Reviews of Out & Out Eatery and Catering (Catering)

Lisa Wheeler

I loved the food here. It's so simple, but great. They focus on a few specific items and make it very casual and fun. Loved the custard!

Thomas Schroeder

Amazing experience at out & out. I would highly recommend eating here. They have delicious food and even better icecream

Gianni Giorgi

Really good, high quality food! The service is top notch as well. Highly recommend!

Lori Poull

Great custard and sandwich. And dog friendly patio.

Andrew Post

Love supporting a local restaurant, especially when they do great comfort food. Staff is always upbeat and friendly.

Peter Mueller

Got to have the burgers

jason prochnow

Good food, served with a friendly staff

David Ralston

Great sandwiches, great soup and great service but the only reason for the 4 is that there mac and cheese tasted like powdered cheese. Good mac and cheese is a hard sale in Wisconsin, standards are strick must be from roux.

Sonya Larson

Better than fast food, great place to pop in for something kid or adault friendly in a pinch of time.

Julie Allongue

Staff was friendly, service quick, and food good. Next time we'll sit at a checkerboard table and play.

Paul Rozeski

Enjoyed the thai quinoa bowl. Cool tables and walls paneled with old bleachers. They don't serve burgers.

patti odell dooley

THE BEST mac & cheese! From the regular mac & cheese to the chicken buffalo blue cheese, they are all heavenly!! I also highly recommend the chili!

Zach Moore

First time visiting. It was supreme! Only problem was lines, but considering the size of the shop, that's to be expected

Sarah Legate

Amazing food, friendly service. Staff were excited to answer questions and wait on us. Getting their catering in a few weeks!

mark engman

Great Americanos for all of us in America!

Jeffrey Liker

Simply sensational. Each time I go here, I'm greeted with great customer service and exceptional food. The Mac and cheese and cake batter shakes are dynamite.

Deborah Paegelow

Good food, healthy options,

Ann Griffin

We stopped today because the food is great and we can dine outside with our dog.

Terry Buck

Excellent food. Pecan chop salad is outstanding!

Laira Biestaad

The kids who work here , work hard! It’s very busy ( the food is so good) and these kids keep up the pace.

Matt Bramm

One of my favorite places in Cedarburg. The chicken bacon wrap always hits the spot and if you want a cool treat ask for a raspberry slushy with the fruit mixed in.

Helen Oszuscik

Great wraps, sandwiches, salads. Our favorite item though is the Mac and cheese with veggies. Frozen Custard treats are on the menu too.

Sarah Bloemer

MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE RESTAURANT IN WISCONSIN. The mac n cheese is to die for and we always pic some up whenever we are having a family dinner. Everthing else is amazing as well. Also the custard is here is pretty great. And the drinks are amazing, there is a huge selection!! I normally get a cherry slushie but the different things I have seen my friends get are always super fun!! this is my go to restaurant whenever my friends want to go somewhere even though it is a good 15 minutes away. always worth it.

Mitch V

Great small business, one of a few places I can find a Cubano sandwich, which is fantastic. On my to-do list when in the area is to stop here and get one.

James Engstrom

They have a good selection of sandwichs and soups as well as vanilla and chocolate custard with a large selection of topping.

Erin Paske

Nice place for a healthy wrap and tasty chocolate malt.

Todd Dicker

I've driven past this place a thousand times, finally went in and was blown away by how good it is. Well prepared, innovative menu with healthy and decadent options. The smells and tastes were incredible. I had the Thai peanut quinoa bowl and it was FANTASTIC! I will be back many times!

Amy Mozey

We used them to cater my daughter’s casual wedding at a barn venue in West Bend. I would highly recommend them. The food was amazing and everyone raved about it. The staff was so friendly and professional. Awesome company to work with.

Austin Winkler

Stopped here after my bike ride. Excellent food, short wait times and quality service. If you have any allergies, they try to be as accommodating as possible. I've heard that their service for gluten-free customers is very good.

A Plus

My favorite thing to order is the Americano or the veggie (hummus) wrap.

Daniel Duffy

Are you looking for solid "take out food" in a cheerful diner? This is your place. The crowd is delightfully mixed from high school dates to families and older couples. What many locals do not realize is that this restaurant serves some of the best catered food around. The menu is wide ranging and you can count on generous helpings of excellent food for a reasonable price. They will quickly put together a lunch or dinner for your work place or party that will satisfy everyone.

Austin B

Love this eatery. Exquisite recipes, plus some classics like mac n cheese. Great vibe, artistic decor, especially the Chuck Weber mural, great prices. Excellent soup, sandwich and chatting place in wonderful Cedarburg.

