Reviews of Indy Meat Shop (Butcher Shop)

Doug Miller

Great meats, good price

Emily Bailey

Person behind the counter took a call while I was mid-sentence on what I needed. No one there seemed to care. The NY Strips we bought were TERRIBLE. I unpacked them and they were so light pink they looked like pork. At the shop I only saw them under the shade of the shelf above so I didn’t realize how light they were. Almost no marbling whatsoever, cut too thin for my taste, and even medium rare they are really tough. I am not exaggerating when I say that the steak I got prepackaged at Kroger was better. We thought we’d treat ourselves but I see why it was cheaper than Kroger now.

stephen hartbarger

Was in the Meat Shop last Thursday, and was ignored the entire time I was there. Attempted to get meat from the female employee, who was in the middle of helping with my requests, but her friend came into the store. They were still engaging in conversation ten minutes later while my friend was checking out. During the wait, I saw a rat run across the front of the meat counter, and that was it. Didn't even wait for her to finish her conversation. I had been there long enough and had seen too much. Really enjoyed going there, buying most of our meat there. I was off to Klauses on the southside-longer drive from the westside, but really paid off. They were bright, cheerful, full of suggestions, and very customer-oriented. They have been around for years-even going back to the days when they were in the city market. Indy Meat Shop has always been one of our stops when it comes to meat, but those days are gone. Clean up the rat poop and get your employees to be more on point when it comes to customers. Ignoring them to long gives them a real feel for what is going on in that shop

Hank Lorenz

What a joke. Ordered a bulk meat package that was not ready by the date promised. Called 4 days after it was supposed to be ready (we were told they would call when it was ready) and was on hold for 5 minutes while they tried to determine if they had our order or not. Finally someone told us that they only had part of our order, they found the ticket, but no longer had all the meat, and didn't know why we hadn't been called . They offered to make substitutions for the items, we told them what we wanted, and they then told us that we could pick it up anytime. We arrived at the Meat Shop 2 hours later and the women at the counter had no idea what we were talking about. We explained again....... We waited for 25 minutes while they fumbled around in the freezer to put together the order that we were told was ready to pick up. While we waited, another customer came in to pick up an order that was also a week late. They left empty handed. At the register they tried to charge us 2 times the price that we were quoted and that is advertised on their fliers. When we questioned the price difference they actually became rude with us. We did the math for them on paper with the prices from their price list. They adjusted the price and told us to "Take our meat and get the hell out of there". We did and wont be back.

Nailz Nikki Smith

Very customer. Friendly

Elihu Haileleul

The best meat shop ever! for real

Jennifer Nevill

Speedy and friendly service. They answered all my questions. Thanks

Brian Payne

I bought some country ribs. They were slimy and they smelled. When I brought them back the manager or owner gave me a bunch of attitude. He said they were fine

Bob parker

Best meat I have ever eaten ! Especially their bacon !

stephen lough

Love the meat here. Will buy my meat here for now on.

Michael Witham

Always had great deals and am never disappointed by the quality of meat!

Doug Miller

Great meats, good price

Emily Bailey

Person behind the counter took a call while I was mid-sentence on what I needed. No one there seemed to care. The NY Strips we bought were TERRIBLE. I unpacked them and they were so light pink they looked like pork. At the shop I only saw them under the shade of the shelf above so I didn’t realize how light they were. Almost no marbling whatsoever, cut too thin for my taste, and even medium rare they are really tough. I am not exaggerating when I say that the steak I got prepackaged at Kroger was better. We thought we’d treat ourselves but I see why it was cheaper than Kroger now.

stephen hartbarger

Was in the Meat Shop last Thursday, and was ignored the entire time I was there. Attempted to get meat from the female employee, who was in the middle of helping with my requests, but her friend came into the store. They were still engaging in conversation ten minutes later while my friend was checking out. During the wait, I saw a rat run across the front of the meat counter, and that was it. Didn't even wait for her to finish her conversation. I had been there long enough and had seen too much. Really enjoyed going there, buying most of our meat there. I was off to Klauses on the southside-longer drive from the westside, but really paid off. They were bright, cheerful, full of suggestions, and very customer-oriented. They have been around for years-even going back to the days when they were in the city market. Indy Meat Shop has always been one of our stops when it comes to meat, but those days are gone. Clean up the rat poop and get your employees to be more on point when it comes to customers. Ignoring them to long gives them a real feel for what is going on in that shop

