In my opinion, this is a fantastic school. The professors here are not the cookie-cutter, white-guilt, socialist, authoritarian, far-left radicals that have become so popular. They have rock solid reasons for believing what they do, and I appreciate that very much. The vast majority of them are great at teaching and engaging, but you have to be willing to work in order to learn and do well. It's not impossibly hard, but Covenant is not a school where you can sleep through class (something I discovered my first semester, and fixed in my school life shortly thereafter). This school does have a few flaws, though. Its food is honestly not very good; I don't know if I would go so far as to say "bad", but it is not good. Another thing (this is 100% subjective) is that the college is very Presbyterian. I know a former student who was asked to not come back because of his firm Baptist views, and depending on your denomination (you have to be a christian to be accepted, as it is a christian college) you may find that very positive or negative.
Among this, however far and away the best thing about Covenant is the community and the student body (with the exception of a certain hall with a fire hydrant). About 70 - 80% of the students are people I would want to be friends with. The halls have a real sense of family, and most upperclassmen are willing to help you with more or less anything they can.
(Mac = Gryffindor
Andreas = Hufflepuff
Founders = Ravenclaw
Carter = Slytherin
fight me)
All in all, I'd say that Covenant is definitely a school you want to at the very least check out.