Reviews of Schatzie Prime Meats (Butcher Shop)

2665 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, United States

Average Rating:


Here you have all the information of people who consumed the products of Schatzie Prime Meats (Butcher Shop) in New York area.

At present the business has a score of 4.4 stars over 5 and that rating has been based on 61 reviews.

As you can see its rating is quite high, and it's founded on a large number of opinions, so we can say that the assessment is very faithful. If people have bothered to evaluate when they've done well with the service, it works.

You know that we don't usually bother to write tatings when these are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Butcher Shop is included in the category of Butcher shop.

Where is Schatzie Prime Meats?

REVIEWS OF Schatzie Prime Meats IN New York

Becksguy .

buddy del rosario

delicious burger..only take out though

Simon C

Excellent small family-owned butcher shop. The way meat selling is supposed to be. Butchers who know meats with great service. Also sell burgers and sandwiches to eat-in or take out. Best burgers anywhere and excellent vanilla shake. Love it.

Gene Parker

A great neighborhood butcher also serves sandwiches and cold beer.

Darienne Dennis

Ordered Frankfurters, stuffed cabbage and Serrano ham ... Delicious! And prompt, on time delivery!!!❤

Avi Smith-Rapaport

My son called it the best burger ever Wife loved the fries

Stephanie Gerrity

Stephen Bloch

Excellent brisket sandwich, pastrami sandwich, pulled pork sandwich, French fries,... Don't miss the Brussels sprouts with pancetta. A little expensive for a cash-only place, but they have an ATM.

Erdem Kent

It’s not mentioned anywhere so watch out: It's cash only!!! There is an atm inside the restaurant but you will be charged an additional fee. So I'm taking off a star for this. another star off for the wannabe funny/rude butcher. As for the food, my burger was indeed fresh but I like my bread also warm, which was not the case. Would I go there again? Probably not.

George Bishop

Michael Fourman

Excellent burger — excellent beef cooked as ordered (we had rare, medium rare, and medium, all nicely seared and perfectly cooked), good fries, good sprouts and pancetta, good beer. What's not to like?

Isaac Alfieri

The burgers were quite fine

Brewer Shettles

doug abeles

Stopped in to get popovers and saw the delicious-looking rotisserie chickens. $13.95 seemed a bit pricey but it came with two sides so I thought I'd give it a try. Man was I disappointed! The chicken was tasteless and dry. I've had their brisket sandwiches and those are good but don't waste your money on the rotisserie chicken.

Ezra Rapoport

Best butcher on the East coast

Patrick Corbett

Isidro Marco A Cristobal

Food is not good. Very expensive and owner is very rude... Tips are 20-25% mandatory


John Webb

Lisa Handwerker

Christopher Frany

Tsadik Kaplan

This place has been a joke since they opened. The prepared foods, the prices, the staff, the owner (ESPECIALLY THE OWNER), all a joke. Now they've reduced the size of their store to 30% of what it was, should be out of business by 2020.

Joseph Mayer

Michael Shapiro

The brisket sandwich is to die for. truly. excellent. then go next door to the wine shop. UWS culinary central with Sal's Pizza and the noodle shop

William Risinger

The "Shatzie" burger with sautéed onions, mushrooms and bacon. Onion rings, fries and cheesecake to finish off an awesome meal. If your in Manhattan and don't eat at Shatzie's you are missing out.

Troy Clough

Jason Galleske

We loved it, burgers were exquisite. My girlfriend said it was the best she ever had!

Adam Chetrit

Anton Rozanov

Jason Reid

Eric Tarr

Everything was delicious. Schatzie and son, Richie were very kind hosts. My burger was cooked perfectly medium rare with crisp bacon, melted cheddar and a runny egg. Sides were excellent. Belgium fries with truffle oil, Brussel sprouts in a delicious sauce with chunks of thick bacon were mouth watering. Buffalo wings were another homerun. Then the cowboy ribeye was for sure something to write in about. Charred on the outside with a spot on medium rare inside. Don't think I've ever had a more perfectly cooked steak. Loved this place.

Kevin O. Cox

Prime meat burger sold by a 4th generation NYC butcher. What more do you need to know?

Sarah Martin

Richie knows what he's talking about. Best burger I've ever had. Must have

Joao Prado

Owner is very rude.

Lynn Delorme

Excellent burger on brioche bun, moist and juicy - even after taking it to go. Summer special $9.95 burger and fries - highly recommend!

