charles

Food was very good! I have a variety plater, the service was great!

Chuck Thilges

Great service.

Derek Austin

Good service but the food was mediocre. I ordered the crab stuffed flounder, portion size was good but had little to no taste

Bandits gameing

It was great sword fish but the steak was a little under seasoned but cooked perfectly

Ladious Abram

I love the food and service. I am never disappointed.

W. Barber Sr.

Excellent food would go back

Mark Glotfelty

Pricey. Small portions. Delicious however.

Koyejo Oyesiku

Busy restaurant with delicious food. The staff were friendly, courteous and helpful. They had overflow parking for rush hour. Relaxing ambiance with pictures of boats, glass case of seafood, etc. The butter tower (on the warmer) was fun to use while eating the twin lobster tails. In summary, I had a great experience.

Thomas Kortz

Great food great server . It's a little expensive. No military discount . SHAME on them...

Kellie Finley

Everything was delicious! Server was very polite and attentive without smothering. Definitely would recommend.

William Perkins Jr.

Good food! Excellent service! Nice atmosphere!

Tony Tumminello

Made reservations a month ago for my girlfriend and her Mom and Dad. Our friend told us about the place so we figured we would give it a try. It took a very long time just to get our waters around the table. Which is okay at first if they’re busy. Then ordering drinks took even longer probably 30 mins until we got those. Finally ordered and waiting forever for the food, 2 of our orders were wrong and 1 of our steaks was not even close to what we asked. Waitress was no where to be found for a good 20 mins, had to ask another waiter to find our waitress for us so we could at least get refills (which they charge double for) offered to make us new food of course but at this time it’s getting too late and I had a 1 Year old getting cranky now on my lap. Finally talked to a (manager) and they just wanna give us dessert which we’re not wanting to wait another 30 mins for that.... start taking everybody’s plates and offer to take it off the bill, still tried charging us for everything but one thing. Had to ask again because they (thought) they took it off. Waitress told us she had a long day which isn’t our fault? Even had to go up to the front to cash out because we have been there so long. Managers wasn’t too pleasant either. We go to a lot of restaurants but never had this happen before trying to show our parents a good time out. Ruined. Nobody got to eat and still had to pay $100 for drinks that didn’t get drunk and appetizers. First and last time.

Joey Greening

Been here a million times, never had a bad experience what so ever.

Tom Dluzen

I'm not usually a chain restaurant person, but for a business lunch venue, it's a great choice. Very consistent and good food, four stars. Easy to have a discussion, clean, and modern, five stars. The waiter shook our hands upon introduction, what if I'm a germaphobe? And he was a loud talker...inside voices, people! I'm hesitant to only give him a three star, you may love the over-the- topness. Maybe he was trying too hard because I'm officially a local Google reviewer and he was nervous, haha! Overall very good experience.

Jessica Smith

Food was great and service was very attentive. Never had to ask for refills. They even brought a free dessert for my son for being so patient during a very busy dinner time while we waited to be seated. We don't go to the restaurant very often because it can be a bit pricey, but it was worth it this time. Seafood Pasta was delicious!

Gwen Bland

Food was sub-par. But the service ok

Jeffery Sagerer

Amazing food, good service. The carribean jerk style swordfish was delicious, with a lot of flavor. Fresh oysters as well!

Warren Barker

Great Food and Great Service

Rebecca Meuser

Great food and service. It was our first time dining here and definitely going back.

Eugene Kay

Made reservation and requested table-to be decorated due to our anniversary. When we arrive I told server that I made special request, she said I didn’t read it I be back, never came back. I ask waitress for a manager! Christina was her name, she said she will take care of it also never came back. Had bad experience, next time will go to Carlos and Johnny’s . Nothing like that ever happened there, top notch service. Fish Market was just convenient. We have learn.

Kelley Risi

Absolutely PERFECT! Do not change a single little thing

Southern Indiana Explorers

I got a hair in my shrimp appetizer so that's as far as I got I left imediately.

Derrik Anker

Great atmosphere, good food, only negative was they fry the scallops.

Hal Felch

Have been here before and had good food and service. Tonight, I was not at all impressed. So, so food, small portions, just ok service, is not what I would expect for the price we paid. I will not be going back.

Tony Perry

We really like Mitchell's. When in the south hills we make it a point to stop in for a bite to eat. The happy hour specials are very well priced and there is a wide variety of items to choose from. There is some stating outside the restaurant but still inside the mall. We prefer to sit at the bar. The waitstaff is usually very good - friendly and attentive. On a couple occasions we had to send the soup back to warm it up a bit more but other than that, they have done a wonderful job.

Sean Skelly

Food was good. Super overpriced though. Everyone in my party ordered drinks that ended up being super strong. The bartender needs to go back to school. Service from your waiter or waitress will be excellent. They made sure you are well taken care of. The atmosphere is casual and intimate with down lighting.

Jennifer Thomas

They recently changed the menu and removed some of my favorite dishes. Some of the new items were tasty, but I still like the old dishes better, but its still a good spot for a nice meal.

SUSAN Capenos

Fair fare

Dave Bock

Always great food and priced accordingly.

James Krim

Great seafood but for the prices service should be at a higher level

L Nel

pricey.. not impressed by quality of food

Robert Smith

Fabulous service and the best bartenders around!

Axel Holden

Sat at the bar for cocktails and appetizers before seeing a movie tonight. Service was remarkable and attentive. That a crab cake it was okay. The shrimp grits and andouille sausage was out of this world. Would love to have an entree portion of that sometime.

Sharron Maddin

Great food Consistent every time. Good service. Noisy. Best to go during the week Did not disappoint.

Ashley Newcom

I got the burger. Was not a fan

Michael Sippy

Very good place to eat. All of their food is super fresh and the prices are reasonable. The decoration inside is also really good and the waitress that I had was very knowledgeable about what everything was.

Brian Craig

Great bar and happy hour.

Shelly Miller

Food was very good. My waitress Brittany was amazing. Very personable and friendly. Great customer service

Lynn Reynolds

Dear Mango-hito. I think I love you! Save a place for me next week during happy hour! De-lish!!!

