Reviews of Shy Cellars (Bakery)

9185 US-250, Strasburg, OH 44680, United States

Average Rating:


Here we offer you all the reviews of real people who purchase the products and services of Shy Cellars (Bakery) near to the state of Ohio.

At this moment the business gets a rating of 4.8 stars over 5 and the rating was based on 195 reviews.

You may have noticed that it reaches an opinions average is practically the top, and it is based on a high number of scores, so we may conclude that the assessment is quite faithful. If people have bothered to evaluate when they've done well, it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to put tatings when they are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is classified in the category of Fine dining restaurant.

Where is Shy Cellars?

REVIEWS OF Shy Cellars IN Ohio

Douglas Murphy

This is a definition of a hidden gem. I went with my girlfriend and her parents to celebrate her birthday and they blew it out of the water. We were greeted with the warmest of welcomes by one of the owners, as we walked over to the wine tasting area we met her husband who made some great recommendations for samples. Once our table was ready our server Missy took care of us like we were family, honestly everyone there was like family. I got their signature "Shy Fillet Mignon" which recently won an award at the Pro Football Hall of Fame. To top it off I split their Cinnabon Cheesecake and their Turlte Cheesecake for the sweetest of endings. Come check it out, make the trip, you will NOT be disappointed.

natalie hammer

Barbara Lesiak

Our favorite! They are so accommodating to tastes and allergies. They are the very best!

Sharon Cooper

Food is fantastic!

Bob McHue

Lisa Little

Excellent food and staff!!

Taylor Forester

We visited for lunch on our anniversary as we were spending a few days in Ohio’s Amish Country, and were treated as royalty. As a vegetarian, I have eaten my fair share of veggie burgers, and none could ever compete with the perfect sandwich I had at SHY. Each bite of food is crafted, cooked, and seasoned to perfection. Chef Tara sent us home with two delicious truffles as a gift that we enjoyed later. Beautiful experience.

Kristina Graber

Amazing experience! My husband and I were able to come here for dinner a few weeks ago thanks to our employees for a gift card. Food was absolutely amazing! We started with pig ears and calamari for appetizers and both were perfectly delicious! We split the prime rib for entree and they put everything on 2 separate plates for us. The entree was easily the best prime rib we have ever had! The service was literally perfect and we had an awesome experience! Definitely coming back!

Ginny Stephenson

Fine dinner

John Fister

David Reed

My wife and I like to think we are foodies. We love all kinds of food. We have recently moved from Cincinnati to Amish country and live in Sugarcreek. We miss the variety of foods we could get in the big city. We discovered a gem tonight. Shy Cellars is great fine dining that you can only usually get in big cities but its located in the middle of no where near Strasburg, Ohio. The steaks are thick and made right. They have filet, strip, and prime rib. We had the crab bisque that was rich and filling. My wife had the chicken rolaude and I had the beef ravioli. These are prepared to order, I can tell this place does not have a microwave for cooking. We finished with coffee and I had the bread pudding anf my wife had the cheesecake. The cheesecake is different because it is not as sweet as most, but thats a good thing when you add toppings. This is a gem in the middle of no where.... Go here, you wont regret it.

Frances Koch

SHY has been our go-to for anything special; meeting with valued friends; or a desire to MAKE a meal special by going to SHY! Atmosphere, Chef Sherry ... incredible!

bill karl

Absolutely fantastic dinning experience

Tim Stevenson

Reliable Upstate

Oh my goodness! Where to start? The warm bread served before dinner was fantastic, the salad was so flavorful and the balsamic dressing was just right. The meat was cooked to perfection and the mashed potatoes were out of this world. I was full but not stuffed ... and then came desert. My wife had the awesome creme brûlée and became super jealous when she saw and tasted my affogato. Wow! In all an excellent experience I will not soon forget!

Anita Davis

This is definitely one of our favorite restaurants! The food is fresh and delicious and the service is the best!


