Reviews of Simple Simon Bakery (Bakery)

218 E Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI 54911, United States

Average Rating:


You will be able to see all the reviews of people like you who consumed the services and products of Simple Simon Bakery (Bakery) near to the state of Wisconsin.

As of day the firm has a score of 4.6 over 5 and this rating has been based on 198 reviews.

You must have seen that the average of ratings is virtually the top, and it is founded on a very high number of feddbacks, so we can think that the rating is very reliable. If many people have bothered to rate when they are satisfied with the business, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually stop to place feddbacks when they are good and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Bakery corresponds to the category of Bakery.

Where is Simple Simon Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Simple Simon Bakery IN Wisconsin

jar_jar_dinks ,

I wonder what there sales are during the summer compared to the school year?

Penny Hughes

Nice little bakery

Mia Soleil

Steve Paltzer

Bicycle Benefits friendly business that is a great place to get sweets, sometimes after bar close!

Jim Haza

Best Bakery Ever!!!

Earl Ruffner


Raeleigh Jones

Loved the cake we purchased. Everything we asked for and more. It was delicious and the frosting was absolutely perfect

Elmin Kurtovic

Jeremy Husain

Jim Cabak

Great doughnuts, breads, and such

Gary North

Great baked goods! Willing to customize things if you call ahead too

Richard McClelland

They had an average product at a fair price. For that reason they served their purpose. I was hoping for a little more variety and higher quality. Simple selection to choose from and simple straight forward taste.

Jennifer Trasser

The staff is always very friendly. The sweets delicious and reasonably priced. I am not a cupcake fan, they usually look good but don’t deliver on taste. My kids talked me into buying a few cupcakes here.. they were amazing. I can’t wait to buy a few for my moms birthday and surprise her.

Tiffani Herlache

Love everything our family has tried here. This is my go to place when I need something sweet that is delicious and reasonably priced!

Larry Gyrion

Poor quality donut that are overpriced.

Chad Stiemke

Great local bakery by people that care about their product and customers.

David Luedtke

Great deal on cookies, love the wheat bread.

steve stoll

A staple in the valley, they have a following like few others. If yoy are looking for quality bakery and a fair price then this is a great place.

Dani Marie

Love their donuts, breads, cookies, scones, muffins, other various pastries and more! The staff is great, welcoming and very friendly. Love them, wonderful people.

Ann Berry

Renee Mazan

I love there bakery items. I've been going there for years.

Wayne Steffen

Michelle Sprunger

Best bakery in Appleton!!!!!

David Mattern

Dawn and the crew are there best. The coffee cake was outstanding. Here is a photo of the cake after the office got to eat.

Seth Berger

Mary is a hoot! Great vibes, delicious donuts, and friendly service.

Debi Sieg


Bill Drumm

Leticia Brown

We used Simple Simon a year ago for our wedding cake. We froze the top to save for our one year anniversary. I was so upset with the cake the first time, this time was no better. My experience from a year ago: My husband and I took in a photo of a cake that we had found online. It was totally out of the ordinary. The lady we spoke with told us that she would have to order a special stencil and she'd have to practice in order to get it right. She assured us that there would be no problem with this. We had asked if we needed a fondant instead of regular frosting due to the design. She said that we would not need the special fondant. I put all of my trust in this lady (not to mention $500). Our wedding day came. Everything was going great until I saw the cake. It was an embarrassment. I had talked this cake up to everyone because it was going to be so awesome. Awesome it was not. It was the complete opposite. So the cake tasted great, but looked horrible. I wrote a review later on on their facebook page describing all of this. To make it short, the response I got was that it was my fault for not getting the fondant and that she told me the cake would look nothing like the picture and pretty much I was a liar. I would not recommend this business to anyone. Ever. Take your business elsewhere. There are plenty of other bakeries that will treat you with respect and that have much better products.

Sam Looker-Koenigs

My go-to bakery: friendly staff, great prices, and DELICIOUS treats.

Randy Cramer

Best service, best donuts in town

Carol Breault

Love Simple Simon.

Mr Smith

Great places to go for fresh donuts

Breccan Kolbe

This place will always hold a special place in my heart for their greatest employee, Marian. Cupcakes and cakes, phenominal... Monkey bread and doughnuts, either soggy or dry.

Ama Capaul

Floyd Palmquist

Great place always a little conversation super cookies super danishes super pies it would take a year to try them all.Marion is the greatest.

Martin Suettinger

Hannah King

Service was awesome and I brought my dpg, we grabbed delicious cheap dog biscuits and they didn't say a word about our boxer lab mix being in there. :)

Jenna Velazquez

Good service. Good cheesecake!

