Reviews of Broken Tree Pizza (Catering)

124 W Wisconsin Ave #170, Neenah, WI 54956, United States

Average Rating:


Here you will be able to see all the opinions of real people like you who are purchasing the services of Broken Tree Pizza (Catering) around Wisconsin area.

At this moment the business has a rating of 4.6 over 5 and that rating has been based on 436 reviews.

You must have seen that the average of ratings that it reaches is practically the best one, and it's founded on a very high number of scores, so we can think that the score is very reliable. If many people have bothered to value when they are happy with the business, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to give feddbacks when they are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Catering corresponds to the category of Pizza restaurant.

Where is Broken Tree Pizza?

REVIEWS OF Broken Tree Pizza IN Wisconsin

Jake Duquaine

People are great, food is great, but the all-you-can-eat pizza bar should be more days :)

Drew K

Excellent... Crust thin and wonderful flavor. I forgot how good sauce could be. I could on and on... But I now have a new place to go to replace Frank's

Lois Dunn

Best pizza in town, bar none! Brick oven pizzas, unique menu (not your typical pizza varieties), great beer menu, friendly staff, and the freshest pizzas around. Live entertainment on certain nights, prime location and an attached ice cream shop make Broken Tree the best!

Jessica Vlach

Would definitely recommend! The front of house manager is awesome and was extremely attentive! My water glass was never empty! He had delicious suggestions for drinks when we were indecisive and was very accommodating. Also had an excellent sense of humor! We will definitely be coming back due to his welcoming customer service (and the food)! Keep up the excellent work!

Jen H

Such an amazing place! They have a wide assortment of wood fired pizzas for all tastes. They also have a beer and wine selection and can even make a mixed drink for you. I sincerely don’t think I have had a bad pizza from here. Highly recommend the broken basil sticks!!

Manat Tiptanatoranin

Great variety of pizza for all you can eat luncheon on weekdays. Quick and easy in and out.

Victor Voss

Stone fired pizza is really good, nice lunch pizza buffet

Breanna Baumgartner

Never been disappointed. They have many unique pizzas. During the week they have a lunch pizza buffet and usually have at least one unique pizza. We keep getting the chicken artichoke one. It's delicious. Two adults will definitely polish off one of their pizzas and could probably eat a salad as well. The sauce has just a hint of heat to keep it interesting. The pizza is hand tossed crust consistency, ends up pretty thin but not crispy. The outer crust is nice and pillowy. They are usually quick. Service is friendly and attentive. If you go there regularly I'm sure you would get to know them. We go there pretty rarely and they recognize us. Kid friendly. Kind of small so on music nights or weekends you might not get a table. Very nice cozy casual atmosphere.


Amazing food and amazing. Will definitely be back!!

Kathy Blumenberg

Great food and service!! Usually get your pizza within a few minutes. They take great pride in the cleanliness and look of the restaurant. I always feel like they care about you and take the time to answer your questions and are knowledgeable about the drink options. Both dinner and lunch have been excellent! Johnny is great!

David Dodge

Great Food! Great Service

Megan Charais

Incredible crust and delicious topping combinations made this a place we'll be sure to return to! A great casual family atmosphere and excellent service.

Dani Marie

The pizza was kind of floppy; it tasted like pita bread with cheese. Our server was nice, but overly involved with our dinner conversations, as we were reuniting.

Jason Hall

Excellent! Service was prompt and the server (John?)was friendly. Not only good service for us (the $24.99 crew

roman c

First time here had the Margarita Pizza and it was amazing. that wood fired oven brings a whole new flavor to your pizzas. Good atmosphere for friends family and kids. Also pretty good selection in wines

Damien Green

Went twice during a three day trip in Neenah! I got the buffet the second time and was blown away! I knew from the earlier visit that the pizza was good but the buffet opened up a whole new level. The staff was cranking out quality pizzas at an incredible pace. Everything was very flavorful the ambiance with the wood fire oven was another added plus.

Katie Peacock Frielund

Amazing pizza that had soft and fluffy crust full of flavor and the ice cream made an awesome ending to the night!