RyRy Turnerson

It’s always a pleasure to dine at the Shy. My wife and I have been here many times and the ever-changing menu offered, always has something new and unique to tickle anyone’s palate. Highly recommend trying the Board. Fantastic is an understatement; paired with the right drink is sure to add to the enjoyment.

Sheila Benedum

I met a girlfriend for lunch last week and we were VERY impressed by the excellence and freshness of the food as well as the great service. Sherry, thanks for dropping by to check on us and even personally delivering our wine! Highly recommend!

Ethan Burdette

Great food great service

Bonnie James

Excellent food! Amazing staff!

danielle botkin

Patricia Abrams

Great food wonderful quaint atmosphere

Jesse Ball

Mark Waltz

Jay Henderson

Had a very very good meal for lunch at Shy Cellars. Susan served us today and her attention to detail, her warmth and care made our outing very special. The food was wonderful. The menu is short but well thought out with selections to please almost every palate. We had a wine flight to sample from their cellar selections and each was memorable. Susan even added a sample of a Cabernet she selected. Our shared lunch included the lobster bisque, Caesar salad, and the best carbonara we have ever eaten! We finished with Affogato, homemade vanilla icecream with a caramel drizzle, served with a side of Frangelico and Expresso. We will be back for more.

Patti Fearon

Troy Ellington

Great food wonderful atmosphere and excellent service. I would highly recommend shy cellars.

Miss Misu

This food will transcend you into another dimension.

Tobias Adams

Food and experience was phenomenal! Me and my SO loved every aspect of our meal.

melanie korns

Logan Kreitzburg

Food was spectacular and the staff was absolutely amazing. Definitely reccomend it especially if you want a great meal and friendly staff

Mike Belopotosky

Wonderful place for lunch or dinner


Great food and quite atmosphere. Customer service was perfect.

Stephanie Walker

Absolutely awesome service! We stumbled upon this gem and are so very happy we did! I have not one negative thing to say...MUST GO!

Mr. Luey

The service and food are to die for and the people make it feel like home. They cater to your meal preference I definitely recommend this place for food fun and memories

Tammy Kidd

A very pleasant surprise!! Will return!

Daniel Davis

Great place for a special occasion.


So relaxing The Food is delicious Decent selection of bourbon

Sigmund Olenzak

5 star food and personable service. Shrimp & fried grit ball appetizer was outstanding (10 out of 10). We'll definitely return for a special occasion.

Megan Garrett

Amazing dining experience. The food was wonderful, and the staff was great.

Eric Mann

Good food and service.

Kevin Burgett

THE BEST PLACE TO GET FRESH, GREAT TASTING FOOD! If you are in the area and want to have an amazing time in your mouth, stop here.

K Griffy

I was excited to have dinner here as i had heard so many great things about it. The bottle of wine, crab bisque and crab cakes were really good. However, my husband's prime rib was just ok, but had more of a taste and texture of a steak. My chicken was full of blood which ran into the rest of my food on the plate. I told the waitress, handed her my fork and plate and told her that if this chicken wasn't cooked properly, it just contaminated everything on my plate. She took the plate, "questioned herself if it was cooked", took it to the kitchen, then came out to me and insisted that it was at the correct temperature and that it was just some kind of blood vessel in the chicken. I did receive a new dinner and in a much speedier time than the original (which I was glad). But then I got my bill and realize I was overcharged for the chicken by $5. It should have been $19 (as shown in the menu) and I was charged $24. I told the waitress, who refunded the amount and the card was recharged for the correct amount (which now shows two amounts pending to go through). I had very high hopes for this place. I knew that it would be a fine dining and a more expensive (than normal) place to eat however, I was slightly disapointed and unfortunately, we most likely will not go back.

Leah Patrick

Awesome food and service definitely at top!

Gary B

Great food. We had crab cakes and prime rib. Everything was cooked to perfection. They have a long wine list but would like more options from local wineries. Presentation and overall experience is what you would expect to find at a five star restaurant. This restaurant is the Crown Jewel of Strasburg and the surrounding area.