Dan Martin

Food is great, always fresh.

Timmy Deutsch

The Americano sandwich is amazing! You can't go wrong with the mac n cheese either!

Moses Nettles Jr.

Great food and fantastic customer service. Not a big seating area so get here asap!

Tony B

Great little cafe. Reasonable prices. Good selection. Try the turkey cranberry wrap.

Joshua James

Great and quick. The staff seemed a little "in their own world" but that's okay. Every sandwich ive had has been delish. Custard was pretty tight too. Great place to hang during the summer.

abigail pachuta

We used Out&out to cater our wedding and were extremely happy with the staff as well as the food. The braised beef short ribs were amazing and the mac 'n' cheese was a favorite for sides. I would highly recommend!

Lu Desteli

Large order of 4 Mac and cheese, 3 large salads with dressings, toppings, and a serving apparatus with fuel to keep the Mac warm prepared and packeged on time on a Sunday. Food was tasty.

Benjamin Nolte

Excellent custard. Mac and cheese was OK. Neat place.

Lauren Wolf

The soup they have is amazing and the Mac and cheese is really good. Good sandwiches and wraps also.

Alexis Barber

almost cried of happiness when i saw everything has a gluten free option. The food is so good!!!

Veronica Woods

Healthy and Fast! Great place for take out!

Chris Maertz

I love the concept and layout of this place. The ambiance and ice cream are great. The food is okay. The vast majority of the food is pre-made and packaged and then microwaved once purchased. Within our group of 10 people, there were at least 4 orders which were either not fully heated or were very inconsistently heated. The menu is promising, the service is fine and the treats are great. But, the heating of the food needs to be corrected.

Carol Hoffmann

Eaten here many times. Food is always delicious, service is great. If this place was in my hometown I'd be there every day.

Patricia Unti

Turkey & cranberry wrap delicious, vegetable soup, very good. Prices reasonable.

Spencer Gull

a better fast food experience. gluten free options, all a+ taste

Adam Werner

Quick bite at a low price. The Mac N Cheese is delicious and they have a lot of variations available. Their custard is comprable to Kopps. There is also Quinoa Salas and wraps. No fries but they have chips.

Stephen Kowal

Good food and fair prices make this place a solid value stop for getting food. My wife loves their mac n cheese.

deb longmier

Great raspberry lemonade!!

Brandon Pokey

The food is pretty good and you get quite a bit of food for the price. I would definitely recommend it.

Tyler Hewitt

The gluten free mac and cheese brought mr back to the days when I could eat easy mac.

Sarah Neuburg

Love the taste and quality of the food. Super fresh.

Charlie Fazzari

This place has pretty good food served very quickly. The staff here has been friendly so far, haven't heard many complaints. I really do enjoy the way this place looks tho, the tables are unique and the paintings add a certain charm. Think of it as a classy fast food place, a step above classics like McDonald's

Adrian D

Good food, fast service, good price, good location!

JAMES MANNES

Very good food. I had a nice soup too.

B Lovrek

So good! The mac n cheese is definitely worth the trip.

Gregg Lengling

Great wraps and paninis. Check out their great catering

Michael K.

Great food, nice location, nice staff.

Corey Hesselman

Fantastic place! A great little restaurant with great food and fast service. definitely one to put on your list if you haven't already!

John Curnutt

The food here was apparently an afterthought cuz it's never really good; not bad, just not really good The shakes aren't anything to brag about either. But it's local, convenient, and not a corporation, so go

Joseph Brunnquell

Great food and service. No complaints. A great place for a quick bite to eat.

Amanda Lallensack

Out & Out is a great place to grab a bite to eat. It is one of my favorite places to stop at when I'm in the area. The sandwiches are fantastic and you really can't go wrong with any choice you make.

Paige Wiesend

Cannot wait for our wedding. This food and service is awesome.

George Barton

Best custard stand I know. The menu is a nice change from the standard burger and fries custard stand menu with great salads, panini, BBQ bowls and their Mac n Cheese bowls. Add to that the 3 topping mix-ins that come with the custard and Out &Out can't be beat.

randumb1

We used Out and Out to cater our wedding in September and it was honestly one of the best parts of our busy day. The food was great as always and it was warm. We had so many compliments that day on how great the food was. To me that is important at a wedding and that is why I chose Out and Out. I wanted real food that I knew was going to taste great. When my husband and I look back on our big day we honestly say that our food was some of the best we have had at a wedding. I would highly recommend Out and Out for any catering and of course to go eat at. I already did send over a coworkers son and daughter for their wedding this coming year. I know they will be just as happy as we are. Thank you again Out and Out and Jackie you guys rock!!!!!!

