Reviews of Potbelly Sandwich Shop (Catering)

Nazar Zhuk

Love Potbelly when in a hurry. -1 on the bathroom cleanness.

Stephanie Fackrell

Good selection and the sandwiches are delicious.

Mike Repa

Power house ranch and a cup of broc Can't beat it. And the service is fantastic

RudeDude2140

We had lunch here, and the food sure hit the spot. Atmosphere was decent for lunch. Very good sandwich.

Donece Thomas

Love their sandwiches

Ai

Delicious sandwiches...

Ariel Gendler

Good place, fast, clean, and nice staff.

Joe Gorman

Delicious but over priced

Boccherini Blacks

Fast service. Good soup and subs. Just a little costly

Curtis Davis

Great food and service

Edgar A Latimer

Love the workers there so nice, and the food so good.

Nicholas Raines

Love their chicken salad sandwich!

Tyree Martina

Not a fan

Randy Stulce

Lunch rush was huge but the crew worked fast and line moved quickly. Sandwich was good and just how I ordered it with extra peppers and onions.

Jenna Mondry

Great food and quick service, but the hours at this specific location are very strange (they close at 6pm on Saturdays???). Other than that, a great location, and super convenient for shows at the Riverside Theater.

Aaron Schulz

Great food and staff very friendly.

Brosian

Amazing! Double meat option recommended

Dee Dee Joseph

Great Sandwiches and Customer service

Sarah McBride

Quite tasty!

Edward Patterson

I had a grill cheese sandwich and a Coke.

Sulaiman Alsowaina

I loved the tuna flat bread and the beef was not bad at all. People are the friendliest.

Milwaukee Comedy

Very good fast served food

peter rabadi

Great place for sandwiches salads cookies and shakes.

Steven Malone

The Rubin is delicious

Elliott Lewis

Go and try them sandwich

Yara Soto

Best sandwich in the area

Angelic Haliga

Love love love!

David Ransom

Pretty good sandwiches

Scott Stevens

Great for a quick bite for lunch, but be prepared to eat it somewhere else between noon and one

Cameron Kollath

Slow delivery, orders often incorrect or poorly made, and they have had incorrect information on their website regarding soup availability on more than one occasion. Edit: Lowered my review to 2 stars. Currently 30 minutes past my scheduled delivery time on my most recent order. Pretty much unacceptable.

Miranda I

The food is fantastic and although the prices are a bit higher than other sandwich shops, the quality of the food is worth it. When I went, the line was long but an employee was there to take your sandwich order ahead of time. It probably took about six minutes to get through the line. Potbelly's is a definite go to for a delicious sandwich!

Carly White

Great employees and customer service. Great sandwiches too!:)

Diane Gray

They have good subs here. It can get crowded around lunch and very limited dining area

Clayton Bohannon

Great sandwiches, soups and salads.

Patricia Adams

Turducken. Turducken. Is it turkey? Is it duck? I don't know but it was better than tenderloin.

Courtney Johnson

People were nice half food order was ok, Slow service though wasted half of my lunch break for order that was called in 20 mins ahead I arrived and order was still not ready had to wait 15 mins more which pretty much blew my lunch break and sandwich was dry but Will think about patronizing again

