We offer you all the information of real people who purchased the services of Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant (Fish Shop) in Florida area.
To this day this firm has a score of 4.5 stars over 5 and the score has been calculated on 497 reviews.
As you can see it reaches an feddbacks average is almost the highest, and it is founded on a very large number of scores, so we can think that the evaluation is very credible. If people have bothered to give their feddback when they've done well with the service, is that it works.
As you know, we don't usually bother to set evaluations when these are positive and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...
This Fish Shop corresponds to the category of Seafood market.
Probably the very best fresh seafood market.
Excellent fresh seafood on crunchy fresh salad!
Daniella and Lina did a fantastic job helping us make the tough choice of which dish to order. They were both so friendly and welcoming. We went with the lobster roll and a salad with grouper. The food was amazing and so fresh. We loved eating outside in a quiet area. Much better than the mainstream crowded restaurants.
Decent seafood. Great selection of take-home goods. Try it at least once while in Key West.
This place has the best lobster roll in town
Everything was great but the parking (not their problem).
A bit expensive, the crab sub is 12 bucks and the lobster toll is 19. But things are yummy
Delicious and reasonably priced.
Really great crabcake and lobster roll sandwiches. Better fresh seafood than is found in the nearby palace.
The best lobster roll. Try it.
Get anything with lobster. My boyfriend says it was the best lobster roll of his life and the butter dip with my lobster tail was extremely tasty. Another detail that I appreciated is the choice of microbreweries and wine the you can choose from their fridge to eat on their picnic tables. The laid back vibe distinguishes it from most of the dining options everywhere else on Key West.
Good place for cooked or raw seafood.
possibly one of if not the best conch fritters in Key West !! IMO
This place is easy to miss if you're not looking for it, they have a decent selection of seafood sandwiches, we tried the shrimp taco, yellow tail sandwich, lobster roll and crab cake sandwich. My personal favorite was the shrimp taco, the sauce on it is amazing! All plates come with a fresh and taste coleslaw salad and a plantain chips bag. They only have outdoor seating (about 4 tables) and no highchairs .
Best fresh caught fish in town! You can pick your own filet for fresh fish sandwich or even an incredible crab cake!!
Been looking for a great Grouper Sandwich. AND I FOUND IT HERE! Fast service, eat outside, clean neat tables, delicious fish menu served the way you like it fresh, and cooked to order! DELICIS! !#
Hands down best lobster roll you are gonna get in your life! Fish tacos are also great. You must eat there while visiting Key West.
Delicious fresh seafood.
Everything is fresh, made to order, and delicious. Nice little gem that is well priced. I recommend the grouper.
Food was incredible! I had some stone crabs and a shrimp taco. Super fresh. Wish the dining area was a little bigger.
Great fish candy shrimp but soggy
awesome lobster rolls
Seafood market is awesome and fresh.
Very good food at a quite good price but sadly, I found the staff lazy and not friendly at all. And I don't like the fact of having to pay and tip before eating and actually getting the service. Maybe it was just a bad day... Otherwise, great place to eat fresh seafood...
The food is absolutely delicious!! I could go on and on about the food... but I wont, the only thing i will say is thay we will definitely eat there again. The service is super friendly and fast, we did not have to wait long for our food. There are only a couple of seats inside, and there a 4 or 5 tables to sit at outside. There are only 4 parking spaces, so you may not want to drive to it.
Good food place to go to
Great place to get your fresh catch fish, shrimp and crab in Key West. Royal Red shrimp is an excellent variety. Handy, one stop shop as you can get your dinner complete with appetizer and dessert... even have a great little wine selection. If you are cooking for troupe on the vaca...you can't beat Eaton Street for quality. Walk or take your bike as parking is but of a challenge. But, hey.... it's Key West.
We first visited here on a walking food tour and had some Key West pink shrimp cocktail, which was very good. We went back afterwards to purchase some fresh goodness to cook back at our condo. We got two types of shrimp and some yellow tail snapper. Of the two shrimp, the ruby reds were the best! Very sweet and tender. The snapper was really good too!