Jeremy Kidd

Absolutely phenomenal!

William Karl

Kyle Caulk

Awesome food, great atmosphere. Karen is the best.

Lee Kandel

Amazing dining experience! Highly recommend.

Allison Griffin

Amazing!! Karen is the best, the food is the best, can't wait to host our rehearsal dinner here!

Kristina Miller

Best cuisine in the area!

Willem Jonker

Perfect. Great food. Nice people

Scott Schlea

Owners take personal pride in providing a quality dining experience!

Tim Makowski

Best place I have ate in years and great service too

Jennifer Popa

Louise Moser

David Daniels

We had a wonderful evening with a delicious dinner excellent service and great advice from our waitress.

Mike Jordan

Gary Richardson

Great food and atmosphere.

Lisa Yoder

hands down best food and service

Jake Herbert

Jim Sholtz

Absolutely amazing!!

Herschell Hargrave

Great food, great atmosphere, excellent service!!

Shawn Stamp

Great food! Worth the drive to Strasburg.

steven p

Simply great food, changing menu, quant atmosphere.

Linda Bailey

Food & Staff are exceptional!

Linda Bernard

The food was phenomenal! We enjoyed everything ordered!

Maggie Olson

Shy notes on their website that they gladly accommodate dietary restrictions. As a longtime vegan, I always go in with modest expectations, but these guys absolutely blew me away! Our waitress was friendly and eager and offered me a few options to choose from. They wound up whipping up an Asian vegetable stir fry with fried onions, served on top of risotto. It was unbelievably good, among the top 5 restaurant meals I've had in five years as a vegan. The atmosphere, parking, and overall service were excellent. I will definitely be back and highly recommend this place for my fellow veggie heads!

Molly Derrow

Amazing food, service, and atmosphere!

Karla Schultz

Jeremy Baldwin

From scheduling a reservation (and rescheduling it twice for same night in 20 minutes) it was a superb experience. Sherrie the owner came by a couple times to see how we liked our food and Karen our waitress was very friendly and helpful and made us feel extremely welcome there for dinner. The food was amazing! Its been 24 hours ans we're still talking about the quality. How fresh it all tasted and the many wonderful flavors in each portion. Just wish she was closer to Cincinnati.

Andre Yoder


Cindy Lorenz

The food & service here are high end, top quality!

Rodney Johnson

The best prime rib in the whole entire world. Anything and everything I've ever eatin at shy Cellars has been totally an amazing experience. Please put pig ears back on the menu please...

Rachael Head

I love this restaurant. They are very accommodating to my dietary needs - gluten and dairy free. Everything is fresh!

Ryta J.

Our experience at SHY Cellars was one of the best we've ever had anywhere! Tara, Sherry and the entire SHY Cellars team were top notch! Their cuisine is authentic, inspired and delectable. The service was above and beyond but felt so warm and inviting. We truly felt as though we were guests in their home, not diners at a restaurant. Tara even went beyond all expectation to create a special dish for us for the second night we dined there because they were out of our first choice the first night. She is one of only a handful of chefs in the US to make this incredible pasta so were were amazed that we got to try it. As former restaurant owners, we know how many movable parts there are in creating a great dining experience from start to finish and SHY Cellars is off the charts amazing! It's worth any time it takes to get there and is a true gem in Amish Country! Being from Pittsburgh, we know great dining...wish SHY Cellars would come to the Burgh! Food, wine and service were beyond 5 stars for sure! We can't wait to plan another trip back!

Joe Shomette

Stopped here on a whim with my mother, my daughter and my three siblings with no reservation. With a bit of rearranging, the staff accommodated our party of 5. We were really impressed with the wine selection and the food was excellent! Definitely on my "do again" list.

Justin Rhodes

The food was excellent. Atmosphere was wonderful.

