Reviews of The Protein Bakery (Bakery)

144 W 19th St, New York, NY 10011, United States

Average Rating:


We've got the opinions of people who used the products and services of The Protein Bakery (Bakery) in the area close to New York.

At the moment the business has a rating of 4.6 over 5 and this rating was based on 27 reviews.

You may have noticed that the average of ratings is basically the top, and it is founded on a large number of feddbacks, so we may say that the valuation is very reliable. If people have bothered to value when they are happy with the business, is that it works.

You know that we do not usually stop to give reviews when these are good and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or issue...

This Bakery is included in the category of Bakery.

Where is The Protein Bakery?

REVIEWS OF The Protein Bakery IN New York

Mike Robinson

Risilda Laho

For all the protein cookie, healthy lifestyle, fitness life lovers seeking for yummy insights. Each recipe is made with high hospitality. As a Google Local Guide I highly recommend The Protein Bakery and strongly suggest on Franchising it.

Jasmine Carter

Sooo delicious! I can't choose which one I like best. Chocolate brownie with almond is so good warmed up a little with some almond milk. The lemon blondie is my go-to when I want something sweet without chocolate. There's no protein powdery taste at all, just pure deliciousness. Yum :)

Yoli Luna

I walked oh about 13 blocks to visit this bakery. I felt like an idiot picking up cakes that were display only! I'm smart but not at that particular moment. The attendant notified me twice very politely and I appreciate that. It can be a cruel world out there. The items I purchased were very delicious and filling. Eating one item is enough opposed eating at a different bakery and you feel like eating the whole store in 5 minutes!! Love visiting bakeries especially in NYC.

Eden Posner

Catherine Fagbeyiro

Great products and great customer service! I went there to get my husband some healthy treats and Stephen was so helpful and kind. I will absolutely be back!!!

Pat Healy

My husband had quadruple bypass surgery and ling issues. For his birthday our daughter had a box of your protein desserts shipped to him. They are delicious and healthy. We are both enjoying them. I will definitely reorder in the future. Just told a friend in Florida about them, her husband is diabetic, needs lots of protein. Pat Healy

Deep Garg

ed reagan

The stuff tastes great!

Mackenzie Thomas

Great selection of baked goods packed with the protein you want and need. The owner is amazing and love how he has continued to expand the brand.

Judy G. Burris

Extremely impressed with this Bakery. Looking Forward to trying the products and hoping they Will franchise out or atleast send we can order From them. So excited!!!!!

Samantha Sheppard-Lahiji

I went there with a gilt city voucher and they were very friendly. The owner was there at the time and I had a nice conversation with him as I browsed their wares. Their brownies are the bomb dot comb and to be honest that's my favorite kind of dessert, so while I've tried the cookies and blondies, nothing can compare to their java based brownie. I just recently got another voucher and I plan on going again!

Jo Rosenburg

Amazing! really great, its a must experience experience ;)

Seul Park

Craig Ryan

I went out of my way to check out the shop. It's not even a retail space. On the 3rd floor there was a door with a sign saying " this is our shop-- if the door is closed we are on the 9th floor, call #.... I had no answer and was a total waste of my travel time. **second review** Upon encouraging me to return I gave a second chance. It took them 7 minutes to walk down stairs and although they advertise gluten free-- they are not. I have Celiac disease and they down played the risk. This place is a joke-- seriously. Look at a nutrition label. It's worth splurging and eating a donut vs the low quality ingredients in the product.

brenda aguilar

I live in Fort Worth TEXAS & buy your brownies at a Keva smoothie location. I love the black & white brownie & the walnut brownie. My question is: can I buy on line from your company? I love having these on hand between workouts , & sometimes they are out. Regardless, I love the product & glad I found it. Brenda

Byron Cortes

What more can I say other than I love this place. Wife and I have been on the Keto diet and this has become our go to splurge for the occasional sweet tooth craving. Big fan of their Low Sugar options. More importantly though, everybody that works here has been nothing short of amazing. From helping you to select items based on what you are looking for diet wise, to going the extra mile and texting/calling to make sure you get the cake you want last minute. The hardest part is to not go there all the time.

Ariella GH Khan

The new store looks absolutely amazing and the cookies are to die for. Perfect healthy snack for satisfy your sweet tooth

Neil Benen

I'm lucky enough to have my office right down the hall. I was having a party and decided to order 25 assorted brownies and blondies. All my guests loved them. I didn't get to try each flavor, but the ones I tasted were AMAZING!! Thank you!!

Rubina M

I’m on the keto diet for over 2 years and I am so pleased to finally find a desert I can REALLY ENJOY without breaking my diet. Love the blondies!!!!! My hubby who eats without dietary restrictions loves the deserts too. We will not eat any other desert again. Stephen helped me personally explaining in depth the process and significance of each item. I have a new favorite stop on the west side. Also found out they ship next day!!!

Ena Da

I went to a grand opening party and they served baked goods from The Protein Bakery. I had the chocolate chip cookies and their brownies. They were absolutely delicious! The chocolate chip cookie seriously goes down as the most delicious chocolate chip cookie I've ever had. The brownie was also really tasty. I've never been to the actual location before but I will be paying a visit to purchase more baked goods!

Nicole Knowlton

I tried your Coconut Walnut Chocolate Chip Blondie at a local smoothie shop (Robeks). It was so amazing I went back to the smoothie shop just to buy the blondies. Since then I have ordered them online twice! I intend to keep your bakery on my regular shopping list.

Shlomi Buzaglo

The best protein cakes and cookie's I ever had Great job

Luna G

Service was great but the goods are too healthy for me maybe - it does not taste good. I guess it’s just personal preferences.

Santiago Suarez

Screwggl Lova

Visited the new space (19th St) only a day after it opened and had a great experience chatting with the owner who reviewed all the selections. Picked up a few items and will absolutely be back to buy more. It's a full retail store with regular hours so it's easier to pop in for a quick re-up on my stash. To my macro counting folks... I stick to the peanut butter options and let me tell you -- I have yet to find lower carb baked goods better than this in a 100 mile radius.

Peter Pugliese

Go Thursday's for the best selection. That's when they restock.

Business Hours of The Protein Bakery in New York



The Protein Bakery en New York
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Latin Bakery
Latin Bakery
Bakery - New York


Bakery - New York

Coffee shop

Perkins Restaurant & Bakery
Perkins Restaurant & Bakery
Bakery - New York


Dean & DeLuca
Dean & DeLuca
Bakery - New York

Gourmet grocery store

Fat Witch Bakery
Fat Witch Bakery
Bakery - New York