Reviews of Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery (Bakery)

1249 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna, OH 43230, United States

Average Rating:


You will see all the feddbacks of real people who have information of the services and products of Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery (Bakery) in Ohio.

At this moment this business receives a score of 4.8 stars over 5 and this rating is based on 85 reviews.

As you can read, it has an average rating is almost the best one, and it's founded on a very high number of feddbacks, so we may be quite sure that the rating is quite reliable. If there are many people who bothered to evaluate when they are happy with the service, it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to put evaluations when these are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is included in the category of Bakery.

Where is Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery?

REVIEWS OF Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery IN Ohio

Hannah Dible

Love, Love, LOVE this place! A MUST eat!!!

Korry Harrier

Yum yum yum yum

Khadra Abshir

I absolutely love the cup cakes in this store they were very moist good sizes and very delicious. For someone who really doesn’t like cup cakes I was hooked . I initially went there to try some for my daughters pre birthday and I must stay she loved it and was very happy that day. Will definitely be getting some for her party .


I have followed this bakery on Instagram and drooled over the pictures for so long! I finally made the trip and was not disappointed! I love cupcakes and ice cream and they combine the 2 and it was amazing! Will definitely try to make the trip more often!

Patti Peterson

Best place,for cupcakes..

Kimberly Jones-Rogers

Red velvet was the best!

Georgia Michael

Yum Yum Yum! That’s all you need to know!

Tracy Parks


I was curious of the place so I went and got 3 cupcakes: red velvet, beach bum (mojito), and smores. The cake was super moist but light and the cake to icing ratio was great! The beach bum was my favorite as the flavors weren't overwhelming and you could taste all the components. The disappointing one was the smores (which was filled). It did not have a strong marshmallow taste; if I did a blind taste test, I would think it was a chocolate cupcake with whipped cream topping. The employee who waited on me did not seem that happy to be there, but otherwise fine service. I'm not that crazy with the white walls, it looks too devoid of personality or perhaps flavor?

Ajayah Winbush

The cupcakes are so good.

Grant Millard

Loved this place! They have some of the best and ice cream I've had in Columbus!!!

Brianna McGlone

Great service and the ice cream is so delicious! I can't wait to come back again. Truly a hidden gem!

Shanel Monique

One bite and you're hooked!! So many flavors to choose from, and the cake is so moist. I'm generally not an icing lover, but with the caramel and pecans this cupcake had me scraping the paper. Enter your phone number for rewards points... I guarantee once you go once, you'll be back.

Brooklyn Culver

Heather Kocher

Love the cup cakes here ! And they have puppy treats

Darren Mcnemar

Great cupcakes...

paulo kirigiti

Cupcakes RULE

Karen Fowler

Love these amazingly dense and delicious cupcakes. I always order 6 to take home and enjoy with family. The rewards program is very enerous. I had the ice cream for the first time today! Oh my my my ...


Patricia Tiebout

Kim did an outstanding job on my daughters Sweet 16th birthday cake. I gave her a photo and she nailed it. Everyone at the party could not stop talking about how moist the cake and cupcakes were. You would not be disappointed if you choose them to do any cake or cupcakes for any occasion. WELL DONE SMALLCAKES!!!! I’m looking forward to having more done in the future.

Kathleen Steele

The cupcakes are a nice size and taste great. They even have dog cupcakes. Awesome.

Kavitha Koppolu


Both the cupcakes (definitely not small) and the ice cream are great - we've had on separate trips. The staff is super sweet and the spot, while minimalist, is crisp and clean. Need to try the whoopie pies!

Robin Comchoc

I bought 6 different cupcakes (snickers, lemon drop, peanut butter cup, pink chocolate, vanilla chocolate and chocolate cream). We taste tested them all and were all delicious. Very moist and the frosting is yummy. Our favorites are the peanut butter cup and chocolate dream. Definitely will be back!

Janet C.