Ceanna Huffman

High class great food.

Matt Petrie

Great service, great tasting fresh food, amazing cocktails. Never been let down here.

Kathy Bauch

Food was very good, large servings. Wait staff were very nice and came back several times checking if we needed anything.

Evan Crain

It's very difficult to find good seafood in the Midwest, but Mitchell's does really well. I found the fish to be just as good as Oceanaire, the brand's more upscale brother downtown, but came with more food for the same price. Classy, with a charming dark wood interior. Service is good, sourdough bread is tasty, cocktails are fun and well prepared.

Michael Jennetta

Excellent food!

Kurt DeLong

Service was good price was good quality was good server forgot to ask for dessert

Lindsey Hickerson

Great food and decent service

Dawn Stewart

Always a great place for seafood. Full bar. Drink specials are wonderful. Food always very good. Atmosphere is great. Waitstaff well informed. Desserts are magnificent

Vijnana Nath

Our service was very slow and unresponsive. They gave us a waitress who was clearly already overburdened by full tables when there was other wait staff who very obviously could have used more; the restaurant was not very full outside of one section. The food was not bad, but not good for the money spent and there was remarkably little of it. In my order of lobster tail and crab-stuffed shrimp, I got three rather small shrimp with a tiny amount of crab on each. My sides were some decent mashed potatoes and, get this, three stalks of asparagus. Over all, the experience was below mediocre. I would choose almost anywhere else.

J W

This was awful and expensive. I got chicken parmesan. The chicken was extremely greasy and tough. There was little flavor. The waitress was almost attentive. Never once offered to refill anyone's drinks and didn't know anything about anything on the menu. The place is so dark, it's uncomfortable. Others with me had the same thoughts. We won't need back. Eat n Park would have better; it's that bad. Just save your money and go elsewhere.

Susan Feye

Great seafood selections. Good service. Seafood platter was very good, but lobster shrimp roll was dry and bland.

Maryam Sepid

We visited this restuarant with a group of friends. The service is slow, so it takes more than 20 min for us to have our appetizers. I love their appetizers, especially crab cake and crispy spicy shrimp. However, the food portion is not enough, considering the price we paid, and I expected more! My husband even felt hungry after eating his meal. The quality of sea foods are great. The staff are polite, but we had a bad experience: they brought only one receipt for our group and didn't check beforehand. When we asked them to separate our receipts so that we can pay our share, they did not help that much, so if you're going with a group and everyone likes to pay theirs, you may want to make sure to have different recepits when you are ordering the food!

kelly young

Great place to eat and hang out with friends or family. Service was excellent as usual with Lauren going the extra mile! Clean and neat surroundings even make it better. Food was good,hot,decent portions and fresh. Bbq bacon shrimp is 1 of the best appetizers I've had!

Alice Barcomb

My husband and I visit this restaurant whenever we are in Brookfield. The fish is always outstanding and east coast oysters superb. The manager, Brandon, goes above and beyond to make the experience memorable; our waiter Jackson took very good care of us. Can't wait to visit again!

Tamara Robbins

Awesome Experience.Waitress Mick was the best ever. Service was top notch, food great. Please stop in and try this. We dined outside and it made the vist atmosphere great!

Lindsey Taylor

Delicious food, and good service!

Tim Shaw

Rainbow Trout and crab cakes were great chicken parmigiana not so great. Hardly any Marinara sauce. First round of chkn. Park had to go back tested like plastic. The made new chkn but did not accommodate any portion of the bill.

Tony 5Tone

I love their tuna melt.

eric Jacobson

Always nice light meals and good service

Jon Reid

Good salmon

Cindy Paukner

Lunch. Seated right away, the service was A+. My only quibble was the food. This place was on the pricey side & that given, I expect the food to be above part, it wasn't. I'll try again, maybe dinner to make up my mind.

Kerry Caperell

Used to be a pretty good place. Quality going downhill. Today, a literal shard of glass in my mashed potatoes! I will never be back!

Kitty Leys

Very good food, great sunday-friday happy hour. Highly recommend.

Charles Cogley

Excellent and well prepared fresh fish. Attentive and helpful staff.

Vince Au

Good food but very noisy

Katrina Tollenaar

Shanghai Trio! So delish!

J. Patrick Spalding

It's ok. Conceptually, it always sound amazing, but have never had anything worth the cost

David Kolpack

Ate outside on the patio, food was absolutely outstanding... shrimp and crab stuffed cod, and my wife had the crab stuffed shrimp. She would love to know what the white cream sauce was with the stuffed shrimp. The young waiter was very good also. Will definitely dine there again next time in Homestead!

Angie Geraci

my 1st there as I live in the Dells. Are waitress was awesome really helped with pairing and timed out our appetizer to the soup to our meal. everything was perfect.

Jeff Brown

It was ok, but great.

Julie Salomon

I dined on 8-19-2019. The dining room smelled of stale beer with nonexistent air conditioning. The staff seemed to be very disinterested with slow service. The drink order was prepared incorrectly with parts of the drink mixed up to form a totally different drink. This was explained to the waitress who stated the bar tender was new. A new drink was brought that was also incorrect at which point straight bourbon was ordered. The food was mediocre at best. Two stars is generous.

Brad Lee

Been multiple times, BBQ bacon shrimp is worth the trip alone. Amazing crab cakes. In general, a solid place. Sometimes service can be slow. They also have some really good cocktails. My wife loves the lavender cucumber martini

MaryAnn Mosso

Best seafood I've had outside Boston since coming to PA

Carol Sallmann

Enjoyed chilean sea bass, crab Cake, shrimp and lobster bisque. Waitstaff awesome. Prompt...food hot and delicious !!!

Carol Goul

EXCELLENT food......good service!

Anthony DiGregorio

This was my first experience dining at Mitchell's Fish Market. We were there for a gathering of family and friends so the food was presented buffet style in their party room. I have to admit that I thought the food was very good and my kids ate all of theirs if that helps other parents. The desserts offered were very good. The servers were very pleasant and skilled. I highly recommend the restaurant if you are on the fence of where to go or if you want to try something new.

