Reviews of Sweet Mary's Bakery (Bakery)

76 E Mill St, Akron, OH 44308, United States

Average Rating:


You have the feddbacks of real people who consume the products of Sweet Mary\'s Bakery (Bakery) in Ohio.

To this day the business has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 and this score has been calculated on 122 reviews.

As you can see it has an average rating is almost the top, and it is based on a high number of feddbacks, so we can be pretty sure that the valuation is quite faithful. If many people have bothered to give their feddback when they are happy, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to write tatings when these are positive and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is classified in the category of Bakery.

Where is Sweet Mary's Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Sweet Mary's Bakery IN Ohio

Jack Johnson

Brent Wesley


Sarah Washington

Katie Dayley

Emily G

Marie Wise

Enjoyed our visit with my husband who’s not a big fan of sweets but loved the carrot cake. Wonderful staff and delicious breakfast quiche. I had the best Carrot Cake I have ever tasted delicious, I purchased a piece at a booth at Maplewood Christmas Expo at Summit County Fair grounds . It was $8.00 and worth it! premium ingredients. All of my future cakes are going to be ordered by Sweet Mary’s Bakery

James Douglas

Try the biscuits and gravy here. Very large proportion. Tasted Homemade.

Justin Phillips

This place is great! The food is delicious, the people are friendly, and the service is excellent. Plus it's within walking distance from my work, but your (literal) mileage may vary!

Kaushik Saha

This is a very nice bakery! The birthday cake I ordered was great!

Shaniah Chilton

Completely disappointed in my experience. When I received my cake it was rock solid from the inside out. I normally go to West Side bakery but wanted to try something new. Cake was flavorless and icing tasted old. I feel like Acme or Giant Eagle could’ve done a better job, I’m just super upset because this cake was for a big birthday but it was just a big let down.

Nikhil Shringarpurey

Nice place with friendly staff. The macarons and tiramisu were quite good. We plan to visit again soon.

Gabby McIntyre

This place has wonderful, high quality baked goods and from-scratch breakfast and lunch specials. I've never been disappointed with purchases from the shop or from the pop-up market days in Highland Square. However, I had a strange experience with a special order inquiry (for a birthday party) I placed online. I was bummed, but I will still frequent the shop for lunches and to-go goodies.

Chris Chiera

Sandwiches kinda dry but the bacon was alright. They had nasty soda. Their cookies and cake are good. The staff seemed to be annoyed if I asked a question.

Taylor Robinson

I was planning a beach wedding in NC but the hurricane changed those plans. We came home to OH to plan an entirely new wedding in just three days. Sweet Mary's was able to put together a desert bar for 110 guests and our cut cake with just a couple days notice. Everything was beautiful and delicious.

Aaron Stanley

Michelle Kovach

John Vollmer

Delicious baked goods.Natural and local sourced. Not inexpensively priced.

Julia Sharrock

Jon Yoho

Just what downtown Akron needed. Got the apple pie and chocolate pie. Crust is so good. Pies were great. Bent tree coffee, wonderful.

emmet z

Great baked goods and more! Excellent spot for breakfast or lunch. You gotta stop in if you are in downtown Akron.

Denise Merriman

Loved the cheddar bacon biscuits and my daughter loved the quiche and cheesecake. Previously enjoyed the berry cream pie. Worth a stop.

LeAnn Tipton

Delicious breakfast

Rachel Hammer

They're all so sweet and helpful in here. There food is AMAZING too!

Eric Cooper, Realtor

The selection wasn't huge, but I showed up at closing and they were suprisingly friendly and answered all my many questions. In the end, my indecisiveness cost me fifty bucks, which is normal for me when pastry and cookies are involved, and should be expected at a high quality specialty shop such a Sweet Mary's. It was worth it... The salted caramel macarons we're chewy and amazing and the pecan pie was the best we've ever had. If I had any gripe, it would be the selection size, and again, I came late, but the small counter didn't have the space for much more. The quality over quantity adage certainly held true though. Save yourself a hassle and park in the water dept. parking deck.

Amanda Peoples

Tiramisu is to die for. The quiche is pure and utter perfection. So creamy silky its smoother than velvet!!! And the unlimited delicious coffee refills while in the shop...pure heaven!

