Reviews of Knepp's Restaurant & Gift Shop (Fish Shop)

Janet Pankonien

Good food

Dan Sosh

Great food love the crab legs

Kara Cooper

Great crableggs

Richard Hall

Great food, catfish is awesome, bread pudding off the charts

Joni Mestas

Delicious food served here at this Amish restaurant. The staff are friendly. The buffet was small, yet well stocked. The food was delicious and well prepared. I highly recommend a dining experience here at Knepp's. You will be delightfully pleased.

Debbie Smith

Too expensive for the choice of food. Buffet was sloppy.

Michael Taylor

Would been better to go to kfc i just paid $19.00 for 2 breast and a drink! Ribs no good at all, no fish on buffet advertise baked fish really didn't matter anyway would of been like the ribs! No rolls had bread but there was fruit flys all over bread! Waitress was nice . Should of just stayed home and cooked a steak very disappointing.

Ronald Allbright

Great food at reasonable prices. Crablegs on Friday night for a few more dollars. Service was also great as was the pie.

Lana Mays

My Pennsylvania Dutch husband loved this place! He said the stuffing was just like his aunt's. Everything was good, hot and fresh, even though we arrived well after their busy time. We will be back!

Amanda Schmakel

Great service and home cooked food

Connie Shofner

clean with good food

Vickie Ritchey

Food is wonderful and just a very pleasant place to eat at plus they have a little gift shop

marty holman

Always a good choice. Especially on weekends.

Bret Graber

Great food...Great people

Andrew Roberts

It’s a buffet style Amish home cooked food. Everything was absolutely delicious. The homemade bread and butter were tasty. I had a piece of the chocolate pie and I’m pretty sure it was the best chocolate pie I’ve ever had. There’s a little general store where you can buy some unique gifts. If I’m back in the area I’ll be back.

Kevin Hill

Good food

T Mar

I saw an ad for the crab legs on Friday nights,went in and fell in love! Excellent crab legs,cooked perfectly. Delicious Mac n cheese,fried chicken and fried fish and shrimp. I was very impressed by everything I tried. The pie! So fresh and so delicious. Our waitress was excellent,nice,attentive and talkative. We loved her and we will most definitely be back! Worth the 35 minute drive,for sure.

Carole Luchtefeld

Always delicious 'homemade' meals

Loretta Boger

Food was great, very friendly employee, clean, well lighted, lots of food to choose from.

Glenn Duthie

Great food. Amish style

Luke Harder

Best fresh food around worked with a group a kids

Rita Henry

Waiter (male) was not attentive to our needs. Never checked on our coffee or ask if there was anything we needed. Very poor service,,

charles baker

Good home cooked food!

Benson Brewer

Was there yesterday at 11:45 a.m. Was looking forward to be there, but was disappointed! Gravy was cool like it had come out of the fridge and just wasn't hot enough yet. The green beans had a lot of onion in them (no problem with that), but the onion was scrunchy. The white fish was good, fried chicken was good. Probably would not return, not worth the drive for us. We have a better Amish Buffet 2 miles from our house.

Levi Murdach

Great place to dine in. Hospitality is always great.

Sherry Williams

Food was very good and service was excellent the place was clean ....we will go back

Mike Picklesimer

Excellent food and service

Brian Nimnicht

Great food.

Heather Kent

Pleasant hometown atmosphere, great food, and very nice staff. I bet your breakfast buffet is as good dinner's!

A V

Took the family for supper. They were very nice and a small but delicious buffet!

Bob Tarter

The food was good although they did not have what was posted on the menu board. But what they did have was very good.

Stephen White

Believe me this is a place where you driving too. Our summer home is about 60 miles away and we always try to find excuses to head that direction. Great cooking very reasonable price and some of the sweetest people on earth. They also sell some nice homemade Goods.

Allan Bradley

We had a good meal. The crableggs were decent. Would be a lot better if they used real butter, or at least had an option.

Steve Overton

I had the seafood buffet on Friday night, with the crab legs. Everything was delicious.

raquel hamm

Too expensive and food wasn't that great! Will never go back

Dorothy Taylor

Food was out of this world good. I finally found a place, that makes better fried chicken than I do, and that's saying a lot. We will definitely be making a trip back to Knepp's in the near future.