Melissa Garcia

Good pizza nice friendly employess

Gabriella Jansen

The absolute best pizza in all of Wisconsin. I can go here knowing my food is made with care, and with FRESH ingredients. Friendly owners and employees that put great effort into awesome food. Highly recommend to anyone who looks for high quality and excellent taste.

Shawn Kipp

Road tripping from Wyo for a packers game and found this pizza place close to the hotel and.... Wow! Best damn pizza place I've been to.. Chipotle chicken pizza was amazing! Highly recommended

Domingo Camarena

Saddest "Chicago style steak sandwich" ever. Tasted like cardboard, no flavor whatsoever. Next time I'll just get one from dominoes

Wyatt Bittner

A little red haired fool was serving me, but did amazing, he was spectacular with his baking technique. I will definitely be back and giving this leprechaun boy a huge tip.

Alexandra Miller

The pizza was great and live music was awesome. The service was just a little slow. Other than that, great place to grab dinner!

Prerak V. Shah

It was a good experience and the server was attentive. I ordered Vegetarian calzone and it turned up pretty delicious..

Patty Block

4 different kinds of sauces and lots of yummy combinations of pizza!

Josh Oshefsky

By far some of the best pizza i have had. If your looking for a quick place to grab lunch or dinner, go here! Their lunch time pizza buffet is excellent.

Troy Schulz

Fantastic gourmet artisan pizzas! They not only taste amazing but look great! The staff is really friendly and outgoing and not afraid to make recommendations. They offer free samples of their on tap brews if you are undecided on what beer to drink. Be prepared, though. All pizzas are the same size and enough for one person (or two if you and your co-diner aren't that hungry). The cheapest pizza is the base of a build your own and they start at nine bucks, so it's not the cheapest place to eat. But the flavor!!!'s worth it!

Sebastian Hanna-Garcia

Awesome pizza and a fantastic salad bar.

Marisa Tainter

Awesome place we would go back again

Cindy Weyenberg

Always have had a great meal, but not this time. We all had the buffet, pizza was cold and been sitting there awhile. It was another 20 minutes before another one was brought out, and another 10 minutes when a few more came out.

Daniel Portelli

Great place to go for lunch with buffet style pizza. Pizza is mostly artisan, but with your standard options as well. Modern street look in the heart of Neenah. Would recommend!

Tony Wendt

Spin Arti app was great, came out quickly. Service was quick, great selections for pizzas, crust was a little underdone, never received silverware, would have been a little easier to eat pizza.

Corey Mielke

Absolutely love this place. Amazing Pizza and beer. Staff is super friendly and helpful. If you're thinking of! You'll be very happy and be a repeat customer.

Mitchell Lukasik

My experience here was amazing. The food was great and so was the service. Especially from this little ginger-haired lad. I think his name is Michael and i think his last name started with a "B" but what ever it was, he was fantastic. Tipped him some big time bucks and he definitely deserved them! Can't wait to come back and I hope he is serving!

Chris Smith

Good pizza if you like different flavors

D Schommer

Love this place. Really great wood fired pizza! Very creative menu.

Jace Raver

Fantastic wood fired pizza! Best I've had in Wisconsin so far.

Kandace Bartell

Great food! Must have old fashions! Awesome service!

Ann & Stewart Ellyson

Great (and unique) wood fired pizzas! I like to order mine "crispy"!

Aaron Vandermause

This was my first visit. I like the building and the design of the restaurant. It's very clean and contemporary. The quality of ingredients and flavors was impressive. The menu has a huge variety of pizzas to try. My wife and I ordered pepperoni broken sticks as an appetizer. They were good but not particularly special. If you're planning to order pizza, I would skip these because they are pretty redundant. For pizza, I ordered a BTP Classic and my wife got Velvet Blues. We both loved the foldable thin crust and robust flavors. The wood fired dough is delicious. When considering portion size, we both finished our pizzas and we're not large people. They seem about right for a single portion of you brought an appetite, maybe sharable if you like small portions. Finally, there is an ice cream bar (serving Chocolate Shoppe brand) attached for some fun dessert options. Recommended.

David Knuth

The food was absolutely amazing and super fast and the customer service was out standing

Kathy Hyman

Pizza was very good. Service was good.

Yaritza Lopez

Overpriced. It’s the size of a personal pizza. For wood fire pizza, the crust wasn’t crunchy at all. Pizza was actually soggy in the middle.

