Reviews of Cottage Hill Seafood Supply (Fish Shop)

Nik Martin

Decent fresh seafood, but rarely local. The crab meat is from South Carolina, and I suspect most other items are NOT local. Most things are $1-2 more than other local shops, but the cooked item menu isn't too bad.

Completly Random

No complaints from me ordered Crawfish from here which to me was great but my wife wanted just a little spicier (cant please everyone) and i ordered their shrimp which they boiled for me. Will be going here again everytime i get a chance. Customer service was excellent. Very satisfied customer.

Jerry Jamieson

Never been frozen.

Tony Rainwater

The food is cooked to order so it's fresh

Charlie Bishop

Great food

Danielle Burch

Got a few pounds of crawfish from them today. Great taste! Nice and spicy like crawfish are supposed to be!

Derrick C. Lott

Food was great

Douglas Butts

Seafood market that serves fresh and cooked seafood of many different types. Both go and service are consistently good. Don't let the gas station throw you off!

Wes Allday

Great fresh shrimp, and really good crawfish!

Jacob Whitehead

A Diamond in the rough! Great portions for a great price!

dorothy ellis

Husband loves their food

Jeff Barnes

Delivered thru door dash. Either old seafood or old grease. Had seafood platter and shrimp and oysters. Both of us have been up all night puking and sh#tting. Stay away or if you go make sure to ask to see the kitchen first.

C Lynn

The facility is unsanitary. Some of the seafood is over priced compared to other markets.

S. L.

Good food. Slightly more expensive on certain items.

christie peterson

One of our local favorites for takeout

Kristi Tanner

Love ordering the catfish filets from cottage hill seafood. Seafood always taste fresh and price good for the amount of food.

Demetrious Johnson

Love this place!!!! They have the best steamed seafood!!!! AND ALSO VERY VERY REASONABLE TOO

Amberly

The young cashier tried telling me that my total was over $40 for two combo meals that were priced at $8.99 & $9.99. She "did the math" 4 different times, so I just ordered separately. Lo and behold, under $22 for both. When I confronted her, she said "Oh well, guess I hit the button too many times" No apology or Anything. Buyer beware, who knows how many people this place has ripped off. Soggy fries and lack of flavor in the batter round out my experience.

Chelsea Nicole

I come here for all my seafood

Annette Cooper

I absolutely live cottage hill seafood. They are my favorite seafood stop. Their food us always cooked to perfection. It is cooked hot and fresh. Crawfish season isn't quite in yet, however, they had crawfish on 12/31. I was so happy and it was fresh and hot. The staff us also friendly.

Michael Price-Williams

Clean and friendly

Emilio Valdez

Great seafood. Spices are perfect.

Jamelle Jones

So much breading on the food you can't even taste what you are eating. I waited 40 minutes for 1 PC of fish and 10 shrimp.

Yolanda Moore

Sweetest lady working . Loved the hospitality

April Pace

Love it

Kim Lewis

Really nice staff always friendly. Good location for hanging out downtown walking around town.

Anithea M

Always good food for me

Jeff N

Came here to pick up so lunch, placed an order from their lunch special. I ordered a catfish platter with potato salad. How they battered it was done very well, doesn't flake off as easy off the fish which to me is a good thing. Potato salad was pretty good and the speed of service was also quick and good.

C-note Player

Too many young folks work here, that don't wanna work or care how they fix you're food... Some will even stick there damn finger in you're cup b4 serving you something to drink, as if they don't understand that's not sanitary... The older people here have better since, but need to train their employees better... I see this a lot at a lot of McDonald's in mobile Al especially the hood....

Tariq Abdullah

I bought a LARGE Shrimp Po Boy... I got it home and opened it up, sad to say I was disappointed as can be. I was lucky if I had a good sized handful of shrimp on the bread, the rest was lettuce, tomatoe and about 5 slices of pickle..

Martha Joiner

Great service...great food

Penny Hipp

I ordered 10 pounds of large steamed shrimp. When I picked them up, it was a small pan. No way was it 10 pounds. I Was embarrassed because 2 of my guest at my party couldn’t eat because I ran out of shrimp. Last month. I bought the same amount and it was 2 large pans and fed 45 ppl. I was shorted/cheated. I will never go back. I paid $101.00 for a little bit of shrimp.

Crystal Schwind

Awesome seafood! Great prices! Will definitely go again when I'm in the area.

Damon Sullivan

Best poboys in alabama

John Doe

Crawfish are way too hot - spice is good but if all you taste is the heat and not the crawfish, it's too much. They can't touch R&R's or DIP's. Poboy's were good, now they scrimp on both shrimp and lettuce/tomato. Nope, they've lost my business.

Ashley Myles

The shrimp were fresh!... Just need a better selection of seafood, and pricing.

adrian johnson

I usually come here all the time and get a fish plate with potato salad and it's usually pretty good, never had any complaints. That is until one day I ordered 2lbs of crawfish and I found a spider in them

Lee Smith

Nicest most accommodating people. Great Catfish! Not a big fried foodie, but it's great hot-good the next day in a toaster oven. Huge portions & cheap.

James B

Great food

Ralph Lindsey

Excellent crawfish