Reviews of The Lucky Goat Butcher Shop (Butcher Shop)

Nathaniel de Leon

I bought a sriracha chicken salad sandwich. Generous helping and delicious.

Paula Eyberse

Highest of Quality products, Fast and friendly service...always...Meats are exceptional, Soups and Chowders are the BEST I've ever had, this is just the place we were looking for and now it's right here in our community. We are very happy you opened this shop! I was having such a hard time digesting anything I got from the local Supermarkets and thanks to your shop I can enjoy not only great steaks and burgers etc...but we can also taste the difference so, Thanks for coming to town and we wish you GREAT success.

Cathie Horan

Great place to shop!

Al Paradis

Great customer service amazing selections of cuts

Danielle

Overpriced, felt rushed by workers, minimal amount of meats on grinder.

Mary Bona

Best meat in miles. Prices reflect quality; I have never been disappointed. I do agree with other reviews that some of the help isn't customer friendly but hopefully they will learn with time.

Nathaniel de Leon

I bought a sriracha chicken salad sandwich. Generous helping and delicious.

Paula Eyberse

Highest of Quality products, Fast and friendly service...always...Meats are exceptional, Soups and Chowders are the BEST I've ever had, this is just the place we were looking for and now it's right here in our community. We are very happy you opened this shop! I was having such a hard time digesting anything I got from the local Supermarkets and thanks to your shop I can enjoy not only great steaks and burgers etc...but we can also taste the difference so, Thanks for coming to town and we wish you GREAT success.

Cathie Horan

Great place to shop!

Al Paradis

Great customer service amazing selections of cuts

Danielle Wright

Overpriced, felt rushed by workers, minimal amount of meats on grinder.

Mary Bona

Best meat in miles. Prices reflect quality; I have never been disappointed. I do agree with other reviews that some of the help isn't customer friendly but hopefully they will learn with time.

Walter Norris

Awesome products, aged beef, fine selection of specialty cheeses, seafood and all is fresh. We will be back many times.

Lori Kapinos

This is best apple pie I ever tasted. The crust is so light and fluffy. The apples divine. Great pie.

Mark Knittel

Great meat, great service.

Douglas Harz

Great meat at fair prices. Staff is always friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. It's great having a local butcher that carries excellent quality brisket and pork butt. Not to mention that the NY strip steaks they carry have never let me down and can be counted amongst the best I've ever had. Hoping this place is around for a very long time.

ECO Coffee House

Hands down, best meats, meals & sides and awesome salads in Connecticut. Best breakfast sammies with their own made in house sausage!! Crushing it!

Jacky Welch

Awesome meAt and fish products!!

Walter Dobosz

The food may be good but their driver nearly forced my wife off the road on I-95 in New Haven today. She was traveling at 54 mph in the middle lane, signaling to exit right at exit 3. The "Lucky" Goat driver, about 30-35 in age, attached himself to her rear bumper. Apparently moving into the available left hand, passing lane would have required far too much energy for said driver. Better to risk the life of a mother of 3. I hope your ambition is ultimately matched by your consideration for your fellow man.

Me

Great food!

Sidney von Katzendame

Hanger steaks? Yes please!!

David Barillaro

Always have had good service, friendly and helpful. Best meat and sandwiches in the area. Also have great chile.

Joshua Scott

Excellent meat at reasonable prices . Won't go anywhere else for my brisket

Sue Makoski

This is a great specialty meat shop. They cater to thier customers requests and the quality is very good. They offer smoked brisket, bacon and kielbasa. My husband loves thier egg sandwiches with smoked bacon.

nancy varela

Lucky Goat Butcher is one of the best!!!

Eric Edwards

Roast beef sandwich is amazeballs!

Walter Norris

Awesome products, aged beef, fine selection of specialty cheeses, seafood and all is fresh. We will be back many times.

Lori Kapinos

This is best apple pie I ever tasted. The crust is so light and fluffy. The apples divine. Great pie.

Mark Knittel

Great meat, great service.

Douglas Harz

Great meat at fair prices. Staff is always friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. It's great having a local butcher that carries excellent quality brisket and pork butt. Not to mention that the NY strip steaks they carry have never let me down and can be counted amongst the best I've ever had. Hoping this place is around for a very long time.

ECO Coffee House

Hands down, best meats, meals & sides and awesome salads in Connecticut. Best breakfast sammies with their own made in house sausage!! Crushing it!

Jacky Welch

Awesome meAt and fish products!!

Walter Dobosz

The food may be good but their driver nearly forced my wife off the road on I-95 in New Haven today. She was traveling at 54 mph in the middle lane, signaling to exit right at exit 3. The "Lucky" Goat driver, about 30-35 in age, attached himself to her rear bumper. Apparently moving into the available left hand, passing lane would have required far too much energy for said driver. Better to risk the life of a mother of 3. I hope your ambition is ultimately matched by your consideration for your fellow man.

Me

Great food!

Sidney von Katzendame

Hanger steaks? Yes please!!

David Barillaro

Always have had good service, friendly and helpful. Best meat and sandwiches in the area. Also have great chile.

