Reviews of Jimmy P's Butcher Shop & Deli (Butcher Shop)

Michael Coront

If it was larger no doubt a 5 star. Meats are the best.

Peter Hepworth

Real meat

Julie Parra

Best Wagyu rib eye you’ll ever find. Freshly cut. Delicious. Nice staff. Great choices of all kinds of meat. Expensive but worth the amazing quality

Matt Clark

Great pastrami sandwich, beef bacon was pretty good, but would rather eat pork bacon.meat selection is awesome.

Tyler Mac

Best in town.

Karri Andrews

Great St. Louis Ribs and signature sauce

bruce rollinson

Aside from the horrible parking situation, I love everything about Jimmy P's except I always leave with far more good stuff than I went there for. Best speciality market in Naples. And off season, I actually meet friends there for lunch and dinner. B Rollinson

Nellie Lao

Food and delicious aNd fresh. Coullette is my favorite meat Love the steak sandwiches and fries as well. Highly recommended..

Aaron Orzack

Food and service was great. Will certainly be back.

MARIA CAVAZOS

Very good food.

Anthony

Best butcher shop!

Sherrie Philips

Always top notch!

Daniel Rock

Very good and filling burgers. Their onion rings taste amazing. A little bit pricey for what it is but, their wagyu beef is every flavorful vs a regular beef hamburger. I will be going again. Their portion sizes are plentiful

Joshua Ritz

Exceptional quality and service

Larry Pratt

Food is delicious and fresh.

Smiley Miley

I have been to this place before, it is a unique and personal favorite of mine. I really enjoy their meats and their creativity, as well as the common courtesies and dedication exercised by the staff. I would like to especially revolve this review around the flexible, decent menu and wide selection of meats, eats, wines, and frozen foods. This establishment’s menu also has a rare – at least in my mind – feature, allowing you to pick your cut of meat from the butcher shop and pay its price, plus a small extra fee. I sure enjoyed my Wagyu Baseball cut today! I have been coming to this place once a year for the past 3 years, and including today I’ve enjoyed each time superbly! However, I recall I enjoyed the first time more, due to the fact Jimmy P’s used to have a bacon-wrapped filet on their menu. Sometime after my first visit however, it was removed, and while I am a little disappointed in that, I’m basing my review on the experience I had today, not past experiences. Today my aforementioned Wagyu Baseball Cut was brought to me rare when I had ordered it medium. I did not notice this at first until I had cut the meat. While I could forgive that misunderstanding easily, since I had at first ordered it medium-rare and changed it to medium seconds later, I could’ve been on a sort of diet, or training regimen. The customer is always right they say, and I endeavor to follow that old axiom. This restaurant is quite wonderful, but I give my visit one star short of what I wished, unfortunately because my steak wasn’t cooked long enough.

godshall1955

Best Kobe hot dogs and waygu steaks/burgers for the grill

David Varisco

WAY - WAY too expensive!

Jonathan Hernandez

The food is awesome!

Matthew Steves

The downtown naples location is the best tried and true! The other locations can be spotty for service and food quality. I want to eat everything in here! Fresh cut wagyu burgers, roasts, hot dogs, and cases full of side dish options. The hot deli counter serves the best wagyu burgers in town! Seating is limited but so worth it. Next door charred by jimmy p is the full service concept. But for lunch the hot deli counter on the butcher shop side delivers!