Reviews of 8 Sisters Bakery & Cafe (Bakery)

6200 OH-95 #300, Mt Gilead, OH 43338, United States

Average Rating:


You will be able to see all the reviews of real people who consumed the products of 8 Sisters Bakery & Cafe (Bakery) in the area close to Ohio.

To this day this firm gets a score of 4.7 out of 5 and this score has been calculated on 326 reviews.

As you can read, it has an average rating is virtually the top, and it's based on a very high number of opinions, so we can conclude that the evaluation is very reliable. If many people have bothered to give their opinion when they are happy with the business, is that it works.

You know that we do not usually bother to give feddbacks when they are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is 8 Sisters Bakery & Cafe?

REVIEWS OF 8 Sisters Bakery & Cafe IN Ohio

Ashley Dean

The workers there were snudy and rude, when you do not know what you want. While the food was good it was not as good as everyone makes it seem.

Michael Ferry

Located walking distance from a Tesla supercharger. Great staff. They had lots of good looking pastries. I had an awesome breakfast sandwich and coffee.

Vernon Rogers

8 Sisters was great! The Reuben panini and BLT were delicious. My kids loved the quiche and the bread pudding. We picked up some donuts, cookies and buckeyes to take home as well. The bathroom was clean and the staff was friendly.

Keith Fudge

Excellent, good variety of goods, plus meet sister no 9....

Julie Samek

Nice quiet bakery with nice seating for your morning coffee, donuts, or breakfast sandwiches. The food was good and started my day off to a good start.

Theresa Geanis

Their baked goods are wonderful and so fresh, yum.

David Ufferman

Great place for. Coffee and sandwiches and pastries

Lisa Bowmar

Coworkers think these are the best donuts ever!!!!

Chrissy Griffin

Such a wonderful place. Wonderful food and mostly wonderful staff! Thanks for your great food and customer service!

AJ Hamman

Cake doughnuts are Heaven on Earth. So good!

Menno Swartzentruber

Delicious Breakfast. Great service.!!!

Christina Littleton

Best Cake and donuts...Nothing compares

Dragon Fire

Great Food, great customer service, not overly priced. I'd say a great place to eat!

Jason Mok

Great selections of baked goods. Awesome service.

Greg Donofrio

Stopped here on the way from Columbus to Cleveland and was so happy I did. Greatt customer service and incredible baked goods! Will be back

Richard Wagner

A nice change from chain coffee and bake shops. Wonderful donuts, pies, cakes and cookies. Good coffee and food including quiche and panini. Nice farm stand next door. A nice change of pace from Micki Ds for a pit stop on I-71 at exit 151. Try it.

Judy Selva

Very friendly atmosphere the food was fantastic

Jim Shaum

Handy location and great baked goods. Excellent service. A little pricey it seems.

Susan Welch

Best Pasteries in Ohio

Tod Bowen

The donuts are great, the coffee is good and they are very friendly.

Andrea Mattix

Fabulous as always!

wes campbell

amazing pastries

Lehnanne Gibbs Kidd

If you've ever had a donut from 8 Sisters you know how delicious they are, if you've not ... get there ASAP. The cream filling is amazing, I promise you won't regret it.

David Bell

Great donuts !

Kathleen Anderson

The cream filling is unbelievable. Nothing can compare to 8 sisters.

Michele Pemble

Good baked goodies!!

ie na

Simple sandwiches, with chips and fresh pickles hit the spot. Then we smashed on baked goods. Was a good trip!

Val Kline

The bakery was a little smaller than we imagined, we are used to bigger bakeries in Amish Country. It had a more open, warehouse feeling to it, in my opinion. You could see right into the large kitchen area. There was a counter top that spanned the length of the building. At one end there was an area that you could sit at and order fancy coffees. The other end displayed their baked goods. We found out that you could also order paninis there. I wish that we had known that.

Brandon Burson

Fresh whole pie for $12

Lisa row-taylor

Great donuts and friendly service

Alexis Weis

Passing through Ohio we stopped for a quick bite. Upon entering I observed limited staff. My husband and I ordered soup assuming it would be quick. We finally questioned the wait, 45 minutes, asked to have a carry out. The soup was excellent, the wait ridiculous.