Gage

After stopping in, and debating if I wanted to weather the line that extended 1/3rd of the way to the door, while paying the deliciously, mildly justifiable $8 on only a half sub.. I left to find somewhere else close by to eat that wouldn't be such a long wait and not as pricey. The McDonald's was too far, and I swore Subway off years ago. I kinda have to watch what I spend most times, being a millennial and growing up in the times of freelancing jobs and struggling with ADD, leaves spending a liiittle tight. So when I do give in and treat myself to my favorite sandwich joint, which even being a rewards member, my smiles (Potbelly's rewards points) always expire before I get to use them (maybe that tells you how not so often I get to enjoy Potbelly) I really expect it to be great, or atleast just as good as the other Potbelly experiences I've been thankful to enjoy. Getting to the point: I did end up back at this location after unsuccessfully finding another bite to eat close by, and thankfully the line died down extensively, though the shift leader was basically the only one working, (despite the nearly 20 Team Members sitting at all the tables (must've been training?)) who asks me what I wanted to eat, prepared it after taking payment and then was still confused as to what I wanted (all the regular toppings).. That kitchen was a disaster, I understand rushes in fast casual dining better than the next guy, which is maybe why I'm seemingly also so critical in my review of this location, but atleast that kept me distracted from the price. Until I ate my sandwich of course.. Was quite dissapointing, maybe I was thrown off by the debacle that I didn't enjoy it as much, or what I fear the most is that maybe Potbelly has changed since I was last there 4 months ago..? Don't know if I'll ever find out.. And maybe it's a sign that I couldn't scan for my smiles with my purchase because she couldn't figure out how to get it working.. But it's all good I guess. I'd still reccomend due to the popularity I witnessed that day and how different the average consumer's taste is these days, especially in Milwaukee.. ✌

Dean Johnston

Good sandwich

J V

Best sandwiches around!

Laura E Coa

Good price

Manessa Rash

Greatttttttt

Kiryama Thadison

Just wasn't feeling it

J K

Pb tries hard, good subs.

Dominick Riesland

Good sandwich shop

alicia baldwin

Great sandwhiches and the soup is good also.

Liam Fruzyna

Friendly staff, it's potbelly what's not to like

Brooklyn

Sandwich poorly made, hardly no meat and veggies, this is the third time buying food at this location and my sandwiches were not made properly. Will not visit this location again

Alina Johansson

Clean, friendly

CykoMF Harley

Good sandwiches, friendly staff.

Jean Jordan

Love the wreck salad...so much meat and yummy dressing.

Steve Blubaugh

Great sandwiches. We always enjoy a potbelly

Weston Hall

Great place! They gave me a free cookie for my first time being there. The sub was great.

Francisco Dubious

awesome sandwiches and soups

Alan Davis

It was okay.

Teacher of spanish

Very good

Jake Wolfe

Yummy yummy in my tummy Hecka good foood

Michael Goetzman

Average sandwich place

Mike Rechel

So good. Great customer service

Megan Palmer

Very friendly service. Tried a new sandwich was not sure what to add and the gentleman behind the counter took the time to help me decide what was best.

Dan

Fantastic food, excellent service. Keep up the great work!

Jackie Vensel

Always a treat to get Potbelly's!

GREG SHEA

Excellent food good food good customer service

TANYA SMITH

Love it!!!

Sultan Nafeesha

Great

Christine Nowak

Nice place for a quick sandwich.

Wayne Simmons

Quick service. Great food

J Tech

friendly staff, great food, great place. Bring your wallet.

Lidaydra Linyard

Chocolate banana shakes!!! Need I say any more people!!!!!

David Fritzke

Great hot sandwich

Jim Ronayne

Very good sandwich...and quick too

Mike Ziegler

Took a long time to order, got the order wrong twice but it did still taste good. 30-40 min affair.

Melissa Cain

The employees at this potbelly were very rude and the sandwich that I received was not made properly I like potbelly but I will never go to this location ever again I'll stick to the Brookfield location

Lina Campbell

Upbeat atmosphere, tasty fresh food, & great customer service.

joel lobb

Good value and sandwich

Shannon LaBarre

I am surprised to see such good reviews at this basic sandwich shop. I had never been to a Potbelly, but see them all over the country, so thought I would try. It was only ok. I tried the customer favorite, which was advertised as the item they had to bring back due to popular demand, the pastrami sandwich. It was bland, nothing special at all. Maybe I will try again to see if I got a bad sandwich.

Michael Kapfhamer

Great sandwiches and pleasant staff!

