Reviews of Gandolfo's New York Deli (Catering)

Krisha Carroll

Favorite place to go! Have been going here for over 10 years! Husband got the ultimate crew and he adds chili! I ALWAYS get the Brooklyn bridge! Family friendly and just plain friendly!

Max Hill

Sammiches are good here

Brandon Jolley

Best sandwhich shop in town, all fresh ingredients.

Courtney Price

Used to eat here a least once a week while I was going to school at Austin Kade. The food is always good, awesome service, with a fun atmosphere!

Robert Lasher

The old owner closed shop and the folks at the store at Taylor's Crossing are reopening sometime in June 2009. If it is anything like the Taylor Crossing store it will be worthwhile to stop by and give them a chance.

Bridget Gould

Best sandwiches and salads.

Nina Zogg

Love their food. Friendly service.

Britiany Mitchell

Love there food and love working there everyone so nice to me

McKay Dover

It was good, the bread was soft and delicious

Kevin Ockerman

Great service and great food.

Cal Smith

Best place in Idaho Falls for a deli sandwich.

Dingo Stephens

Best French dip around........

Miranda Manning

Favorite sandwiches place in Idaho

Eve Miller

Love this place sooo much!

Collin Hanson

I like their atmosphere and the sandwiches are good. For sure try the potato salad.

Hunter Wilson

Best sandwich chain I've ever been to and the staff at the Idaho Falls location are very friendly and helpful!

Kevin Malcom

My favorite sandwich shop in Idaho Falls. Traffic Jam hotdog is worth a try. Double play is a great way to start the day. Any knuckle sandwich is great if you are looking for a larger sandwich. When available the gobbler with turkey, cranberries, and stuffing is the one to go with. Not fast food but REALLY good food.

Kristan Lazzarotto

So yummy! Very few places make breakfast good sandwiches in Idaho falls and thats our number one reason for visiting.

Desiree Cormier

Great staff and great food

McKenna Buckley

Gandalfos has gone way down hill when it comes to quality and service! So disappointed!

Rich Hansen

Love their subs especially their breakfast subs. This is not a fast food place so expect to wait a little bit for your food, call your order in a ahead of time if you don't want to wait to long.

Michael Mcenaney

This place is got some great NYC Decor and the staff are super friendly. We came in After the rush so it was real quite. And because it's my first time they gave me a free piece of cake! Nice touch!

michele buzzard

Good sandwich. Bread was really thick, $11 for a whole sandwich. That's a bummer.

Debbie Grace

Great Sandwich Shop!!!! Beats the buns off of Subway!!!!

Barton Weaver

I love there pastrami and rye sandwich. My wife and son love there hot dogs. On Thursday they give you a piece of mousse cake for free when you buy a sandwich and drink.

Michael Barton

Sandwiches are much more substantial than I was expecting. I guess that's to be expected if you've previously had the bad habit of eating at Subway where the bread is 70% air and the meat is so sparse they weigh it on a cocaine scale first to make sure they don't overfeed you. Gandolfo's has a great variety of hot and cold sandwiches. Of the few I've tried now they've all been excellent. They fill me up so much I actually have to order the half sandwiches, which is a new experience for a guy with love handles.

Troys messy jams G

Great sandwiches, and desserts!

Scott Stufflebeam

Some of the best sub sandwiches anywhere.

Jasmine Nochebuena

Amazing sandwichs! And great customer service!

Tom Smith

The food was great as usual Glad we decided to stop in.

Cyrano Jones

Excellent lunch spot. I got a pastrami Reuben with mustard instead of dressing, without even having to ask. Unfortunately thefountain is all Pepsi but they sell Coke in bottles.

Porter Lyman

Friendly staff. Delicious food. Overpriced but worth it.

Doug Webster

Delicious sandwiches. I'm usually overwhelmed by all the choices on the menu, but I've yet to make a choice that I'm not happy with. It's all good.

Micah Brown

Really good sandwiches. Prices are a bit high.

S F

Some sandwiches are better than others, and I've had a few not-so-good-ones here. Overall, everything is very fresh and they give out free cake on certain days of the week!

