Reviews of Bluescreek Farm Meats & Market (Butcher Shop)

Tom Hollern

Great spot for meats. Wonderful people service etc

Joel Campbell

Had chicken salad.

Amy Lozier

Absolutely the best meat you can buy anywhere! They raise the animals with respect, and treat the meat with the care it deserves. And their sausage is beyond compare. The only meat I buy. (And a great little restaurant, too!!)

Julie Dean

Very pricey & meat is not organic.

Shawnie Rump

Everyone is so nice and the meat quality is amazing. They have great local dairy options as well and a variety of other products.

Jocelyn Andras

Very friendly, helpful faces. The food always smells good and what I've gotten tastes good too. You will pay a lot for it but depending on your tastes it may very well be worth it. It's definitely worth a try to decide for yourself.

dee mccullough

Great staff and selection

Lisa Geitgey

The employees were friendly and the food was delicious! Can't wait to visit again

Scott Burch

Great people. Good product. Revising 6/9/18: Threw a large Turkey pot pie in the oven lastnight, cooled and threw in the fridge. Heated up a piece for lunch today --- annnndd it's going to be a good week for lunch.

Bill Mershon

Great place to shop for local fresh meat!

Laura Lee

This might be my new favorite place! What great people. They opened the door for my husband and me even though it was closed and they were so welcoming and helpful. We got beautiful steaks that look amazing plus we got all of these awesome gluten free treats. I can't wait to go back when the cafe is open. I highly recommend.

Rebecca Ladowitz

Everything here is delicious!

Alaura Meister

I had the cheddar chorizo bacon burger and it was sooooo good!!!

Sharon Shaffer

Excellent service. Cooking and grilling advice helpful.

Nathan Downing

Best burger and fries I had in years! Bluescreek Burger* (with bacon) ...their own beef burger, caramelized onions, muenster cheese, local dill pickles, lettuce, tomato and the Mustard Man's simply sweet mustard on a brioche bun

Debra Hillman

The staff there were helpful and courteous. They cut my meat the way I wanted. They had a nice variety of everything from chicken, to pork to steak to cookies.

Sharon G Scaggs

Great meat market, bakery items, and misc items. Great staff!! Highly recommend.

X Johnson

The selection and staff make this the best butcher and market around. They are knowledgeable and willing to help. Great shop!

Colleen Koehler

Great meat, great people.

George Grambo

Assume best place for fresh meat

Christopher Marshall

I absolutely love the people and the food. You just cant beat it.

Barb S

Great service and wonderful selection.

Bill Nickley

Great selection of quality and local meats!

Eric Eby

Great food in the cafe- taste and quality. Friendly service and lots of locally sourced items for sale.

Sheila Hunt Rossiter

Exceptional butcher and fantastic market. They offer items from local small business and farmers and offer products from several Ohio Proud members. They also offer artisan baked goods and just opened a cafe. Highly recommend.

Kyle Berry

Excellent food and meat products, fresh or frozen. Have been here several times and never disappointed with any selection I have chosen. TERRIBLE cashier at check out this afternoon on my lunch break from work which is leading to one star review, lost customer and business. Ok, so after my meal I grabbed a few frozen items to take home and proceeded to check out and pay for these items and my meal. I presented my MasterCard from my bank which I have always used, and was asked for ID. OK, I was a little frustrated and it was weird of the cashier to ask, but I gladly showed her. Shocking results: The name on my card and name on my license matched! Phew. BUT, much to my dismay, it wasn't enough. She looked at my picture....looked at me....looked at my picture....looked at me, a few times. Now as this was happening, she was holding my bank card up and away from me as if I was a doppelganger or thief of sorts ready to snatch it away from me. "Oh looks like you have a beard now" Well, seeing as how my license is you know, a few years old, I do! Anyway, still keeping my composure I said "No one has ever asked me for ID for my own bankcard before, this is odd." As to her reply "Well I don't know you that well yet" .....Ok, after her answer and at this point I realize I am talking to a complete moron and just leave with my coworker who was with me. After paying of course. Now mind you I am 32 year old professional adult dressed in my work uniform from head to toe, again with my coworker and my work truck with our name plastered all over it sitting right outside. This is a multi million dollar company I work for, I also own my own painting business and have a college degree. ( I know not pertinent info for this scenario but I am trying to make a point.) So clearly I am not a 12 year old child trying to steal some meat and pull one over on Blues Creek so I can take home my plundered goods to my iron deficient family and little Timmy. It also felt great having everyone around me in the cafe(which was packed) look at me and I'm sure make their own opinions. So thank you so much for the wonderful checkout experience today! Never again will I be back and it really is a shame because it's a great place, and one person has to ruin it. Quite a degrading exit and sour taste in my mouth.