Deeleen Sawyer

Great place for food that is wonderful for kids and adults of all ages. Reasonable prices too. Check it out!

Laurie Henkel

Food was delicious. We tried the turkey cranberry wrap and chicken bacon ranch wrap. The shakes are awesome too.

Monica Cooley

Best mac and cheese in the North Shore area. Quick service, cute interior, can take out or eat in. Original mac is my favorite, but can't go wrong with any of the specialty macs! Americano sandwich is also a treat.

Brian Seehafer

Mac n cheese, sandwiches, quinoa and Custard!

Jason Schmidt

Great Mac & Cheese. Fast Service with a smile. One of my favorite lunch spots during the work week.

Lindsey Carlisle

Large quantities and good food!

Gary Nice

Great Mac and cheese, large portion, cranberry turkey wrap is big, at least a foot long and tastes delicious. Prices are very reasonable.

Carl P

Friendly staff, relaxed atmosphere, and some of the tastiest Mac n Cheese around! Wraps, sandwiches, and all kinds of Frozen Custard round out the menu. They are very accommodating of dietary restrictions . Tons of character in the dining area and a great outdoor patio for summer months and braver patrons. Oh, and quality catering too!

jeanne M

One of my favorite stops. Fresh and lots of variety including veggies and gluten free options

Jasmine Neuser

Such great mac and cheese! Cozy and modern inviting atmosphere. Try the custard shakes!

Chris Harnevious

GREAT FOOD, SERVICE WAS AWESOME!!

nikolas giuliani

Always have great food. The mac and cheese is a must try for first timers! Don't forget to leave room for some yummy custard as well. Disclaimer: this establishment does not sell burgers as some might think. They do however have delicious paninis and wraps. I make sure to stop by every time I am in town. Keep up the good work!

Athena Big Mountain

Excellent Pecan Chopped Salad! Their Ham and Bean soup is absolutely delish! The service was great too!

Katie Boyer

Amazing food! Love the Mac and cheese. S'mores custard is always my fave but can't go wrong with the frozen lemonades

Michael Toll

Really nice menu. The southwest quinoa bowl was amazing. The tables and other decorations were all repurpose. The table tops were from a Racine art room showing many years of love. Look for the hidden goodies in the tables.

Jordynn Holtan

Love this place, although the change in menu did take away some of my favorite options and wasn’t impressed with their replacements. Bring back the Italian sandwich! Only place I would order Mac n cheese, way better than Panera!

Evan Chamberlain

Pretty good most of the time. The mac n cheese has been on the cool side a few times as I'm sure its reheated.

John H

It was nothing spectacular nor nothing that I would go back for either. Average food at best.

Joseph Conley

Pretty solid, not amazing but not regretable by any means.

Leah Husemoen

LOVE. LOVE. LOVE. This place. Best mac and cheese, and it is like a cheaper version of panera. Very affordable prices for GREAT food.

Erin Notson

My husband and I chose to use Out & Out as our caterer for our wedding at the Schlitz Audubon Nature Center. We wanted food that was interesting, different, and representative of us as “foodies”. We decided to have a barbecue theme to go along with our summer wedding and it was absolutely perfect. The food was hot and delicious, and we received numerous compliments from our guests. We really enjoyed the buffet style food service and the team did a great job keeping things organized and efficient. From our initial meeting, tastings, phone conversations, and the day of our wedding, the entire team was incredibly professional, helpful, and supportive. Multiple team members came up to me during the reception to ensure that everything was going as planned, which meant so much. I can’t say enough positive things about Out & Out!

Brad Schacht

Been going to Out & Out for years. Now that I live in Milwaukee it's been more difficult to make the trip, but I went the other day and it is still as good as it used to be. Great little spot for a date or a quick bite with friends. Really nice outdoor eating section. One of the best mac and cheese's in the area!

Alastair Samuel

A great family friendly pace to eat. Gluten free options. Delicious homemade soups and chili. Mac & Cheese is their speciality. With lots of unique and delicious variations. They also do fine wraps and sandwiches. Finish off with a decadent sundae, made with frozen custard. For those not in the know: frozen custard is a richer form of ice cream (because ice cream is not rich enough!!) made with egg yolks.

Ally C

Second time in a row they've messed up their own menu. Chicken bacon ranch wrap but they forget tomato provolone and ranch?? Should be renamed dry meat with lettuce and wrapped. Very unfortunate because I usually love this place.