John Jory

Great selections and fresh ground coffee. Quick lunch too.

1 Cricket

Great stuff

Pete Berry

Some of the biggest Donuts I've seen

Kelly Lopez

Very good quality very tasty

Andrew M

A little pricey but very good options

Ben Merica

My wife and I were traveling thru Ohio in the area near I-71 and pulled off to get a donut and a hot morning drink. We found this quaint little spot and decided to venture in; to our surprise there was a breakfast menu that we opted for.WOW! The best gravy and biscuits I ever had. The coffee was so smooth and flavorful! Decided to take a sour cream donut as well to finish my coffee. Great price! Friendly staff and relaxing atmosphere.. I will stop again when I travel in that area and it is suggested you do the same!

JINO0372 Model Railroading

Ok donuts. Not as good as they used to be.

Kevin A

You MUST try breakfast here. Not just the pastries. I recommend the "Amish Slam"

Larry Gregory

never have had any bad food here it is always good

Heather Staton

I love 8 sisters and glad they have a nice place now near us. I bought donuts at this location for the first time last week and was greeted friendly upon entering. They had plenty of donuts available and the quality was great as usual!

Deb Mccann

Friendly staff, incredible baked goods and coffee.

Michelle Lindsay

My family, friends, and colleagues love the donuts from 8 Sisters. They are huge, made fresh daily, and lots of options to choose from.

malcolm curry

Amazing selection of specialty donuts and great tasting breakfast sandwich. Quick service with a smile from the whole staff.

R Riggs

Delicious eats and treats! The Vanilla Cinnamon Rolls are the perfect balance of sweetness.

Mr smith

They got it right each time

Lee Hitzfield

If you want donuts you have to go in the morning, otherwise you probably won't get any. I like to get donuts there on Friday night for the weekend, but then they are usually out. There are a few unfriendly workers. Easy access from 71 and 95.

Powers Plays

Good all around

Ghostrider13 OOF

Good laid back place to enjoy a donut and a cup of coffee.

HeatherandScott Somerlade

I have tried several times to get the great experience here that everyone seems to have. The donuts are not fresh tasting. Got the twisted glaze donut and had to put in microwave to get it to even somewhat fresh. The staff ..needs to work on being smiles at all. I see this has been mentioned in several reviews as well.

ron Spruce

I go in at least twice a week to pick up a breakfast sandwich or lunch and the food is always delicious and the employees are very courteous and friendly and the baked goods are so good.. would highly recommend 8 Sisters to anyone looking for a great bakery.

Edward Drachenberg Jr.

Smells and looks great but wasn't very good in my opinion. Im not sure how to reply. My wife liked it, but we had 6 donuts and a brookie. it just wasn't sweet like im used to. the apple fritter didn't have any apple flavor and the cream sticks were not sweet inside. The brookie was not sweet ether, just bland and oily. portions were very large and like I said my wife enjoyed, just wasn't for me.

Tina Howard

Made to order baby shower cake. Delicious and quick turn around. Reasonably priced for a double layer cake with raspberry filling. Extremely friendly and helpful! Highly recommend!

Deena Malhotra

Not fresh


I’m giving 1star because the icing was very good. But the cupcakes were very dry and stale. I picked them up the morning of my event even so they would be fresh! They tasted like they had been made a few days prior and fresh icing put on them. Very few were eaten because of this, and I was left with a ton of dry, old cupcakes! Definitely not worth the price I paid for the “gourmet” cupcakes. Very doubtful I will be back. Such a disappointment after what I paid for the cupcakes. Considering these were the only desert for my daughters baby shower I’m pretty upset! And the customer service was awful! The lady seemed very annoyed and acted like I was bothering her because I asked her 2 questions. Left a VERY bad impression on a first time customer!

Dennis Turner

Great food. This place is a gem.

Timothy Good

Always delicious...

Kathy. Bukey

Great donuts!

sherri meminger

Clean friendly family place! A must stop.great bake goods great prices

Braden Kehres

Had them do muffins and doughnuts for our wedding where we had breakfast foods and they were amazing.

Carolyn Lutz

I often stop at 8 Sisters Bakery to pick up donuts to take into work or a cake for special occasions. All my coworkers love their baked goods and the cakes are really nicely decorated and delicious. Highly recommend!!