Sharity Worman

Extremely friendly. Great food. Small shop as well with cute items.

cynthia gurchiek

Absolutely the most Tasteless food ever! Y’all call this Home Cooking? Amish no less? Well your no more Amish, than I am , this place is an absolute waiste of Money.! Don’t get your hopes up as you wander in, with No one to greet you or even Take your payment( of which , you really won’t want to pay for what you just got as Food) but, ya must! Thank God it was Senior Day 9.99 verses 12.99! Please don’t be Fooled by this Tourist trap! October 2919

Kurtis K Allbright

Friday evenings are crab legs

Brenda Moore

Thought this place would be good but boy was I wrong! Poor selection of food and little of it. Would choose a McDonald's over this place any time.

David Sparks

I ALWAYS love the fried chicken here, and who can turn down dessert when they bring a tray of options!!!

Shayleigh Thomas

Very good food, and service!

Betty Hart

Need more food variety

Joi Martin

Service is great.

Ronald Blanford

Very good food and price

Joyce Vogler

The food was very good & the price was great too, at under $10.

Paul E. Hart II

Good food at a fair price

Pat Faith

Not the biggest place or the fanciest, but the crab legs were cooked perfectly and breaded tomatoes delicious, everything else was pretty good and I will be back.

Gary Kramer

Good food good service.

Carly Dixon

Kinda pricy but great atmosphere!

jonathan frederick

Great food and great staff. Can’t wait to go back

Thelda Woolsey

Great place and very friendly people

B K

Nice selection of home cooked food, great homemade bread and applebutter.

E Green

Took my mom out for her birthday. Really good food, reasonably priced and friendly staff. We'll be back!

Cassi Miller

SO good!! Fried chicken is delicious, desserts so tasty. We will stop by again when we pass through.

Richard Lance

Always great food!

Patty McDowell

Food is excellent, reasonable price, far exceeds quality over Gastoff

Lea Ann Taylor

The food was good but the server was not attentive to her customers

Mary Thompson Lappin

We eat here every time we come to Montgomery,the food here is delicious and the waitress's are amazing.we love knepps.

alan allbright

Good home food

Ryan Rheam

Disgusting

w b

Ok. Not great but not bad either.

Rhonda Myles

My husband and I will definitely eat here again. Nice atmosphere, food was excellent and service was excellent! Definitely worth our 30 minute drive to eat at Knepps family restaurant!

ANGELA WILDERMAN

Food was good. Friday night crab legs, yummy! Water not so good.

Elizabeth Graham

Very tasty country buffet type of restaurant. Salad selections are fresh and plentiful. Entrees are fresh basic country/Amish offerings. Deserts are pies, cobblers and ice cream. Service is good and seating is plentiful for around $12 per person.

Tina Hahn

Good food and service. Kind of $$$

Audrey Rowe

Food was delicious and priced right. Pie could use more flavor.

Denny Pitts

The food was very good ! The service was just EX !

Jerry Ervin

I have always loved this place and it never fails to be the bestest ever! Thank you and keep up the great work

Tony Brumett

Crab legs kept coming. Great food.

Ace

Real Amish Cooking

Donald Bridges

Crab legs were over cooked and hard to get out of the shells, the shrimp had a strong fishy taste to it, the chicken was over cooked and dry, the service left a lot to be desired and it was really over priced for what we expected. Maybe we just went on a bad night but I really don't see us going back in the near future.

LuAnn Kennedy

Extremely friendly, and amazing food!

Royce Keeling Jr.

First time here. Food was very good. Homemade pies were a nice end to a good meal. Will definitely go back.

lone wolf

Great service. Love the chicken

Brady Youngblood

Very good home cooked food

Buck Mc

It was very good. People are always friendly and good food

jack vayhinger

Good buffet.

melissa steele

Food was over cooked. And we had to ask for our drinks after she asked what we wanted. Very heart broken

James Young

Better food than previous experiences.

Derek Burris

Oh my the food wuz the bezt ive had in a long time reztaur....im thinking abt bringing my family and some friendz there soon....price wuz good along with the service....and the dezzert made me wanna go take a afternoon nap....

Scott Heberling

If your hungry, stop here. If your not hungry, stop anyway, the food is truly amazing! Worth driving out of your way for. Brought back memories of Grandma’s Sunday dinners.

Billie Malone

This is the "Amish" restaurant the locals love and don't tell the tourists about lol

Dianna Fisher

The prices r a little high for a salad

Allyson Robling

Good service good food

Janie Shepherd

Awesome!

My Name is

It was really good food. The price was very fair for a buffet. The strawberry pie was delicious. Our server was also very nice. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was chicken was the only meat on the buffet. Some of the other dishes had a little bit of meat in them like stuffed peppers for example. Overall I would definitely go back.

Greg Burton

Good homestyle cooking, friendly service

Raymond Wininger

Not to bad for a local buffet. They have a good variety of things. But there are a few things that could be improved.

