Reviews of Myrtie Mae's (Coffee Shop)

David Barker

Breakfast served all day, nice salad bar, very friendly staff. Parking and building shared with the hotel. Lindsey is a very attentive server. He always takes time to chat with anyone wanting to bend his ear. Kept my tea glass full, be it forgot to leave out lemon as requested, twice... but he smiled the whole time. Food tastes great and very easy on the wallet. My go to for breakfast and lunch when in town.

Angie Cope sears Hometiwn Store

This place has amazing food...everything seasoned to perfection. Prices are wonderful for what you receive. The staff was lovely and so friendly. Definitely recommend!

Barbara Parker

It's a homey place with great service and great food, not expensive. We've been going there for many years. That's our favorite place to eat. I could always find some little gift there too.

roy slocum

Really good homemade food. I almost didn't stop because it's in a hotel. So glad I didn't pass this by. Nice salad bar, the fried Chicken looked great. I had the homemade chicken fried steak and I was the best I've had in a long time. Don't miss this one if you're in Eureka.

M Walker

Great food, did not cost much for 5 of us we ate very good for around $10 each and had leftovers to take with us, highly recommend this place they have a wonderful soup and salad bar also.

Barb Ross

Great service. Great portions. Good food

Le Johnson

Great food. Very friendly staff. Great prices

Tammy Baker

Have the barbecue chicken Sandwich and salad bar. In my husband had the chip roast beef sandwich and salad bar. It was great service was great.

Ron Branson

Really nice place to stop very friendly staff

Christy Specht

Salad bar was nice wasn't impressed with the buffet. Fairly cheap for the area but everything tasted like a tv diner. I did like the blueberry muffins

Doug Myerscough

Great home cookin'

Chris Grat

On a hot day, salad bar is the way to go... other than that, whoopdeefrickendoo!

Janet Randolph

Friendly, "down-home" atmosphere. Buffet food was just so-so. Priced reasonably.

Wesley Grubb

Great food and service

Margaret Tullis

Chicken was old fashioned fried like grandma used to make. Huge portions and lunch comes WITH soup and salad, (unless you just get a burger) lunch has best prices but the exact same menu as dinner. Homemade pimento cheese is the absolute best thing I ever ate. (Except for their chicken, THAT was the best) my 3 piece chicken, mashed potatoes, white country pepper gravy, chicken gumbo soup, salad bar was only $10 and we signed up for Myrtie Mays free membership. You get a free dinner on your birthday and free (soda, tea, etc) drinks when you visit.

Mike W

The best buffet I have had. The catfish was delicious

Katrina Mcpeters

Service was great. But food was ok. Salad bar was excellent. Was a bit pricey.

Kim Gerlach

Food was amazing and so was the service!

Paul Hawkins

Decent place to get a cheap brunch on Sunday or breakfast any day but the main menu is , let’s just say less than impressive. If you are local don’t forget to get your Myrtie May card!

iHennesy Hennesy

GREAT ATMOSPHERE! The waitress was REALLY concern, helpful, joyful, informative, pleasant and JUST DOWN RIGHT AWESOME!

Cameron Dunaway

Good place to have a lunch meeting or to take out your older more conservative friends. On Sunday there is an extensive brunch buffet, calling ahead for a reservation is recommended. Breakfast lunch and dinner at reasonable prices. Be prepared to pay at the cash register as opposed to with your waiter. Kind of annoying idiosyncrasy to be honest.

Robert Myers

A little dated but great food and service!!

Marsha Rorie

Always nice eats. Great salad bar

Margaritt Quimby

It was a great restaurant, but they over cooked my fish. The people was quite friendly and the food was good.

K.C. Shultz

After many over priced mediocre meals around town, we found Myrtie Mae's. Great food, good prices, awesome service.

Jerry Layton

Best there is just like grandmas home cooking

Jim F

Nice clean restaurant. Good value, very casual. Nice change from the downtown Eureka restaurants

Michelle Grenier

I went for lunch and had the salad bar it was great. The waitress was very nice.

Beth Dalton

Fantastic food and great service!

Valor Bee

Excellent food and excellent customer service! We took our party of 9 there twice, and we were all very impressed both times. Joyce did a great job, and was very friendly the entire time she helped us. We all had a great experience here and will be back again!

Stephenie Bolinger

Cafe is located in the Best Western Hotel. Menu is mostly fried items, burgers, and sandwiches but they have a good salad bar. The tomato basil soup was very good as well. Nice atmosphere and clean as well.