Mike Bray

fake iced tea. this is really important to me. i figured a deli would make it fresh. but the roast beef was awesome

brandi knoelk

Great sandwiches, good service

Cori Stephens

First time coming. A little pricey but VERY good food, well worth it

Thomas Moffett

Simply the best deli style sandwiches in Idaho falls. I think the Rockefeller Reuben is the best!

Sheri Hunter

Great service, great food!

Kirk Nielsen

We have tried every sandwich/hotdog on the menu except the breakfast items. We have our favorites but like all of them.

David G

Friendly folks. My corn beef sandwich was darn good. Lots of non-fatty meat. The bread did start falling apart of it. Little chilly in the place too.

Nathan Harrington

Good food but pricey

Keith OMasters

Great smells, great food, great customer service! Open a Gandolfo's in Coeur d'Alene so I can have it everyday! -Just an out of towner

Carmen Centore

The soup and half sandwich is the perfect combo. I love their gouda and red pepper soup, so yummy. I usually pair it with roast beef on rye.

Clarence Wolfe

My favorite sandwich but closes too early

Doyle Hone

If you want a sandwhich better than subway with ridiculously priced sides this is the place for you. The sandwichs are a little overpriced but really good. The sides aren't anything special and you get a tiny portion for a price that you would expect 3 times more to still be considered overpriced.

Jan A. Cullen

I enjoyed my sandwich and salad. The People working there were really nice. I will definitely be going back

Trish Jorgensen

I bit into my sandwich to find a long hair.

Emma-Lea Jacklin Warsaw

Yum. The philly cheese steak is not what I would call a philly cheese steak (considering I'm from the east), theres cream cheese on it? And it just doesnt taste like the philly's I'm used to. Its still a delicious sandwich, just not a philly. but the food is good regardless. Lots of sandwich options, cool place. Almost like a peice of home in Idaho.

B. W.

Better enjoy it while u can since this is the last gandolfos left

jody Johnson

The best deli sandwich in this area

Lenn Heighes

Great sandwiches. Gotta try the sour cream potato salad

Cody Olson

Great staff

Darkheart Adventures

This place is worth the visit. Don't be afraid to order the half sandwich, you'll get plenty full. They have a great selection of sandwiches, salads, and dogs. Order your sandwich deli style to get an experience closer to an actual East coast deli. The walls are packed with nonsense. Movie posters, old time baseball stills, etc. King Kong is my personal favorite. I had the Chicago hot dog and the Dagwood sandwich. Both were big, filling, delicious, and dripping with spicy mustard. The price was a little high, but the food was worth the price.

Michael Sorenson

Love their Ruben. The pastrami here is unmistakably the best in IF. Throw in an awesome toasted rye, sauerkraut and Russian dressing and you have the recipe for true love!

Darren Haller

Place used to be better. The glass case at the front counter looked like it had mold growing in it and there was something dripping from the top into the salads

Lilly O'Handley

I like their sandwiches (and that they always have soup). Friendly staff. I could do without the TV blaring FOX news though (not relaxing for lunch).

Amanda Cockerill

I love their sandwiches always fresh and delicious! They are a little spendy for the sizes of sandwich, but no other place in town makes sandwiches like them! And they have amazing desserts! Employees are always super nice too, so that's a plus :)

Lance Holladay

GREAT sandwiches! Huge sandwich menu.

Adrian yo

Good food, nice staff, a little pricey for what you get but we continue to go back.

Tanner

The sandwiches are amazing and the service is very good.

Chris Petersen

Best deli style sub in town! Great people and great food! Godzilla is fantastic!

Lyn Gaumitz

Luv the Chaz Bagel

lori smith

Best Sammy in Idaho

Bradley Moran

We ordered over the phone At first when he said it would be $22 for 2 sandwiches I thought that was pretty rediculous and thought "why don't I just go out to a restaurant?" But when we got the food it was worth every single penny. These sandwiches are amazing. I had an "I <3 New York" and oh my gosh... Fantastic. Highly recommend!!

C Dubbya

Great sandwiches, service & their broccoli salad was always my favorite!