Zachary Brown

Restaurant atmosphere is great. Low key ambience and relaxing dining area. We had the Fungi pizza and it was incredible. Amazing crust, one of the best pizzas I've had. Also highly recommend the fire sticks for those that enjoy spicy food!

Sam Bigelow

The menu is very unique! Everything we ordered was amazing, and was ready in 20 minutes! The person we picked up from was friendly and fast - my 2 favorite qualities in a customer service provider! The prices are high for the amount of food (all pizzas are 14 inch and cost as much as a large with 3+ toppings at a chain pizza restaurant), but as a treat it is a must try!

Mark Chamberlain

Always great food at reasonable prices.

Chuck Tomasi

Good lunch buffet

SlumpBuster Tackle

Great brick oven pizza at a reasonable price.

Calvin Meier

Each pizza is handmade and cooked in fire oven, so delicious!

Matthew Stephani

Great handmade pizza! Highly recommend their broken sticks as appetizers too!

Marykate Webber

My friend Fran and I love coming to Broken Tree Pizza. The pizzas are always great and the staff are very accommodating. The wine list is wonderful. We each have a favorite. The beer selections look great! I would recommend Broken Tree to any pizza lover !!!!

Jorgen Carter

Great food! Great ingredients, people and atmosphere makes for pizza that keeps us going back for more. They've also a very good beer and wine selection. It's clear the owners care about the food and service they provide.

Chris Wieneke

Personal size pizzas with good variety of toppings and premade specialities and other options like sandwiches and a salad bar as well. Friendly staff.

Gerald Voigt

Good food and a nice place too. Whether as a couple of a small group, it's a top pick of ours.

Dale Saunders

Tried the lunch buffet, lot of variety but i prefer pizza with a little more sauce.


Our waitress Kayla was super courteous and attentive. Pizza was great. Really busy though, expect to wait for a table.

Brian Gottfried

Great pizza and the waitress Emma was great!

Jesse Ross

Really unique pizza! Arugula, truffle oil, mushrooms and goat cheese was amazing! Plus, they have an ice cream parlor.

JoAnne Kohler

It was fantastic


Descent pizza, good service, comfortable setting. The prices however... $80 bill to feed a family of four. That’s a bit much for “decent” pizza.

Larry Rueff

Great wood-fired pizza! Haven't tried their brunch but will do so soon.

Jeri Zimmermann

Excellent pizza and service! Great dining!

Ralph Angiulli

Excellent pie, sit at the bar and enjoy the pie prep and cooking.

Lori Glassco

Delicious eats, friendly customer service in a cozy atmosphere.

Todd Wood

Good variety on the buffet. Wood fired pizza oven adds flavor. Prices are going up to add a drink or salad bar.

Phillip Schmidt

Great service. The pizzas were well above average but the highlight of the meal was the Basil Broken Bread. I could have made a meal of that alone. It was nice to have a marinara sauce on a pizza that actually had some flavor and spice in it. Makes me want to see what their other sauces are like. I will go back. Might even stop this week to try the lunch buffet.

squeaky boi

Fantastic pizza and a great atmosphere.

Cody Henson

Super awesome pizza and service. Wisco needs more local joints like this!

Matt v

Wood fired pizza

Michelle Eilers

Amazing pizza, great beverage selection, awesome staff... highly recommend trying it out

Steve Randall

Excellent food and nice selection of drinks. Will definitely go again.

Megan Stadler

I used to love going here. At my recent trip on a Thursday afternoon the customer service was non existant. There were 6 employees working and we were told they didnt have a server that day and we would have to get our own silverware and drinks and order at the register, even though there was only one table with 2 people. Weird but we are capable. Then we ordered a breadstick appetizer but received my friends pizza first then 10 minutes later or breadsticks came and another 10 min later my pizza came. The food did not taste as good or fresh as the last time either. I understand I dont know how their company needs to be run or how many employees are needed for tasks but compared to the other 2 times I have been here this was obsurd. I give 2 stars because I have been here before and had outstanding customer service. This day was terrible. I hope they can turn this around but I will not be returning.