A L

It's inside the Best Western but don't let that keep from giving it a try. The salad bar is stocked to the rim with all fresh veggies. We had the turkey club and chicken fried chicken. The club was DELICIOUS. The chicken was a bit bland but a little salt and pepper changed that. Get a widow seat for a beautiful view! Definitely will be back.

Kristi A Yokley

Pretty good old fashion buffet for Sunday brunch. Very nice staff

Jeremy Mullins

One of the better buffets I have had. Plenty of options. I usually do not care for buffets. But this was great.

Silas Gray

Tuesday or Thursday chicken and roast beef on the buffet.

Paul Woodhouse

Their Sunday noontime fare is an omelet station, salad bar, with full buffet and desserts, including homemade muffins, cookies, cobbler, and mousse. Only negative...the wait. Staff is friendly and helpful.

Beth Brown

Sunday buffet was a win. Roast beef that was so good made to order eggs and priced very economically.

Nancy Pierce

Very friendly staff. Great salad and dessert bar. Food wasnt bad. Was strange though...I ordered open faced roast beef which usually comes with brown beef gravy....this came with a brownish creamy gravy that had a ton of sage in it. It wasnt horrible but it was a bit strange for me. Just a bit too different for a dish I love. I will still go back and try other dishes. The cookies are fantastic.

Becky Gambill

We love to have breakfast here at least once when we come into town.

Lona Fox

Every time we visit Eureka Springs, we eat at Myrtie Mae's Sunday buffet. Consistently delicious. Tender, juicy, prime rib and roast pork loin. Also ham, which I didn't try. Excellent shrimp salad and seafood salads. The salad bar has such a great variety of salads, it's hard to choose. Oh, and an omelet bar with about a hundred choices for ingredients. $29 for the 2 of us with 1 coffee and that included the tax. If you are interested in the history of Myrtie Mae's and Eureka, speak with the owner and his son Langley, our server, a 5th generation resident of Eureka.

Steev Merrbach

Big portions. Nice menu selection. They even have liver. Great job.

Becky Muncy

The server tried to fix the foods issues but it was over done. A leaf ended up in plate, a hair in the other. Hoping it was just an off night

Sarah Dexter

The food was great, and the staff was personable. It was just what we needed after a long drive. Awesome salad bar. Great soup. We loved the chicken fried steak with mashed potatoes and gravy.

Jenny Martin

Soup and Salad bar is the best. Very polite staff. Clean and comfortable.

Ryan Miller

Wonderful cashier she had all of patience possible for my wife adding things as she was trying to ring things up. Lol

Wesley Crawford

Well food was pretty good but they charged $2.50 For like a 6 oz glass of milk said it was a large??? Ridiculous serious no more than 6oz. And they didn't open till 7:00. If your working you don't have time to eat. Or your late. But the 6oz glass of milk for their large and charging $2.50 ridiculous

Ronna Richardson

Food is always good and the staff is so friendly. The best coffee around. Their fried chicken is a must try!!!

Melody Marlay

Best restaurant in Eureka! Awesome home cooked meals and a lovely salad bar with homemade muffins and cookies. I would highly recommend!

Chris Lee

It is walking distance from our motel room, was a good breakfast.

Gregory Harvey

They get food right at this restaurant. Perfect bacon, juicy and crispy chicken, fresh salad bar. Service is great and prices reasonable. Gift shop with reasonable prices too!

Jackie Koller

Very good food. Was in town just for the weekend and we got lucky choosing a great place! Salad bar was delicious and so were the meals we ordered. No complaints from anyone at our table!

Stacy E

This is a great place if you're craving comfort food! I had the parmesan catfish and my husband had the soup/salad bar. No complaints on the food whatsoever! The bar had "delectable" (as my husband called it) muffins. The waitress was sweet and attentive; however, the hostess wasn't the most pleasant lady...not enough to downgrade the place though! We left full and happy!

Billy Plunkett

I had the roast beef and mashed potatoes, it had a sour taste. Didn't eat ,so the only charges me for my free salad. Same price !

Robert Reed

The BBQ chicken was good. I wouldn't recammend the potato wedges. They were burnt. The service staff are very friendly.

Michael Hardy Sr

That place was great! Nice and friendly staff and the food was delicous!

Ralph Marshall

Great food, fast service with good prices

Rhett Moyer

Really good spot. Very relaxing and friendly.

Moonleaf Meta

I am not sure why they have such high reviews. I have eaten there three times and the food is really mediocre at best. It tastes like microwaved frozen food. Nothing to write home about. The salad bar is okay. From all the descriptions, I thought it would be more impressive. The best thing I have eaten here are the muffins on the salad bar. Make sure to try one of those. Our last visit we were seated under an air conditioning vent, and it was dripping condensation onto our table. We didn't notice until we were done eating. Hopefully it didn't drip into anyone's food or drink. They do have very friendly service.

