Reviews of L. Simchick, & Co. (Butcher Shop)

988 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022, United States

Average Rating:


You will be able to see all the opinions of real people who consume the products and services of L. Simchick, & Co. (Butcher Shop) in New York.

As of day this firm has a score of 4.1 stars out of 5 and that score has been calculated on 15 reviews.

As you can read, the average of ratings is good, and it's based on a large number of feddbacks, so we may conclude that the assessment is very faithful. If many people have bothered to value when they've done well, is that it works.

You know that we don't usually bother to give reviews when these are positive and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Butcher Shop is classified in the category of Butcher shop.

Where is L. Simchick, & Co.?

REVIEWS OF L. Simchick, & Co. IN New York

Katherine Wallace

Janusz Szubert

Best of the best. Mr. Simchick and his amazing, hard-working staff manage to accommodate every persons' order and always meet the needs of the customers and always know the best recommendations to any occasion you may have. You don't find service this spectacular anywhere else. The wide variety of meats and on-site prepared dishes, as well as their deep understanding of meat dishes are what makes this family run brick-and-mortar butcher shop its' claim to fame.

Carolina Sanchez

Worst business ever.

John F

Horrible customer service the non documented employees have no respect for anyone. This place is infested cockroaches and insects.

Elia Rodriguez Gonzalez

Best Short Ribs!!! Excellent Customer Service.

The Corcoran Group .

Great old school butcher shop – friendly and exceptionally knowledgeable. Try their hot Italian sausage.

Brett Minarik

Quick and friendly service at this old-school, authentic neighborhood butcher. I emailed ahead for a large order and the owner coordinated personally and gave me a fantastic price. It would have been a great price even outside of the city... but it was out of this world for NY butcher shops! Customer for life.

Maria Fornella-Oehninger

Great food, great service, bilingual employees

[LeTaL] Hitokiri Battousai

enid nemy

Jason Krueger

If you are in midtown east you shouldn't be buying meat anywhere else. Old school butcher with friendly service

Tim Hand

First time coming here, even though I've been in the neighborhood for more than a year. Great little place with a large selection of pre-made meals. Of course they have a great selection meat. Very helpful staff who are willing to take the time to answer questions and cut to your liking.

Claudia Brizendine

Horrible Customer Service and tried to scam me! I will not be coming back to this place even if I was offered free meat for 1 year. Yesterday I bought 2 steaks and a piece of organic chicken for my baby. It was almost closing time but there were still customers inside. First thing I noticed is that their entrance doesn't have an easy access for the disabled. I was with my baby in a stroller and no one bothered to open the door for me. The young butcher was right there, close to the door, where he saw me struggling to open the door and push the stroller inside. When is my turn, I ask a few questions about the steaks and if they have organic chicken. The butcher seemed annoyed that I was asking those questions. Very well. I placed my order and asked for a receipt. For some reason I asked for a real receipt, the ones that states your purchase and how much each item costs. My baby starts fussing a little bit and I give her some water while the butcher is writing the receipt. When I get home (15 min after) and realize that I don't have the butcher bag with me, I immediately call them and leave a voice mail saying that I forgot my purchase there. I know I have been very exhausted due to lack of sleeping but I don't usually forget things like that. I was not given then bag. I was given the receipt while I was attending to my baby and just left without asking for the bag. This morning I go there and ask the butcher if he remembers me. I say that I left my order in the store. He looks at me with a suspicious look and say "oh yes you bought chicken" I said yes and that I also bought 2 steaks. He immediately got defensive and doesn't believe me. Then I say that I have a receipt and he says 'I want to see that receipt". Then he goes off by saying that he doesn't have the bag with my meat. That he put it in the counter and that I should have not forget to take it with me. That they don't give credit for things like that bla bla bla. (WHO ASKED FOR CREDIT?). Then one of the Spanish butchers opens some fridge door and gives me my bag. I thank him and head to the door to leave. The young butcher still has the nerve to come tell me that I should not forget things and that if someone had taken the bag they couldn't do anything bla bla bla...I just told him a few things and left so I didn't have to loose too much my temper in front of my baby daughter. My conclusion is that they were trying to scam me. Trying to scam a woman out of 2 steaks and chicken for her baby. Shame on you! (This place was suggested to me by the neighborhood fish store that I love. I will tell them what happen next time I go buy fish)

Nicky Chang

Bought veal shank for osso buco that served 7. Best osso buco turn out ever. No complains. The marrow is delicious too. Hands down best meat.

Jason Silva

Business Hours of L. Simchick, & Co. in New York



L. Simchick, & Co. en New York
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Big Apple Meat Market
Big Apple Meat Market
Butcher Shop - New York


United Meat Market
United Meat Market
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop deli

Oneg Shabbos Gourmet Butcher Shoppe
Oneg Shabbos Gourmet Butc...
Butcher Shop - New York

Butcher shop

Harry & Ida's Meat and Supply Co.
Harry & Ida's Meat and Su...
Butcher Shop - New York

Sandwich shop

Samsung 837
Samsung 837
Butcher Shop - New York

Event venue