Ian Brettell-Adams

My favorite pizza place. Lots of fresh style pizzas and a relaxed atmosphere. The owner is often waiting tables and is a great guy!

Matt Troge

I haven’t had pizza this good since Cafe Porta Alba in Madison. Was on the fence about visiting Broken Tree or Cannova’s and I definitely am not disappointed in my choice. Place looked super cool inside, super busy, but never felt like we had to wait. Great beer selection, energetic and friendly wait staff, oh and then there’s the pizza...... WOW. So many phenomenal ones to choose from! I was happy to take leftovers of my “Pete-Za” home just so I could experience it again the next day. HIGHLY recommended right in the heart of downtown Neenah.

Ezra Schoonover

Every za is amazing. Even custom pizza (veggie fiance) it's great. Superb beer selection. Keep an ear to the ground for live music nights.

Chris Voigt

All the pizzas are 10-12" of delicious handcrafted, wood fired, artesian goodness! Their salads are very good as well!

Nicholas Becker

Excellent Pizza! Good beer selection. I went on $1 off draft night so I of course got that. I had the pet-za was awesome!

June Longoria

Wow! Great pizza. Innovative!

John Weber

The broken sticks are delicious in 1/2 or full order. Pizza is deliciously simple. Service was impeccable.

Nick Hawley

Very good service, pepperoni sticks, and pizza crust. It has a cool atmosphere as well. Only giving it 4 stars because I wasn’t a huge fan of the pizza sauce. I’ll be back to try one of their sandwiches

M Jaws67

Awesome! Best pizza in The Fox Cities!

g t

Great food and friendly staff!

Angie Pappas

Very good food, great staff

Kevin Mahar

Great pizza! Very good local beer selection.

Benjamin Phelps

Good beer selections. Good calzone.

Mason Lawrenz

This place is awesome! Great prices, great service and amazing pizza.

Jeff Cloninger

Great time at Broken Tree. Very family friendly, great pizza, interesting beer on tap. Staff was all very friendly. We had a selection of pizzas and while none were the best we'd ever had all were very good and I'd say the best we've had in the Fox Valley (I'm a sucker for wood fired pizza though.) 6 taps weren't a huge selection but all 6 were interesting and provided a good selection. We'll definitely be back soon.

Peter Bermudez

High quality pizza, expertly fashioned, reasonably priced

Stephanie Hahn

Pizza is always so darn good! Love it, my favorite pizza

Susan Anderson

First time visiting. Great friendly service and great food. Stopped for an ice cream after.

john litzau

The pizza's were very good and the waitstaff attentive to our needs. The reason for 3 stars was the kid's meal. We ordered Mac & Cheese for our 2 year old, which came with apple sauce and milk. Price was steep at $7 but figured it was quality mac and cheese--we were wrong. The mac and cheese was at best boxed stuff you get at store for $0.75. Would like to rate higher but the kid's meal really felt like a rip-off.

Kenya Heskett


Jacob Odell

Not your typical buffet! Turnover is so fast that the pizzas are always fresh and unique. Can't beat the price either! Love this place for lunch!

Brian Drake

Amazing pizza and a down to earth cozy atmosphere right in the heart of downtown

Luke Sebo

Extremely friendly staff and delicious pizza. 10/10 would recommend a visit.

Peter Bebeau

Great za, great service, quick, happy.

Steve Ebbens

Very tasty pizzas, but be warned, they are personal sized and are a little light on the cheese. I'm not a very big eater but I easily put down an entire wheel my self. It paired well with Lions Tail's Juice Cloud IPA.

Brad Schumann

Great pizza and apps.

Chris Timm

Great pizza

Michael Kuba

Small portions. Get the weekday lunch buffet if you want your dollar's worth. Delicious pizza with homemade crust baked in a wood-fired oven. YUMMY!!!

Chris Troge

Good selection of different beers, pizza was insanely good. Portions were large assuming a single pie per person. Friendly staff.

Paul Peters

Love this place assume wood fired pizza

Carlyn Cooley

Service was great nice interior food was good and not slow highly recommend it pizzas are personal size so makes it easy for a group who cant agree on what type of pizza to get will be there again.

Ross Peters

Amazing wood fired pizza. Tons of interesting pizzas to try.