Best lobster roll- so much lobster it’s crazy good. I wish I would’ve known about it sooner!
Food was awesome. Best tasting conch fritters so far out of 5 different places I've tried. Ridiculously fresh fish (duh), perfectly prepared. Probably the best tasting shrimp I've ever had, and I don't normally like breaded food.
The fish tacos were delicious. Grilled mahi and plantain chips. The shrimp basket was delicious and you get plenty of yummy fries.
The lobster roll was heavenly. Very large portion, and tasty. Good service..
I am literally obsessed with this place I spend most of my money here whenever I come down to visit from Miami. You HAVE to get the lobster roll it’s beyond delicious. The owner is such a great guy and it’s always a pleasure to talk to him.
Small, unassuming little place on Eaton Street. The lobster roll was delicious and the portion size was very generous. It's a very laid-back, casual place. Seating is limited and located outside, consisting of only 5-6 sitting tables and a couple 'standing-room-only' opions. If you plan on staying, try not to go there during the busy lunch and dinner rush.
Food was good, the staff seemed less than interested in being there and not very friendly.
Even though we came in near closing tonight (7/23/19) we were greeted by Friendly staff ( one man working behind the counter) he was VERY helpful with picking out our dinner and working through the menu. Great selection of fresh fish, lobster, shrimp, scallops, shrimp salad...the list goes on and on. Small indoor dining but patio seating seemed plentiful. our dinner was the following..The stone claw crabs were perfect and the sauce they served with it was great ( don’t know what it was called) , boiled peel and eat shrimp were delicious and the cocktail sauce served with it was awesome. I had the grouper sandwich and it was tender and perfectly cooked, wife had the grilled spiny lobster tail it was perfect and my daughter had the fried fish and fries it was great as well. The tartar sauce tasted homemade and didn’t last long, I could have ate that by itself! Genuinely enjoyed this place, was a nice break from some of the other touristy restaurants in Key West. Strongly recommend stopping in and getting lunch or dinner..maybe even picking out some fresh fish to take with you to cook at the house. 5 stars!!
So good and fresh would highly recommend to all my friends and family !!
Our meals here were by far the most excellent and delicious in town! Do yourself a favor and try it; they won’t disappoint! We will definitely return.
Awesome food. Fresh fish sa kn switches and the lobster roll are excellant.
Great food! Service was a little tough at first but th ed girl behind the counter opened up a bit. The inside was a nice little market and became apparent the lobster roll was the item to order. Hand as down the best food I have had in the last 3 days of being here and will be making more stops. The grilled lobster tail was also worth the cost. I highly recommend wandering away from Duval to this gem.
The best lobster roll in Key West! You get so much meat and it's so fresh and delicious. You'll do yourself a huge disservice by not grabbing one while visiting. The crab cake sandwich is very good too but the star of the show is the lobster roll.
One of the best lobster rolls I have had. Lobster rolls are my weakness
Excellent food and fantastic prices (for Key West). Don't expect waiters/service, that's not what this place is about.
We stumbled on this place while down in Key West. I'm so glad we did, we had the best lunch of the entire week we stayed in the Keys. This place has the best lobster roll I've ever had. My wife had the fish tacos and they were prepared and tasted like you would make them at home but even better. I would highly recommend this place!
Great selection of seafood.
A small seafood market with great food. Prices were a little high (but it's Key West so what can you do?)
Fantastic Food. Not cheap but sure worth it. We had the lobster roll, crab cake and shrimp sandwhich. It was one of the best we had. Not the typical US fried fish stuff....
Great place to eat sea food sandwiches. A must do at Key West
It's a great place for lunch or anytime when you are in the mood for a fish sandwich. Most of the time you will have to wait for a table, but the wait it's well worth it. They have about four parking spots but you might have to go around the block to find one. Regardless, you need to put a check mark on this one.
Great seafood! Nice, quaint place!