Ashley C

The food was amazing. We did have a reservation, but probably could have gotten away with not having one. The staff were so kind and well informed about the wines and food choices. Will definitely be back.

Brenda Larrabee

We were visiting Sugarcreek and looking for a place for dinner. We too just happened to stumble across Shy Cellars. We had been in Cleveland the previous night celebrating our 40th wedding anniversary. We had a delicious meal in Cleveland and a nice time. We had a fabulous meal and an "experience" at Shy Cellars. They have an open kitchen design and we were fortunate to get a table next to the kitchen. The whole kitchen staff along with Chef Schie interacted with us the whole evening. She even came to our table to make sure our food was prepared correctly. And I can't say enough about Chris who took care of us the whole evening. She is an absolute gem and Chef Schie is fortunate to have her on her team. We would definitely recommend Shy Cellars and we will go back if we are visiting that area again.

Earl Ash


My mom and I went to Shy for the first time last week. All I can say is WOW! What a fabulous place! Everything about it is impeccable...the food, the service, the ambiance.They also have an extensive wine list. I did a flight of dry reds which was quite impressive. Our meals were some of the best we've had in a long time. Our server, Val, was amazing! I inadvertently left my debit card there, and an hour later she called and offered to bring it to me when she got off work. Need I say more?

Mike Petcher

My wife and I came here as part of our 40th anniversary celebration. We were warmly greeted and shown to our table. Our extremely accomplished server ("little") Sherri made us feel like we were the most important people in the world throughout the entire meal. The food was impeccably prepared and beautifully presented. The missus started with Tenpenny Amber Ale and I had the Smoked Old Fashion, which was divine. The homemade bread is amazing! The shrimp & calamari appetizer we enjoyed is a perfect example of the creativity here, a sublime marriage of spice, sweetness, and seafood. Yum! Our filet mignons were among the finest I have ever tasted, and the accompanying vegetables and potato were fantastic as well. Delicious homemade vanilla bean ice cream topped things off. Every element of the meal was top notch - there were no weak links anywhere. Chef Sherry stopped by to check on our experience, and she is a delight. She enjoyed my description of our perfect meal, which is that it creates a long lasting memory. It is easy to give Shy Cellars 5 stars, and we can hardly wait to return.

Rick Meadows

Diana Malcolm

We had heard so much about Shy Cellars and decided to celebrate my husband's birthday there. We had the most enjoyable experience. The food was delicious, I especially loved the signature salad comprised of grilled Romaine with dried cranberries,nuts, raisins, crumbled feta and a wonderful salad dressing. The best part for me was the fact that the kitchen is totally exposed to the patrons allowing one to view all preparations. This restaurant has the class of ranking in markets like New York or Chicago.

Beth Thacker

Janet Boetticher

We did the wine tasting and really enjoyed the wines. Our server really knew the wines.

Anthony Domitrovich

Lynn Dalsky

Excellent experience. Great food and service.

Cher Hathaway

Great food and atmosphere!

Todd Kotler

Fine dining in the most unexpected place.

Sean OToole

Kraig Rion

dustin cleveland

Took the wife for her birthday! Great place to eat. Very relaxed, small, great food. To be honest, at first the outside appears to be someone's home but once inside it feels like a 5 star restaurant. Open view of the chef's and staff and good music. Karen was our server and she did a great job. Thanks!

Alissa Bryan

Awesome night out on the revamped patio. Great food and service as always!!

Am 156153

Great food and atmosphere. Everyone was very welcoming. They add a personal touch to service. Tuscarawas County has never had a place like this before. Had the prime rib. Everything was amazing. Pleasantly surprised.

Best hunt of you're life

John Pope

Great food and stmosphere different food selection depends on what is in season

Rickey Woodard II

Absolutely amazing food

jane russell

The best place. Friendly staff and amazing food!

Holly Long always

Sal Vaccarino

Great food. Great service. Dining area is a little small but the atmosphere is fantastic. Server was great and very cheerful. Orders were taken quickly and served almost as fast.