Cheryl Gentry

Loved the food. Best fried chicken around.

Chris Hollingshead

The food was great and waitress was friendly and wonderful.

Vickie Trigg

Great salad bar and great service!

Kittye Williams

Great food, huge portions, good prices.

April

My boyfriend had steak and eggs with a biscuit & gravy. I had the Belgian waffle which was good, but the corn grits with bacon and cheese were just “okay.” The service was good and fast but the food was pretty average, nothing too unique or bursting with flavor. I believe we’ll try a different restaurant next time we visit.

Lillian Sims

Favorite place in eureka to get breakfast beautiful view if u get a table by the windows

Derek Norvell

Food and service were excellent. Will be back for sure.

Randy White

The best place we found to eat in 4 days here

Chelle Thompson

Great food at a great price.

Thomas Whitley Sr.

Salad bar is 4 stars. Menu items, including fried chicken, 2 stars. Service 4 stars. Good value for the price.

Mary Payne

Fantastic lunch buffet, great value at a low cost. Must visit!

Rachel Garcia

Nice and good prices! The waitress was the best! ☺️

Annette Shifflett

This was an awesome buffet for Sunday brunch.

Bagus Sudiro

Very friendly staff and the food was very good as well.

Linda Ford

This is my new favorite restaurant!!! Food and service excellent!!! Love the salad bar!!! Prices reasonable!!

Nancy Morris

It was ok. Nothing to go out of my way for. Prices were affordable.

Nick Sullivan

Great price great service!!!

captain brutus

Best salad bar you can find a great value, try the fried chicken.

Kasey Chaney

Best place for breakfast in Eureka, hands down! The waffles are THE BEST WAFFLES EVER! Seriously worth the stop 10/10 for my husband and I

Carl Close

Service was great food was good price about average I would recommend it

Jeff Kelley

Eureka Springs breakfast tradition. The Eureka omelet never disappoints.

Irene Meyer

I had the liver & onions, delicious! Also the salad bar. Besides the usual salad bar food they had AWESOME blueberry nut muffins & 2 homemade soups. And to top it off banana pudding w/ whipped cream! I left full & ready for a nap.

K Bradbury

Always great. Amazing food and service!

Kaylan Clark

Sunday brunch is good. The small space gets crowded and likely to be a wait on Sundays.

P Green

Friendly staff. The food was great. If your in eureka springs stop by.

Sean Jones

Wife said it was the best chicken fried chicken she had ever had. I have liver and onions and it much reminded me of moms. Service was great.

Ted Shrader

I know why don’t you seat us in the corner so we can look at the wall. Catfish was over cooked, soup was almost ok. By the way, there we’re lots of open seating.

Angelia Batson

Kind people, great salad bar, fantastic fried chicken and Sunday brunch to die for

Kense Woodall

Great food for a good price with good service!

K&B Leasing

Good food. Service was great

Tina Ross

Absolutely great fried chicken!! Nice salad bar too. Friendly servers. Nice to see teenage kids working so hard and respectful too.

Her Home

Most disgusting kitchen I've ever seen! And the handlers of that food I'm surprised no-one has gotten ill. Especially the salad bar. Disgusting!!! Will never eat there again nor recommend to anyone, unless they're my enemy. On second thought I don't even think I could do that to them. Place should be shut down!!! How do they even pass a health inspection?? Someone must be getting paid well.

Nancy Key

Enjoyed eating here...the salad bar was good. The whole group enjoyed everything that was ordered.

Rachel Freeman

A great place for fried chicken and breakfast! The brunch buffet on Sunday is great too, lots of choices! Be prepared for a wait though. Servers are friendly and prompt. We eat here every time we come to Eureka Springs!

Marie Huie

The service was quick and food was tasty. I had the bacon and cheese grits which I believe was the real thing. I only wish it was tad creamier but the flavor was good

Karen Evans-Timm

Myrtie Mae's is great, the buffet is wonderful. I love the salad bar. The folks are friendly and we go several times a month, once a month for a birthday/anniversary celebration with church folks.

Terry Cameron

Good breakfast at a good price. The service was awesome.

Sandra Brooks

Excellent food and service. Reasonable prices too.

Charlotte Riddles

Great salad bar.....food was really good service was good, friendly place, price were perfect....