Jane Black

Food was good as was the service

Hashem Aswani

Super fresh and delicious menu! Will be back

Angelo Colon

We are excited to try out a new place having heard good reviews and planned our Valentine's Day. We Arrived at 6:45 with a 7:15 reservation. Fully understanding it was Valentine's Day we wanted to make sure we got there with adequate time let them know we had arrived and had a drink at the bar proceeded to cash out and wait for a table. We were seated at approximately 720 which was not a big deal and then everything went downhill from there. Due to confusion our table was not spoken to for over 25 minutes. At which time I spoke to the hostess who promptly got me a server to let me know that no one knew whose section we were. We waited for quite some time to receive our water or wine appetizer came out fine and then we ordered our dinner which ended up coming to the table cold and the state was slightly under cooked although that was not a big deal. I ordered the chef's choice which was a 6 oz filet with a lobster Oscar style and my girlfriend ordered the chalet and sea bass and although the sea bass was delicious to her everything else on her plate was cold so we sent everything back. The manager Dave I believe was his name addressed the issue and let us know that everything would be fixed we were then given fresh new portions After about 25 minutes which is understandable since they did remake everything. At that time everything came out warm and my steak was cooked properly however her fish tasted more like Cod then sea bass. We did ask just to make sure they didn't make a mistake in the swore it was sea bass but it's really tasted like a McDonald's fish filet sandwich and unfortunately she was unable to eat it we of course paid our bill in full tipped accordingly our waitress was kind and busy. We will not be back. Overall it was an upscale red lobster. sadly disappointed.

Anne Burmeister

Went for our Anniversary. Service was great. I had the Salmon and it was delicious! Nice place for special occasions.

Kashif Mufti

Nice restaurant in Clay Terrace. Plenty of seating available both indoors and outdoors and they have bar seating as well. Tried their grilled Atlantic cod, which was cooked perfectly and was very flavorful. My wife tried the crab cake which was also good. A bit pricey but definitely worth it if you are in the mood for some fine dining.

David Oliphant

Excellent food and excellent service. The Lobster Bisque was the best I've ever tasted.

Gary Eberhart

We have never been disappointed at Mitchell's. It is one of our special places.

Jim Burgraff

The food and ambiance were good, the service was terrible. They let one of our members know that they were out of the ahi tuna he ordered when they were delivering the rest of our meals. The place was very empty, the waiter made us feel like we were imposing on his personal time. I cannot recommend this place and suggest you look elsewhere.

David Schmitt

wanted to be impressed with this place but just didn't happen. the food was ok. the lobster was good, the scallops were good, the fries tasted like they were reheated from lunch. the drinks were the best part of dinner but we waited over 15 mins to get them after they were ordered. service was polite but lacking. it'd be different if they were busy or we hadn't made reservations but that wasn't the case. maybe we just caught them on a bad night but I won't spend that kind of money again to find out.

Natalie Misiaszek

Only posting 2 stars because the waitress was the only good part of our experience back. Waited 45min+ for our table when we had reservations, food came out an hour after orders were put in 20 min after being seated. The filets were a joke and then dinners finally came out with a dinner missing saying they ran out of steak. No one came to approach the table to say they ran out an if anyone would like to choose something else. The manager and waitress were very nice and the manager comped the bill, but even so, this is so crazy to happen on a day like Mother’s Day. Whoever is in charge of ordering and cooking, needs fired or seriously re-evaluated. The quality of the food is terrible and this location has went so down hill it’s not even funny. Hate to leave this bad of a review, but it’s necessary that corporate reads. Get it together

Julia Strobos

Always liked this place. Always come here when I am in town.

Nathan Berner

Very good food. Nice size portion for the typical meal for this area. I picked up and food was just getting at the time asked. Hostess was really friendly and went through order before bagging it up to make sure everything was correct.

Linda Bruchert

Food and our waitress, Ashley, were both good. The only negative was there was a garnishment of chopped tomatoes on the cod and lobster that wasn't listed in the dish description on the menu nor on the picture on the website. I am very allergic to tomatoes and that was a disappointment to need to pick it off. Once this was done the dish was very tasty.

Kevin Stannis

Great seafood and now have added more non seafood choices.

Katrina Scott

My friend and I had a few appetizers and drinks from the happy hour menu. They were all delicious and the service was terrific! The baked oysters and crab cakes were amaaaazing. This might be my new favorite restaurant!

Gabby Leachmon

The service was subpar and the waiter was not attentive enough. I had to keep asking for water and other things at a time where he serving just my table and another. The food was decent and I enjoyed my meal, it would be 5 stars if I had decent service.

Tati K.

Excellent food and service!!

Lotus Hadden

The waiters are extremely hard working and the food is the BOMB!! I took my mom and dad there yesterday for lunch and my dad really loves there food.

hirsch golde

Lobster and shrimp stuffed Cod was okay at best but the cherry cheesecake was the best...

Ashley James

They made my birthday celebration a delight!

Jonah Bobsin

Excellent food, even better service. I arrived early for what was a family dinner with parents and grandparents, and needless to say that can be stressful. I asked my waiter if he would get me a glass of wine before my family arrived, and there was no hesitation or delay. He rushed me my wine and my check to rid of the evidence. I drank my wine and paid the gentleman and it was as if nothing ever happened. I will be returning!

John Johnson

The meal was great and so was service. Tracy our waitress was great!

Amanda Bundy

Very bad food

Tracy Snyder

Excellent service and fresh food!

Erin Hardwick

We ordered several appetizers- the ahi tuna, mussels and calamari. They were all okay. There were six of us and we all enjoyed our meal. The fish was perfect and the Shanghai sauce is spectacular. The asparagus and Brussels side dishes were okay. We went for my Dads 80th Birthday and they gave us the Happy Birthday menus- Happy Birthday was printed at the top. The shark fin pie was very tasty! The Service— our server was friendly and started out strong but most of the night was spent with empty drinks or waiting on food. We arrived at 6:30 and did not eat our main course until after 8:30pm... we had dessert and left close to 9:30. The gave us a dessert for free due to the excessive wait... but it was a long meal. I will give it a go one more time for the main dishes but if the service is poor again I will not go back.