Amanda Dawabsheh

I come here about once a week. The food is always great and the staff are very friendly.

Joshua Dalton

Mediterranean with chicken is full of flavor...quick staff, good prices.

Kyle Salewski

I always enjoy Pot Belly's sandwiches and this location is very nice as well. They need to stop charging an extra $0.50 to add 3 slices of cucumbers to your sandwich though...

Lizandra Rivera

Great

Shaun Booth

Run of the mill sandwich shop. Overpriced but tasty sandwich if you aren't worried about money.

Andrew Stoginski

Always a great food option when I'm working downtown. Never had a bad experience, and top notch service.

Apryl Leonard

I love it

Sean House

I had a spare hour on a business trip to wander around Milwaukee and find somewhere for lunch. I didn't want the regular chain stores. This place fit the bill perfectly; good atmosphere, good food, friendly staff - ideal for lunch.

Linda Brent

Sometimes after you haven't been at a restaurant for a while you go back and then you remember why you liked it so much. That's what Potbelly's is all about. I forgot how delicious their subs are and how incredibly happy and wonderful their staff is. They say hello and thank you ... what a concept.

Shawn Duket

Affordable and delicious sandwiches. The soup is really good and the shakes are amazing. One of my favorite places to eat.

Davidson Kane

Good sandwiches

Molly Murphy

I've had Potbelly sandwiches twice in my life, and the food was never impressive. I guess a good place if it is convenient, but I personally wouldn't go here for a quality sandwich.

Analisa Peterson

Nice place

Bill Edlebeck II

Beef and cheese sandwich was a little dry, macaroni and cheese was great, little tiny malt was the perfect size.

Brad Serdan

Great sandwiches, gotta love they Zapp's Potato Chips offered in Milwaukee.

Brooke Meitz

The customer service at this location is fantastic. I always leave feeling like a happy, appreciated customer! My order is always correct, without fail, and the employees are the nicest in the city. Highly recommended!

Katie Wolak

Great Midwest sandwich joint. Small cozy corner location with 20ish tables and the potential for live music. The staff is always friendly. Get there before noon or the line is almost out the door-but well worth the wait!

Tricia Vine

Always a fun time! The theme and decor are entertaining, and the staff is very nice. Good drinks, if not a bit pricey. Definitely a place to check out in Milwaukee!

Mauriem Mananga

One of my top sandwiches spot

Issa INTJ

Consistently great customer service. Their shakes are the best!

Tod Jaymes

Excellent food, and even though it was crowded for lunch, the line moved fast and I was helped promptly.

Matt Waggoner

Potbelly's is always a good place to eat. Good atmosphere and good food.

jason schutta

This store always has incredibly fast service and a great team working during the lunch rush. I would recommend getting there before noon to beat the lunch rush.

Ginamarie Athy

The food was delicious,it was all served fresh,good quality ingredients,great bread,fast service and very friendly staff,I will be back,can't say enough good things about this place,and to think I meant to order the chicken breast sandwich and accidentally said Chicken salad sub sandwich,that was a tasty mistake :)

Jim Kopps

My favorite chain sub shop

Robert Seefeld

Fun to sit and see the old photos on the walls. Reasonably priced and clean. Friendly staff. Go by yourself or with the family. Free parking.

Jack Kuczynsky

Convenient location, Good sandwiches, Friendly staff!

Sheresa Lindsey

Very friendly people. Delicious soups and sandwiches.

Alicia Thomas

Delicious àll the way around

Craig Reasoner

Fantastic food!!!

James Stedl

Good sandwiches, lines can be long at lunch

McKenzie Driscoll

Come to atlanta please Potbelly! Love those strawberry shakes

Vanessa Leflore-negron

Loved the live entertainment!!!

Donald Krause

Fast, hot and delicious subs

Keanna Hibbler

Food is absolutely delicious! Definitely will visit again.

Danny Hughes

Awesome. I'll go back and get a pocket sandwich for later.