Sara Pheil

Evan Smoll

Bryan Robertson

Small mom & pop shop that to me is a hidden gem in the bakery world, some of the best cupcakes and cookies I've ever had! The service is super friendly also! Love this place!

Lori Harthon Weis

Wonderful bakery

Jennifer Nolde

Simple Simon was recommended to us for cupcakes for our wedding last minute. We had chosen another bakery originally and they were going to charge us over $600 for cupcakes. I called Simple Simon very last minute(a week and a half before the wedding) and they were able to accommodate us for a MUCH more reasonable price. They were so nice to work with and the cupcakes were great! We got so many complements on them. I would definitely recommend them and order from them in the future.

Katie Giese

Anything here is great

Ron Young

Mandy Vale

Michael Buelter

Best bakery ever!

Andrew Shank

Cupcakes are amazing, way better than anywhere else in the valley. Everything else is pretty darn good too.

Steven Dickinson

Great tasting but always seems to be made too early or the day before so they are dried out. Especially with our daughters birthday cake a couple years ago. Never been back for cake that is for sure .

Megan W

Had Simple Simon do our wedding desserts for both the rehearsal dinner and reception. Everything tasted and looked great!! Dawn and everybody else there was great to work with. Incredibly pleased we chose them.

John Vick

Nice little donut shop that's been there for a very long time

Ashley Janssen

I went through Simple Simon Bakery for my wedding cake and also for a baby gender reveal cake. I was extremely satisfied with both cakes and would highly recommend going through them.


Heather Elias

They make just about anything you want and how you want it! Nice people.

Haley Soltau

Only bakery I go to and I absolutely love this place! Parking is a bit weird but dont let that stop you from going in and grabbing a sweet. There cupcakes are so filling and super big. Plus they are only 2.50 a piece! They have so many varieties! Theres an older lady that works there and she is super helpful and super sweet. The muffins are pretty good too if youre looking for something more "healthy"

Benjamin Ziemba

Always fresh, always delicious. I've ordered several custom cakes for various occasions and they have never let me down. The cookies and donuts....oh my goodness good!

matt dietzler

Very pleasant seasoned staff.

Jennie Micke

Very poor service and when I called to let them know that they got my order wrong, I was hung up on once and made to wait on hold for 8.5 minutes when I called back. We will not be going there again.

Brian S

Delicious bakery goods!

Jay Valentin

Mariah Ervin

Best bakery in Appleton, family owned and operated!

Danielle Bell

Yummy sweets. Fantastic staff.

Scott OConnor

All around good food.


Have had great experiences with cupcakes for our wedding and cake for a birthday party. Delicious and creative!

Shane Morrison

Small selection of donuts, but the ones they had were great! It looked like the other baked goodies were popular with the other customers and the entire placed smelled wonderful. The only downside is the lack of seating. The shop is small and there is one small bench outside...

Jon Goetz

I was looking for donuts to take to work....everyone wanted simple Simon.

Derek Kuhlman

Awesome people and the girl that greeted me was a delight and helped me with my first time visit. Definitely will be back.

Sam Telin

Very helpful service

Kevin Palmer

Great stuff!

El Spaniel

Real early bakery perfect- I miss Tastee Bakery - but this is a fine local spot tons better than you get at mander bread type place.

claire gray

Exploit their employees by sometimes firing teens who turn 18 to avoid paying higher wages.

James Heinz

Greay backery

Bonnie Hanson

Donuts were hard wont go back

Cassi Cassi

Wonderful treats

C Larkin

Great service however the donuts and cookies are just okay.


This is my go-to for a free day! Friendly staff, great prices and fun seasonal desserts. Also the best cookies nearby.

Jacci O.

Simple Simon did the dessert bar for our wedding in October and it was incredible! Our personal cake was beautiful and exactly what we wanted. The desserts were delicious. Several of our guests asked for to go boxes so they could take some with them. They let you borrow items for display and deliver them to your venue. Once you return their items they refund the $75 delivery fee. Honestly cannot say enough good things about them. Highly highly recommend them! Get the mini pies and cheesecake, you will not be sorry!

Kate Jaloszynski

Janell F

Great cookies, great donuts, great service! Highly recommend!! Visit on a Wednesday, $1 off dozen of cookies.

Allegra Taylor

Greg Gurta

Very kind, had a "day old" discounted section that was awesome and at a great price

Casey Chrudimsky

Great bakery and likely the best cakes in Appleton.

B Lietz

Tasty baked goods for a decent price.

david willems

I agree with one of the comments below, its just nasty, bottom line. I live near this bakery and I almost never go there. The cookies are way too sweet, donuts have an oily fake taste to them. Not the kind of place id recommend to anyone i know. The service is friendly so sometimes ill go in for a can of soda, and the hamburger buns aren't horrible either but stay away from the bakery especially the fried stuff.