Carrie Fidler

steve hunsinger

Deb H

Just disappointed. Very expensive for what they serve. They destroyed a prime rib. No meat flavor due to over spiced grilling. Gnocchi was good with good sauce. But I added chicken. It was over cooked & dry. Salads not included. Noisy restaurant seating. Kinda felt like sitting in a garage or some cheap concrete floored room. Appetizer was calamari & shrimp. Tiny little fried shrimp. Greasy texture. We spent $100 for 2 people and it was not worth it! We travel a lot & don't mind spending good $ on a good meal. That wasn't the case hear.

Emily H

Great food and great service! Love the wine too!

Mike Duplay

Most amazing hidden gem for first-class food experience. Wonderful vegetarian and dessert options.

Bobby Fanclub

Susan Lalewicz

Excellent, excellent, excellent

Ariel Snyder

mark chisnell

My wife and I usually love this restaurant, but our dinner tonight was sub par. The service was excellent, but the cook oversalted every dish. The waitress did her best to make things right, but it was a very disappointing meal. Note---the owner/chef Sherry was not there tonight. We hope the staff takes our suggestion to back off the amount of salt in their dishes, or we won't be back

Steve Peters

Great food

John Tarulli

Good food and service. Way overpriced.

shelly love

We had a wonderful Valentine's Day Dinner here. My filet mignon was amazing. Our waitresses name was Traci and She made our experience perfect!

Lauren Painley

The food was amazing. The lamb just fell apart and it was perfectly cooked and we appreciated the chef coming out to say hello. But it was our first time there, and celebrating our anniversary. We noticed everyone else received signs for their birthdays and anniversaries except for us. The waitresses seemed to give a lot of attention to other tables and we did not receive the same sort of attention. Overall, food was great, service could be better!

David Arbogast

Outstanding. In the middle of nowhere but first class and great wine list.

Bobby Harrison

Very nice and worth the money, a must visit if you are in this area.

Shawn Kapper

The ultimate dining experience!

Alicia Makowski

Amazing food and service. Top quality all around.

Nick Weaver

Alex Soduk

Fantastic food! Get the bread pudding dessert.

Jeffrey Magers

Wonderful ! The meal was fantastic .

John Uvena

Fantastic! I had the strip steak and my wife had the bacon wrapped scallops. We will definitely be back!

Bill Ratliff

Excellent service only to be overshadowed by the excellent food wonderful experience! Definitely a return customer

Tadd Hunt

My wife and I made a reservation for an early evening dinner on a Saturday. It wasn’t to celebrate anything special, necessarily. But it was a special night out to us because it was one of a the VERY few times we had been out on a date together since our baby girl was born a year and a half ago. We were excited just to be out but the service that we got at Shy Cellars just enhanced our evening as they matched our level of excitement. We were treated as guests, not customers. They seemed genuinely happy to have us there and were eager to welcome us. The excellence of the food matched the excellence of the service. I ordered fillet mignon with a glass of Merlot and my wife ordered a veggie lasagna with a sangria. The fillet mignon was hands down the best I’ve ever had, and I’ve had more than my fair share of fillet mignon from many other esteemed dining establishments. Shy Cellars actually exceeded my expectations of what a fillet mignon should taste like! Thank you, Shy Cellars, for a very enjoyable date night with my wife and for making us feel so welcomed. Again, the food and service were excellent!

John Martin

Awesome every time! Sea Bass, Goat, Prime Rib, Filet... no matter what we rec'd it was spectacular...oh and the risotto was to die for!

Ambrose Perduk Jr.

The finest restaurant in Tuscarawas County.

Jesse Allison

Delicious food, good drinks and very personal service!

Amber Mikec

Tonight was the third time we have been to Shy Cellars. The first time was a year ago when visiting the area and we immediately put it on our list of places to eat the next time we were in the Berlin area. The second time was last night and it was so amazing that we made reservations for the very next day (today) so we could fit in one more visit before heading home! Having come two nights in a row, we tried much of the menu. Our favorites were the crab bisque (they will split the bowl for you to share), the small plate crab cakes, the spicy shrimp and calamari appetizer, the scallops on fried polenta cakes, the lamb shank, and the filet with creamy herb couscous! The menu doesn’t offer a plethora of choices but everything they do offer is superb!! All the staff that waited on us were attentive, knowledgeable, and lots of fun. We also met Executive Chef Tara to rave about the the wasabi that came with our complementary Asian shrimp cocktail, which we were given since we were the first to sit at their new communal 14 seat table. We’d love to see the shrimp cocktail on the regular menu as it was a nice light appetizer to start our dining experience. Although we were the only ones at the communal table this time, we’d happily sit there again since it gives you a great view of the open kitchen! Overall, we had a wonderful experience at Shy Cellars and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fun, fine dining establishment.

April Lewis

Kurt Rybak

The veal chop and duck breast are great.the wine list is extensive.Great place for an intimate meal....

Brian Hall

Very good food with a menu that changes weekly.

Tamara Legere

Best in class! Absolutely fantastic!! Great food and outstanding service

clayton livengood

The Very Best Food and Service in Ohio

Jeff Bodziony

Got to sit and enjoy a beer on the patio and chat with the owners... What wonderful, hardworking people.... Great atmosphere. Will be back!

lavern yoder

Great food and service!

Pete Hager

The shrimp and grits were top notch- some of the best I've had

Chuck Pulley



Good food and a clean place

Zach Ford

My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our dinner! Everything was delicious. We look forward to going back soon!


Great food & service!!

Pam Maurer

Every meal I've eaten here has been spot on. Imaginative daily specials and very good service!

Jean Flinner

A Gainey

Robert Kern

Had a great Filet Mignon! Unique place to get great service and delicious food!

Wil Bagley

Great food and service

Gregory Walker

Unexpectedly Wonderful... Came 'south' from North Canton for a drive-in movie and found a wonderful, sophisticated restaurant.

Cody Lollathin

Best bread pudding ever

Darin Kearns

Shy Cellars isn't what you might expect at first glance. The restaurant appears to be in a converted house and the exterior is neat and clean. The interior is modern and casual with a touch of hominess. The food was excellent and the service was very good. I enjoyed the blackened scallops which were cooked to perfection. Another member of our dinner party had the filet mignon and it was nearly tender enough to cut with a butter was also cooked perfectly to order. The restaurant is a touch loud with an open kitchen and background music but overall it was a great experience and is well recommended.

Michael Fish

Best food ever. Chef visited pateons, made sure everything was fantastic. It was.

Les Myers

Dale Estep

Very fine restaurant.

rob yoder

Very Pleasant dining experience

Joe Roof

Fantastic food. Got the steak and it's one of the best I've had. The bread is fresh and perfect. The place is small and personal, they make an effort to make sure you enjoy your time and your meal!

Jules Marie

Dawn Mowen

Great food Excellent service Will be back

suzy uvena

My 8 year old said they have the best Mac n' cheese EVER! He wants to come back for his birthday! Excellent meal & wonderful staff! Traci made us feel like family! We can't wait to go back! Thank you for the fabulous meal!

Business Hours of Shy Cellars in Ohio

12–3PM 5–9PM
12–3PM 5–9PM
12–3PM 5–9PM
12–3PM 5–9PM


Shy Cellars en Ohio
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Cakes By Karin
Cakes By Karin
Bakery - Ohio

Wedding bakery

Hannah Marie's Bakery & Coffee Shop
Hannah Marie's Bakery & C...
Bakery - Ohio


Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery
Smallcakes Cupcakery and ...
Bakery - Ohio


Busken Bakery
Busken Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Giant Eagle Bakery
Giant Eagle Bakery
Bakery - Ohio