Laura R.

I attended one of their classes and it was well worth the price of the ticket. You can tell the owners have a passion for their business and were willing to share their knowledge. Plus the food was awesome. It is worth the trip out to Plain City to get locally sourced products and pick up a few tips as well.

Shay Hamper

Lamb burger was excellent and the loaded fries were good also. and yes with the egg

Robert Fisher

High prices but worth it!

Joshua Cooper

Great quality meats. Friendly service. The food at the cafe is amazing and priced well. Support the local guy!

Alejandro Rios

Good quality and excelente service. I like that the staff is willing to help and advice the customers

Rachel Vogel

This place is delicious, all of the staff is super friendly & conversational. Locally grown & produced menu & store! I'm going to be a new regular!

Christopher Fox

The guy was knoligable and nice. First time there was able to help me with all my questions.

Melissa Mead

Such wonderful people and great atmosphere. The selection of meats are amazing. So worth it!

M Clarridge

Pricey but meat is excellent. Brisket is competition barbecue grade along with the Boston butt. Great place

Diana Durfey

Great customer service!

Jennifer Barr

Great selection of amazing meats and local products like ice cream and fresh baked bread and cookies. Excited to try the herbed pork fat to fry eggs in!

Kendra Harpster

Friendly service and food is delicious.

Jon Andrews

This was THE best sausage egg & cheese sandwich I've ever eaten. It was even gluten free! I was floored. Amazing selection and Jamie also shared the info on the gf fazookis. She explained that they have difficulty keeping them in stock...well I have to try one of those too, ring it up. My stop for lunch meat ended up also including organic coffee, the sandwich, the frozen cookie creation and a tip! Our brunch trips to Sunny Street Cafe might be permanently replaced by trips to Bluescreek! Just up the street from the Steam Threshers event and Shekinah Festival in Plain City! A must vist!

Joshua Morris

Excellent service and high quality meat. This is a full service butcher shop and which is rare anymore.

Cary Warsetsky

Best meat in ohio

Eric Raber

Awesome carry out food!

phillip cadle

Great service

Bill Wolcott

Great selection

jim phillips

Freaking closed what a joke who goes on vacation during summer when u own a business

Anna Gribbell

Top quality meats and lots of other great local products to explore. Friendly service and personal touch.

Joe Chapman

Hands down the best service and best meat quality / selection i've experienced, I order it ahead of time and it's ready upon arrival. 5 stars all the way!!

Julie Pappas

Great food!

Jey Tee

Stopped by and had an amazing burger and fries. Great food and service, all local.

Gary Vinson

INCREDIBLE! Owners are very nice and accommodating.

Diane McCullough

Quality products and great staff

John League

Great selection of meats. Farm to table approach.

Ben Craig

They are always so helpful in getting me what I need, based on my terrible explanations. Will always use this butchers wherever I live.

Sophie

Excellent locally produced meats & other foods.

Nate Whitaker

Can’t say enough about this place. The cafe never disappoints for lunch; the double comfort chicken sandwich is the best chicken sandwich ever had. And the meat behind the counter is always fresh, always different. They’ve also given me great advice on how to grill some of the pieces of meat ive never grilled before. Jamie even recommended a digital grilling thermostat that has made life easier and our steaks to everyone’s desired temp.

Tyrone Tatum

Just let them know what you want and they'll get it for you. These nice people know what good service is about and aren't afraid to go the extra mile to show me something even better. Highly recommend.

Thalia Johanssen

Excellent meats! I think I found meat paradise. Bought some liver....it was amazing!