Michelle Jilg

I’ve only been here once so I’m sure it was just a bad experience but it was sad because I came here to try it on my birthday. Our server may have been new and he did seem a bit overwhelmed. Our drinks were never refilled (even after asking) and our food came out cold.... I may go back to try again but not any time soon.

JOHN JOHNSON

Stopped in for lunch. Staff was great. The host was friendly. Had the stuffed cod. It was great. Wanted the beets but they were out. That's why they only get 4 stars.

Ashlea Sayre

Great atmosphere and good location. The service was sub par for a Saturday evening. We got there between 5:30 and 5:45 not busy at all. There were only two of us and we sat for over half our meal with empty drinks. The food was not the quality I would expect and lacked any real flavor. I probably won't be back.

Jeff Detrick

I had the lobster stuffed cod and the lobster Mac and Cheese and it was seriously good. The bartender knows a good Moscow Mule. Final bill with tip for my date and I was close to $140 with drinks so bring the heavy plastic my man to impress the lady.

KidMars .

This place was wonderful. The food, the environment, ect. But my favorite part was our outstanding & beautiful hostess named Karla. She was an absolute pleasure! Will most certainly be back (:

T Richards

I'd have to say for my first time going I am very underwhelmed at the taste of the dishes and the price that you pay for the small portions that you get. Our waiter was very nonchalant and offered no suggestions at all for drinks or food. The restaurant itself was very nice and clean. I got the very very small crab stuffed flounder, heavily covered in old Bay seasonings.. needless to say I will not be going here again.if you're going to be overcharged for seafood you might as well go to Ocean Prime or The Oceanaire..

Jody Hill

Lol I can't review this place. I worked here and it wouldn't be good

Commissisiong Ward

My daughter was served a raw hamburger. She’s only 6. When I told my server he took the meal off stating that he was sorry the didn’t get the order right the 2nd time. I asked for a manager because I felt that he should have came to see the raw meat. He came only to give me his business card if my child gets sick. I can promise I will be calling a lawyer not him if she gets sick! I felt it would have been only right to take care of our entire meal. The fries were soggy and cold. The fish was soggy on the bottom like it has been sitting in grease.to top it off the noodles that came with the Parmesan crusted chicken were so dried out it was pathetic. I have never been so disappointed before. We didn’t even eat the food or send it back after the hamburger issues. We paid for our ticket and left a $10 tip for our server! It wasn’t his. I wish we would have stuck with Drake’s where we know the food is always right!

Eddie Bullock

I've added a couple of negative reviews in the past, but I'm pleased to say that my latest visit was fantastic. On a busy Saturday night, the service in the bar area was great with a friendly staff. The seasonal Shrimp + Crab Linguine dish was wonderful. I'll definitely be back soon!

Athena Brown

My daughter took me here tonight for my birthday I had never been here before we had the Ahi tuna for appetizers and we had the blackened scallops with the rice green beans and etouffee for dinner I also had a Cuervo margarita with all the food was wonderful service was great we were extremely happy prices are good for what you get the quality of the food is excellent we will be back

Lesley Bolds

I've cooked better food at home

Marj Kozlowski

The Shanghai Sampler is awesome. I had a house salad with it, and I was very full when I left.

Stacy K

This is a great seafood restaurant. The prices were mid range. I had a gift card, so we splurged. We both had Lobster bisque which was very tasty. The hubby had cod Oscar and I had shrimp and scallops. The service was outstanding. Dessert was just okay, and over priced. Overall it was a great dining experience.

Griff Potter

Quality seafood. Attentive staff. I eat keto and they adjusted dishes to meet my needs.

Theresa Wiese

Excellent food, delicious lobster bisque, the best salmon, tasty sharkfin pie, but slow poor service. Too bad.

Andrew Miller

Dreadful experience, would NEVER come back and will actively dissuade people from going!!! Food was "ok." Came here for a business dinner, made online reservations for 5pm (well before the really busy time). On arrival, restaurant was mostly empty and we were quickly seated at a nice riverside table. That was the last enjoyable moment in this dinner. Server took around 5 minutes to come over and offer drinks (didn't bring water at that time), water showed up with floating debris in all glasses (requested and received replacements that appeared clean but staff miscommunication and they brought new water twice). LONG delays in getting starters, entrees, and dessert going. No explanation of food when it arrived (just dumped on the table). Server forgot to come back multiple times with promised items (menus, drinks, etc). Server was unable to provide helpful navigation/suggestions of the wine list AT ALL, except that she personally likes Pinot in general (and this is the server with a wine list with multiple bottles over $100... yet can't tell us about any of them). Food was "ok," certainly not spectacular. Oh... and the check showed up without a pen (seemed in line with the evening). This was the only 3 star rated restaurant in the area. I give service a -1 start, food a solid 1.5 star. This restaurant should better be properly rated 2 stars on Google (barely). Suggest NEVER bringing business clients here unless you want them to leave with a wholly disappointing experience. Very bad. Equivalent to a run-down chain restaurant 20 years past its prime.

Avery Cyr

Over price for what you get

Karen Bosnak

Perfect food...nice atmosphere

Bryan McDowell

It's been 3 years since we have been here. Last 2 times weren't great either. It took 30 minutes to get shrimp cocktail and a dozen oysters, no joke and it was 3pm. Shrimp cocktail was decent at best. My wife ordered cedar plank salmon and almost laughed at the portion size. I had seared tuna that was most likely old...no flavor and soggy. Didn't look remotely fresh. My dad's scallops were rubbery.

Jack Quinlan

Went there for Christmas Dinner 2017, reservations at 5:15, still no meal by 6:15, no water refills, wine pours of 3 oz. maybe, sent back to be corrected which they agreed. All tables around us were also complaining, our server Abbey was MIA the whole night!! They ran out of a lot of the menu items too. Once food was finally delivered, one Seabass meal was Cold, total joke for the prices. Was nice that they were open Christmas but everyone had a bad time and we should have just stayed home. No enough staff to take care of patrons. So disappointed.... Glad Christmas in general was awesome!!