Mambevon Consulting

L Nicolia Burts

Jeff Vance

Had these at a meeting at work this morning. frosting was standard sugar/shortening, Cake was extremely dry and tasted like freezer burn. Not sure if these were supposed to be dairy or gluten free, but something was very off. They were pretty, though; colors of our new corporate logo.

Luke Davis

Great baked goods! Stop in for a delicious quiche and some Bent Tree coffee.

Jim Bell

The staff, Heather, is a hoot. Friendly, knowledgable, great food. Loved the quiche. Coffee is great. Loved the macaroons. Try it.

Shareise Melvin

Cute place, expensive but fun lots of frozen yogurt flavors to choose from, had fun there!

Andrew Barry

Daniel Figueroa

Nathan Keith

Great small bakery. Pricey, but good

Paula Apley

So friendly and great vegan peanut butter bars

Michelle Labozan

Wonderful treats n very nice people

K & D Toles

Fantastic place for any sweet treats you could want. Got a birthday cake here - it was delicious and beautifully decorated. They also have great cookies and pies. Check their website and order ahead!

Kevin Smith

Nice little bakery with both sweet and savory breakfast and brunch items. We have also ordered custom baked goods here.

Paula Holman

Amazing food!! Amazing owner and staff!! I am never disappointed.

Andre Williams

Kimberly White

Mark Nicolino

Rene Rockwell

I went to pick up a cheesecake my daughter ordered. Since I had some time, I ordered the Chocolate Creme Pie Parfait and it was excellent!! Very yummy!! Parking was easy in the garage next door.

Mark Williamson

Vaykareth Aurori

Katie Russell

I am leaving a review here because I am sure they will not post it on their website. We ordered our wedding cake here and although it was very pretty we were VERY DISAPPOINTED. When we ordered the cake they asked us what time we wanted to pick it up on our special day, a time was chosen and agreed upon but when we arrived at the scheduled pick up time the cake was NOT DONE and we had to wait an extra 45 minutes for them to complete it!!! For any of you who are married or understand how tight a wedding day timeline is, this is totally unacceptable. It through off our whole timeline and ended up costing us valuable time on our big day. The cake was also incredibly dry! Like, the cake itself was made too far ahead of time and had either been frozen or sat for too long before being used for our cake. The icing was yummy but overall the cake was not good and the 45 minute time discrepancy a total disaster. Very sad.

Rocky A White II

Camille and Rocky love this place

Gloria Conley

Roger and Marcia DeKock

michael roberts

The Earl grey macaroons are amazing!!!!!

Sandra Williams

A taste of home... Everything here is cooked fresh, daily. No additives. Nothing artificial. Just straight up delicious baked goods that your mom might have made. And the service compliments the quality! I was stuck in the rain across the street and called the bakery to see if anyone would come out and bring me a menu. They brought the menu, took my card, made the payment and brought the cinnamon roll back to me… All with a fantastic smile and wonderful attitude. This is a regular stop for me, now. It’s tiny, but you can eat in enjoy the ambiance of Akron “back then”.

Samantha Imrie

Try a cinnamon roll, thank me later

Jonathan Porter

Sweets and treats and top notch. Macaroons are some of the best in the area.

CBear Gaming

Kimberly Jones

Emily Durway

Rebecca Falck

Steve Parton

A fantastic selection and a staff that goes above and beyond!

Patty Fann

Ali Capoun

Tony Liu

Heather Brown

Brian Hartman

The best bakery I've every been to

Jasmine Holt

I go here at least once a week and never leave disappointed!! All their food is delicious and the staff is so so so kind!!

Dean Paolucci

This place is an absolute GEM. I've never had anything but the best tasting treats there, then I tried the quiche and my goodness... PERFECTION! You will not be disappointed.

J Hos

Cynthia Kline

Tiffany Hammonds

Delicious everytime!

Courtney Courk

Macarons are amazing! As are her cakes

Jayson Shenk

You must try the bacon and cheddar biscuit. Amazingly good.

Benjamin Pollock

Mary H

Cheryl Stockman

The white on white cake I ordered for a special birthday was flavorless, dry and had way too much icing between layers. Very disappointed.

Chris Beckett

Mmmmmm m...... Chocolate cake with Bailey's frosting.