Michael Maglott

Good bakery items

Pam Swaney

I bought alot of different things to try. $40 worth of items and it was okay. Expensive.

Sheila Jeffers

Everything they make is delicous

Susan Meyers

Wonderful surprise as we head back to Dayton - My husband had a Amish breakfast sandwich and I had the club delicious and the bread pudding was perfect!

Shaun Miller

A unique bakery/cafe. Close to car wash and Tesla charging station.

Douglas Garrett

Good but to high 23.04 for 6 of them

Sandi Hall

Best donuts in town. Expensive but best I ever had

Marty Yanchunis

Good time and supper people. I loved the Fox cookies !!!

Thomas Hinger Jr

A little pricey, but outstanding products!!!

Keith Johansen

Donut holes are good, cookies are nothing special

Larry Martin

Ok... it looked good but big disappointment. One of the worse bakeries I've been to. Apple fritters.. no apple.... muffin had to be days old! Wife got a cream filled donut, very dry, and zero cream. Sad... keep driving!

Susie Kanter

Love these ladies!!! Always so helpful at accommodating our bible study size. Food is to die for.

Carly Westhoven

Good coffee, breakfast sandwiches, and the best donuts I've ever had!

Terrie Kinniard

I have been hearing about your bakery for a while now and it did not disappoint! I had a cream filled maple iced stick donut and all I can say is , if I had to choose the last thing I wanted to eat before dying, that would have been it! One of the best things I have ever eaten! I was an assistant bakery manager for a few years and later a cafe manager for 10 years. I started in food service almost 50 years ago as a 15 year old so you should consider this a huge compliment! Don't change a thing! Congratulations on what you have accomplished!

Linda Roberts

Unbelievably yummy baked goods and breakfast sandwiches!

Scott Brown

Wonderful baked goods (custard-filled donut, no bakes, and creme puffs) and great people!

Lusee Learning

Wonderful relaxing place to stop coming off 71North. I always stop on my way home from Columbus, Easy access parking, well made coffees and the best bakery goods I have ever had. Over the years I have had just about everything on their menu!

Kimberly McNeil

Completely yummy is an absolute understatement when describing what these 8 sisters can accomplish with the mere mortal ingredients of sugar, butter and flour!!

Nina Atwood

Nothing wrong here. Pleasant people,great food and a veggie stand with fresh jams,pickled good and canned goods. Wish it was closer.

Amber Kissling

First time visiting. The display case was wonderful. We opted to try their maple bacon creme stick. It did not disappoint. It was so good! The facilities were clean and well kept, staff was super friendly.

Margaret Ruhl

A little slow but good donuts.

Joel Smythe

More than just Donuts and baked good! If you haven't had the Amish Grand Slam you are missing out (It's an incredible breakfast sandwich). I really like their Chicken Salad, too!

Charlotte Chipps

Good quiche but crust was a bit dry. The bread pudding that comes with it is to die for!

Cindy Robinson

Friendly staff. Good baked goods.

Gregory Gompf

Excellent doughnuts. Always fresh with lots of variety.

Logan Fadeley

A coworker brought these donuts in for a meeting and, without a doubt, these are up there with the best.

Cassie Glassford

Some of the best donuts ever you can't go wrong with fresh-made donuts and food from 8 sisters.

Patricia Weis

We stopped to get some desert. We bought a apple pie (

Earlene Wallace

Extremely sweet employees. It must be all the sugar they work around. Fresh baked goods and everything a pastries person could want. I loved the fried pies.

Chelsea Dalgord

Excellent variety of tasty sweets and friendly customer service.

Jeff Riggs

Great staff and tasty treats!

Gary Funk

Great bakery! Huge donuts.

Veggie Myers

Best donut ever

Lindell Brooks

Fantastic donuts, no willpower can survive this place.

Terry Fitzpatrick

Stopped twice in the same morning at the route 95 location near I-71. Phenomenal bakery - thus the two visits. Standard donuts, creme sticks, apple fritters and cookies reasonably priced or for a little extra $, specialty baked goodness such as their Oreo creme stick, custard filled creme stick abd bacon covered maple creme stick, to name a few. The cafe menu has signature breakfast items, paninnis and sandwiches, soups and salads.