Igor Sadovyi

Dreadfully inaccurate and inattentive service - made a mistake on every meal and drinks, not to mention the bill. Food was fine. Drinks were overly sweet/syrupy.

Doug Highfill

Food was amazing! Staff was excellent, everyone seemed happy to be there!

Rhonda Manna

Good service but the food has really went down hill in the past 3 years. The shrimp and salmon were over cooked and the Shanghai sauce was overly salty. The creme brulee was awesome as was their signature house salad. My family has visited the restaurant several times so it may have been an off day in the kitchen. Generally this place has food that is amazing.

Larry Walker

Our new favorite seafood restaurant!!! Jambalaya was amazing, calamari best ever. Excellent service and atmosphere!!!

Leigh Steger Postel

Over the years the quality of the food has gone downhill. I haven't been there for about a year and my opinion is the same.

Brian Heyz

Had a GREAT ANNIVERSARY meal with my SWEETHEART!! The waitress, Bryn, was a excellent host!!

Andre Hazlip

3 stars only because I didn't know the prices were so high And the food was OK I have to try to again to see whats good

Zach Kyukca

I would have been disappointed if I paid 12 dollars as opposed to 28. Over cooked, bland, and tiny portions. Service was mediocre. I’ve had shrimp from fast food chains that were better.

Juanita Maggio

Great food value and service

Amanda Ray

Really dark inside, which we didnt care for. And it is pretty pricey. Server was friendly. I had the ginger crusted salmon which was great. My husband had the shrimp & chips. He said the shrimp was pretty good, the rest was just alright. We definitely want to come back and try some more items on the menu.

Clairissa Digiovanni

As I'm sitting here eating I cannot think of a better place that I have visited in Carmel Indiana. The broth and their muscles was light but rich and I'm not even the muscle fan but I ate an entire bucket full. And now I'm watching this beautiful lobster and crab stuff fish come out to me and I cannot wait to dig in.

Mo Hamer

Great place to eat that while the cost of a meal is on the high side, it is worth every penny!

Joseph Cusick

Excellent service....meal was great.

R. S.

We don't get to Pittsburgh very often but when we do, we always have dinner at Mitchell's. Their menu varies every day and it's fresh! It provides us with plenty of tasty options. Service has always been very good and the prices are reasonable and in line with what you would expect when getting well-prepared, fresh seafood.

Niko

I gave it three stars because the food presentation was excellent but the attitude and behavior of the staff was unprofessional. Our server let us know early on that she was supposed to be cut already and was being triple sat. Our ticket time was almost fifteen minutes and we ordered salads and a Sushi bowl. There was laughing, yelling and at one point literally shrieking coming out of the kitchen. The manager was walking around visibly angry because a server hadn't shown up. Where is your passion for food!The staff needs a lesson in professionalism.

Guy Sahatjian

Great seafood

Asit Patel

Delicious seafood. We appreciated the light but crunchy batter on the shrimp.

Janet Brighty

My husband and I came for dinner to celebrate our 50th wedding anniversary. Everything was wonderful. Food was delicious; server, Sue, was spectacular. She was helpful with the menu and very attentive. It was a leisurely, romantic time. Thanks, Mitchell's.

lowell mays

Delicious meal excellent service, small portions!

Shayla Zarate

This was my first time eating here . The food was plated very beautifully and tasted very good.

David Ferens

Mitchell's has great food, today I just went there to purchase 2lb piece of tuna to take home and grill since the butcher was out. I always forget they are a fish market as well. Quality was fantastic!

Todd Levenson

Food was bland and was expensive. Patrick the server was excellent, friendly and provided great service.

Charles Keithley

Food is so so, service was slow but friendly, and location is kind of a pain depending on the time of day

Todd Reyburn

Savor, fresh, sustainable, fish and seafood meals served with expert care inside, outside, or seated around their well supplied bar.

Amy Smith

Great lunch and happy hour. Always consistent food quality and great service.

Marlina Malone

Food is exceptional, staff was friendly and provided great service.

Heather Dougherty

Food was good (love the shark fin pie) but seems really expensive for what it is.

Dan Evans

Gregg Wood's third favorite place to eat.

denise gunn

The portions really small for the price. Food ok not great.

Michel Bullard

The food was disappointing but we had a very nice server.

KELLY HENDRIX

The steak was amazing and I love their sourdough bread. The carrot cake was ridiculously large, but good enough to still want to eat it all in one sitting. I almost made it, but have enough for lunch tomorrow.

Taylor Stuart

We just moved back to the area from living in Savannah, GA and looking for good seafood. This place was absolutely delicious. Our server, Kristen, was wonderful as well. Will definitely be returning!

Diane Haag, Esq.

They have completely changed their menu. Only a couple seafood pasta dishes, and no catch of the day. They have about 1/2 their menu as chicken and beef. The food was fairly bland, and you get a tiny portion of food.

Gary

Great place, food was outstanding, staff where vary professional, I was visiting my family in Pittsburgh, staying at the waterfront, I found this place on line,,my in laws thank me for finding a great family place like this,,I told them thanks, I know classic, whenever I see it...

S. Alan McVicker

I took my wife, son, and daughter in law here last night after many years in between visits. The environment is classy yet dimly lit. I had reservations for 715 and still needed to wait 15 min for the staff to clean a booth even though there were clearly others table options open and available. The menu is somewhat limited but offers good variety. Drink prices are quite steep. Appetizers were good. There was a significant lull in time between them and main course. When it did arrive I found the food to be quite plain. Where I was expecting, based upon the sheer price of the food, to be blown away, my party instead found our entrees to be nothing out of the ordinary. The very best item I had experienced was the jambalaya. Which was a side dish. On a good note. Our server was very friendly and attentive to our table. With all the options available in my area to eat, unless something significantly changes in the near future, I personally do not feel I will be returning back here to eat. The sheer cost of the night coupled with the ordinary taste of the food just does not warrant it.

Nathan Stoner

Good fresh seafood. Decent service. A little pricey though

Rick Krekel

Tasty food and great service.