Steve Danelski

Christopher Pascale

Great donuts and friendly staff.

In Christo

They are also at the Farmer's Market.

Cheryl Eichsteadt

Simple Simon met a pie man and they opened a bakery


Very friendly, great service always!!!

Larry Briski

Excellent Customer Service! Great bakery.

Ron Allen

Reminds me of bakery of the past. The smell brought back memories of 30 years ago. Love all their stuff. Pie and dozen donuts to go.

Catherine Spaulding

The staff are super friendly, and they are able to put anything you come up with on your cake, and all their bakery items are delicious.

Carrie Stevens

Simple Simon bakery is our family's local bakery. We love going there on a Sat morning to pick out doughnuts, but more importantly they make fabulous birthday cakes. For the last 2 years I've asked for very particular cakes and they make it happen.


Best bakery in the fox valley

Christapher Prill

Love it

Tommy Lee

Who doesn't love this place? Omg

Joel Pethan


Carl Gustavson

Nice shop!

Ann Lythjohan

Very nice staff, good food. Old time feel with great choices.

Holly Kretlow

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie .I loved theirs will definitely go back for more

Jacob Fahrenkrug

kevin rocha

This place was extremely friendly I loved it

Simple Simon

Johnny Jackson

The smell alone is worth paying for. Small cozy store that has that grandma is baking so welcome home vibe.


Great tasting pastry and baked goods

DJ Adkins

Aiden Verkuilen


Erik Larson

Ida Jones

Varieties & fresh!

James Hodgkinson

Desiree Fenton

It's a small bakery and I thought the items were pricey but, everything was delicious and well worth the price. My favorite was the cherry pie! It was sweet and tart and just all around yummy!

Luz Olivas Lopez


Loren Forslund

A regular for us.

Josh Becky

Love this place

E-Ben Grisby

NEW PAWSibilities

we used Simple Simon for our wedding on May 1st of this year and all I can say is everything from start to finish was amazing. from the service we received the minute we walked in until the day everything was set up at our wedding every person was so professional. we did an entire dessert table that blew us away even though we had seen pictures they outdid themselves our guests went crazy for it we had over 300 people at the wedding and I have received nothing but amazing comments about how great everything tasted and how so many more family members will be using the entire dessert idea instead of just a wedding cake for their events in the future. a huge thank you to the staff for making our day special. Jim D

Amy Veldhorst

I got married this past summer and we decided to go with a variety of desserts instead of just cake. We had tiers of petit fours, cupcakes (three different flavors), cookies initialed with our last name, cheesecake, cake pops (two flavors) and cream puffs. It was absolutely beautiful and was so delicious! The guests loved the variety. The leftovers were used at the gift opening the next day and the rest was put in the freezer. When we pulled the leftovers out of the freezer weeks later, they still tasted delicious! We would recommend Simple Simon to anyone and the cost was very reasonable.

November Gudas-Andersen

I wish I could post a photo of the cake I just picked up for my daughters second birthday party! I forgot about a cake and called last night, and they had it ready for today! It's so beautifully decorated and a SUPER fair price of only $40. Their cake decorator is seriously SO talented. I will be exclusively shopping there for any cakes from now on.

Laura Rodda

Would highly recommend for your wedding! They have tons of options at fair prices compared to other bakers in the area. We were able to customize a small cutting cake for our wedding and then chose from many flavors of cupcakes and cheesecakes for a dessert bar at our wedding. They also had an assortment of trays/decor to set up the dessert bar at no extra cost. We received so many compliments on the desserts! Thank you, Simple Simon Bakery!

Jacie Groeschel

We hired Simple Simon's to cater our wedding dessert bar. They have always been a family favorite bakery and we decided they would be the perfect bakery to leave a sweet taste in our guests mouths after dinner to remember the night on. We had a mix of cupcakes, brownies, and cookies and they were all done extremely well and placed out in a wonderful display.

Elizabeth Hokamp

We had our wedding cake made by Simple Simon as well as the cake for our son's baptism dinner. Always great customer service. They work well with the customer to get everything exactly as you'd like it. The cake is delicious and tastes fresh! Will definitely go back and will highly recommend for anyone looking for a cake for wedding/birthday/graduation, etc.

Carrie Falk

Dan Nord

Patrick Casey

This is the BEST BAKERY in Appleton Wisconsin, and besides being the BEST BAKERY the staff is the most friendly people, with great stories to tell! In warmer weather, you can stop with a friend and get some Bakery and a coffee, or whatever and sit on the bench, for warm conversation and scrumptious bakery, and a drink! It just doesn't get any better than that! I love my neighborhood BAKERY, SIMPLE SIMONS, the best!

Ina Montgomery

A beautiful family run Bakery.

