Reviews of Utah Catering by Magleby's (Catering)

Benjamin LaDue

Booked these guys for our caterer the lady we were initially working with was phenomenal! She had some sort of family emergency and I hope everything is ok. Our replacement who's name starts with a D was kind of a D. The other staff at the wedding was freaking amazing the food looked fresh and tasted amazing and the bar tenders we exaquisite and spot on! I highly recommend this company just avoid D if you can. Also they pack you food to eat later in your hotel room!

Cody Parkinson

if I was stuck on an island and could only have one catering service I would choose Maglebys. You can tell the customer is always first. They made my wife a special to-go box for are honeymoon night. Also the chocolate cake is unforgettable.

Summer Gates

They did a great job! We got our wedding cake from them. Keri was great to work with in figuring everything out and making sure we had exactly what we wanted. The person that delivered the cake took his time to help us set everything up. The cake was delicious! And afterwards, they emailed me to make sure everything went well. Great customer service.

Kira Dunn

I have been so excited to write this review because I have never worked with a more amazing caterer- Magleby’s has the kindest and most wonderful/professional employees, excellent presentation and a fun atmosphere, and most importantly… DELICIOUS FOOD!!!!!! It does not taste like mass-produced, standard catering. On top of everything, their pricing is incredibly reasonable. We met Magleby’s at a bridal expo and tasted their famous chocolate cake (I was practically sold on the spot). We spoke with Gwen, who was so nice and informative and would eventually be the event captain on the day of our wedding. Gwen put us in touch with Mary, who is the wonderful consultant who works with brides. Mary arranged a tasting for us, so we drove from Salt Lake down to Springville and had our minds blown by a wide variety of amazing food- we knew we absolutely HAD to go with Magleby’s after tasting the food and meeting the staff! Mary walked us through different menu options and eventually helped us choose a dinner, a dessert buffet, and our wedding cake. Everyone at Magleby’s was helpful and responsive- we even met the owner when we went for our tasting and he was very nice. It is obviously a family establishment and the food is so good because it’s also a restaurant with talented chefs. The day of our wedding went perfectly- the staff set up everything beautifully and efficiently. They are known for presentation, and everything from our food stations to the soda bar were lovely. Gwen and the other staff were incredibly helpful and even brought water to me, my husband, and our parents throughout the night which was very appreciated! They also handled the clean up effectively and quickly. I have been to lots of weddings, and usually the food is nothing to write home about… but I had SO MANY people seek me out specifically to tell me how delicious the food is! Lots of guests at the wedding are people who take fine dining and food quality seriously, and they all loved the food. I still have people complimenting me on it weeks later! For all of these reasons, I HIGHLY recommend Magleby’s to anyone who needs a caterer for any occasion!!! They cater all over Utah (our wedding was in Salt Lake). Give them a call and taste their food- you won’t regret it. Thank you for making our wedding a roaring and delicious success, Magleby’s!

Caitlin Ellers

Mary was amazing to work with! She is so kind and thoughtful and made sure we had everything we wanted and that it was all correct and she took care of us in every way! We love her and the food was delicious! We were so pleased with every experience we had with Magleby’s. Service, food quality, professionalism, display, EVERYTHING! Thank you for catering our wedding!

Karen Western

Outstanding catering/food service for our daughter's reception. Keri was easy to work with. They won us over at the tasting; not just the taste of the food but how they treated us as customers. We had a milkshake bar which was a hit with the guests. All of the food was delicious and beautifully displayed. I highly recommend them and will be a repeat customer.

Kelli Oswald

I Highly Recommend Magleby's!!! We use them as our company caterer and they are very accommodating! The Food is so good and the portions are excellent! Plus, the people who work there are truly wonderful!

Ashley Forakis

I cannot say enough amazing things about Magleby's! The food was AMAZING. We had them do a flaming donut station that was the hit of our wedding- definitely ask about it! Not only was this the best food we had tried for the wedding but they were also the best price! Their professionalism is also top of the line. HIGHLY recommend!

Geoff Larson

Overpriced cheap American food. Really dont know how they've stood the test of time. Eaten there a few times. But I'll never pick to go there..

Adam Nelson

The entire team over at Magleby's is beyond incredible. I have done many, many events with Magleby's and have had nothing but amazing experiences. I highly recommend them!