Quality baking and lots of choices of flavrs

Jerry Sexton

Nice little place

Corinne Byers

We recently purchased cupcakes from Smallcakes Columbus for birthdays in our family. The cupcakes were a hit and everyone loved all of the flavors. There are SO many different flavors to choose from - we will absolutely be back to try them all!

karen kendrick

Samitra Jackson

Great place to get cupcakes the cupcakes are a decent size and extremely moist and delicious love the frosting it sweet but not too sweet.

Dianne Penn

My friend dropped the lemon cupcake off to me today. So moist and wonderful. Can't wait to take my husband there tomorrow for dessert. Yum!

Tom Gillotte

Our first time visiting Small cakes was amazing! We got a variety of cupcakes and each was a good as the next. We ended up cutting many in half to share because we all wanted to try so many different flavors. We will definitely be back. Maybe for ice cream and coffee next time too!

Chris Garfield

Andrew Kohler

Colleen A

Fabulous! Scrumptious! These very big cupcakes are Moist with Heavenly icing! Gluten-free Saturday is a big bonus for some of us! Thanks! Love your place!

Laura Gilmore

I had fun in this cupcake. The staff helped me choose the best selection for my mood and told me "Happy Birthday"!


Cupcakes are moist and delish!! Ice cream was good too. All good things!! We will be back!!

Sara Barto

We discovered Smallcakes last spring when were living near the area temporarily. We ended up going three times in the first couple of weeks! The cupcakes are so moist and delicious, and the ice cream was amazing. We weren’t expecting much from the ice cream, as it’s called “Smallcakes,” but it was just awesome, and homemade!! They also come out with special and seasonal flavors, which are creative and yummy. We’ve since moved a little farther away, so we aren’t able to just pop in, but we will be planning a trip to have some treats soon.

Sakura Kinomoto

Nothing too special that we tried. Single scoops of ice cream for a family of 4 after dinner, but $3.50 was a bit expensive for tiny cups more fit for jr scoops you'd get at other places. The ice cream themselves weren't as cold as expected since they were half melted before we even sat down. They sold cupcakes but we weren't in the mood to try them. They did have a few books for kids to read and crayons out but no coloring pages to accompany them. The setup was small and clean.

allan kocher

Great ice-cream and great cupcakes. Woman putting them together offered sample tastes of the ice-cream and was very kind and up beat. Service with a smile. Will be back.

Kylie Pearson

Always fresh and tasty - I especially love the Churro cupcake! Great customer service and I highly recommend ordering some mini cupcakes ahead for your next get together...or for yourself so you can sample a lot of flavors! :)

Terri Rials

Tried Smallcakes for the first time yesterday, the service was outstanding and the cupcakes were outstanding too!! Super light and moist cake with just the right amount of delicious buttercream frosting!! Will definitely be back!

Gene Pierce

Love their cupcakes, so moist and fresh

Beth Johnson

Excellent cupcakes! I highly recommend the lemon drop!

Audra Watts

Delicious cupcakes and the homemade ice cream is the best. The red velvet cupcake with red velvet ice cream is my favorite!


Mary Ryder

Stopped in to check it out and was blown away by how nice the staff was and knowledge of the offerings. I will definately go back.

Sean Flynn

Meg Boley

The most delicious cupcakes with so many fun flavors!!!

Katrina Sumpter

We were cupcake hunting and stumbled on this cupcakery. What luck!! Absolutely decadent. The lemon is heavenly. The chicken and waffle and Birthday cake did not disappoint. I highly recommend them!

alisha rook

Such a cute little cup cake shop!!! I have tried the cupcakes, the smash cakes and even had them make a birthday cake for my husband! Great rich flavors with just the right amount of icing! Highly recommend❤️❤️❤️

Christyanna Madero

While I was pregnant my sweet tooth was out of control I always researched sweets near me and small cupcakes and creamery popped up, so I finally tried a cupcake and omg the best cupcakes hands down in Columbus. The cupcakes were so flavorful, soft and always fresh but however the frosting is way too sweet for my taste. The cupcakes became my biggest cravings and still is lol, and don’t get me started on the ice cream!!! The ice cream taste so natural and so creamy!!!they also have a very unique cupcake and ice cream flavors!!! Trust me guys you won’t be disappointed!!!!