Hank Lorenz

What a joke. Ordered a bulk meat package that was not ready by the date promised. Called 4 days after it was supposed to be ready (we were told they would call when it was ready) and was on hold for 5 minutes while they tried to determine if they had our order or not. Finally someone told us that they only had part of our order, they found the ticket, but no longer had all the meat, and didn't know why we hadn't been called . They offered to make substitutions for the items, we told them what we wanted, and they then told us that we could pick it up anytime. We arrived at the Meat Shop 2 hours later and the women at the counter had no idea what we were talking about. We explained again....... We waited for 25 minutes while they fumbled around in the freezer to put together the order that we were told was ready to pick up. While we waited, another customer came in to pick up an order that was also a week late. They left empty handed. At the register they tried to charge us 2 times the price that we were quoted and that is advertised on their fliers. When we questioned the price difference they actually became rude with us. We did the math for them on paper with the prices from their price list. They adjusted the price and told us to "Take our meat and get the hell out of there". We did and wont be back.

Nailz Nikki Smith

Very customer. Friendly

Elihu Haileleul

The best meat shop ever! for real

Jennifer Nevill

Speedy and friendly service. They answered all my questions. Thanks

Brian Payne

I bought some country ribs. They were slimy and they smelled. When I brought them back the manager or owner gave me a bunch of attitude. He said they were fine

Bob parker

Best meat I have ever eaten ! Especially their bacon !

stephen lough

Love the meat here. Will buy my meat here for now on.

Michael Witham

Always had great deals and am never disappointed by the quality of meat!

Leslie Hooten

Love this place!! Good meat and very reasonable prices!!

Debbie Carben

Great Meat Great Prices. We go here every month to save money

Richard Mcintire

Was the worst New York Strip steak I have ever had in my entire life. It was so tough we couldn't even chew it. Will never buy from them again

Live Life

We are new to the area and we like to buy meat in bulk. Went here after googling meat markets. Prices seemed soso but feasible so we decided to take a trip there. We walked in and decided to place a order then Lord behold we saw roaches crawling across the floor. Disgusted we told the staff , they did NOTHING. Shrugged it off and went on their way needless to say we cancelled our order and left. Be careful with your food choices.

Belinda York

Went there yesterday and bought a rack of baby backs and a rack of spare ribs, while standing in line I noticed a pot roast in the display case had greenish spots on it (like bad meat) also noticed the same thing on some short ribs in the case! I should have left then but I figured since ribs were wrapped in shrink wrap and looked ok I would ahead with it. Got the baby backs home and unwrapped them and the house was immediately filed with a horrific smell like sewer gas. We took back, the guys told us the meat was gassy but not bad, I did some reading there is such a thing, but I'm not talking any chances I have had food poisoning from pork before I not eating anything that smells like that. I went to Sam's club theirs never smell like that!!! SO, NO MORE MEAT SHOP FOR ME!

James Herald

Great service as always

Wade Smock

Last year I got a 10 point buck took it to them to have it caped and went ahead and had them processed the meat even though I've always processed mine before every dear I've ever got I've processed myself never had one piece of hair ever in any grind that I did. On the other hand they did to 22 pounds of grind for me and every single package has had multiple hairs in it I find that unexcusable. One piece of hair in one package would have been fine but not multiple hairs in every single package I had to throw it all out I can't give it to anybody I can't use it myself. It's dog food. And really how do you call and tell a butcher that he is left hair from your deer in every package of grind they'll just want to argue with you and tell you it didn't happen so it's not even worth my time. I would give them no stars if I could.

Leslie Hooten

Love this place!! Good meat and very reasonable prices!!

Debbie Carben

Great Meat Great Prices. We go here every month to save money

Richard Mcintire

Was the worst New York Strip steak I have ever had in my entire life. It was so tough we couldn't even chew it. Will never buy from them again

Live Life

We are new to the area and we like to buy meat in bulk. Went here after googling meat markets. Prices seemed soso but feasible so we decided to take a trip there. We walked in and decided to place a order then Lord behold we saw roaches crawling across the floor. Disgusted we told the staff , they did NOTHING. Shrugged it off and went on their way needless to say we cancelled our order and left. Be careful with your food choices.