Delicious sandwich of fresh catch fish! We ordered tuna sandwich with medium cooked, and a Crab cake sandwich. We like them very much. Will Definitely go to this same place next time in keywest.
We visited Keywest for the first time last week, we had no idea what to order for our family but the girl was really nice. She was very patient even though we were indecisive. The food was amazing lobster roll, lobster tail and fish were the best we’ve ever had. Small, clean family and pet friendly restaurant.
Don't miss the lobster rolls, it's worth the effort to find this place
Seating outside! You can pick your seafood from the cooler! Very unique dining experience! Loved it!
Delicious menu..... fast friendly service. A must do.
Excellent fresh fish sandwich - you pick out your fish fillet you want them to cook. Also fresh salad with fresh grilled shrimp was excellent. We will be back
Crab cakes are awesome almost size of pancakes and lobster roll just as good.
The food was pretty good. Its in a nice location and the staff is really nice.
AMAZING, DK's lobster roll place is closed in September so we went here instead. Big chunks of lobster & the toasted bread that had a slight crunchy garlic taste set the sandwich apart. It is $21.00 but it is big.
Yum. Great food and service
Everything taste like fish. Not worth the money. Family of 5 on vacation and personally being from FL this is gross! My son had the chicken basket-taste like fish. Daughter had shrimp-taste like fish. I had the lobster roll-again taste like fish. Husband had fish tacos of course they were fish. Bottled drinks all the way around. No true service. Would not recommend to anyone on vacation I the keys. The price is crazy for this kind of food and service.
They have one of the best tasting lobster rolls. I'm so happy I found this place, the locals turned me on to it.
Friendly lady ..Grat tips on how prepare and cook..
GREAT lobster roll sandwich . Buttered toasted rolls were perfect. Lobster was plentiful!!! Did not over dress with mayo.
Worth going out of the way for one of their amazing lobster rolls. Take a stroll, enjoy the gorgeous neighborhood while you finish your beer!
Awesome conch ceviche. My buddy had the red grouper sandwich. Also excellent.
Grab a quick bite or fresh fish cooked for u amazing
The lobster roll & stone crab/artichoke dip were delicious!
Got some excellent Black grouper, Scallops and Conch ceviche even though it was late in the evening. Made the seafood BBQ a big hit
lobster rolls are delicious!
Absolutely fabulous!! Very fresh and perfectly prepared fish! Highly recommend!
Good food, very nice folks. It's seafood and it's a tourist town, expect to pay accordingly ($20-$50 p/per). Would gladly go again, everything was very good.
Great food...lobster roll was awesome: lots of lobster and a fabulous bun. The salad my companion got had a large portion of fish on it and was excellent as well. Although it's not cheap, I highly recommend Eaton for a quick, satisfying meal.
Very good and pretty big portions In
They've got a case for fresh fish to cook yourself as well as stone crab and lobster. I've never had a place where I can cook, but their lobster rolls are excellent. No filler, just so much lobster you'll be stuffing it back in and wondering if you should have split one
Very high quality seafood and very friendly service. Only down side is a lack of vegetarian and vegan options. Still, would recommend to any seafood enthusiast.
Food was good but prices were crazy.
Freshest seafood I've found so far. You pick your own ingredients for lunch or buy by the lb. Delicious! Had both mahi and blue crab yum yum!!
The lobster roll was great and filled with meat better than the original Maine Lobster roll. The bread could be a bit crisper. Shrimp salad sandwich was incredible.
Very good seafood market and restaurant, I been here many many time already, I refer all the people that I know when they when to key west, specialty the lobster roll and stone crab craw are the best in town, of course there more selection of seafood, strongly recommend to go here, is a must try place!
My parents like the lobsters there, bread toast is good too to go with the lobster tail. Can't have a whole lobster cooked for you though, only saying the whole one for fresh. We lived in a hotel there and now way we could've cook that.
Buy a pound of cracked stone crab claws and you will not be disappointed. Loved this place.
Try the Lobster Roll and the key lime pie!
