Reviews of Otter Creek Bakery (Bakery)

14 College St, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States Located in: Middlebury College

Average Rating:


Here you will see all the information of people like you who have information of the services and products of Otter Creek Bakery (Bakery) near Vermont.

As of day the firm receives a rating of 4.4 over 5 and this score has been calculated on 78 reviews.

As you can read, it reaches an opinions average is really high, and it's founded on a high number of scores, so we can say that the rating is very credible. If there are many people who bothered to leave their opinion when they've done well with the business, it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to write opinions when they are positive and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is Otter Creek Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Otter Creek Bakery IN Vermont

Susan Eisenstadt

Had a west coaster-1 slice of turkey, a little cheese, some lettuce, a smear of avocado and a piece of sundries tomato. This on a lot of bread for $9.00. Won’t do that again

Laura Lavery

Barely any chicken in my sandwich. You should ashamed for charging 8 dollars.

Tim Green

very nice for a treat!

Nicholas McMillan

Nate Hodgson-Walker

Great sandwiches and assortment of sweet treats.

Linda Tatsapaugh

Quick and friendly service and delicious baked goods! We had pastries and coffee, including hot cross buns for Easter. Yum!

Jay J. D'Lugin, MD, MS

Candice Matthee

Sam Schifman

Glenn L. Bolton III

Super cute tall boy to serve you on most days! Get there early on Sunday if you want your chocolate croissants! And if you really need something rich go for the chocolate XTC!

Roberta Barone

The blueberry topped cheesecake was tough and rubbery and if it hadn't been labeled as cheesecake you would have never guessed. The fruit tart was not objectionable, just tasteless. Otter Creek Bakery used to have a wonderful reputation for delicious treats. This was just a waste of money as we tossed those "treats" into the garbage after two bites.

Shannia Fu

delicious, albeit a bit expensive.

Julie's bites

Nice selection of deserts, sandwiches, and breads

Alex Melnick


Amazing pastries.

Terri Hanagan

Great food, croissants and desserts. And the owner was very accommodating in helping me set up an account for my son, a student at Middlebury College. And homemade doggie treats!!

Brian Asciutto

Leah Malka

Birk Louis Aarseth Grindal

Marney Borisov

very nice bakery!

Claire McEachern

Hello Delicious! Every single detail has been mapped out from decorative paper straws, flawless cookies, deliciously fresh savory bites and a cozy outdoor space. Upon entering, I was welcomed and before leaving I was acknowledged.

Dana R

Very pretty food too bad it doesn’t taste as good as it looks. Given them a couple tries and just not impressed. Their coffee drinks are downright horrible, worst cappuccino I’ve ever had undrinkable!

James Marca

William Keller


Great food, great staff, local watering hole where town and college lives cross in the best of ways. I highly recommend a stop if you're in town!

Stephen Towne

Everything is good

Peter Thewissen

jim Meyersburg

It's been our go-to spot for morning coffee and treats for years. Never a disappointment here.

Sarah H

Fred Robins

Marks Landing

Pat Chagnon

Mountain Ale old fashioned is the best

Kim Jimmo

I love the bakery!! You guys are all so friendly and have delicious food. Kayla is the nicest always so polite and welcoming!!!

Robert Rejzovic

Andrea Abernathy

Delicious baked goods. The maple cheese danish was incredible.

Carl Sedon

As always, friendly, delicious and welcoming.

Nancy Smith

CJ Schellack

Sweet little bakery with good soft pretzels. The staff are friendly. Small but nice outdoor seating.

Mark Hall

Antigone Eriksen

Great food! A variety of baked goods and bread, cakes. Sandwiches and salads are also available. Parking is near the bakery.

Jennifer Klauder

Otter Creek made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding and they were DELICIOUS!! Everything was absolutely incredible, we received so many compliments. They even handled the delivery and setup which was a huge huge help. We can't wait to go back and eat more cupcakes—highly recommend!!

Diego Murcia

Small bakery, tasty treats, good service

Thomas Roberts

Amazing food with fresh ingredients and a vert friendly atmosphere!

Kelley Browne

Absolutely wonderful food, coffee and great service!!

Justin Palmerlee

Wow... I went here for a sandwhich on the way to the airport and ended up buying a ton of baked goods for my wife and I. They serve delicious coffee as well. I had the East Coaster sandwhich, with crab meat and cole slaw which was great if you like seafood. Lots of other options as well. I highly recommend!

Eli Madden

Best coffee in town and friendly people. Lots of delicious treats! Custom birthday cakes too. Nice shaded outdoor seating.