Matt Krueger

The crab legs are very good. I just wish i was on the beach eating them. I guess not really their fault.

charlie reitz

Great service from Linda!

mark schroeder

Exquisite meal..interfering waitress..deleted from our future

Anthony Cholewinski

Surprised it was so quiet on a Friday night. Good service, very good food, excellent key lime pie

Kimberly Bobrow

Food was awesome! Defiantly will be going back . First time there, won't be last.

Samantha Danone

Our first choice when we crave seafood. Good selection with reasonable prices.

Maureen Scordato

Loved it. We will be back. We were looking for a reputable seafood restaurant for oysters. They prepared them perfectly and were delicious. The food was very well prepared and beautifully served. Nice decor. Dress was everything from dressy to casual. The staff was friendly and not overbearing. It is a fish market so be prepared for a little fishy smell in the air. We knew we were at the right place when the oysters were served fresh and yet had the right amount of palatable texture to them. The prices are very reasonable. If you are looking for great seafood then you will be glad you came.

Gina Gatti

Service was good. Food was average. Bathrooms were filthy.

Randi Grigson

Not a great experience. I'm really surprised that this place has such great reviews. The food is nothing to write home about and the management didn't offer any resolution when told about it. He made it seem like it was my fault for not asking them to cook it longer (yeah because cooking FISH longer makes it better...smh). I love seafood, but I will never return.

Lawrence Buckley

Great place for a business dinner. Staff were accommodating and responsive, even to our crew that got in late and had luggage to store. Food was delicious and (most importantly) fish and seafood was fresh. Would recommend to anyone looking for good seafood. Didn't personally try the steak but those that did endorsed it.

Lizette Correa

Over priced, so not impressed by the food or the service for what I paid. My food was cold my drink was salty.

brittany tinney

Always fresh and fish is some of the best cooked to perfection! Love their catch of the day menu. Offers gluten free menu :) The seared Ahi Tuna appetizer is amazing.

Walter Kirslis

Excellent staff and great food

Andy B

Surf n Turf with Lobster Tail. OMG.

Bethany Michelle Keckler

The last time we were at Mitchell's, it reminded us of when Fulton's decided to continue charging prices as if you're at an exceptional restaurant while serving food you could get at Red Lobster. But...we decided to use our $25 rewards and give Mitchell's another try last night. The bottom line is...if you order a fresh cut of fish prepared however you'd like and some veggies or sides and a Caesar salad, you're likely to pay too much but at least it's for a meal that tastes delicious...HOWEVER... anytime a restaurant of this caliber - or of the caliber Mitchell's used to be - decides it's okay to continue charging Mitchell's (Landry's) prices for entrees like crab cakes or crab stuffed anything and they use way too much filler or anytime a restaurant like this continues charging you lobster bisque prices for lobsterLESS bisque, it's time to cut your losses, remember the good ol' days when going to Mitchell's was something special with an absolute guarantee you're going to have a seafood meal in Louisville, KY that rivals the seafood meals you get at any fine dining establishment in your favorite coastal town, and just move on. We're not going to waste our money there anymore. We prepare more exquisite seafood entrees for ourselves at home and I grew up on the Chesapeake Bay so we'll just get our special seafood meals when we're visiting my family where the seafood restaurants know you can't put a noticable amount of filler in your crab and expect to stay in business. Fulton's went this route and we all know what happened to them... Mitchell's is going down the same path but they may survive longer because they're in Louisville, KY where not everyone knows good, quality seafood but if/when Mitchell's does close, it'll be a shame and it'll be due to greed. You all are making enough money to serve proper crab cakes and proper crab stuffing and still make money!

Lisa Weigand

We always enjoy the food and service here. The patio is beautiful to sit on in the summer.

Shannon Moore

Always a great atmosphere & excellent food!

Dave Meeker

I walked away quite disappointed. The reason that I did not give one star was due to the potential this type of place could have. Anyhow, when I walked in, the hostess was just sitting down at a bench close to the hostess stand. She sat me at a booth, as requested. I went to look at the fresh fish case and all of the fish looked very dry and older. I was hoping that was just for display and not where they grabbed their servings from. I ordered a half dozen oysters and the pan-seared Chilean Sea Bass. The oysters were good, no complaints there. While I waited for my entree, I watched as another server came out of the back bringing two salads to another table while she was chewing on some food. That's the opposite of classy. When my entree arrived, the mashed potatoes were luke warm at best and my Sea Bass was overcooked, but only seared on one side. Not once did any employee ask how my food was. Overall, the place is definitely not worth the asking price and fail to deliver on what they represent. I will not visit again.

Kristina E

Great service polite staff prompt and great food

james noble

Hour and a half wait for a table for 2 really

Happy Couple

Enjoyable dinner. Great service!

Erika Smith

Mitchell's never disappoints. Delicious food, impeccable service, and a clean bathroom.

Hayley Parsons

Best garlic bread ever

Benjamin Geraci

Such a great atmosphere

bryan lanier

food is always good and so is service came on new year's eve for happy hour wasn't informed that there was no happy hour on a non holiday not in person or on the internet so sadly disappointed in the misdirection made by Mitchell's sea food will be along time before we will return there are a lot of other sea food restaurants in the area that honor there menu on the internet or in person like the bone fish grill for example

Adonya Anderson

Sever and food was amazing! Mitchell's always delivers, never a disappointment.

bren norris

I am on the keto diet and chef personally made me a fantastic lunch. Loved the salmon grilled in butter and herbs.

Namaste Williams

The food and service is top rated

Lindsey Hickerson

Great food and decent service

Marlene Curran

Calm atmosphere. Raw oysters amazing fresh. Try the trout.

Cody Bratton

New port location offers better service. Best oysters I have had in a while at this location thou.

Linda Kohl

Friendly service and very accommodating to our elderly mother. Food was delicious.

S. Spence

Always amazing food and great service.

E C

Used to love this place. No idea what happened. Our most recent visit was not great. Almost an hour wait for food. Our server didn’t even apologize and checked up on us only once. He told us the kitchen was backed up and rolled his eyes. I got the tuna- dry, over cooked and not even close to being worth the $31 price tag. This place has gone downhill. I would recommend to skip if you’re thinking of a visit.