Brandie Fabian

First time we had visited this sandwich shop and I was impressed. The staff was very informative when we told them we had never been in before. The lady who took our order made some recommendations and told us what some favorites were. The only reason I give this place 4 stars is because they forgot to give us our sides with our order (we had to go ask for them) and the mac and cheese noodles were way over cooked. The sandwiches were fantastic though!

Scott Worley

Found my favorite sandwich shop! The Rockefeller Reuben is fantastic, the people are very nice and so many great things to choose from! I'll be back many times to try out all of the great things they offer.

Marc Jorgensen

Great sandwiches

Nick Mahan

Great food, great employee attitude and if anything is wrong with your order they are quick to make it right. One of my favorite places to get a sandwich.

Mike Stiffler

Great place. Try the Urban Cowboy.

Donna Sheedy

Love this place! Best sandwiches around. Fresh bread, fresh meat makes for a mmmm mmmmm mmmmm good meal!

Ann Bowels

This is my favorite place to eat I would have given a five star but the lady taken my order put it in wrong! Customers sever was a epic fail on her part! So upsetting even the best restaurants have bad days!

Ben

Great service, great food.

Eli Lainhart

Love this place. Always eat lunch here when we are in town.

Yusheng Luo

Nice people work there. Yummy food.

Shellie Shurtliff

Yummy sandwiches and helpful people working there

Nancy Lynn Haltli

Great sandwiches, helpful in helping me get something that I can eat.

Chad Russell

Gandolfo's Deli catered my company meeting today and I must say that I was impressed. We had bread bowl soups, salad, and cookies for desert. The bread bowl soups were fantastic. We had the choice of clam chowder or roasted potato. I had the clam chowder. It was hot, not too thick, and very flavorful. It had large chunks of potato and clam meat. The salad was your typical side salad that included romaine lettuce, tomato slices, olive pieces and filthy cucumbers. Ranch dressing on the side. The desert was chocolate chip and macadamia nut cookies. They were fresh and tasty. I recommend Gandolfo's when you want to change up your dining experience.

Elizabeth S.

Was not impressed at all. My sandwich was soggy very little meat and overall not satisfying. There are a lot more choices to choose from that give you a better quality meal and value.

James Cook

Good sandwich, reasonable price, nice atmosphere

Mitch Motley

Really good sandwiches, I haven’t had a better sub in idaho

Riah Lyn

The food was very good and filling but for some reason I get charged twice every time I go there with my card!

Darren Wolters

Best pastrami and corn beef sammiches.

Clayton Sherman

It's all about the Knuckle Sandwich and great service. This is the most legit Gandolfo's I've visited.

James Haynie

Worst egg salad sandwich I have ever been served.

Barbara Gleason

It was quick, easy to order and good quality food. We had breakfast sandwiches

David Bush

Best sandwich place in Idaho Falls. If you are new to it, get the chocolate mousse cake, you won't be disappointed.

Genesie Miller

It's a bit cheesy with the NYC kisch, but the sandwiches are good. The marinated mushrooms are particularly good

Matt Hickman

Solid food experience. Staff is very helpful with their menu, and the sandwich was amazing!

Dug Kub

Great food good people!

Nancy Landon

We had a great experience today at this restaurant. We even got a couple pieces of cake free. Thank you my 88 year old mother was so impressed. She did freeze half the sandwich meat for another time.

Allison Ortega

The food is delicious. But they truly are New York style. My fiancée got the taxi driver (6.99) and I got the Hampton (6.99) and ended up getting charged 19.00 (say what?!). When they offered deli salad and chips, we said we’d take just the sandwiches but they said they were included. On a previous time here, I got the knuckle sandwich, and wasn’t even offered chips and my order cost exactly what I expected. When my fiancée was ordering his sandwich, he asked to see the sizes they were- to understand the difference in size vs. price. They said they were the same size and didn’t show him a piece of bread or whatever to gauge it, so he said he’d get the “regular” size, since they were the same size, and was charged 10.00 instead of the 6.99 advertised for the half-even though they’re apparently the same size??? When trying to talk to them about it, they didn’t really seem to get what I was talking about. I’m not very confrontational so I didn’t push it, but looking back I really don’t understand what the extra money (excluding tax) was for. Just like NY-hidden charges included.