Joshua Scott

Excellent meat at reasonable prices . Won't go anywhere else for my brisket

Sue Makoski

This is a great specialty meat shop. They cater to thier customers requests and the quality is very good. They offer smoked brisket, bacon and kielbasa. My husband loves thier egg sandwiches with smoked bacon.

nancy varela

Lucky Goat Butcher is one of the best!!!

Eric Edwards

Roast beef sandwich is amazeballs!

Daniel Stimler

The Lucky-G is where I go for the good stuff, hands down. I found the Lucky Goat while searching for real steaks a few years ago. I didn’t want the Supermarket BS. So a quick google search had me heading to East Hampton and well, the rest is history. They also have a great supply of homemade gourmet dog treats! Also, the service is super friendly. Enjoy!

Sarah Grover

Matt helped me pick out all the foods for my sons birthday party, and even gave me tickets to the Durham Fair to bring the family to celebrate my 6 year old sons birthday. Genuine, awesome people there. Glad to have a business like this one town over from me.

Mark Rolfe

Great quality food.

Christian Petrarca

Top notch from seafood to beef to lamb. Specialty dishes as well as meats.

Aaron Flaum

Great quality of meats and seafood. A little more then the grocery store but you are paying for quality

Douglas Raitz

Over priced and quality of product was poor. Won't buy here again!

Greg Ratti

They have great product, some of there prices are up there but with meat and other food products you get what you pay for, their sandwiches are great!

Joey Guest

Great food

SnipesUdown01 Originals

If you haven't been here yet you are missing out, after one visit I became an instant regular. Don't let the Butcher shop aspect deceive you, this place is a refreshing stop for any meats, cheeses and veggies. It feels like a modernized old school country general store. They serve breakfast sandwiches in the morning and all day you can pick up a fresh made to order sandwich or pick up a hot cup of coffee. It may not be as cheap as a big brand store but it is hands down higher quality. You get what you pay for here.

frank palmisano

Fair selection of meat.

Iliya Yerukhimovich

Its a decent little place, but the prices are outrageous, the bread on the sandwiches isn't fresh, and the ingredients while tasty arent anything special at the price point. Friendly staff and nice location earns the 3rd star.

Brian Holdt

Minimal amount of meat on the grinder? Did someone really write that? Nonsense. The Lucky Goat packs more ingredients into a sandwich than was previously thought possible by mankind Top notch quality, amazing sandwiches, and great premade foods. Five stars is not enough.

Julia Simons

I went in days ahead of Christmas to discuss about getting a lamb roast. The butcher I spoke with showed me a shoulder roast of lamb with just a few rib bones; after I called in and specifically ordered SHOULDER LAMB ROAST, but what I picked up the day before Christmas is a LEG roast with a huge femur bone in it - which will completely change my cooking plans & I'll prbly have to cut the femur out myself & I'll go down from 3 lbs to 2.5. I also asked for thinly cut fatty meat for hot pot but after being asked what I wanted by 4 ppl and telling each - a rude, brusk older man that someone was already helping me, he said "NO, I'm the one helping you, I'M the one cutting your meat." Well he was wrong b/c we ended up with 2 sets of meat & the brusk guy's meat was not fatty at all but lean. Both sets were not as thin as I had asked.

Giorgio Dicesare

Excellent

Nancy H

Excellent products at excellent prices.

Nate Bodnar

Went in for deli sandwiches. Disappointing experience as a whole. Some staff was unorganized and in general the quality of the sandwiches were subpar. This was the agreement between the 6 people in my group. Skip this spot and drive a little further to Salem prime cuts or Nadellis to get a larger, better quality sandwich.

Daniel Stimler

The Lucky-G is where I go for the good stuff, hands down. I found the Lucky Goat while searching for real steaks a few years ago. I didn’t want the Supermarket BS. So a quick google search had me heading to East Hampton and well, the rest is history. They also have a great supply of homemade gourmet dog treats! Also, the service is super friendly. Enjoy!

Sarah Grover

Matt helped me pick out all the foods for my sons birthday party, and even gave me tickets to the Durham Fair to bring the family to celebrate my 6 year old sons birthday. Genuine, awesome people there. Glad to have a business like this one town over from me.

Mark Rolfe

Great quality food.

Christian Petrarca

Top notch from seafood to beef to lamb. Specialty dishes as well as meats.

Aaron Flaum

Great quality of meats and seafood. A little more then the grocery store but you are paying for quality

Douglas Raitz

Over priced and quality of product was poor. Won't buy here again!

Greg Ratti

They have great product, some of there prices are up there but with meat and other food products you get what you pay for, their sandwiches are great!

Joey Guest

Great food

SnipesUdown01 Originals

If you haven't been here yet you are missing out, after one visit I became an instant regular. Don't let the Butcher shop aspect deceive you, this place is a refreshing stop for any meats, cheeses and veggies. It feels like a modernized old school country general store. They serve breakfast sandwiches in the morning and all day you can pick up a fresh made to order sandwich or pick up a hot cup of coffee. It may not be as cheap as a big brand store but it is hands down higher quality. You get what you pay for here.

frank palmisano

Fair selection of meat.