Phil Betz

Great pizza, and wow, was it quick. We did come mid-afternoon between lunch and dinner so getting waited on quickly was no problem. Once we ordered, the pizza was on our table in 5 minutes, and it was great pizza with an awesome wood-fired crust.

Mike Vande Leest

Some of the best pizza since I moved back from Michigan.

Hal Murray III

Great pizza. Great atmosphere.

Barb Conaty

Excellent food and service!

Jean Vander Heiden

Good prices, welcoming staff, delicious food


It's a smaller place, but the food is very delicious and they have a nice lunch buffet.

Doris Palfrey

Awesome pizza. Great atmosphere.

Kevin Kaufman

Very cool atmosphere. Unique, wood fired healthy pizza and great staff. Just wish a little more was offered on salad bar. Great atmosphere to bring someone to talk and visit and enjoy a warm experience.

Mary kate Webber

I would like to recommend this Pizza restaurant to anyone who loves a great pizza. The wine list is wonderful and I have been told the variety of beers is remarkable. The wait staff is great. Johnny is a favorite of ours!

timothy joachim

Good Pizza buffet.

Theresa Faucher

They offer a variety non traditional flavors. A definite place to patronize when you are ready to take your pizza experience to the next level. Friendly staff, small eating area, get there early cuz it does get busy, and they offer Wisconsin brewed beers only. Keeping it local!


Fantastic pizza and an awesome wait staff!

Branden Jacobsen

Their weekday lunch buffet is awesome and at a great price. Get there early.

Cha Yang

We came after the lunch rush so it was pretty empty and therefore we got great service. We had the Fun Guy which was just enough for the two of us. It was delicious. Would go again and highly recommend it.

Sandi Stephani

Great pizza! Great service!

Daniel Tuchscherer

Amazing pizza, some of the best I've ever had and super high quality ingredients too. PS wood burning pizza oven!

Josh Hetrick

Great pizza and a great location... Would love to return when it is less busy.

Kristina Chamard

Delicious pizza and very fast service


Pizza is equivalent to Chuck E Cheeses. They just have better beer selection. Not worth the price.

Chris Sternitzky

One of the best Pizza Places in Neenah. They have a pizza buffet every Monday-Friday from 11am-2pm. Very good variety of pizzas and also a good quantity. They also offer a salad bar during this. They also have take out pizzas which are a great value for some fantastic food. All of their pizzas are wood fired in a custom stove which makes the crust fantastic. The building is easy to get to, extra parking in the back, located within one of Neenahs old shopping centers. I would recommend anyone who likes pizza to try out Broken Tree!

Elton Saunders

Great wood fired pizza served fast. Our server was great. We pulled in with a large group, and everything was perfect.

Ryan S

We went for the buffet and it was amazing! Great pizza selection for a great price! Highly highly recommend!

Ric Dominowski

Good food.

sandy kohl

Love pizza made in brick oven. Will definately go again

Jessica T

Great local spot! We were a large group amd the manager was very accommodating. Although they don't have gluten free pizza, my many family members tell me it was absolutely delicious. Great wine by the glass with very reasonable prices and a good selection of craft beers.

Solomonster1 Solomonster1

Love it! So good and super fast!

Robert Forbes

Unique wood fired pizza that never fails to disappoint!

Gregory Bunker

Very good service and great pizza. I will be back to try more of the menu

Robbin Freeman

Love this place. Any time friends or family comes into town, we have to take them here. Every pizza I've tried has been delicious. Never disappoints. Yum!

Kiersten Litzau

We really liked the restaurant and the pizza was delicious. We were unhappy with the price of the macaroni and cheese due it tasting like the box macaroni and cheese we buy and make at home. That was the only disapointment

Jess Krawczyk

Great place to eat, small pizzas but they make up for it in taste. Super delicious!

Dan Beckwith

Best pizza ever had.

Father John

Wonderful experience, great food, great service. This one red-haired spaz made my day. We talked about sports, weather and even his current educational life at St. Mary Catholic High School. He is a wonderful employee and he deserved his big tip. Look forward to coming again soon because of this fine, young chap!