E. Miller

Kaiya Willis

Great pastries and friendly staff, unfortunately I witnessed a worker touching the sandwhich I ordered with ungloved hands. I threw the sandwich away. Watched how the workers handle sandwhiches the next time I was in and again witnessed ungloved hand to sandwich contact.

Yvette Mason

Went yesterday with a group of somewhat persnickety seniors, parked in back and went up good graded ramp--accommodated us (11 total) outside, but as weather was just warm enough..Lucky for us! Will return but with younger/smaller crowd. Yummy soups, great portions and home grown. DESSERTS are to die for! And they took a purchase order, which is the only way we can do business, due to our non-profit status...which was great! Staff was very accommodating, given that we just BOMBARDED them at the height of LUNCH! Cool place. Great owners.

Parker Hoblin

What a glorious selection of baked goods! And well brewed coffee too!


Priscilla Harcourt

Elizabeth W

Ian Banks

This was a really nice place to stop. A wonderful feel of Vermont and local tastes and styles. The staff were absolutely fantastic: very understanding and prompt. A wonderful lunch place.

Shea Murphy

Wonderful pastries to be had. The coffee is average, but the reason to go is the deli and baked goods. Absolutely wonderful on a peaceful afternoon.

Nancy Coan

Good sandwiches, cookies, and lots of tasty looking pastries to choose from, great shady spot with tables out front.

Heather Byrnes

I love the maple products the cookies

Cindy Davis

Make a good hot chocolate

Doug Butdorf

Great yummies. Wish the interior was larger.

pame daily

Love their sour dough and honey wheat breads. We get bread and pastries frequently ! Their dinner rolls are excellent too! They’re a Thanksgiving & Christmas must at our house!

nigel uphoria

The Bakery is 'Middlebury Central' and should not be missed. Lovely atmosphere, squeeky clean, committed staff and lots of fresh foods and beverages. Bread, pastries, soups, salads, sandwiches etc., hand made and baked on site. On certain days each week there is also wood baked sourdough bread and pork or chicken smoked on site. And in summertime there's lots of shaded outdoor seating amongst the flowers.

Diana Simonson

This place is OMG good! Bakery/Deli offering healthy lunch options as well as stuff that's so good, you'll feel like you have to have a healthy lunch as penance.

Casey Gilfillan

Friendly staff. A lot of variety. I ordered the Greek pita and an iced cafe latte, they were both delicious. I brought the moose gingerbread cookies home to my kids and they were so excited and proceeded to eat them right up!

Tina Brant

Ordered the West Coaster sandwich on rye bread. The sandwich was quickly made on very generous slices of bread. The downfall is that there was only 1 slice of turkey on the sandwich. Would not go there again.

Joe Klementovich

Softshell crab sandwich in Vermont, yeah and it was great.

Holly Goodale

The food is good, I just find it expensive.

Gastro Sophe

Good cookies ... A home made taste at last in this country ! Quality over quantity. JK ;-) PS: and good Expresso also !

Martin Beatty

The best sandwiches in town! Everything is so fresh and the bread is so tasty!

Peggy Malec

Henry Romp

Great coffee, smiling cheerful staff, beautiful sidewalk-cafe seating, perfect location, all around one of the best spots in Middlebury. Try their Olive Twist.

Jed Malcolm

Michael Simpson

Great bread, but I've never had anything from OCB that wasn't amazing.

Wile Rockell

Lovely place with good coffee and very friendly staff. Sandwiches are skimpy on the meat not trimmed well and pricey for the quality. Pastries are almost always great. But watch the cookies not always up to par. Fruit tart is exceptional.

Kim Murphy

Had a sticky bun that was so so and a little dry. Perhaps because it was later in the day?

Shane Harper

Tasty spot with tons of variety. Tried the breakfast pizza which was a fantastic idea!

Nadine Zylstra

Must try the Ruben!

Dan Young

Friendly staff, yummy treats and several good Vegitarian options. Good place to meet friends and enjoy some slow down time.

david Devine

Great coffee and confections. Now that it is warm out, their limited seating is expanded outdoors.

Business Hours of Otter Creek Bakery in Vermont



Otter Creek Bakery en Vermont
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Sweet Alchemy Bakery and Cafe
Sweet Alchemy Bakery and ...
Bakery - Vermont

Vegan restaurant

Bohemian Bakery
Bohemian Bakery
Bakery - Vermont


Piece of Cake VT
Piece of Cake VT
Bakery - Vermont


Monarch and the Milkweed
Monarch and the Milkweed
Bakery - Vermont

American restaurant

Bakery - Vermont

Coffee shop