Alan Jezusko

My wife and I were on and weekend trip with another couple. We ate at several nice restaurants. Myrtie Mae's was the highlight meal of our trip! They had great food. The quality of food that they served was much, much better than you would expect from a buffet. The food was more like something that you would order off of a fine restaurants menu. But you got to eat all you wanted! And the dessert was delicious! if I ever get back in that area of the country, I'll make sure to stop in at Myrtie Mae's again.

Vicki Cannova

Had the Hot Beef Sandwich with Mashed Potatoes and Brown Gravy, it was delicious!

Nadia Kleinschmidt

The food is so delicious. Very comforting dining room area... I ordered the fried chicken this evening, it's my second time there this week. It was perfect, nice and juicy. The staff is very friendly as well... The other day we went for breakfast it also was good and the prices are reasonable. Very nice place. I've been to Eureka Springs 3 times and I've been here all my visits.

willie canaan

Excellent food and service. Not anymore expensive than your average restaurant. Unique history about Myrtie Mae posted on the walls. We dined their on 2015 and did not miss it in 2019.

Jessica Gibson

LOVE MYRTIE MAE'S! It is a very family friendly place!! Great salad bar! Fabulous wait staff!!!! ❤️ It!

James Welk

Very nice rooms pool aera helpful staff

Brenda Morris

Food was good, service was fast and the staff was great.

Tonia Kingham

Delicious food and a restaurant with lots of history! Some of the servers have worked there 20+ years and were attentive, friendly and taught us a lot about Myrtie Mae herself. Definitely a place where locals gather and although we were from out of town, everyone, including other patrons, made us feel right at home. We will certainly dine here again on our next stay in Eureka Springs.

Alisa Main

Its ok but not much food to offer

Timothy Roe

My wife and I ate here this week on my birthday. Because so many other places were unexpectedly closed, we chose Myrtie Mae's because I wanted a steak. I loved the well-stocked and fresh salad bar, the warm mini-loaf of bread, and my steak. It was very tasty and I ate every bite. I would gladly return here again.

CC Jeep

Loved it! Home of the working bunny!

Laura Bonham

Amazing food. Salad bar is great. Always awesome service!

Mike Marrone

Great food !! Fried chicken is sooo good. And the breakfast is a must.

David Glover

Fabulously friendly food and fellowship

Mavis Wilks

Lunch with a. Friend. She has not eaten there before, SHE LOVED IT! We had country fried chicken mashed potatoes and it was delicious

Robin Garrison

Best restaurant we have eaten at so far in Eureka Sprjngs. We closed the place and the waitress Rhonda was very friendly and helpful like she just showed up for work. I know she had to be tired. It was great food and pleasant atmosphere.

Sommerville Langaas

Generous portions of delicious food. Great service and fair prices.

Elijah Smith

Waited 30min for a basic breakfast.... Barely enough gravy 4 spoonfuls for the biscuits. Eggs and hashbrowns were under done, didn't feel like waiting another 20 min to fix those.... All in all Jamie's in Harrison is worth the drive!

Ellen Archibald

Delicious food, mostly friendly staff, nice atmosphere

Charles Gilbert

Very friendly staff very good food

Gary Dahlem

Really impressed with this place! Located inside the hotel and easy to find. Our service was a good as the food! We got there around 3pm and ordered off the lunch menu. My wife enjoyed the fried chicken while I ate country fried steak with mashed potatoes, both smothered with gravy. All you can eat salad bar got us started while waiting on our meal. Definitely a great place to eat if you don't want to go into the historic downtown Eureka Springs.

Nancy Wright

Food was good, service was good, conveniently located at the hotel.

Robert Clark

Soup & salad bar is the best. Food is also great. Try their fried chicken. Tue. And thur. Are buffet days at lunch. 11 - 2, Excellent!

David Kline

One of my favorite places into eat in Eureka Springs! Very popular with the locals. Tuesdays and Thursdays are all you can eat buffet so its busier then. Sunday after church expect a wait. Like I said, its popular! Enjoy!

Kim Harris

Pros: The staff is very nice at Myrtie Mae's, super friendly and helpful. The restaurant is clean. Service is fast. They have a great salad bar with plenty of options. Prices are fair. Cons: Each one of us ordered a different meal from the dinner menu and we all experienced the same issue... The food was just not good. Very greasy. I wouldn't recommend for dinner. (No hate, just an honest review)

Jennie walton

Great food! First time to visit the town .Had the best waitress we've had in a very long time. So sweet, kind, fast and good service. Thank you to Leslie our waitress for a great first experience.