Lisa Kalmerton

Yummy!

Danny Norris

A unique fast food concept restaurant. The menu is well thought out with tasty offerings that come out pretty quickly from the kitchen. I had one of their more common selections, the Classic Cuban which was good, however not really outstanding. I also tried the soup which was very good but not served hot enough in my opinion. I was impressed that the manager (owner?), came by specifically to ask how we liked their unique approach (it was Russian potato with green beans). To that showed a real interest in the customer experience and in gathering information in order to tweak the menu.

Thomas DeRosa

Good food, fast service and friendly staff

Mandy Whitaker

Custard was excellent, service was fast and friendly, and the decor took us on a walk down memory lane.

Erik Freeman

Fantastic sandwiches! Friendly and quick service along with a clean dining area, made for a great time.

Anthony Abts

By far the best place in WI for mac n cheese!

Jason Rumohr

Good food, had the buffalo chicken mac & cheese and liked it a lot.

Jory Pradjinski

Great food, wonderful atmosphere.

William Loughlin

Love the fast service. The chicken bacon wrap is good. Love the Cuban sandwich.

Gwenn R

Got a salad that was the perfect portion and they definitely don’t skimp on the toppings. You can “create your own ice cream” by selecting up to 3 mix-ins which was slightly misleading as the mix-ins were really toppings like a sundae. Still delicious either way.

Amber Schmidt

Great atmosphere. Good food. Amazing ice cream

Angela Carian

Great location with extensive menu selections and surprising finds for the gluten free and vegetarian populace. Gracious, prompt service staff work hard to make the most of a small order window and, at times, long lines. Reasonable portions for the prices. It's not just custard, folks!

Michael Schmitz

Don't eat here. I got the fresh veggie Mac and cheese and it was absolutely the worst Mac and cheese I had eaten in a LONG time. First when I saw them nuking the food in a microwave I was instantly turned off, why not take some extra time and make it fresh. Second they put this nacho cheese sauce on it before sending it to North Korea to be nuked. Once served, the dish was way to hot to even eat, the sauce turned into water and fell to the bottom of container. The taste resembles Kraft Mac n cheese. But even that might be to much of a compliment. the person I was with got an American cheese grilled cheese we did not like it. Why not use better and different cheese because American is just yuck. The kitchen manager wearing a black shirt was upset because they ran out of something and we heard her swear through the window. we did not eat more than %10 of our food and feel bad as we spent almost $15. This was our first time eating here and probably our last. save your time and money and eat somewhere else.

Amalia Jording

Great food! Love this place! Highly recommend!

Samantha McCarthy

Best mac & cheese! Quinoa bowls are delish, great staff!

Carole Giersch

Lovely night enjoying a friendly game if checkers! With a perfect hot fudge sundae.

Pamela Schwalbach

My kids love this place!! A great healthy option!

Jen Locke

One of the best bowls of mac & cheese you'll ever eat. Great sandwiches, too. And they have good-tasting gluten-free options if you need them. Good shakes and malts. And they have Sprite! My all-time favorite lemon-lime soda. I highly recommend it.

Kaitlyn Thode

The Mac and Cheese was very good, but I was thoroughly disappointed in their Turkey Cranberry Wrap. The greens to meat ratio was not balanced. Way to may greens to very little meat. First picture is my sandwich, second picture is a screenshot from their photos on Google maps.

Emma Nelson

I haven't tried a single thing on their menu that isn't good. Even the new vegan Quinoa bowls are absolutely spectacular. They also offer catering and boxed lunches which we've ordered for work events. They are very easy to work with.

Katie Brister

So many gluten free options!! They have the best prices and best custard.

Patrick White

Excellent job and amazing service

Abby J

Try the mac and cheese! I look forward to coming here, the place has both comfort and healthy food options with a neat atmosphere and friendly employees.

Rita Pampel

One-of-a-kind eatery with tasty sandwiches, wraps, salads, and the best macaroni and cheese! Gluten free options as well! Yummy custard for dessert. Awesome food and service for catered events as well!

Sahara Adams

DELICIOUS! Very fast service at a GREAT price as well.

Robert Barkley

Deliciousness in a bowl. Great Mac n cheese, frozen lemonade and shakes are awesome too

Melissa Zimmer

First thought was that workers kinda seemed dead. But I can understand it. Anyways, I really enjoyed the Mac&Cheese I got. It's a nice atmosphere as well. The outdoor seating did seem a bit nicer than indoor.