Mark Nixon

Cute place just off 71 with delicious Amish donuts -try the maple bacon! Very friendly staff.

Heatherlee Hull

Always a good place to stop for a treat. You have to go early or they may be out of all the good stuff.

Maria Aurigema

Have been here often absolute love 8 sisters. This review happens to be from a donut Friday when they're open till 1:00 a.m. there was quite a few people. Service is always excellent. One of the best parts is that you can smell and wait just a few minutes until your delectable choice of treats comes out of the oven. Their baked goods are a little slice of heaven.


Omg this place is amazing. It’s a must stop for any Tesla owners. Great fresh good. The donuts are amazing mmmm

Bill Miller

Highly recommended! Great place to get full filling on sweets, great service!

Martha Mooney

Where else would you go on national donut day. Best donuts ever

Noah Johnson

Friendly people

Valerie HeArt Brown

Breakfast was wonderful. Bread pudding was delicious.

Deborah Ralston


mike doyle

Amazing doughnuts

Matt Ward

Got some fried pies for Easter Dessert. They were mighty fine fried pies. Was going to stick him in the oven but the oven was full! Instead I put them in the microwave for about 30 seconds each. It warmed them up enough that they started to soften. I had a whole damn fried pie myself. My family lives near here. I will be back. FIVE STARS!!!!!!

Jennifer Emberg

A new favorite place of ours! All sorts of yumminess. I'll have to go for lunch once of the days. The doughnuts are very distracting - lol!

Bill Trovato

I gave it 5 stars because I couldn't do 6.

Kenneth Pritchard

Very good variety and quality of food. Excellent service.

Albert Sheldon

Passing thru glad we stopped. Now I have to arrange any trip so this is a rest ,food stop . Mid Ohio #1 ,8 sisters a must dont miss it . Staff great ,fried balogna ,BLT and array of great goodie STOP A MUST.

Lyn Calderwood

Cute, clean & good food & coffee!

Dale Seg

Nice stop for a fritter and latte

Abigail Gerdes

Cute find! Delicious homemade donuts (try a maple cream stick)! Friendly service. Clean space.

JB Brown

The new bakery does more than just the sweet treats. They have wifi and they make a very good breakfast Sandwich.

Amanda Stabley

We love going up to 8 Sisters on a Friday evening when they are open late, and stocking up on our donuts for the weekend. They are sooo yummy!

Jamin Mills

I've never had a better donut in my life, brother . Better get to 8 sisters

Ashlee Anvik

5 STARS! A true diamond in the rough sea of fast food chains surrounding it. A simple lunch menu but everything with homemade BREAD which is a game changer. The Reuben and the Egg Sandwich were delicious. The baked goods, equally as hand crafted to perfection. This is a rare find these days. We are happy we stopped.

Lauren Fink

What a great place to stop if you're travelling on 71! Loads of great baked goods, like donuts and pies, plus a full menu with sandwiches, soup, etc.

Tim Parker

Best doughnut shop around... unless you have a special Amish connection

Robert Hilburn

Great chow. No service to tables though


Yummy home style goods

Mary Neviska

Fun place to just as it and chat. Great bakery products, good food though limited and nice people.

Dan Arthur

Best Bakery in Morrow County. Great service and always with a smile.

Kilu Ball

I was quite sad my first trip. I drove up from Columbus to get a cream filled maple donut. They didn't have any. I looked forward to it all week. I was so depressed. Wasn't their fault though; a problem on my end caused me to show up just before they closed. I moped around the rest of the day. Finally I come before they close and get the donut I've been dreaming of. And all was well.

Donald Adair

We stopped in on a travel and were so pleasantly surprised... we had the Italian Sandwich and Club wrap.. both delicious... I asked if the sold bread by the loaf since non was displayed.. young baker said she had some coming out of the oven just then.... SOLD!!! Their display case was filled with doughnuts and sweets... What a great place... we will be back Great food Wonderful staff...

Elaine Snow

Fabulous Bakery!! Delicious food and amazing Bread Pudding!!!