Vitaly Druker

Derek cope

Joanie Axelbaum

Best delivery burger.

glen soria

Best place for a burger and a beer

Michael LaRocca

They've got awesome burgers, whether you dine in or buy the chop meat and cook at home. Ask for their special "burger blend" of meat. You can't go wrong!

István Cseh jr.

Jimmy C NYC

The burgers here are definitely some of the best on the west side. Had a great conversation with Schatzie, who told me stories about the old days in the Bronx everybody was really friendly. Splurged on my diet and had a vanilla milkshake for dessert it was out of this world. Before I left I met his son Richie who was telling jokes with my friend really nice people old fashioned type of service and dedication to Quality my new go-to place for burgers have to try the other stuff on the menu

susana de lara

Best burger I've had in a long time!!...definitely worth stopping by....and the owner is awesome!

Jason Ayala

Just finished off the "Schatzie" burger w/cheddar & bacon and a side of fries, everything was great.

Michael Rosenberg

My brisket sandwich was excellent and the staff there were extremely friendly and accommodating. Would definitely return!

Daniel Rosenhaus

Couldn't have enjoyed this place more. What a great burger place, butcher, and take-away restaurant on the UWS/Manhattan Valley/Columbia area. It wasn't crowded on a Thursday night, so my girlfriend and I were able to talk with Richie a while and he was really nice, knew a lot of about the food industry in NYC, and was a pleasure to talk with. The food was outstanding. We both ordered cheeseburgers, one Schatzie's and one grass-fed, and loved them both. You could tell the meat was high-quality and that was the star. They weren't as greasy as others but still had a ton of flavor. We got the fries with rosemary and they were just a bit crispy but soft and delicious. Someone else ordered the truffle ones which smelled great. The fried Oreos though were one of the best desserts I've had, the pancake batter they use to fry made all the difference, super good! They also have a solid roster of beers, some of which are harder to find. Overall, this place is worth venturing to for a meal and I can't wait to try the rest of their menu.

Ruth Forero

Edward Tapia

Friendly service, quality meats good pricing.

Orlando Godoy

Best steak in the West side!

Evan Guillemin

best burger in town, terrific butcher counter as well. i could eat here 7 days a week.

Oliver Schwede

Great fries and pulled pork Sandwich. Good service and authentic NY butcher atmosphere. Really worth going there.

TJ Compton

If you like paying steep a la carte prices for every burger topping and condiment, eat here. If you like tasteless, bland burgers that your ancestors probably ate on the Oregon Trail, this is your place! If you like milkshakes that won't even bring street rats to the yard, order one here. If you like getting hit by a parked bike on your way to the bathroom AND toilet paper carpet, use the bathroom here.

Yvette Mitchell

Stop here for a good burger or brisket, or chicken, you can't miss it look for the cow

maryam ataei

Best burger in NYC!

Steven Gutierrez

Brandy Allen

Beware of the burger joint side. The brisket sandwich is over priced dry.

William Crosson

I had the French toast, bacon, and popover with strawberry butter for brunch - all were on point and fresh. Their coffee is excellent also.

alan lane

Best burger under $35 in upper Manhattan. Great beers on tap. What it lacks in creature comforts (ambience) it makes up for in local color. $13.95 gets you a burger, fries, & all the trimmings including lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Also fully functioning prime butcher shop third generation family owned.

Ermolay Romanov

Dan MaDDan Al-Mateen

Went to harvest fest uptown no food stands had nothing for ny appetite or wallet ..then looked up and saw this inviting sign $8.95 burger w/fries special..wha could hurt??i could awesome awesome burger w fries..perfect .don't the size/shape or the looks of dah joint fool yah..this id crazy good food at crazy cool prices..Thank You Ritchie n family guys made my day my stomach thanks you n my wallet is pretty vool friend n i walked to 72nd subwaycfrom here just to settle the tummies...

Business Hours of Schatzie Prime Meats in New York



Schatzie Prime Meats en New York
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Queens Natural Meats
Queens Natural Meats
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop

New Public Meat Market
New Public Meat Market
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop

United Meat Market
United Meat Market
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop deli

Murray's Cheese
Murray's Cheese
Butcher Shop - New York

Cheese shop

Jerrys Italian Market inc
Jerrys Italian Market inc
Butcher Shop - New York

Sandwich shop