Erin Alexa Sotelo

The food is really good and the service is good too. The restaurant looks very nice and clean. Just wish that the nutritional information was available and not just the ingredients so that I wouldn’t have to try and guess for myself. Overall, a great restaurant and I definitely recommend it.

Katy Dietrich

Great salads. Great value.

Cheryl Kuebler

Amazing food and custard! Super fresh! Clean and neat. It’s a favorite place to us!

Denise Wamser

Consistency with fresh food fast, and super easy going staff.

Wally Stefan

A wonderful place. Everything is delicious!

Dee Joy Leroux

Service was good and the food was delicious!!

Nordi Kat

4.5 stars. Known for their varieties of tasty Mac and Cheese. Great Frozen Custard with a wide variety of toppings. Would have given 5 stars; however order taker apolegetically made several mistakes.

Tweetie

Fast service. Good food with affordable prices. Can order by phone for later pick up. Great hangout place.

Amy Harnevious

Really good food, will never stop going there.

Brianna Schwanbeck

Great food! If only they would stop using SO MUCH plastic. I hope they will eventually become more environmentally conscious

,Dianna Olnhausen

Good, reasonably priced food, pleasant casual, clean eating area--excellent ice cream--all in a downtown made for exploring.

Jordan Radick

Good food terrible service. Cashier was awful to people. Asked for a soda made me wait at the window instead of just turning around and grabbing it. Never the one to do this but she made me feel like a problem just making an order. Just don't expect the people to be nice. Good food though.

MARY RENTSCHER

Not your run-of-the-mill menu, with consistently good food and nice atmosphere

Wyatt Yst

Great food, great place. The only problem is the chess board tables face the wrong way.

Michael Kokta

Mac n cheese is awesome here!

Bridget Lorenz lemberg

Great Raspberry smoothie and lunch panini!

Alison Bicek

Always amazing food and service to match!

Jack Ziegler

Unique menu for a fast (healthy) food place. Atmosphere is great.

Michael Dugan

Fantastic place to eat!

William Braun

Delicious.

Peter Giersch

Great food, unique offerings. Not the regular burger and fries. You can go comfort food or go healthy. And great custard options that you can customize.

David Hanschke

Great service and wonderful food!

Loren Gehr

I LOVE this place. The Mac and cheese is something I'll find myself craving. I usually get the bacon carbonara Mac that's got peas, fried onions piece and bacon layered on top of their already delicious Mac. They're usually busy, but orders always come out in a timely matter and this place is always clean. If you love Mac and cheese, give this place a try! If not, they have wraps, sandwiches and salads that are also delicious. Not to mention their specials of the day are usually pretty great too!

Ashley Smith

I can't say enough how much I love this place. I drive out of my way to grab some mac & cheese and some ice cream any time I'm in the 'area'. The service is always friendly and everything is always tasty. Cake batter shakes are my all time favorite here. If you are looking for a place for a quick but tasty lunch or a sweet treat, this should be your next stop.

Kelly Kabitzke

Great food and prices!

Cynthia DeGroot

Great selection of tasty gluten free options. Friendly staff. Outdoor seating when weather allows. Always seems to be busy. Highly recommend!

Sam Collins

Great food and better ice cream! I remember when out and out didnt have an inside area, when it was a little shack, and I would say the remodel was done amazingly, food only got better !

kay ramthun

Great gluten free mac n cheese!!!

Kelsey Uuskallio

Americano with extra garlic sauce 100%

Ellen Swanson

To start the staff is very nice, attentive and makes you feel good. These kids do not fool around, they all work together, which is hard to say these days.

Mark Mitchelson

The Classic Cuban and Americno sandwiches shouldn't be skipped.

T Weba

great food, great prices and friendly staff. I always get the tuna wrap and my kids love the mac and cheese.

Kyle Dunfee

I always love out and out. Even when they are super busy, they bust good food out quickly.

Elle Govek

Amazing food. I have never been disappointed.

Bob Monroe

Really good food in a great location.

Phillip Strobel

My wife & I again shared two wraps: 1) Veggie, 2) Tuna. Nice & fresh & loaded & quick! Nice people. Newer place. Next door to our newer Commerce State bank. Walkable from our house. Delicious!! $11.60 total pre-tip.

Maxwell Blooming

Great food for little money

Hoff Family

We loved the mac'n cheese options. Yummy custard for dessert!

Andrew Mattick

Food was just okay. Open kitchen concept gives you full view of the half dozen microwaves your food is made in... atmosphere was nice.