Very delicious restaurant. Lobstertail, grilled rare tuna, grilled shrimp salad...these people are good at what they do. Unpretentious seating under the outdoor fans. Friendly owner recommended the Old Town bakery for key lime pie rather than oversell his own...
Great place for a Northeast style seafood lunch. I've always gotten the lobster roll and have never been disappointed.
DON'T GO THERE FOR THE FRIED SHRIMP!! We looked at all of these reviews and thought we were in luck...we rolled craps! Based on some of the other reviews, maybe ours was an anomaly...but it was BAD!! We ate there on 4/3/19 and were looking for great seafood on the cheap and off the beaten path...don't count on it here!! Three of our four had the Fried Key Shrimp...they were butterflied, but came out FLAT, horrible breading and were probably the DRIEST shrimp I've ever eaten!! They came in a basket with frozen BLAH fries and cole-slaw. The slaw was decent, but that meal was certainly not worth the $17 price tag...not good at all!!! One other guest had the Blackened Grouper Sandwich...he said it was good. I also had the Conch Chowder...it was good, but not over the top. We were VERY dissapointed and wished we would have waited in line at one of the other more popular joints in Key West...so much for trying to find a diamond in the rough!! On a side note...we DID find great shrimp on the way back to the mainland...King Seafood Market and Restaurant in Marathon...$10 for BIG, JUICY, DELICIOUS Shrimp...would recommend them for trip coming and going!
The crab cake sandwiches and stone crab simply beat the hell out of Joe's. I stop by Eaton every single time I visit keywest, And I believe the owner has said hi to me and took my plate when I finished this time. I have been to key west 4,5 times, this restaurant never disappointed me even a little bit. Forget about the noisy restaurants at the harbor, you deserve something better. Just try this out! Sorry, didn't take photo for the crab cake sandwiches, which is a croissant. :)
The food is really good. This is a small place where you order and pay at the counter and sit outside to wait for your food. It's also a sefood market. It was delicious and affordable. Would go again for sure.
The food was good and not too expensive (for the most part) for Key West. The problem is that the staff was not nice and not efficient. If you purchase crab or shrimps, although the taste is good, it is served cold so that's not very nice. I would have given more stars if the staff had been nicer. Also, as you pay before getting your meal, you can't really tip based on the quality of food/service.
For the freshest finest seafood in KeyWest. Sean has devoted his career to this place and he really cares. Now it’s making its name as a restaurant in the tradition of BO’s Fish Wagon, outdoors and extremely casual. Select you entree from display case and they will prepare it to your order. Shrimp Roll is die for!
This place was wonderful. The staff was kind and our orders arrived in a timely manner. My food was delicious. I highly recommend the fish tacos. I also purchased smoked fish dip and key lime pie. My tummy was very happy. A great restaurant to eat at. I would definitely eat there again.
Great food that came out quick! Yummy and they had cold beer too! Would recommend and go back!
Great place to eat broiled spiny lobster.
The fish dip is soo good there
Stone Crabs in June? Yes sir. The we're previously frozen but delicious. We put down 7lbs between the three of us. The mustard sauce was among the best I ever had.
Great place to stop for a mid-day snack. Their Buffalo shrimp and crab cakes are delicious.
Best sea food in the Keys. The owner was absolutely amazing and personable. I would definitely recommend the lobster roll, so much meat with a simply delicious recipe on a mouth watering buttered roll. Hands down the best meal we had while in Key West.
Great little place to eat. Super fresh food.
Fantastic lobster roll. Full of meat and toasted buttery bun. Best I have ever had !!!!
Had dinner there, food was top notch at a great price. Casual outside seating. Definately a must!