Daniel Moody

I have never been let down here! They always have great service! The owner knows how to keep customers coming back!

Donna Fraga Abt

Very good...a little to messy but great flavor.

Shelly Smith

GREAT sandwiches and a lot to choice from. We eat here when we go to Idaho falls. Friendly service.

Izz Bak

I love the quality and quantity of food you get here. The prices are worth it and really enjoy the options you have to pick from. I personally love the Undertaker option.

John Idema

My sandwich was supposed to come with avocado & I had requested extra avocado. My sandwich had NONE & hardly anything else for about $8. I will NOT ever go back! WHAT A RIPOFF!!!

BeckyLord Lord

Great sandwiches, large selection.

Tiphanie Bohn

1st time in, members were very friendly (: took a chance and tried a sandwich recommendation from Gabby(king of queens and the ultimate crew) and it was easily the best breakfast sandwich I've had. Definitely will be back to try the rest of the menu

Kallan Hawkes

Great sammy!

Jeffrey Wass

Top notch food, service, and staff!

Victoria Newell

Family & I were STARVING! These guys were RIGHT about to close when we stopped by and they came over to unlock the door & fed all 5 of us. It was so awesome. SO THANKFUL

Molly Gaston

Came in with my son today for the first time and had a wonderful experience. This is my first written review but they definitely deserve it! Great costumer service and yummy food! Extremely impressed!

James Blake

Great Deli! Tons of choices. Go with the "Urban Cowboy" Delicious!

Michael Hyde

Gandolfo's is never a bad choice. I love their hot subs. I also really appreciate the quality of the food. Can't eat at Subway anymore.

Windy Spencer

LoRita is always very accommodating!

Ryder Paggen

Completely understaffed and took forever to order and get food! Need more people if they expect to complete orders in under 25 minutes.

James McGrane

Ruebens are amazing, potato salad was delicious as well!

N Croston

Really wanted to hate it based on cost/quantity analysis. Very expensive. Sandwhich and cole-slaw $13. I also ❤ New York, but wouldn't dishonor them with a sandwich by that name which would cost you little more than half as much and have twice the meat. That would even be in Manhattan at a Jewish deli.

jerry crall

Sandwich was grate and the egg salad

Mitch Larsen

Awesome sandwiches, ine of my favorite places in Idaho Falls.

Ezer AceMun

luv the pastrami and cornbeef sandwich

Lance Eliazar

Good variety. Great taste! Great staff.

Eric Avalos

Cheap great Sandwiches and amazing Chocolate Mousse cake!! Love it and the staff is great

Sam Bluemel

Great Service and Its nice to have something different from Subway or Jimmy Johns.

Martha Clark

Excellent food and service. The owners and crew have always been very nice..

Randy Ferrill

Could eat here everyday and never run out of fantastic foods to try!

Cecilia England

First time eating there today, it was awesome! Friendly staff, great sandwich.

James Glancy

Great sandwich shop! Friendly talented staff. Almost too many sandwich choices. The Crew breakfast sandwich is fantastic. If you want a nice pastrami the Giant is a good one, simply meat, mustard and pickles.

A Buck

I love the real subs, real meat, real veggies and good value! It's like being back East!

Sanju Choudhury

Love the service and the food, great stop

Melissa Nieves

I'm from NY and had been wanting a good breakfast bagel, I stumbled upon this place and it did not disappoint. A little costly for this area. Two sandwiches cost me almost $20 but the food was great. Nice and fresh.

Gregory Freeman

Excellent Subs! Love this place.

Glen Garner

This place is friggin yummy. Kicking myself for not trying it before.

Michael Reynolds

I got the Urban Cowboy and loved it. I only needed the 6" and it was plenty. there was a ton of meat on that sandwich. I also got the cheddar bacon chips and they were ok, but they have plenty of well known options other then that. I have been back since and it was just as good the second time.