Josh Hilton

Don't the let the Best Western exterior fool you. This place has a tasty breakfast at a reasonable price. 1. Atmosphere 3/5 2. Service 5/5 3. Taste 4/5 4. Price $

Scotty Kindrick

Gooood fried chicken! Stopped here on a Friday night. Definitely a place for the locals. Heard from a shop keep about the fried chicken and said it was good stuff. They were right. Unbuckle your belt, you’re not going to leave hungry! Service was great and friendly. Home town feel with home town cooking!

Selena Harbick

Consistently Good food. Good service.

Tonia Hawf

Nice place for a family breakfast.

Barbara Anderson

Love the food and everybody is so nice. They all do a awesome job.

Janet Stuart

Waitress , Connie is the best in town, thanks for awesome service

Amber Wells

First time trying this place, customer service was great and the food was so delicious .

swiggame

We always have to go to Myrtie Mae's when we visit Eureka Springs! Great breakfast!

Roger Stone

This is a restaurant in the Best Western motel in Eureka Springs. Great food and service. Had the prime rib on open sandwich with mashed potatoes and salad bar. Excellent and delicious. Priced under $30 for two.

Trina Grimes

Love this place. I eat here every time I come to town. Breakfast, lunch, dinner it's all great.

Mark Reed, Sr.

Home cooked comfort food! The fried chicken was excellent and the possum pie for dessert was delicious!

Ronald Fagan

Great food , nice people !

Mary Szafranski

The salad/ soup bar is excellent. Add their famous fried chicken and you are in home cooking heaven. Service was great.

Darla Hunt

Wonderful! Prices, food, service, everything was awesome.

Alexander duff Newton

A wonderful place for family dining with a large hotel to stay and visit while in eureka springs.

Jonathan Gillip

Great breakfast, better than your typical hotel restaurant.

David Walstrum

Wow. We went to Myrtie Mae's with some friends. The staff was very friendly and prompt with our food. The soup & salad bar was very fresh. Looking forward to our next visit.

Pete Reeves

Great food. Great selection. Very reasonable. Excellent staff. Had a table today with a direct view of the kitchen. Whoever posted that the kitchen was disgusting, well I saw zero evidence of that. I might also add that the salad and desserts were fresh and good. Very clean restrooms too.

Rose Dillon

Always wonderful. The staff is very gracious and accommodating. The food is very tasty.

Ben Parker

The best way to find out about a place is to see how they respond when there is a problem. There was a problem with my food and they responded quickly and kindly. The food was great abs we really enjoyed our time.

SUE FRYE

Service slow. Salad bar is about the least appetizing I've seen in a while .Reminded me of an old Shoneys. Staff friendly. Needs some serious menu updating. And cloth napkins please.

Melissa Tierney

The only complaint I have was the lack of either a roll or bread with my meal. I had the chicken fried chicken and it was very good. The salad bar was fresh and had a good variety. I did not have any soup but it did look good and not greasy like so many buffet soups are. For a take back to the hotel dessert, I had a fruit and nut muffin off the bar, it was moist and good. The server was very friendly and attentive. This was a great place for a meal.

Bess Livingston

Great Sunday brunch buffet. Best fried chicken ever!!!

Dave JONES

Service was good. Food wasn't as great as other times. We've enjoyed it all the other times. Will go back next time in Eureka Springs.

Mike Meek

Good food prices right

Jacob Durnin

Very big salad bar. I got the BLT, but it was more like a LTB sandwich. There was a lot of people there but I just don't see what the buzz is all about. The food was mediocre and it felt like I was dining from a place in the 1950's. I don't need to go back.

patrick c

This place was amazing! We stayed in the area for several days and had planed to eat somewhere different each meal, but after eating lunch here we decided to also try breakfast and dinner as well. Every meal was fantastic! We ended up having dinner there twice. Out of all the places we ate while in Eureka, this was hands down the best! We had a different server each time and they were all so friendly and did a great job. Don't miss the opportunity to eat here while in area.

Terry Durnin

Salad bar was very nice. Food was good.

chris cline

Excellent salad bar, the pimento cheese is amazing as is the deal cutlet!! Actually everything there is great! Great atmosphere and service!

Steve U

Great food at a great price. Don't let the Best Western part stop you.

Tushar Prabhu

Good buffet spread. The 'make your own omelette was excellent. They also have a large dessert spread

Laurie Lewis

Top notch "old fashioned" breakfast. Even my picky kid found he loved the pancakes.

Gail VanCoevering

Dinner was so good and breakfast delicious. Prices very reasonable. Good soup and salad bar. Tomato basil soup was killer!!!

Paul Ewald

Great place for some homemade food... excellent service

Rob Lacy

Excellent food and service. The rainbow trout was superb and salad bar fresh. Thanks for an excellent evening meal after a long day's work.