Belinda York

Went there yesterday and bought a rack of baby backs and a rack of spare ribs, while standing in line I noticed a pot roast in the display case had greenish spots on it (like bad meat) also noticed the same thing on some short ribs in the case! I should have left then but I figured since ribs were wrapped in shrink wrap and looked ok I would ahead with it. Got the baby backs home and unwrapped them and the house was immediately filed with a horrific smell like sewer gas. We took back, the guys told us the meat was gassy but not bad, I did some reading there is such a thing, but I'm not talking any chances I have had food poisoning from pork before I not eating anything that smells like that. I went to Sam's club theirs never smell like that!!! SO, NO MORE MEAT SHOP FOR ME!

James Herald

Great service as always

Wade Smock

Last year I got a 10 point buck took it to them to have it caped and went ahead and had them processed the meat even though I've always processed mine before every dear I've ever got I've processed myself never had one piece of hair ever in any grind that I did. On the other hand they did to 22 pounds of grind for me and every single package has had multiple hairs in it I find that unexcusable. One piece of hair in one package would have been fine but not multiple hairs in every single package I had to throw it all out I can't give it to anybody I can't use it myself. It's dog food. And really how do you call and tell a butcher that he is left hair from your deer in every package of grind they'll just want to argue with you and tell you it didn't happen so it's not even worth my time. I would give them no stars if I could.

tabitha peterson

I ordered meat to be delivered today!! And it's a no show but the money's been taken from my card and now no one gmhas answered and I'm sure closed now... I had a party this was for I now have to cancel... I' am beyond pissed!!!! No call no nothing!!!! I want someone to cokntacr me now!! U have both my numbers

Betty Bates

I will never shop at this store. The staff has a very bad attude not helpful. Very nasty and grouchy.

Bob Brown

Just a meat shop. Nothing stands out to include prices

Taylor Butner

6:25.....closes at 6:30.....door is locked and blonde cashier acts like she can't see me outside. Really?! Thanks for everything.

diana barnett

Alway has the freshest meat i have found. They can even cut the meat to your specification.

glenn waltman

Great place,fresh meat,prices can't be beat with lots of options meat is to order great people to deal with.

Willie Maekit

Good selection of freshly butchered Beef, Pork and Chicken. Well priced cuts from beef fillet to butterflied pork chops. Some frozen stuff too. Most of the fresh beef is 'SELECT' grade.

tabitha peterson

I ordered meat to be delivered today!! And it's a no show but the money's been taken from my card and now no one gmhas answered and I'm sure closed now... I had a party this was for I now have to cancel... I' am beyond pissed!!!! No call no nothing!!!! I want someone to cokntacr me now!! U have both my numbers

Betty Bates

I will never shop at this store. The staff has a very bad attude not helpful. Very nasty and grouchy.

Bob Brown

Just a meat shop. Nothing stands out to include prices

Taylor Butner

6:25.....closes at 6:30.....door is locked and blonde cashier acts like she can't see me outside. Really?! Thanks for everything.

diana barnett

Alway has the freshest meat i have found. They can even cut the meat to your specification.

glenn waltman

Great place,fresh meat,prices can't be beat with lots of options meat is to order great people to deal with.

Willie Maekit

Good selection of freshly butchered Beef, Pork and Chicken. Well priced cuts from beef fillet to butterflied pork chops. Some frozen stuff too. Most of the fresh beef is 'SELECT' grade.

John Q Public

excellent

Barry Morrow

Great place been getting meat from them for afew years and every thing is always great. And the price of things are way cheaper then the big store's you will not be disappointed

Val Thompson

Best porterhouse I have ever ate. Ask them to cut them to 1 1/4 , They are glad to help you.Good prices. Old people get 10% off on thursday.

Aaron Parrish

i love this place

Angie Biggs

They break the meat down and wrap it for me since I am single. Never had one complaint about doing it. The meat is great quality. Staff is always nice.

John Q Public

excellent

Barry Morrow

Great place been getting meat from them for afew years and every thing is always great. And the price of things are way cheaper then the big store's you will not be disappointed

Val Thompson

Best porterhouse I have ever ate. Ask them to cut them to 1 1/4 , They are glad to help you.Good prices. Old people get 10% off on thursday.

Aaron Parrish

i love this place

Angie Biggs

They break the meat down and wrap it for me since I am single. Never had one complaint about doing it. The meat is great quality. Staff is always nice.