Stephanie Luczkowski

A little bit pricey but very tasty! The cupcakes are moist and the frosting is delicious and light. Wide array of flavors that change weekly / monthly / seasonally.

Megan Bohman

Amazing place to work and eat! Fresh cupcakes, homemade ice cream, and new sorts of treats all the time. A must-try!!

Brittany Geiger

Amazing place , treats and staff!!

Joe Crum

I’m especially fond of the salted caramel ice cream! I love the variety of flavors, some old reliables as well as always something new.

Teresa Ramos

I was dying to go there and sample their amazing cupcakes....and did not disappoint. They attended me very nice, they took their time explaining and I finished purchasing 1/2 dozen(red velvet, chocolate, mimosa, peanut butter) Really moist, good size for a cupcake, fresh and tasty. 5 thumbs up...

Jay Bohman

Ces Gon

Ericka Thompson

Johnathan Leonard

Of course the cupcakes are the draw, but the shakes here are the real show stealers. A nice plus was the dog cupcakes with the little bone on top.

Roni Bennett-Shye

Smallcakes is my go-to cupcakery! If you want cupcakes that are HUGE, always soft, the best icing ever than this is the place. I drive here more often than I’d like to admit from downtown nonetheless. These are hansdown my fave cupcakes in all of columbus and I’ve tried many places and consistency is key and these cupcakes and flavors NEVER disappoint.


I love the cupcake and ice cream combo. Every cupcake I had was very moist cupcakes and the red velvet ice cream is truly a winner.

Isae Fire

Debbie Thomas

Ethan Miller


Chris Jordan

kelly huskey

Love, love, love Smallcakes! The cupcakes are amazing and the ice cream is fantastic.


Moist and delicious! I love that they are not afraid of flavor.

Salema Rice

Extra moist cake, delicious icing and incredibly creamy in house homemade ice cream. Yum. Big fan!

Jennifer Pribe

Stephen Anderson

Heather Huebner

GREAT SERVICE! All my cupcakes have been delicious. Nice and moist, the perfect amount of icing. My coworker were mad I only bought them one in.

Brian Halley

mark cannella

Great treats and good eats/coffee.

Shronda Howell

Red velvet cupcake today was my first time here. Delicious I'll be back lol

Natasha Dog

Beautiful looking products. Maybe I'm just picky but I expected something that would taste special somehow, sadly while very moist the taste was no different than had I made it at home myself.

Tori Hummel

Mmm the BEST cupcakes in Columbus !! Seriously some of the best cupcakes I’ve had and the cutest !! Will def being going back :)

Sean Anthony

Brad Oyer

We randomly stopped in here after eating up the street. This place is amazing!! Literally everything we had was unbelievable. I absolutely recommend a visit here for sweets.

Jen Clayborne

On a recent shopping trip to Home Goods in the Stoneridge Plaza, my son and I stumbled upon Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery. I’m so glad we did because the cupcakes were amazing and the vanilla ice cream was so creamy and a perfect match with the cupcakes. The cupcakes were moist and the icing to cupcake ratio wasn’t overwhelming like a lot of bakeries that over do it. We will definitely be back and next time will be sure to take some goodies home.

Sarah Jones

Bee Gee

Delicious and high quality

Susan Moore

Kathy Fout

First time there and I will be returning. Best cupcake I’ve ever had.

Emily Grant

While this isn't my absolute favorite cupcake spot in town, I absolutely adore this place. I love the concept of ice cream and cupcakes. It's like a birthday party! They offer a dessert called a "smash" it's a cupcake cut in half with ice cream inbetween. It's 100% a must try!

Business Hours of Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery in Ohio



Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery en Ohio
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Jeanie's Party Cakes & Supplies
Jeanie's Party Cakes & Su...
Bakery - Ohio

Wedding bakery

La Puf Sweets Bakery & Candy
La Puf Sweets Bakery & Candy
Bakery - Ohio


Larder Delicatessen and Bakery
Larder Delicatessen and B...
Bakery - Ohio


Resch's Bakery
Resch's Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Blue Oven Bakery
Blue Oven Bakery
Bakery - Ohio