Reviews of 8 Sisters Bakery (Bakery)

29 S Main St, Mt Gilead, OH 43338, United States

Average Rating:


We have all the reviews of real people who bought the services and products of 8 Sisters Bakery (Bakery) in the area close to the state of Ohio.

Right now the business has a rating of 4.4 out of 5 and this rating has been based on 61 reviews.

You must have seen that it reaches an reviews average is good, and it is based on a large number of opinions, so we may think that the assessment is very reliable. If there are many people who bothered to rate when they are satisfied, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually bother to put scores when they are good and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is 8 Sisters Bakery?

REVIEWS OF 8 Sisters Bakery IN Ohio

runner 96

We get doughnuts and pies every time we are in town!

John Haggard

Always friendly service and wonderful baked goods.

Denise Sagar

Maple bacon and Strawberry creme donuts are the best!!

Donald Hartsock

Best bakery in central Ohio

Monica Staley

Far and away the BEST donut I have EVER had in my entire life! My coworker who lives near you brought these in today I opted for the cream-filled donut on the right and it was truly phenomenal. Normally I am not a donut fan because I do not like the taste of buttercream icing, but the filling in this one was more of a whipped icing taste and I LOVED it! Thank you for making delicious donuts and if you ever come to the Zanesville area you will have a customer for life!

Olivia Millisor

The donuts were good but the service wasn't

Gerry Davies

I love their donuts, however I had to adjust my review as the last two times I have been there they were out of everything. Today it was 9:30, and there were like 3 or 4 items left in the case. Very disappointing.

JB Brown

This locally owned and operated bakery does a wonderful job. Great place to buy a pie.

Lehnanne Gibbs Kidd

Fresh maple cream sticks were amazing!!

Lisa Fox

William Whaley

If it's the pound cake i had from there..excellent.

Robert Hobbs

Ramonia Smith

Kelly Lopez



Jeremy Barr

Great local bakery! Go early for the best selections!

Trey Tietz

Awesome place with great coffee, baked goods, breakfast and lunch! Love that they are right next to Tesla superchargers too!!

Squad Squid

Mary Kamyar

I ordered quite a few cakes from this lovely bakery for activities at the local High school. All the cakes were delicious and got a lot of compliments. The store was fairly new at the time and was not so great at being sure someone was out front for service. I am sure it has improved. I no longer live in the area but I have heard such good things I was thinking of taking a drive up from Columbus to check it out again!

09 Ford Superior

Tommy Carpenter

JLR Shenanigans

Absolute amazing food

Veonca Loft

Alicia Shurts

The cakes are really, really tasty and the cake I ordered for a birthday turned out nicely. Looking through their picture gallery on their FB page, the range of decorating quality is surprisingly wide. Some appear to be amateurish, some are like what you'd get at a grocery store bakery, and many are simply stunning. Other baked items such as their donuts, noodles, and sweet breads are fantastic, but I am not a fan of their wheat bread - it's on the salty side. 4 stars because it can be hit and miss depending on what you order...the good far outweighs the bad.

Toni Mays

Gina Brewer


Kimberly Hott

Very simple shop but super delicious goodies!!

bob shaffer

Robert Garner

Clayton Fraysier

Hannah Adamson

Great food and great service!!!!

Kelly Hand

Always a great, yummy treat. Fast, friendly service with some of the best donuts around!

Tammy Beall

Yummy doughnuts

Kevin Adkins

we just visited the store in Mt Gilead. Bought a pumpkin fry had MOLD inside. They used to great. Manager was not there. The young lady called her supervisor. Supervisor said she was too busy at tge fall festival. Couldn't even talk to us to apologize. .. "my boss will call you back Monday." This was NOT handled correctly.

Carly Szilagyi

I asked them to do a drip cake for my birthday and got nothing like the reference that was given to them. On their web site they have a picture of a beautiful drip cake so I thought yea they can do this, no problem! Nobody told me hey sorry we can’t do anything like that or we don’t do fondant or we need to change the size to get that effect. Very disappointed. Although the taste of the cake was good.

Scott cochran

Love there donuts

Melissa Robinson

Sandy Hyer

Amy Baldy


Susan Smith

I would like to know what is up with the price of your cakes. When you first came to MT. Gilead, I spent alot buying your cakes for our families Birthdays and Anniversaries because they tasted good and was of good quality. But then you went and raised your prices, almost Tripling them. And there not affordable any longer. I thought $40.00 was high for just a normal 2 layer cake. But I purchased them because my family enjoyed them so. I have nothing against a person making a living, but I feel as high as your bakery items are now, Your just gauging the common every day person!

Maria Aurigema

Thee best donuts ever. Love them. People are so nice and friendly.

Jeff Mabe

You have to try the maple bacon cream stick!

Abe Schrock

The best donuts

Rachel G

Jon Wilson

Lisa Frost

Jessica Osborn

The best donuts ever!

James Lendon

Wonderful food. Even better family. A true blessing.

Mahmoud Abdel-Rasoul

S Jones

Best donuts in the country. Seriously I don't think I have ever had a better apple fritter anywhere.


Briana Elias

The custard-filled donuts are the best!!

Troy Mac

Michael Fraser

Incredible doughnuts with a great story. Probably the best creme sticks & glazed doughnuts I've ever had.

dane johnson

Bacon donut and biscuits and gravy...omg

Cheryl Driggs

I have stopped many times at 8 sisters bakery in their many locations. Always good & food always clean. Normally I would rate them 4-5 stars for food and service. However this sat, 7/14 I don’t know who the staff is but currently working but you can tell their definitely not happy to be there or to wait on you. From the dirty looks to the bad service, and hard dry donuts I would only give them a 2-3!!! I’m sure the owners wouldn’t be happy with their lack of customer service and food prep. Disappointing!

Lee Ann Hoffman

The best donuts! Great bakery!

Samantha McClaskey

Brooke Baker

Best donuts

Dustin Good

Jon Mccoy

Business Hours of 8 Sisters Bakery in Ohio



8 Sisters Bakery en Ohio
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
MCL Restaurant & Bakery Whitehall
MCL Restaurant & Bakery W...
Bakery - Ohio

American restaurant

Our CupCakery
Our CupCakery
Bakery - Ohio

Wedding bakery

Michael Angelo's Bakery
Michael Angelo's Bakery
Bakery - Ohio


Steineck's Donuts & Cakes
Steineck's Donuts & Cakes
Bakery - Ohio


Hershberger's Farm and Bakery
Hershberger's Farm and Ba...
Bakery - Ohio