Reviews of Ottomanelli Bros (Butcher Shop)

1549 York Ave, New York, NY 10028, United States

Average Rating:


We have all the reviews of people who are purchasing the services of Ottomanelli Bros (Butcher Shop) near to the state of New Jersey.

Currently the firm has a score of 4.7 over 5 and that rating has been calculated on 29 reviews.

You must have seen that it has an average rating is nearly the best one, and it is founded on a large number of reviews, so we may conclude that the rating is quite reliable. If there are many people who bothered to leave their review when they are happy with the service, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually stop to set opinions when these are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or issue...

This Butcher Shop is included in the category of Butcher shop.

Where is Ottomanelli Bros?

REVIEWS OF Ottomanelli Bros IN New Jersey

Phil Sanzari

A Yorkville staple! Great products and reasonable prices. Great service too.

Alexander Riccio

Heh, I've never been to a proper butcher before, usually buying steaks at Morton Williams/Food Emporium/Stop N' Shop/Publix, where it's kinda hit-and-miss to get a nice, thick, steak. So now that I'm learning to cook, I've found that I can't even really cook thin steaks reliably. I can't stick a meat thermometer in them! So I went to Ottomanelli Bros today - it's a little bit out of my way, and I had to take the Q train one stop - and found my way over to York avenue. It's a nice old fashioned place! I got a great cut of sirloin, about 1 pound, for only a buck or two more than the supermarket... I was actually expecting to pay more, but this was a nice surprise. Once I cooked it, I was quite happy that I'd gone out of my way :) I like this place, and I bet I'll be back.

Marge McGaughan

I can't condemn something I haven't witnessed. I am here to rank the food which having eaten it, I can honestly rank as wonderful.

Sana Ahmed-seghir

We took two sandwiches and they were absolutely delicious! Very friendly staff and great food, we will come back!

Frances Katz

Graham Hixon

Great classic butcher

Lance S

Kevin Buisson

Giulia Wood

Great quality meat, great selection, extremely friendly staff. I feel so blessed to live near a real, old-school butcher shop like this one!

Victoria Melignano

Zoe Heineman

Simply the best.

Duncan Corr

John Herron

Fabulous old time butcher. Their bacon, steaks and lamb are family favorites.

Nicole Daniel

Zach Zangeneh

Really good food and very nice butchers

Criscelis Claudio


Everything is fresh and we'll presented. Whenever I'm in the area, I make it a point to stop in.

Donald Aridas

Marc Zdanow

On Valentine's Day I had to pick up some skirt steak and these guys waited for me as I was in a cab stuck in traffic. Despite the fact that I arrived 5 mins after closing time; they took great care of me and my Valentine's Day dinner was saved. Great service - above and beyond!

Stefanie Sierra

If you want excellent quality meat, this is where you come. ( This isn't the butcher shop that's associated with investigation that recently came up it was in Ottomanelli & Sons Meat Market. Completely different from this location.)

Bruce Johnson

Best brisket sandwich I've ever had. Highly recommended.

Anthony Ricco

Cooked best steak of my life with this meat!!

Holly Burgess

Great selection of steaks

Uri T

Mario Paez

Best roast beef sandwich you'll ever have in your life. I've been living UES Manhattan for 7 years and have eaten at plenty of Delis all over NYC, including ones that make it on TV, and Ottomanelli's Butcher Shoppe at 82nd and York Ave in Manhattan will beat them're getting a meat sandwich at a 100+ year old butcher shoppe on the Upper East Side...i mean you really can't go wrong. Come eat sandwiches here !!!

Donald Schink


Jay Perez

mikey v

these fellas hooked me up with the greatest steak i ever had. thanks.

John Drivas

Friendly service. Great food and good coffee.

Ray Hubley

Mediocre butcher (once decent); horrible people. Patronize CItarella for better quality and service.

Business Hours of Ottomanelli Bros in New Jersey



Ottomanelli Bros en New Jersey
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Monmouth Meats
Monmouth Meats
Butcher Shop - New Jersey

Butcher shop

Paisanos Butcher Shop
Paisanos Butcher Shop
Butcher Shop - New Jersey

Butcher shop

Arnie’s Gourmet Butcher Shop & Culinaria of Ocean CIty
Arnie’s Gourmet Butcher...
Butcher Shop - New Jersey

Butcher shop

Rosario's Butcher Shop & Itln
Rosario's Butcher Shop & ...
Butcher Shop - New Jersey

Butcher shop

M&M Perrotti's Prepared Foods
M&M Perrotti's Prepared F...
Butcher Shop - New Jersey

Butcher shop