Don't underestimate this cozy little seafood market! After dining here, I cannot believe how UNDERRATED this place is!! WOW. I ordered 3 medium stone crab claws (priced by weight) and the crab cake sandwich. Let me tell you, they don't skimp. The crab cake sandwich consists of a LARGE crab cake (with pretty much all crab) between two halves of a toasted, buttery croissant with some greens and sauce. I'm not from the east coast though and haven't tried east coast crab cakes but I was seriously blown away by the quality of the crab cake. I also tried the stone crab from here and it was really great and tender--almost as good as Joe's Stone Crab in Miami. What I really loved about this place though was the fact that the staff and ownership are SO friendly. (Maybe it's a Keys thing??) I walked in and was immediately greeted by one of the owners, Sean, who gave me a menu and offered to explain it to me. He was so personable and gave me his recommendations and then checked on me after I got my food. He really went above and beyond to make sure everything was great. One of the cooks/other staff members also followed up with me about the food as well. With the amazing food and personable staff, this place should be a staple to anybody's trip to KW. I'm seriously so blown away by how great this place is!!!
Good food. Simple but very tasty. Outside seating only. Will be back.
Really good place for quick seafood. I wish they had whole fried fish.
Food was good, but very little seating and must sit outside
The first thing I do when I check into the guest house, I walk over here and get a lobster roll to go just as good as any lobster roll in New England. Perfect way to start off the vacation.
18$ für a basket of store bought fries, store bought Sauce and 4 little peaces of tasteless white fried fish, tasted frozen, was very disappointed...
Good service and selection. Small find in Key West but a must try. Local seafood
Excellent food for dine in or take out. The market sells fresh seafood at reasonable prices. I generally stock up on fish, ceviche, shrimp, etc. before heading out on a sailing adventure and have never been disappointed. Eaton’s is a not to be missed, family owned business in Key West
Fantastic! I've only ever ordered the lobster roll, and will likely never try anything else! We look forward to it every year when we come down!
Great food and very friendly staff! Highly recommend visiting here. My wife and I had the fried shrimp basket and the crab spinach dip. Both were very good. They have parking available, but not much. Great experience!
The lobster roll is amazing
Picked up a few pounds of yellow tail. Was fresh and really good. Only a few fish choices though.
This is in my opinion the must-go seafood place in Key West. They offer fresh, delicious seafood at a very reasonable price. I tried the grilled lobster tail, lobster rolls, crab cake sandwich, and the blackened scallop sandwich during my stay (stone crabs were sold out), and I was amazed by every single one of them. Everything's fresh and flavorful with good portion. I placed to-go orders each time, but they have some seating outside the store too. I highly recommend this place for seafood.
Lobster roll and crab cake sandwich really great. Especially the crab cake sandwich, it is the best among all the restaurants tried here and in NOLA
Best fish market in Key West
A little pricey but the fish is fresh and great
Oh my! What a great fish store! We found you on google and drove here from a great day at the beach! We wanted fresh fish to BBQ in foil with some butter and seasoning! The young lady behind the counter gave us 3 great options. The golden tile was fresh and she highly recommended it! It was amazing! She also found a dry seasoning that they make! Grabbed a key lime pie for dessert to make our meal and experience here perfect! The fish turned out perfect! I highly recommend this place! Thank you from Washington state!
I ordered the blackened shrimp sandwich and my wife ordered the grilled grouper sandwich and we shared the ceviche. We absolutely loved all of our food! Great place to eat with free parking!
Good food and local catch. Small joint, but quick and easy.
Best lobster roll made with fresh lobster. Great off the beaten path of Duval street.
Great food ,reasonable prices.
It was cool, it was a bit pricey for what they served but good quality food
Love the fresh seafood. We have party of 6, spending 200 bucks with stomach pack of pink shrimp, stone crab ....
Very courteous. Wife doesn't eat seafood so limited to two items on the menu, hot dog or chicken tenders. She chose c. tenders and fries, which she enjoyed. I on the other hand love seafood and ordered the lobster roll ($20). When they brought it out I couldn't believe my eyes. Looked delicious, huge portion, but it hardly had the sweet lobster flavor I was expecting. I'm a little puzzled why it lacked flavor because it looked better than any I have ever had. Magazine picture perfect.
Great little place with a fresh seafood market as well a small restaurant. They have some fish that is harder to find as well as big ole crab claws for days! I had the fish cake sandwich and my wife had mahi. Both sandwiches were wonderful, no complaints. My only regret was that I failed to notice they had lionfish prior to ordering. We recommend this place!