Eric Markert

Edit - after visiting the restaurant more recently, I wanted to change my review and let all know that improvements were made and my last visit was awesome! Glad to have a place like this in Neenah! Previous review: I hope the owner sees this. I’ve ordered delivery from here a few times and have done the Buffett. The food is always good, never had a problem there. For those that complain about the toppings during the buffet, I am betting they skimp our due to the low price. If so, I feel they should change that and simply charge more. If that’s not the case, then quality control needs to be better. Also, I have an issue with some of the staff. They seem very unprofessional. I saw one gal with long hair handling dough with no hair tie or net. They also don’t wear any type of uniform and the one gal was wearing a sweatshirt that said something similar to “anti social club”. You’re in customer service - I don’t care what you serve or what services you provide - find staff who is happy to be there and wants to promote your brand. I manage a computer service department and it’s not easy, but if my guys wore that kind of clothing or handled a circuit board without proper equipment, they’d be reprimanded and the behavior would need to change. I really like the food and the atmosphere here, but the leadership should step it up a bit and demand more of their staff, or I’m afraid this place will be a dream short lived.

Nicole Marie

It was not good and won't go back. Went there for the first time. No to go menus and the website is hard to read the pictures of the menu they post. When I mentioned to cashier he shrugged his shoulders and said he had nothing to do with the online site. I ordered the kids pizza combo for our daughter and even though description said 1 to 2 toppings, I was charged extra for both toppings. The regular side pizza wasn't much bigger but they charge more of course. Both were pretty blackened and tasted burnt. We've had wood fire pizza before so wasn't impressed with the food, service for pick up, or pricing.

Jim Armstrong

always great pizza

micky steiner

Tasty food and they had good music when I was there

Gavin Schmitt

If you like wood fired pizza, it's the best a d very filling!

Herb C. Numrich

Love Broken Tree Pizza. Had to try the Italian Hoagie today. It was delicious.

Tou Vue Moua

Excellent artisan pizza. Had no idea this was in downtown Neenah, WI. Plenty of selections to choose from. I ordered philly steak with garlic cream sauce along with a raspberry tea. The pizza was hot and chewy. Toppings were fresh and evenly distributed. Will definitely return to try the other pizzas and appetizers.

Ryan Ames

Wonderful brick oven fire. The crust is delicious!

George Collier

Good food nice atmosphere


Individual crafted hot stone baked pizza. A bit high priced. But a unique experience. Many beer and local soda choices.

Brian Schmall

Great pizza and service. Decent beer selection.

Aria Graff

This is possibly my favorite pizza place. The music, service, and food are all excellent.


Awesome food! It doesn't get any fresher than watching your pizza made fresh from a ball of dough, topped, and baked in a wood-fired stove in front of you. Watxh out for Johnny, though--he's a sassy one! ;-D

Darci Strobel

Nice, fast place to eat and the waitstaff are great. Salad bar while your pizza cooks in a real wood fire oven. Super fast. BIG soda and refills are free. Thumbs up!

Jan T

Great food......wonderful waiter. Will definitely return.

Justin Stanelle

Awesome stone oven cooked pizzas! The lunch buffet is great. They offer a lot of options.

Adrienne Kennedy

First time we went it was great the food was fresh and delicious second time the pizza was not as good nor the service.. not sure if I would return.. it also seems like they lacked enough staff..

Chris Marquardt

Pizza is wonderful but It's a little pricey

Jack Gadzala

Very good wood fired pizza (my favorite was the "Fun Guy". Pleasant atmosphere (was surprised to see a band setting up with all the families and little kids). If your waitress doesn't introduce herself, she's probably Cassandra (very pleasant).

Aryan Eick

Love the food every single thing I've tried and great atmosphere! Wood fire grill you can stare at from behind the bar.

Business Hours of Broken Tree Pizza in Wisconsin



Broken Tree Pizza en Wisconsin
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Jason's Deli
Jason's Deli
Catering - Wisconsin


Bartender 608 Intoxicologists and Cocktail Caterers, LLC.
Bartender 608 Intoxicolog...
Catering - Wisconsin

Mobile caterer

From Scratch Catering
From Scratch Catering
Catering - Wisconsin


HoneyBaked Ham of Appleton
HoneyBaked Ham of Appleton
Catering - Wisconsin


Larry's Market
Larry's Market
Catering - Wisconsin