Reviews of Sugar Pie Bakery (Bakery)

Mama Hen

Their pumpkin roll is to die for and the cheesecake is amazing!

Dawn Morrison

Ordered a $70 cake for my daughter's college graduation. It was supposed to be white, it was off white. It was supposed to have a black grad cap with white tassel, it was grey with off white tassel. It was supposed to say "Congratulations Madison", it said "Congrats Madison" in huge letters that looked like a kindergarten kid wrote it. It was supposed to have rosettes, it looked like smashed roses. My husband picked it up. I called the next day and they had me bring it back in. The paper they wrote all the directions on was there, with everything written and drawn the way it was supposed to be, colors and everything. They did refund my money, but we ended up with a cake from Kroger's (it was very good).

Caitlin Bronaugh

Everything Sugar Pie makes is gold! From their delicious red velvet cupcakes to their mini cheesecakes, you can’t go wrong!

Richard Jackson

Delicious

rochelle green

Awful I asked them to make a frozen theme cake for 5 yr old girl they made it blue and put number 5 on it and told me I still had to pay for the cake

Julia

Cake was very, very dry and tasted old. The cakes didn't have enough icing on them to cover the cakes. The boxes that cake came in was very flimsy. We were very disappointed. We will never go back and definitely won't recommend them.

Robin Sizemore

Blackberry birthday pie. Exactly what I wanted : )

Mark Hedrick

Nasty

Laura Cinae

Excellent cupcakes and baked good.

Ty Spurlock

The cupcakes are just mediocre. I could honesty make better cupcakes out of the box at home...

Karla Boyd

Good food but expensive

Mason Blake

I agree with some of the reviews in regards to the awful part. I picked up some cupcakes for an anniversary event. They were on sale due to being yesterday's flavors. The clerk reassured me that they were all fresh and would not be dry. I paid $22.00 for them. They were all the worse cupcakes I had ever tasted. All dry, old in flavor and just nasty. I couldn't even get the dog to eat them. When i called to tell them, they just said, "Oh sorry we have never had anyone complain before". From the reviews listed on this page, I assume they do not read them. I would have no idea who would be voting them best in the Valley because based on their product and customer service, they are worse in the Valley.

Jenny Palmer

Tried the cupcakes and cake balls. Went later in the day and the selection was a little limited but the items we bought were delicious!

Dorothy Prudich

We have made several trips there and love the treats!! Great service and great taste!!

Shannon titus

Absolutely the best I have ever had! You must try it!

Tamara Mount

I ate a piece of cake in the survivor's tent at the Susan G. Komen walk today. I am a icing snob. This icing was the best ever!

Mike Cottrell

Mom an pop place they could be a lil friendlier but this is chas so.

Carmen Zezima

I went into this shop with very high expections. I guess that was my first mistake. 3 1/2 prior to closing their shelves were practically bare. Not going back.

Jenn S

Best bakery around. They're red velvet cupcakes are the best!!

Travis Samson

We had a large party for my parent's 50th Wedding Anniversary and Sugar Pie was able to help us do a recreation of my parent's wedding cake. They did a 3 tier wedding cake with Almond Cake and Vanilla Buttercream. It was seriously out of this world...took me back to the old school wedding cake that we used to be used too. Everyone at the party was going on an on about it and having more than one piece...wish we just would have gotten it a little bit bigger due to the double dipping on cake. They were even able to deliver for a charge which I appreciated. Easy to work with over the phone since I'm in Columbus, OH.

Ashley Noland

Cupcakes, macaroons, and rolled sugar cookies are all delicious! The staff are courteous and friendly, and the shop is adorable!