Venitra DeGraffenreid

A Lovely Place to Lunch!

Bruce Jacobs

The server was very good, the food very good (yet expensive), and the atmosphere was very nice. Upon being seated by the hostess I expressed concern that it was cold in the windowed area. She stated "she does not like to be warm when eating," I said I like to be comfortable when eating. A male, not our server, came around after we were finished eating and asked "how was everything " I said it was too cold in the area. He then stated " Oh, the heat just came on." Keep in mind we were finished eating. DO NOT SIT IN THE WINDOW AREA if you don't like being cold during your meal. I am irritated that the hostess and the man totally disregarded my concerns.

Thomas Pride

I had a discrepancy with the waitress but the food was excellent.

Lindsey Taylor

Delicious food, and good service!

Q 1

Great food great ppl made my day!

Robert Jameson

Food is always outstanding. A bit pricey.

chris robb

Good food! Its a little on the loud side.

Elyse Eckoff

Excellent service. The spinach and goat cheese salad is basically my favorite salad, ever. Also, hot and buttery sour dough bread is delightful.

Alexandra Chambers

Michelle‘s fish market by far has the best lobster bisque I’ve ever had. They have a good quality selection of fish from farm raised and wild card which I thought was great the waiters here are very attentive and accommodating would definitely recommend to anyone

William McVay

Every thing was good, food was excellent but could have been hot instead of warm.

Andrea Kovar

Wonderful service and food. Waiter especially patient with kids !

Rob D

Always quality food and service

Kerry Caperell

Used to be a pretty good place. Quality going downhill. Today, a literal shard of glass in my mashed potatoes! I will never be back!

Vincent Nesci

Large seafood selection. Good. Waitstaff good. Bit pricey but not so much.

Lisa Velasquez

Excellent service first & foremost! The atmosphere was great & the food was exceptional!!! The dessert was just the best topping for a lovely night!!! Will definitely be back for more visits!!!

William Pinkett

Took my wife herr for her birthday and the restaurant doesnt do anything to celebrate like candles or a free dessert. That was disappointing, but the calamari, caesar salad, and lemonade were exceptional. The lemonade is not free refill and the waiter was slow and not a great listener. Was expecting similar similar service that I received at McCormacks last week, but i suppose mitchells is more for the casual diner.

Cheryl Sutton

This place is awesome . Best Seafood in the area bar none . will be going back for sure

Chris K

Great food and amazing service. good happy hour too

Mark Pavinich

Crab legs were inedible, food quality very poor. Wont be going back. Service was good and waitress did take the crab legs off the bill.

J. Patrick Spalding

It's ok. Conceptually, it always sound amazing, but have never had anything worth the cost

Tim Spurlock

Food, service, and atmosphere was amazing. We had a problem with a gift card but the general manager was able to help us and did an amazing job to ensure we were able to use it. The staff seems very passionate in their work!

George Seurkamp

Good food. Good value. Good service.

Markus Klein

What great and fresh food! In an informal yet entertaining atmosphere!

Steve Anderson

Excellent seafood. Sides and salads are very good as well.

JonMichael Sinanis

This place is absolutely fantastic. First, the service was great and very friendly. The soft shell crab appetizer I had was very tasty and succulent. The clam chowder and lobster bisque were solid as well. The tuna poke bowl I ordered tasted very fresh and the tuna was great. I would also like to note the crab cakes and lobster mac and cheese were phenomenal. I highly recommend this restaurant!

Dave Vincent

Great Christmas Eve dinner. Thank you.

Rebecca Reilly

Not as good as the waterfront location

Chris Barkoozis

My first time here. I ordered the tuna, ot was ok/good. A little pricey for the quality. Great service, friendly waitstaff.

Angelo Colon

We are excited to try out a new place having heard good reviews and planned our Valentine's Day. We Arrived at 6:45 with a 7:15 reservation. Fully understanding it was Valentine's Day we wanted to make sure we got there with adequate time let them know we had arrived and had a drink at the bar proceeded to cash out and wait for a table. We were seated at approximately 720 which was not a big deal and then everything went downhill from there. Due to confusion our table was not spoken to for over 25 minutes. At which time I spoke to the hostess who promptly got me a server to let me know that no one knew whose section we were. We waited for quite some time to receive our water or wine appetizer came out fine and then we ordered our dinner which ended up coming to the table cold and the state was slightly under cooked although that was not a big deal. I ordered the chef's choice which was a 6 oz filet with a lobster Oscar style and my girlfriend ordered the chalet and sea bass and although the sea bass was delicious to her everything else on her plate was cold so we sent everything back. The manager Dave I believe was his name addressed the issue and let us know that everything would be fixed we were then given fresh new portions After about 25 minutes which is understandable since they did remake everything. At that time everything came out warm and my steak was cooked properly however her fish tasted more like Cod then sea bass. We did ask just to make sure they didn't make a mistake in the swore it was sea bass but it's really tasted like a McDonald's fish filet sandwich and unfortunately she was unable to eat it we of course paid our bill in full tipped accordingly our waitress was kind and busy. We will not be back. Overall it was an upscale red lobster. sadly disappointed.

john pitrone

Great happy hour and food. Equally great service from Nicky.

Fili Goddess

Mikhail was our server and while service was slow, (long waits between drinks, app, entreés, corrections, dessert and bill) he took very good care of us. We were really able to enjoy the 2 hours and 15 minutes, al fresco, celebrating my birthday. It was a lovely, breezy evening.

DexAmp Gaming

Best food and service in town!

Nicholas Boshears

Good food, great staff. On the expensive side compared to other restaurants.

Chuck Norris

Best fish I've ever fookin tasted m8

Jared Nerenberg

We used to love Mitchell's, but the entire table agreed it does not taste as fresh as it used to. It wasn't bad, just not great.

Angela Thompson

Good food, great wine selection and great food.

Brad Nowlin

I would not recommend this place. I used to be a fan. The quality of the food is definitely on the decline over the last couple of years. Me and my wife recently ate here a she got severe food poisoning afterwards. We suspect under cooked scallops. The other food was all over cooked and definitely not worth the money.