Iliya Yerukhimovich

Its a decent little place, but the prices are outrageous, the bread on the sandwiches isn't fresh, and the ingredients while tasty arent anything special at the price point. Friendly staff and nice location earns the 3rd star.

Brian Holdt

Minimal amount of meat on the grinder? Did someone really write that? Nonsense. The Lucky Goat packs more ingredients into a sandwich than was previously thought possible by mankind Top notch quality, amazing sandwiches, and great premade foods. Five stars is not enough.

Julia Simons

I went in days ahead of Christmas to discuss about getting a lamb roast. The butcher I spoke with showed me a shoulder roast of lamb with just a few rib bones; after I called in and specifically ordered SHOULDER LAMB ROAST, but what I picked up the day before Christmas is a LEG roast with a huge femur bone in it - which will completely change my cooking plans & I'll prbly have to cut the femur out myself & I'll go down from 3 lbs to 2.5. I also asked for thinly cut fatty meat for hot pot but after being asked what I wanted by 4 ppl and telling each - a rude, brusk older man that someone was already helping me, he said "NO, I'm the one helping you, I'M the one cutting your meat." Well he was wrong b/c we ended up with 2 sets of meat & the brusk guy's meat was not fatty at all but lean. Both sets were not as thin as I had asked.

Giorgio Dicesare

Excellent

Nancy H

Excellent products at excellent prices.

Nate Bodnar

Went in for deli sandwiches. Disappointing experience as a whole. Some staff was unorganized and in general the quality of the sandwiches were subpar. This was the agreement between the 6 people in my group. Skip this spot and drive a little further to Salem prime cuts or Nadellis to get a larger, better quality sandwich.

Susan Popielaski

Beautiful Store wonderful staff great selection of meat and seafood fresh fresh fresh

Marlene Geary

Fantastic.

Nancy Gibbons

The Lucky Goat has fabulous foods! My entire family and all my friends love everything they offer. They have "specials" all the time and add new items often so you never get tired of their menu. Just bought Fresh Shimp Cocktail and all our meats (wings) for our Superbowl party! Can't wait to eat it all tomorrow, Yummy!

Jon Herron

My wife and I buy pretty much everything at The Lucky Goat that they sell, in preference to the usual supermarket fare. It is a bit more money, but the quality is *so* much higher… it's just no contest. Try some of their heat-and-serve meals. Their meats (butcher and deli) are sensational. Also try their in-house smoked fish and BBQ. Oh, and the home-made bacon-and-potato salad. You get the idea. We can't believe we in East Hampton lucked out with this specialty butcher shop. If you are not from here, believe me when I say it is worth the drive.

Bryon T

Great local deli and more. Great food,.friendly staff. Excellent food.

Liz Lafleur

Always have a good experience here. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly and the meats fish and sandwiches couldn't be better.

Laurie Muhlberg

Great service! Amanda is awesome! I have celiac and she always makes sure she prepares my sandwiches on a gluten free surface, new gloves, & clean knife. She takes all the preparations so I won't get sick. Great food and great people!

Stephen Bennett

Love it! Small mom and pop shop, Good meat selection, lots of goodies, i'll be back!

Rob R.

Always high quality food and service

Gabrielle Braun-Fales

BEST SANDWICHES YOU WILL EVER BUY!!

Jordana Costa

Gluten free rolls, generous portions and delicious beef stew

Susan Popielaski

Beautiful Store wonderful staff great selection of meat and seafood fresh fresh fresh

Marlene Geary

Fantastic.

Nancy Gibbons

The Lucky Goat has fabulous foods! My entire family and all my friends love everything they offer. They have "specials" all the time and add new items often so you never get tired of their menu. Just bought Fresh Shimp Cocktail and all our meats (wings) for our Superbowl party! Can't wait to eat it all tomorrow, Yummy!

Jon Herron

My wife and I buy pretty much everything at The Lucky Goat that they sell, in preference to the usual supermarket fare. It is a bit more money, but the quality is *so* much higher… it's just no contest. Try some of their heat-and-serve meals. Their meats (butcher and deli) are sensational. Also try their in-house smoked fish and BBQ. Oh, and the home-made bacon-and-potato salad. You get the idea. We can't believe we in East Hampton lucked out with this specialty butcher shop. If you are not from here, believe me when I say it is worth the drive.

Bryon T

Great local deli and more. Great food,.friendly staff. Excellent food.

Liz Lafleur

Always have a good experience here. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly and the meats fish and sandwiches couldn't be better.

Laurie Muhlberg

Great service! Amanda is awesome! I have celiac and she always makes sure she prepares my sandwiches on a gluten free surface, new gloves, & clean knife. She takes all the preparations so I won't get sick. Great food and great people!

Stephen Bennett

Love it! Small mom and pop shop, Good meat selection, lots of goodies, i'll be back!

Rob R.

Always high quality food and service

Gabrielle Braun-Fales

BEST SANDWICHES YOU WILL EVER BUY!!

Jordana Costa

Gluten free rolls, generous portions and delicious beef stew