That Guy

Great unexpected gem. Had a donut muffin and some coffee while supercharging. Great quality. Food was great and was a nice family owned restaurant that I was happy to support.

William Mertler

Great food.

Larry Coleman

We tried the Pecan Rolls and Apple Fritters and they were excellent.

Marty Rainford

Might be the best doughnut I have ever had. Fried bologna sandwich was terrific. Wonderful staff. Very happy I found this place while passing through.

Outdoors Deluxe

Delicious food!

Katie Kanable Rogers

Stopped here for lunch and it was delicious! Even bought doughnuts for breakfast tomorrow and Christmas cookies for Santa to enjoy.

Leila Pinchot

Delicious breakfast sandwiches and doughnuts

Nathan Kitchen

Excellent food and coffee!!

Brian Dible

Heard good things about 8 Sisters Bakery. Stopped by on way to Mt Vernon to try their famous maple bacon donut. I can say I was definitely surprised at how good it actually was. Didn't think I'd like it but it was tasty. Not exactly cheap at $2.99, but it did have quite a bit of bacon. Only downside I had was the employee wasn't really friendly and made no eye contact or attempt to smile.

Michael Johnson

Nice coffee shop with snacks, hoof hearted coffee ,try a cup

Laurie Mooney

Love the soups and quiche and sandwiches! Always great service and the atmosphere is so upbeat and cheery.

Jason Clever

Great place to stop when traveling up 71 for a break. Clean, great baked goods, and super service. Locally sourced. My new go to.

Kayla B.

Sugar cookies are decent. Very cute

Kevin Ball

Giant donuts and treats. Stoped by on the way to visit a friend and was very impressed with the selection of pastries and treats they had.

Gregory Givens

They are the best doughnuts I have ever had.

Chris Hightower

Great little place too grab a sandwich, while Supercharging.

Jerri New

Amazing Amish bakery & cafe. Food was wonderful

Sondra Carey

The place to get the perfect doughnut off the " beaten path."

Robert Katter

Nice supercharger stop for the Tesla tasty panini


Great pastries! Their blackberry-filled one is a must-have. Definitely the perfect place to stop on a road trip.

Andrew Haag

Love your biscuits and gravy

Denise Davis

I saw the sign from the highway on my way back to Columbus from Mansfield.... So I got off the freeway at exit 151.... Went up the road about a minute's worth of drive and I'm glad I did!! Their baked goods were DELISHUS!! I ESPECIALLY loved the Apple turnovers (I bought 2!) And the Cinnamon Apple croissant like donuts were THE BEST!! It was my first time there, but it will NOT be my last!!!

Carrie Gutowski

Both bakery and farm stand are excellent. I stop here any time I am remotely close. The fry pies are addictive. Great pumpkin pie as well.

Gary Hickerson

Amazing bakery! Outstanding!

Michelle Smith

Best bakery around! Specialty items. Muffins cookies donuts. Cakes coffee and even cookies for kids! Delicious and fresh!

Aubrey Keyse

These donuts are LIFE. Our favorite!

Mary Cline

Love love love

Jeffrey E

Both the coffee and service were great!

Sarah Fauque

The sandwiches and donuts are very good! Quick service and friendly staff. I definitely recommend especially if you are waiting at the super charger.

Jeff Evans

Great doughnuts

Monica Staley

Far and away the BEST donut I have EVER had in my entire life! My coworker who lives near you brought these in today I opted for the cream-filled donut on the right and it was truly phenomenal. Normally I am not a donut fan because I do not like the taste of buttercream icing, but the filling in this one was more of a whipped icing taste and I LOVED it! Thank you for making delicious donuts and if you ever come to the Zanesville area you will have a customer for life!

Luke O'Brien

The donuts are incredible, the staff are all friendly, and the prices are great

Business Hours of 8 Sisters Bakery & Cafe in Ohio



8 Sisters Bakery & Cafe en Ohio
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Doughbox Bakery
Doughbox Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Wixey Bakery
Wixey Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Cakes and More
Cakes and More
Bakery - Ohio


Scratch Bakery by Justin Tyler
Scratch Bakery by Justin ...
Bakery - Ohio

Cupcake shop

Family Donut Shop
Family Donut Shop
Bakery - Ohio

Donut shop