Excellent place for fish tacos you can pick from a few different types of fish and have them grilled, beverages are very reasonable $1 for a water
FRESH and so tasty. Casual and very friendly atmosphere. Great flavor combos
Ordered the crab cake sandwich and the lobster roll and oh my goodness, to die for. The best I ever had so far. The 1 star is for not having a big enough place to dine. Other than that, a MUST place while in Key West.
Lobster roll brimming with fresh lobster meat -✔ Fresh Stone Crab -✔ Quality Seafood - ✔ Located in Key West this place is primarily a seafood market but they do sell ready to eat items that you can enjoy outside (they've got a couple of picnic tables that serve as seating). They've got one heck of a lobster roll, and they serve up the ever so popular stone crab claws with a side of mustard sauce. This place is a "Must Visit" for me whenever I'm in the Keys.
Awesome food, lobster roll excellent but conch ceviche and pineapple hard cider made a great combination and stole my heart. Very casual: picnic tables outside under umbrellas but who cares with food this good.
Great place to buy fish or get a healthy lunch.
Amazing fresh fish and crab cake! Lobster roll also worth a try.
Best downtown fresh seafood! And authentic Maine lobster rolls!
Amazing cant find better food
Choose one of the fish on offer that day, they will grill/blacken it and put it in a sandwich with salad. Eat at one of the few table outside or take out and sit at the harbour with your loot. A really fresh, tasty, and filling bite to eat. Great quality produce. Highly recommend.
Stop for lobster roll and stone crab claws
Great food, very quick. Owner was very friendly and engaging
Shrimp in case was old looking. I know because I grew up on the golf coast and what fresh shrimp looks like. When I asked for fresh shrimp I was told I had to buy old shrimp. Poor service!!!!!!
Food here is excellent!! They catch the fish in the morning and filet it up fresh in big portions. Lobster roll is on point, and fish tacos are the best on the island. Service is great too. Make this place a must-do on your stop at Key West.
Great food, have option to eat here or take away. Not a typical restaurant setting. You order food and they make it to order and pick it up to eat at the tables set up or to take out. Not necessarily a table service diner. Don't let that deter you, food is amazing and very fresh seafood. I would highly recommend to anyone!
Absolutely without a doubt the freshest, best cooked fish I've had so far. Friendly and professional staff too!
Great seafood. Prices aren't too bad. Self serve kind of place. I hope the kitchen staff received the tip because the front doesn't seem like they do much.
I used to buy those delicious dips, like: tuna salad, mango salad, smoke fish, ceviche, artichoke. twice a week in this place but since a few weeks ago is not the same, their products are terrible, I do not know if they changed the cook or the ingredients.
Great lobster roll!
Lobster roll was out of this world. Lobster meat to bread ratio was nutty, probably enough lobster meat for 2 sandwiches packed into one
Read in Southern Living Magazine that this restaurant had the best lobster roll...My husband loved it...they were right. The owner helped me select a fish and seasoning I would like for my fish sandwich. He was right on. It was delicious!! Loved this place! Highly recommend for fresh seafood!
The best lobster roll.
The absolute best seafood market! They also make a great meal with fresh seafood also. And there take on the key lime pie is delicious. I think it's the best just cause it's so different
Must try stone crab claws. Awsome!
LOVE the crab cake sandwich.
The best seafood in the keys!
Awesome! People are passionate about food quality. Literally the most perfectly prepared scallops I have ever had. When the owner can tell you everything about how all their food is sourced and why it’s a great sign you’re in the right place. Highly recommended!
Great Stone Crab Claws. Friendly staff. A relief from bustling Duval street and off a quite street. A must stop for a quick bite
It's in Key West! Some of the freshest seafood I've ever seen and at very reasonable prices due to local availability. Very helpful staff and very convenient location. But let's face it, Key West is only 4 miles long...
Food was good and fresh customer service was good nice little outdoor seating