Sam Stockwell

Their bakery is good

Heidi Jopling

pretty boy zombie

Kyle Bunker

It's a bakery it's going to be good it's not like you're buying the crappy Bakery stuff they tried to give you at Kwik Trip that is overpriced

Cathy Epps

I treat our children to donuts from Simple Simon Bakery the first Saturday of every month during the school year. They love it!

Mrs Woodberry

Oh my goodness!!!! I contacted Dawn at Simple Simon and through email we contracted to have them do a wedding cake for my son’s wedding. I am disabled and cannot travel from my home to the bakery so I never actually went to the store. I knew what flavors I wanted for my new daughter in law and I had a rough idea of the cake I wanted made. My husband is a talented artist so I told him what I wanted and he sketched the cake for me. Dawn had me send her the flowers to be used because we needed a particular type of orchid. When the cake was delivered to our venue, I about cried!! It was so perfect!!! Every flower in its place, the custom cake topper fit so perfectly. And I was in awe at how beautiful and perfect this cake truly was. My daughter in law had no idea what her cake might look like. We kept it a secret the entire time. She cried because it was exactly what she had hoped for and more. The cake was so moist and delicious. All of the guests loved it. Everyone wanted to know where we got it from. I never have met the folks at Simple Simon but if I ever need another cake for any reason.....I will not hesitate to call or email them. Thank you to everyone involved on this order. It is exactly what we wanted!!!

Keanna Schulz

joseph pahlow

Small shop home made pasteres good

Chris Klingman

Always friendly service, delicious baked goods, and extremely wallet-friendly prices. I needed a snack that could be cut up and shared for my toddler's daycare, and I decided on a loaf of sweet bread. The woman behind the counter helped me select the cinnamon loaf, and then went and found a label for the bread so that I could take it into daycare for the classroom. Extremely friendly and helpful. That bread also made amazing french toast, FYI.

Richard Petty

Really nice Bakery. Prices and food are both great!

Brittany Gerhardt

Always on point.

Mariah King

The baked goods are very good, however I would have to say that they are very disorganized. I used them for desserts for my wedding and I emailed in my final order and they came back with a order that was from the original conversation. Each email I sent them with questions, the questions weren't answered until I asked 3 more times. Never received an email with an invoice, and when I called to pay my balance, they expected me to know the remaining balance without ever being told, even when I asked for it in prior emails.

Kim Geiger

Awesome as always

Andrew Kazik

Made an amazing wedding cake for my wife and I. Can't say enough about them.

Jeff Baumann

Very good bakery friendly staff

Yvette Dunlap

The Day of the Dead cookies were a work of art, and the apple pie was absolutely delicious. Simple Simon is our family's bakery.

Nicholas Pintarelli

This bakery has amazing cupcakes, cookies, doughnuts, and cake. Staff is super friendly and helpful. We had wedding cake through Simple Simon and couldn't be happier with the result.

T Hess

Dirty, outdated. Not the best at decorating cakes.

Adam Staszak

Bonnie Faestel

Awesome bakery, friendly employees.

Rachel Forster

todd grethey

Excellent food.

Karli Edgerton


Amazing doughnuts and bakery!

Alex Ringmeier

I had the red velvet cupcake. It was excellent- soft and moist with a generous topping of cream cheese frosting. The chocolate chip flakes were a nice touch.

Angela Hummell

I ordered my daughter's birthday cake in advance from another local bakery with very specific requests and even provided an image of what I was aiming for. The end result was a complete disaster. We called Simple Simon to see if they could help us out in emergency. Not only were they totally accommodating, they completely understood what I was asking for and provided EXACTLY that in a mere 1.5 hours. The cake was awesome looking, great tasting and the customer service was OUTSTANDING. Thank you so much for fixing a very important part of any birthday. My daughter loved it!

Stephanie L.

Emily Bowles

I've gotten three of my daughter's recent birthday cakes from Simple Simon, and they have all turned out perfect. One was a Star Wars cake, and this year was Little Red Riding Hood (she saw "Into the Woods" and wanted the fairy tale theme).

Kathy Berger

Excellent bakery. Super friendly!!

David Peterson

Wonderful local bakery. Great Paczkis for Mari Gras. Warm breads everyday. They do wedding cakes too.

Bill Busha

Business Hours of Simple Simon Bakery in Wisconsin



Simple Simon Bakery en Wisconsin
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
The Bakery
The Bakery
Bakery - Wisconsin


Hill Top Bakery
Hill Top Bakery
Bakery - Wisconsin


Linda's Bakery
Linda's Bakery
Bakery - Wisconsin


Cakery & Bake Shop LLC
Cakery & Bake Shop LLC
Bakery - Wisconsin


Quality Bakery
Quality Bakery
Bakery - Wisconsin