Reviews of Poorhouse Pies (Bakery)

23 Park St, Underhill, VT 05489, United States

Average Rating:


You will see the reviews of people like you who are consuming the products and services of Poorhouse Pies (Bakery) in Vermont.

Right now this business gets a score of 4.9 out of 5 and that score was based on 63 reviews.

As you can read, the average of ratings that it reaches is nearly the highest, and it is based on a large number of scores, so we may be pretty sure that the evaluation is very accurate. If people have bothered to evaluate when they've done well, it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to set reviews when these are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is included in the category of Pie shop.

Where is Poorhouse Pies?

REVIEWS OF Poorhouse Pies IN Vermont

Gabrielle Robinson

Taylor Schneider

Chelsea Russell

Micah Arrowsmith

Every time I go they sell out or they are closed

Laura Salas

We drove for a long time to get to the Poorhouse Pie shack. I love the set up of this place. It's refreshing to see the honor system still works. We bought a strawberry and peach pie and ate it on the table set up outside. They even have plates and silverware available. The pie was delicious and the crust melted in your mouth. I can't wait to get back to Vermont to try another variety!

Chad Ray

Some of the best pie I have ever had, nothing dissapoints.

Laura Gricius-West

Maggie Paquette

Outstanding! Best raspberry crumble pie ever. The crust was perfect, filling not too sweet (hint of tartness), crumble top was just right to balance the yummiest pie ever.

Benjamin Houchen

Jeff Botas

Torrey Ah-Tye


Zina Gomez-Liss

The fact that a place like this exists is proof that life is truly good. The pies are delicious. The maple cream is a taste of Vermont. Gotta try one of you ever visit.

Michael Bogin

Maple cream pie may be the best dessert I've ever had... period. Definitely worth the stop.

Alan Dibler

Amazing pies & the ladies who run it are amazing as well best pie I have had in a VERY Very long time prices can not be beat

Dawn Wheeler

Great place to get a pie, we stopped here on our trip, we live in Alabama and saw this on the food channel and marked it on our phones as a "must go to"! Loved it!

Barbara Shatara

Perfect in every way. Delicious pies, multiple flavors. Get there earlier in the day for best selection. One of my favorites things about VT.

Kathleen Dandurand

Priscilla Barry-Gillilan

Such a cute and unique little place, definitely a hidden gem in Vermont.

Brennan Martin

Great pies and, when they have them, donuts!

Mary Jorgensen

Most of the pies are quite delicious, though we did get a few chocolate and caramel pies that were a bit too sweet for our taste. There are also donuts on Sunday and, though we've heard tales of lines first thing in the morning, we were able to get a box of donuts out in the shed a little later in the morning recently. Yay! Love the variety of pies from day to day and the adorable pie shed - something about getting pie from a shed makes it even more fun.

Cynthia Feltch

Awesome pies! And donuts, sometimes.

Erin Covey

Once you have a Poorhouse donut, you'll never want any other donut again. Beyond delicious!!

Thomas Farrington

Pies were delicious! We look forward to our next trip to VT and picking up some Poorhouse Pies!!

Meg Cardinal

Best pie I ever purchased! I got a maple crumb. Amazing.

Debra Kattler

Such a lovely place and the owners are really cool and love what they do! Amazing pies and donuts.

Matthew Woolever

Like a farm stand, but for pie. Pretty cool.

Amalia Force

Simply the best pie you'll ever have. Make the trip, take the detour. IT IS WORTH IT.

jennifer mcgaffigan

Dean Pierce

Pie is life. Eat these pies and your life will be good.

Carl Sedon

What can i say? I ate a whole pie outside their little shack. Amazing

Paul Kiripolsky

Great pies in a quaint village setting. Life is simpler with pie and pie makes everything better :)

Crystal Neskey

So good!! My favorite place to get a sweet treat!

Scott A

Ethan Bergeron

Friendly staff, good prices, and great pie, not much more you can ask for!

Corey Hammond

Joe Handley


David Rogers

Toby Hamand

Awesome pie shack

Stephanie Nickles

BEST pie I have EVER had. Take the time to drive out here - $16 for a pie and it is absolutely worth it!!! They take checks or cash (change given at their home)

John Carney

Quantity home made goodies

Charles Cunningham

Best pies around

Daryll Kemp

Quite the staple in the community! Always look forward to Donut Sundays!

Zoran Bjelic

Jeremy Escott

That's my pie, pick another

Nya Tanaka

This is the cutest little shop I've ever seen! The pies were delicious! The maple chocolate cheesecake pie was a huge hit!

Jonathan Haraden

Great little gem have seen it for years in magazines like yankee. Finally stopped the chocolate cream pie was amazing.

Abbey LaMay-West

Drove an hour and a half to taste these pies! The maple pecan was the best I ever had. The crust is flaky and buttery. Well worth the drive!

linda bishop

Sadly this experience isn't what it used to be but the Coconut Pie is still great.

Jenny P

Rhea Mongeon

These pies are delicious! The owners are so sweet and welcoming. The price is not cheap but it's fair for the good quality of the pies and the care put into making them.

Charles Corbally

Got my first Poe today, can't wait too try it!

Sarah Lemay

This pie is worth the detour, trust me. The owners are also incredibly nice. My husband called before we went on a trip to Burlington to ask if they would have key lime pie when we would be there, and sure enough there was one waiting for us! If you have a chance to try the key lime pie, you will not regret it. The other fruit pies are also delicious, probably the best pies I have ever had.

E Baumann

Delicious pies, we came from far away just to try it

Eli Gordon

camie opulski


Katie Wagner

Bill Patton

Yum in several flavors

Dan Tomaino

Amazing Donuts! We love the variety and your pie hit is adorable!

Mike G

Jeremy Fortune

Matthew Fioti

Business Hours of Poorhouse Pies in Vermont



Poorhouse Pies en Vermont
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Sunup Bakery
Sunup Bakery
Bakery - Vermont

Coffee shop

Great Harvest Bread Co.
Great Harvest Bread Co.
Bakery - Vermont


Jocelyn & Cinta's Bake Shop - Catering Wedding Cakes - Donuts Cookies - Bread - Pie Shop
Jocelyn & Cinta's Bake Sh...
Bakery - Vermont


Poorhouse Pies
Poorhouse Pies
Bakery - Vermont

Pie shop

Birchgrove Baking
Birchgrove Baking
Bakery - Vermont