Judi Henderson

Great bar, great seafood, great people!

Emily Korte

Ordered shrimp and scallops and only received scallops. I am not a big fan of seafood, however, I love shrimp. So I was rather disappointed. When we asked our waiter, he said it was only sea scallops. My family was certain the menu read “shrimp and sea scallops” and I even looked the menu up online and that is what I saw. So in essence, the waiter lied for absolutely no reason.

David Schmitt

wanted to be impressed with this place but just didn't happen. the food was ok. the lobster was good, the scallops were good, the fries tasted like they were reheated from lunch. the drinks were the best part of dinner but we waited over 15 mins to get them after they were ordered. service was polite but lacking. it'd be different if they were busy or we hadn't made reservations but that wasn't the case. maybe we just caught them on a bad night but I won't spend that kind of money again to find out.

Tanya Rhody

Always great. I get the Chilean Sea Bass with the ginger encrusted preparation. It nearly melts in your mouth. It is crazy good. I have never been anything but happy with anything I have ordered.

Lotus Hadden

The waiters are extremely hard working and the food is the BOMB!! I took my mom and dad there yesterday for lunch and my dad really loves there food.

Lizzy Flush

Decent place

hirsch golde

Lobster and shrimp stuffed Cod was okay at best but the cherry cheesecake was the best...

Jonah Bobsin

Excellent food, even better service. I arrived early for what was a family dinner with parents and grandparents, and needless to say that can be stressful. I asked my waiter if he would get me a glass of wine before my family arrived, and there was no hesitation or delay. He rushed me my wine and my check to rid of the evidence. I drank my wine and paid the gentleman and it was as if nothing ever happened. I will be returning!

Ag Rump

Fresh fish specials very well prepared Drinks were a good poor send wine pairing was doing on, service very right pace . Fits all your needs groups, family, and romantic

Jim Jasko

The gumbo and pecan crusted trout were superb!

boa Levandowski

Rated this place before

Mary Mcginnis

Great food, wonderful service! Really clean restaurant.

JOHN JOHNSON

Stopped in for lunch. Staff was great. The host was friendly. Had the stuffed cod. It was great. Wanted the beets but they were out. That's why they only get 4 stars.

Conessa Kirkendall

Unfortunately this place has gone downhill in the past year or so. Use to be one of my favorite places. Food quality last two times we've been have been sub par.

ward schiller

Minds me o the good ol days in Bristol. The cod tasted nice and fishy like Slacky's Fish on the Estate. When I'm home alone I like to cover myself in Vaseline and pretend I'm a slug.

Jody Hill

Lol I can't review this place. I worked here and it wouldn't be good

Commissisiong Ward

My daughter was served a raw hamburger. She’s only 6. When I told my server he took the meal off stating that he was sorry the didn’t get the order right the 2nd time. I asked for a manager because I felt that he should have came to see the raw meat. He came only to give me his business card if my child gets sick. I can promise I will be calling a lawyer not him if she gets sick! I felt it would have been only right to take care of our entire meal. The fries were soggy and cold. The fish was soggy on the bottom like it has been sitting in grease.to top it off the noodles that came with the Parmesan crusted chicken were so dried out it was pathetic. I have never been so disappointed before. We didn’t even eat the food or send it back after the hamburger issues. We paid for our ticket and left a $10 tip for our server! It wasn’t his. I wish we would have stuck with Drake’s where we know the food is always right!

Terry Patrick

Good food and service

Gretchen S

They have a nice happy hour. The people that work at the bar are very nice and friendly.

Iftekhar Ahmed

Good quality seafood!

Sue Hart

The lobster Cobb salad was fantastic. Such a great twist.

Peter Makres

Superb restaurant...great food, great staff and great atmosphere. Highly recommended.

Melinda Stepanek

Had drinks. Nice bar tenders

David Griffis

Not happy with my experience at Mitchell’s. Went there for seafood week and service was very slow and inconsistent. Had to ask for everything that I wanted and also asked for it again. Asked that my entrée be hot but saw it waiting on the service area. It ultimately it came to me luke warm and I sent my entrée back . Not a very happy camper

Brenda Ott

nice atmosphere and great food

Avery Cyr

Over price for what you get

Danaka Abron

Great food and friendly

gerald wheat

The food was good A little overpriced but the food was good

J Christian Toronto

We celebrated a special family occasion this afternoon. Gretchen's service was exceptional, the food excellent and the key lime pie prepared in house the best we have ever had.

Niema Lewis

Service and food are good!

Jonathan Fisk

Excellent salmon and Caesar salad

Elizabeth Sabo Johnson

Great food and Staff

Joyce Shackelford

Food and service was great.

Cheyenne Coughran

Overall exceptional experience. The service was excellent - attentive and friendly. The attention to detail, like warm bread, soft butter, and plating was great. Extra touch on my iced peach tea was that it was shaken, not just a big glop of syrup at the bottom of the glass and the addition of sprigs of mint was classy and thoughtful (nice touch Ben!). The red potatoes in the clam chowder were buttery soft and there were plenty of clams. The Tabasco remoulade carried a lot of kick, but paired well with the crab cake appetizer. And while the corn relish was tasty, maybe a nice mixed greens with a simple dressing would've lightened the dish a little. Dessert was a hard pick between the key lime and the creme brulee (which won). The vanilla creme really stood out and the brulee topping held a nice crunch. Would highly recommend and definitely will return for more.

Larry Walker

Our new favorite seafood restaurant!!! Jambalaya was amazing, calamari best ever. Excellent service and atmosphere!!!

Todd Mittler

Awesome

Leigh Steger Postel

Over the years the quality of the food has gone downhill. I haven't been there for about a year and my opinion is the same.

Uncle Scroge

Excellent, as was expected. The salmon was really good and the filet mignon was cooked perfectly and so juicy!

Kevin Carter

This is the best place to get fresh seafood. There is nothing bad on the entire menu. Staff is great and our meal was amazing as always.

Zach Kyukca

I would have been disappointed if I paid 12 dollars as opposed to 28. Over cooked, bland, and tiny portions. Service was mediocre. I’ve had shrimp from fast food chains that were better.