Reviews of Pellegrini's Prime Meats, Fish & Catering (Butcher Shop)

104 Covert Ave, Garden City, NY 11530, United States

Average Rating:


Here you have the feddbacks of people who are consuming the products of Pellegrini\'s Prime Meats, Fish & Catering (Butcher Shop) around New York area.

Nowadays this firm receives a rating of 4.6 over 5 and that score is based on 31 reviews.

You must have seen that it reaches an opinions average is basically the top, and it's founded on a large number of reviews, so we can be pretty sure that the assessment is very reliable. If many people have bothered to leave their feddback when they are satisfied, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to set evaluations when they are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or issue...

This Butcher Shop is included in the category of Butcher shop.

Where is Pellegrini's Prime Meats, Fish & Catering?

REVIEWS OF Pellegrini's Prime Meats, Fish & Catering IN New York

Jacqueline Vita

This is a long time favorite of many locals here. Growing up my Mom's trip to Pellegrini"s always meant we were eating good tonight and using the outdoor grill. While this market is no longer within walking distance, I do make my way back here to treat my husband. They have an excellent choice of meats and prepared dishes to take home as well as a good section of fresh produce too.

Matthew Kuehnlenz

Robert Darin

Incredibly over priced and terrible quality. This is not a real butcher. It's a deli with a meat display. Much better off taking a trip to Queens.

Richie D

Andy Zuke

They always the best

gerard gomes

The food is delicious homemade Deli counter the meets are prime grade the fish is fresh every day I highly recommend this place very friendly atmosphere very inviting

Aryan J

Pellegrini Meats has great butchers and good quality meat. Unfortunately, I won't be visiting them any longer. On an Amex Small Business Saturday, I asked the cashier, an older women who never smiles or says hello, if I could run the transaction twice to take advantage of a special offer. She scoffed and refused, saying it was impossible. She barely looked me in the eye. That isn't customer service. On top of that, the prices are quite high. For a better deal and better meat, head to Iavarone Brothers on Union Tpke. in the Lake Success shopping center. It's well worth it.

Mel Davis

James Wysocki

Jane Centrella

I always find what I want. They have good quality meat and fish and courteous friendly help.

Mary Reno

Great food & workers!

Marcy Fetyani

Just had an awesome graduation party thanks to the fantastic "Barbecue" done by Pellegini and our griller/server Jim. The guests were thrilled with the selection and quality of the food at the event and there was plenty of everything. I would definitely recommend using them if you want an awesome offering of delicious food! And the best part was that I didn't have to do anything but entertain my guests. Thanks Pellegrini!

Jeff Roth


Excellent Butcher


The best

Frank Foto

Ernestina Nelly Garcia Sarmiento

Rob Maier


Nick Italiano

Great local butcher with Italian Specialties and wide seafood selection.

Richard Signoretti

At 2 pound lobsters they were phenomenal as usual

Rich H

Awesome quality of meats and prepared foods!

Mark Haase

Tom Koslo

Michael Pariti

Very knowledgeable and fair prices for quality meats

john steiner

Excellent staff and great meat


Thank you Pelligrini Meats for hosting our Housewarming Party! Our waiter Danny and Chef Michael did such an outstanding job and was the highlight of our party ! Thank you to Christina and Danielle for all the text messages and calls This entire staff went above and beyond to cater for our guest and make our event such a success ! We highly recommend them and will be using them in the future

John M

Best butcher around!

Frank Langela

This is the best butcher and best quality meats and seafood. Sometimes in life you get what you pay for.

Bob Menak

Always the best!

Rachel Waters

The quality of meat was good. However the person helping me refused to speak English and then joked with others behind the counter in Spanish. I had questions he either didn't want to answer or was unable. I would have purchased more than I did if they had been more helpful. Can't see myself going back there

Business Hours of Pellegrini's Prime Meats, Fish & Catering in New York



Pellegrini's Prime Meats, Fish & Catering en New York
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Whole Foods Market
Whole Foods Market
Butcher Shop - New York

Grocery store

Super Foodtown of Washington Heights
Super Foodtown of Washing...
Butcher Shop - New York


Staubitz Market
Staubitz Market
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop

Essex Market
Essex Market
Butcher Shop - New York


Las Americas Meat Market
Las Americas Meat Market
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop