Reviews of Gartman Model Bakery (Bakery)

30 N State St, Painesville, OH 44077, United States

Average Rating:


We offer you the feddbacks of real people like you who are using the services and products of Gartman Model Bakery (Bakery) in the area close to Ohio.

At the moment this firm receives a score of 4.4 stars over 5 and that score has been based on 56 reviews.

You must have seen that it reaches an feddbacks average is positive, and it's based on a very high number of opinions, so we may be quite sure that the assessment is very faithful. If many people have bothered to value when they are happy with the service, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually stop to put evaluations when they are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is classified in the category of Bakery.

Where is Gartman Model Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Gartman Model Bakery IN Ohio

Robert Porter

Since I was introduced to this local bakery about 3 yrs. ago, I have ordered no less than 4 Cassata Cakes for different events and/or celebrations. Each order was taken at least 3 to 4 days in advance up to about a month. And every time was the Best Cake we had ever enjoyed. My wife is part Italian, which was in part, the reason for this special cake. My step father is Italian, which is another reason for such a cake. If you are a person who loves ITALIAN or Sicilian desserts/pastries.. Then I invite you to "call ahead", and order a Cassata Cake for your next celebration! You will Not be Disappointed!!!

Molly Anderson

Dayton Eckart

Great Cakes and Pastries!! Oh and Awesome doughnuts!!

Matt Griesmer

Although the girl who greeted us was knowledgeable and nice, the woman we dealt with wasn't too friendly. In addition although I have gotten some great product from here before I ordered a six pack of brownies for four dollars and the brownies were normal size so I thought four was a bit high for regular size brownies but we got them anyway because he product is generally tasty. However the brownies were totally not fresh, they were crumbly and dry and a huge disappointment for my sons b day surprise! Disappointing!

Amber Cunningham

Kevin Dickard

Dave Grgurich

Great bakery

Michele Laskowski

Awesome bakery, nuff said

Judy White

Lisa Brown

Best balish

Bubba Bentley

Best bakery hands down

Second Times a Farm Chardon

Frank Svegel

Nice variety of bakery items. Great breads

Pamela J Morse

They have wonderful cupcakes and the decorators will put on all types of flowers for you. The kids love to chose their own flavor and flower..perfect to put the candles into. Yummy cassata cakes with whipped cream frosting and decadent Bavarian creme with strawberries. Even better in June during the strawberry season. For a local bakery that you can special order from you cannot beat the quick curb side pick up and great yeast smells when you walk into the 100 year old bakery. They always have a hot cup of coffee and a cake doughnut to take the mid-day edge off of your hunger. Stop in and enjoy a part of local history.

Jordan Levy

Great local bakery, if you are looking for doughnuts, cakes or breads. Sometimes they have bags of yesterday's doughnuts and pastries for $1. Those still taste good.

Britt Sampson

Tony Woloszynek

Sue Norris

Gartman's Bakery is my sister's go to bakery and for good reason. They recently baked a cake for a fundraiser I was doing and the cake they provided was amazing. It looked beautiful and tasted even better. Great job!

Dave Puckett Sr.

Marcus Freeman

David Pirovolos

They have the best pies love the Blueberry pie

Dawn Moran

John Germano

gavin moyer

Cassie Peters

J. J. Flabenowitz

Everything is good here. Yes, even the large bags of day old pastries for $1.00. Good donuts. The variety of donuts is good as well. I have had a few of their other pastries, and there is definitely nothing to complain about. The service has always been good when I went. I THINK they only take cash, so call ahead or take cash.

Dever Hennessey

Stopped in for a dozen doughnuts and was sold day old doughnuts very disappointed

Kimberly Hall

Good old fashion bakery,just wish they had pizza bagles..nobody sells them out here

Danice Kavick

Vaughn Spargur

Great friendly customer service.

Deborah McGee

Pam Morse

Yummy local baked goods in the heart of historic Painesville, OH. Stop by on the way to the river for a coffee and donut or a yummy pastry. Your family and friends will love their Easter Specials and delicious treats. Yesterday they provided wonderful pastries for the Social Media class for the merchants. THANK YOU!!

Amy Seeds

Great local bakery .... Lovely pastry and very reasonably priced fresh breads

Cesar Morales

Gary Holbrook

Always great pastry pie cake cookies... will make a skinny guy fat..

Crystal Bolden

Love it

Josh Marks

Mary H

This place has Amazing Donuts Tried the pumpkin ones they were delicious!

thomas Massey

For some reason everytime I visit this establishment..A woman that goes bye the name of Catherine is very very rude to me ..I told her I was going to address her superior about her rude attitude and she responded go ahead...Terrible customer service

Sharon Glady

Very friendly and accommodating. Ordered a special cake for a shower. Can't wait to see how it turns out!

Troop 62

Just like Grandma used to make!


My family has been buying from Gartman's for three generations, and I can think of no other place I'd rather go. First, I will admit that my experience is limited to their donuts and cakes. If you are looking for a review on other items...sorry, this isn't going to help. Their donuts are outstanding, especially the creme filled. Unlike Dunkin, Gartman's donuts taste fresh-baked, and are incredibly rich and filling. But the cakes are what keep us coming back. I would recommend the white cake with the white frosting...the chocolate is good, but nothing special. The white cakes with the white frosting, however, are a family favorite, and keep us driving from the other side of Lake county to buy for birthdays and special occasions. We even have relatives from out of state who, when they visit, hint at how wonderful it would be to have a Gartman's cake, and we have taken some with us as a surprise when we travel out of state. Their cake is great, it is inexpensive (especially compared to many of the tasteless grocery store bakery cakes), and is well worth the visit. And the smell of the store, when you step in, is beyond smells like heaven.

Anna Sweeney

Steve Sulzbach

Best bakery in town

Julia Vaughn

When we when’t it was closed but the open sign was on and we didn’t realize it was closed and walked in. The lady was super rude/had an adatude when we said “oh I don’t think we have cash” and she said in a very nasty tone “well we are closed anyway” so I am not sure if I will go back but the bakery part is good.

Edgar Land

It's been in painesville Ohio for a long time

Gina Ramos

Michael Barbina

Doughnuts here are amazing, baked fresh daily

Becky P

Great service awesome owner!

David Liukkonen

Rene Goldrin

Oh unbeatable quality and price!!! Love their bread! Always buy in bulk and freeze!

Velma Heath

The best bakery ever!

Kasanda Milligan

The smells when you walk in are amazing and everything looks so good. The prices are fanominal. And everything was so fresh. Very impressed with my first visit there.

Amber Brooks

Hoss Lors

I love Gartmans - been eating doughnuts here since I was little

Dale Rannigan

Business Hours of Gartman Model Bakery in Ohio



Gartman Model Bakery en Ohio
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Cherbourg Cyprus
Cherbourg Cyprus
Bakery - Ohio


Kennedy's Bakery
Kennedy's Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Sidon Lebanese Grille & Bakery
Sidon Lebanese Grille & B...
Bakery - Ohio

Lebanese restaurant

Vines Bakery
Vines Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Kroger Bakery
Kroger Bakery
Bakery - Ohio