Michelle Davis

Nathan Smead

Amazing!!!! Sure can brighten your day.

Anthony Miller

Such a great and friendly staff, and amazingly delicious made from scratch baked goods!

Bo Williams

Great little spot. Gluten free selections, too!

Travis Forshey

Great cheesecake!!!

Robert Arnold

We were sent here by a great friend working at the uni nearby and WOW did we really enjoy breakfast here! And the staff and regulars were so cool, too! I've been abroad 17 years so these fun "back home" interactions are really special for me. :P

Christine Howard

Jennifer Kay Jeter

Glad they expanded hours to include Sunday!

Sandi Aupperle

victoria stump

Daniel Ciccarelli

Good stop for coffee and a treatw

James Wilson

Service was fine the food thow scimpytazted good price was rediculous. $17. For a bowl of soup and a piece of cake.

Teresa Johnson

Aron Morris

Jessica Berry

Johanna Conrad

This place is great! My son needs gluten free food. I ordered his birthday cake here, and was possibly the single most delicious chocolate cake I've ever had in my life. All the pastries are great. I highly recommend the pecan roll. My daughter lives the macarons.

Anjelica Purnell

Brian Gay

Extremely friendly. The Nutella coffee cake was excellent. I'm glad to see small businesses like this in downtown Akron.

Neil Weakland

Everything they make is delicious and it's a great spot to get breakfast and lunch too!

Channel T


Im planning a wedding and they were SUPER helpful with all the cake stuff.

Michael Morina

Awesome bakery. I can tell this owner cares for her customers upon a one time visit.

Anthony Rhodes

Wonderful all good with great service and hot coffee.

Julie R

Have always loved all the baked goods I have tried. Very nice, small place. If there is a line service is slow. They offer breakfast foods which the biscuits and gravy are amazing but they don't have servers so it makes it kinda awkward.

Rocco Galizio

Always delicious food, plus a selection of local products like honey, soda, and hot sauce!

Andrew Amadeus

Josh Troche

Simply the best way to consume some of the most amazing baked goods in the area. Not only do they have that, but also some of the friendliest people you'll ever find working behind the counters. Sweet Mary's is currently my favorite baked good spot ever

Cristina Gonzalez

A foodie's heaven. Mary delivers brilliant, unique & appealing made from scratch goods. She is sure to blow your mind and taste buds! I go crazy for her earl gray & matcha macarons, the hazelnut chocolate scone & her newest March "green" creation: lemon matcha cheesecake. Her desserts are works of art that you would expect from a bakery in New York, yet here we are in downtown Akron savoring mind-blowing dessert and savory goods (especially those made with Not Yo' Daddy's Mexican Hot Sauce!)

Zach Zylstra

A fantastic local Akron business!

Chris Siminske

Great place. Glad they are in downtown

Robert Beveridge

Zack Hirt

Emily Zimmermann

Delicious! Great service as well. Very friendly!

supr3m3 magn3tic

Adena F

David Ingram

Brad Lemmon

Bacon cheddar biscuit's are amazing

Julia McPherson

So cute and friendly inside! Delicious treats, I'll definitely be back.

Nikki G

kimberly davis

Yummy yummy.


The best baked goods in the area by far!!!!

Katie Ridinger

The food is BEYOND delicious. Super friendly staff too! Also the bathroom was like a luxury hotel.

Joe O'Rourke

Ryan Ferguson

Cristina González Alcalá

Joe Heisler

Uhhhhhhh the tiramisu today was great !!!! Coming back for this again for sure!.....:)

Dawn Arter

Business Hours of Sweet Mary's Bakery in Ohio



Sweet Mary's Bakery en Ohio
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Baraona's Baking Co
Baraona's Baking Co
Bakery - Ohio

Cake shop

Andie's Cakery & Eats
Andie's Cakery & Eats
Bakery - Ohio


Kiedrowski's Simply Delicious Bakery
Kiedrowski's Simply Delic...
Bakery - Ohio


MCL Restaurant & Bakery Whitehall
MCL Restaurant & Bakery W...
Bakery - Ohio

American restaurant

Dan the Baker - Toast Bar
Dan the Baker - Toast Bar
Bakery - Ohio