Reviews of Preferred Meats Inc. (Butcher Shop)

7617 Old Hwy 60 #3, Sellersburg, IN 47172

Average Rating:


Here we offer you all the opinions of real people like you who bought the services of Preferred Meats Inc. (Butcher Shop) in Indiana.

To this day the firm receives a score of 4.8 stars over 5 and that rating was based on 62 reviews.

As you can see its rating is basically the top, and it is founded on a very large number of reviews, so we can be pretty sure that the evaluation is very reliable. If there are many people who bothered to leave their review when they've done well, is that it works.

You know that we don't usually bother to set opinions when these are good and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or issue...

This Butcher Shop belongs to the category of Butcher shop deli.

Where is Preferred Meats Inc.?

REVIEWS OF Preferred Meats Inc. IN Indiana

Nathaniel Parker

Michael Portwood

Great staff will excellent product. Good selections. Beef, bison, pork, duck, you name it. Boar's Head deli meat and cheeses. Craft beer and local wines.

Rebecca Gaskill

Always helpful and always great merchandise.

Josh Allen

Joseph Cole

Love this place

Jeremy Bettis

This place is amazing. The people are wonderful. They have great cuts of meat. It is a one-stop-shop.


Ani Pell

Jonathan Davis

Always great service. Except for Sarah.... Just kidding.

Jessica Batman

Excellent quality meats and wonderful customer service!!!

Jeremy Kruer

Very nice staff, great choice of meats, and good price.

Jen Alvarez

Zachary Blair

Beautiful store, beautiful meat, and amazing employees! Great family owned butcher!

Anne Bruker

Great selection, nice staff. Will be back

Zachariah Peacock

Jon Neace

Hands down the best place to get meat, fish and any butcher supplies in Southern Indiana

Sherry Csereklye

Martha Crenshaw

Absolutely the best place ever. The butcher is great and explained to me how to debone my turkey. Very kind! And the selection of seasonings meat cheese Awesome!! Very helpful nice staff!!

John McJohn

Very rude and disrespectful woman running this place. We were loyal customers, going several time a month until a rack of ribs we bought was bad. First the lady tried to tell me on the phone the smell was normal. When I took it in she tried to make me feel like an idiot and acted like I was trying to cheat them. She was EXTREMELY rude. Never once apologized. They will not see us again and I'll be sure to tell all my friends and family in Sellersburg, Jeffersonville, New Albany and Crothersville. A business that doesn't care how they treat customers probably doesn't care about what they sell to customers.

Linda Francke

Great products, great service, and friendly service.

John Wojciechowski

I live in Louisville and have heard tales about this place. So, I decided to drive 9.5 miles to visit. I am so glad that I did. The selection of meats and sausages was great. The staff was friendly and quite helpful. I purchased a bit more than I wanted - but it was worth it. They also have pure lard that they render themselves! Just a warning folks - I'll Be Back!

Todd Miller

Wow this shop was way more than I expected. Their name does not say it all. This grocery has a bit of everything! I'll be back!

Kayla Altman

I use to buy my meat from kroger until I stopped here. You can taste the quality. The ground beef tastes 100% better than the Laura Lynn I bought. My burgers swelled in size rather than shriveled. They have a lot of different items including duck, Amish chicken, fish, and shrimp. The store smells clean and the staff is always helpful. Oh one last thing the prices are awesome!

Robin Shope

Always fast and friendly service. Great quality and prices. Highly recommended!

Alexandra Miles-Lasseter

Excellent beef, bacon and sausage. They sell dairy from JD Country Milk in Kentucky which is low heat pasteurized and non-homogenized. Only had a problem with product once and when I called they took my name and I brought it to them the next time I was in--replaced, no problem.

kevin knott

Amazing selection, very helpful and friendly service every time.

Joel McCauley

Adrian Harris

Their meats are just beautiful and fresh

April Dawn

Trevor E

We absolutely LOVE preferred meats. The amish eggs we get there are fantastic. My wife doesn't get any headaches after eating them like she does from store bought ones. We enjoy the ground chuck and steaks as well. I think we've tried just about everything they have. Sausage, bacon, brats, you just can't go wrong!

Clyde Whitt

Great service! Excellent products and services.

amanda b

So much better than box store meat!

Dave Brown

They have Boar's Head deli meats and cheeses. If you have never had it then you are really missing out. The staff was very knowledgeable and fast.

Paula Roark

My favorite food shop...great service and products.

Richard Kellams

Great people, great place!!!! I bought a large amount of items and they were very professional..

Kevin Graves

Brian Holdaway

Awsome place. Great local meats and food.


Top quality, very clean, great knowledgeable customer service.

Christopher Hamm

Sherri Kendall

Susan Martin

We have been coming here for a couple of months and there hasn't been anything that wasn't delicious! The people are friendly and helpful! We are so glad we found this place.

Rebecca Lane

I love this place, they have the best meat around

Matt and Marianne Bellucci

Tim K

took home some ribeyes....grilled up to be the best ever...ever

Emily Kaskie

j budd

Wouldn't buy Christmas beef tenderloin anywhere else!

Michelle Cooper

Awesome meats. The Hawaiian sausages are the best! Great steak tips! Excellent service too.

Danielle Self

Exceptional customer service, reasonable prices and a great selection.

Traci Wood

This place is the best butcher shop around. Great quality at a great price. Staff is friendly and very educated on all cuts of meat. Sell a variety of meats, cheeses, fresh vegetables, wine and even already prepared items to throw in the oven.

M Fitz


First time to the store . Very clean and the staff was extra nice. I would recommend this store to anybody. Great prices.Have anything you would want. Try the thick bone in pork chop

Tony Geraghty

I love this place. The meat here tastes so much better and fresher than from the grocery store.

Darren Justice

My new one stop shop for dinner parties..they have everything and its all high quality

Karen Spies

Deb Duffy

They have the best meat in town and the staff are super.

Shelby Martin

carol forbis

great place to get fresh meats/poultry. Excellent flavors-much better than what you will get in the grocery store. Great selection of deli meats and cheese. Everyone always VERY friendly and helpful

Trent Hunt

Awesome store with great service and products. New ownership with Samantha and John Huber (January 1st, 2017) has taken it to a quality level unmatched in the area. Love the new layout and additional products available including beer and wine. Cannot go wrong here!!!

Frank Putirka

Well with the drive and paying a few more dollars then you would at the grocery store. The quality of there meat and customer service is well with it.

d soby

A little pricey, but good quality

Sarah Milligan

I just love this place! The staff is out of this world!! The meat is good too

Business Hours of Preferred Meats Inc. in Indiana



Preferred Meats Inc. en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Dave's Meat Market
Dave's Meat Market
Butcher Shop - Indiana

Butcher shop

Bill's Meat Market
Bill's Meat Market
Butcher Shop - Indiana

Butcher shop

Taylor's Cajun Meat Company
Taylor's Cajun Meat Company
Butcher Shop - Indiana

Butcher shop

Lange's Old Fashion Meat Market
Lange's Old Fashion Meat ...
Butcher Shop - Indiana

Butcher shop

Boilermaker Butcher Block
Boilermaker Butcher Block
Butcher Shop - Indiana

Butcher shop