Melissa Wagoner

Delicious food and great, friendly service

Dennis Herrmann

Very good food. Excellent service

Sondra Rippy

Great place to eat

mike oniones

Chicken is to die for. Go on friday for homemade fried catfish not to be messed.

Jeff Wilson

We were there on Crab Leg night. Mmm. All you can eat Crab legs, great fried shrimp, tasty catfish fiddler's and fillets. Everything seemed hot and fresh. The bar was clean and well organized. Our waitress was very busy but quite attentive and a special young woman. I am partially disabled and this is a handicap friendly restaurant. Nice people. Highly recommended restaurant.

JR Davis

Best buffet in the area. Breaded tomatoes and Fried Chicken are my favorites. The food has seasoning and doesn't taste bland. Great Job!

Martin Preston

Great meal and friendly

Deborah Warnsholz

I’m in love with their white chicken gravy, but to my dismay they only offer it on Thursday. So today being Saturday I knew they weren’t going to have it so I reluctantly told my husband let’s stop and get a bite. We do LOVE their chicken and salad bar!! We were waited on by a very handsome and personable young man by the name of Ethan. My husband mentioned we loved the white gravy and Ethan looked at me and said “ would you like some?” I starry eyed said” oh absolutely!” Thinking they would just heat up leftover from Thursday as that was only 2 days ago. A few minutes passed and my husband said “ I guess your not getting your white gravy “ I said that’s ok. Then Ethan came over and said “ go up there, I left you a present “ so I ran up to the buffet and there under a spotlight( not really) was a bucket of white chicken gravy. I about died. He asked the chef in the back to make me some and by gosh, no leftover gravy for me , it was made fresh!!! And to no disappointment it was stunningly delicious!! And so was the chicken and salad bar!!! HIGHLY Recommend Knepps!! Pies and breads are delicious too!!! Can’t say enough about Ethan and his AWESOME customer service! We wish him the best with his nursing career and Knepps is now my favorite restaurant in Indiana ❤️

Martha Ellis

Ate breakfast here and it's always hot and fresh. Good customer service.

Linda Miley

Plain food, but good

Vanessa Lemasters

Always so good, very traditional food. I love bread pudding and their's is my favorite

Daniel Beachy

We got there early, were waiting for them to open ,15 min before opening time they came out and invited us in,got started with drinks, coffee and orange juice till buffet was ready,I would reccomend it to anyone.

Nicole Buzan

Very pleased, staff is very friendly and the waitress gave wonderful service!

MaryJane Tarrh

Great food and service!

William Maharry

Great service! They should have crab legs EVERY Friday!!

Stephanie Lewis

Oh my we will be back. Loved the food and the staff and owners

Osmo Petty

REASONABLE , FINE TASTING MEAL !

K

Sorry folks, but the food here is NOT good. 90% of dishes were way too salty and you couldn't eat them....just not good.....would never eat here again

Gwen McClintock

Really good crab legs awesome service

Lee Murphy

Very good simple buffet with salad bar, coblers, vegtables, moist fried chicken, stuffed peppers, bbq and dessert!! Good price at around $12 with a drink! My favorite Amish Restaurant in Washington because I always stop in for lunch!! Hilda was a great waittess! I would go back again!

Dusty Higgins

Great quiet atmosphere laid back staff is rediculously nice food was amazing so only downfall is there isnt much to choose from however this also ist a standard buffett but their homemade peanut butter is a must have if you dont see it on a shelf ask they will get you a fresh batch its like 3 bucks for a tub of it AMAZING!!!!

Bill Pearcy

Good place to get good food

G. Frank May

The food is excellent although a couple of items were too salty. We especially like the fried chicken, creamed peas, and white gravy. I thought the gravy was the best I have had in a restaraunt. Excellent deserts too. Be sure to try the bread pudding. Our server was delightful and we enjoyed ourselves very much. We were there at 2:00 p.m. and the place was mostly deserted. If you don't want the buffet you can order a meat and two sides for something like $5.95. We have eaten at the other Amish restaraunts Black Buggy (closed), Stolls Evansville, Stolls Lakeview, and Gastof and I think this is the best. Visited October 2015

Darrell Weber

Fresh food, good chicken

Nguyen Toan

Great food and service!!

Bobbie Byrer

Always a reliable place to get a great meal

Terry Wade

Great food, fast service.

Kevin Large

If you like all you can eat crab legs on the weekends, by all means go here, otherwise below average buffet fare at above average prices. Probably won't return.

Anthony Russell

Awesome food, great atmosphere and even better Strawberry Pie!