Craig Larsen

Gandolfo's New York Deli has the best sandwiches I've had in a very long time. Their French dip, my favorite, is really a mouth watering treat that I love. The desserts are also great. The staff are great and friendly. If you really want a great sandwich, go to Gandolfo's, they are great!

wizwarrior1

Best sub shop in town. Love the selection and the atmosphere. The sandwiches were always on point. Thursdays free cake is great.

scott baguley

Amazing food. One of my favorites.

MacInlay Ross

A great place to stop in for a great sandwich. They have tons of different options and combinations most of us probably wouldn't think of. My personal favorite is the Urban Cowboy. If you're looking for a new sandwich shop to try out, this is definitely one worth looking into. Friendly service, fair prices, and good food. (Also, their chocolate cake is phenomenal.)

Jane branch

This place has really good sandwiches. And OMG the selection. Right now the Gobble is my fav! It is Thanksgiving on a roll and a party in your mouth.

Casey Pullar

Very good breakfast sandwich. I need to go back for lunch and try out their specialties.

Andrew Stott

Great variety of sandwiches! A sandwhich for any type of sandwhich lover. Great hotdogs too! Pasta salad was amazing. Don't have enough words to explain how hood this place is.

Daniel Karavan

Great food. Authentically made. Some sandwiches are better than others. Overall very nice staff.

Melissa Middleton

Oh my goodness the smell of bread hits you like a freight truck when you walk in. The food delivers what the smells promise. Great place for breakfast or lunch.

Alan Hanley

Oh that was so good. The staff was friendly and helpful, great recommendations. Food was fresh and tasty. Prices are good for the amount of food they give you. I would so go again.

Durak Ironhyde

Best deli in idaho falls

Francisco Espinoza

One WhiteStone Bridge please

J Williams

The food is amazing! I have never been and will go back again

Nova Creek

AMAZING! The food and staff are so great! The staff is very kind and warming to be around, they take pride in their work and love to chat with customers! The food itself is to die for and this place has quickly become one of my favorite places to eat! 10/10 I will definitely be back again ♡♡♡

Rachel Grubbs

Awesome service, tons of choices, and delicious food! Highly recommend a visit!

Darin Carlson

This is my go to spot for lunch. Best sandwiches in town. The variety on the menu, the flavors and the freshness make for a great meal. I'm especially pleased with the pastrami anything. (I love pastrami)

Eric Schaat

Great place good sandwiches love the staff.

shayne avison

My favorite sandwich place in town. Huge menu and it is all delicious

Thomas Case

THE CREW! Oh man! The Crew is a breakfast sandwich you can get all day, and it is so delicious. It has BACON, and EGG, and SAUSAGE, and CHEESE all together on huge bread. It is big enough to share, but I DO NOT, because it is so good. They have a LOTS of options on the menu including sandwiches, salads, and lots of dessert choices. They also have a great beverage selection including a few DIET drinks.

andrew horan

local delicacy! damn good food. slightly pricey but damn is it worth it!

Pierre La Count

Very tasty food! Best in town!

C Dust

Delicious but expensive and closes early.

Dillon H

Delicious, fairly priced, tons of options, friendly service. The man at the register was very patient and helpful as we perused the huge board of options. We split a foot long Urban Cowboy sub for $9 (about the cost of most of the foot longs). They prepared it quickly and and a nice lady brought it to our table. The huckleberry soda was also good. This deli is high quality, so it´s a little pricier, and slightly slower than Subways (wish is fast food), but the range of options is impressive, and you won´t be disappointed in the taste. I wish it was a little more in my budget, though I would go again.

Chuck Rose

Good food, highly expensive

Ida Nitowski

Food is great and very clean!

William Walrath

Great food. Fast service@

Fritz Friesen

Excellent, true NY style sandwiches!

Cory McHugh

The Big Apple sandwich will make any day amazing. However, if you get one on Thursdays, you get free chocolate cake. Sooooooooo good!

MaCade Vineyard

Great sandwich and New York deli options.

Parker Parish

Love the food here. Great service and and food. I think they could live with a bit lower prices but it doesn't stop me from going there

Oded Paz

We got what we needed and the service was as could be expected.